A. I. Auto-Replaces Sky with REFLECTION? vs Photoshop!
video description
Date: 2022-07-19
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 20
DK
Wow. I love and use both PScc and LAi for sky replacement and some images work better with one than the other. I am very disappointed with your review as you have made very obvious image selections for the examples to favor Luminar. The reflection addition to LAi is cool and in many cases it will make a good addition to your image but on the other hand it is seriously flawed. It is very clear that you are aware of those flaws as you very deftly sidestep the issues in several cases. With the Luminar reflection you mention several times how you can move the sky and the reflection from side to side but fail to note that if you move it vertically the reflection moves in the wrong direction. You also fail to discuss what happens when the original image has some distinct reflections already in the water and how Luminar fails to cope with these properly. You don't show the luminar sky moving vertically until your NYC example with no reflection. I would encourage viewers of your video to keep trying both and keep a much more open mind than what you are presenting here. I will continue to use both and always settle on the one that does the best job.
reply
Wow. I love and use both PScc and LAi for sky replacement and some images work better with one than the other. I am very disappointed with your review as you have made very obvious image selections for the examples to favor Luminar. The reflection addition to LAi is cool and in many cases it will make a good addition to your image but on the other hand it is seriously flawed. It is very clear that you are aware of those flaws as you very deftly sidestep the issues in several cases. With the Luminar reflection you mention several times how you can move the sky and the reflection from side to side but fail to note that if you move it vertically the reflection moves in the wrong direction. You also fail to discuss what happens when the original image has some distinct reflections already in the water and how Luminar fails to cope with these properly. You don't show the luminar sky moving vertically until your NYC example with no reflection. I would encourage viewers of your video to keep trying both and keep a much more open mind than what you are presenting here. I will continue to use both and always settle on the one that does the best job.
reply
Alan
In this world of changing technology and constant innovation, it's quite healthy to watch these opinion pieces: hopefully, the two companies are humble enough to watch the video and concur that maybe the comparisons are quite legitimate. Open minded companies can benefit greatly when provided with constructive criticism. When they respond with innovations (at a faster and faster pace I might add) we all win. All we really need in this evolution is that continued focus on time saving simplification (hence AI.
In the world of digital cameras, look at how many people have converted to Sony's products! You can bet that the master of sensor technology is really shaking up the older, long time players. I can't imagine what we'll see in terms of future mirrorless cameras because of the increased competition, but in addition to unlimited resolution, wouldn't it be great to see exposure latitude issues as a thing of the past! It's gonna happen. some day.
Keep comparing Unmesh - we all win.
reply
In this world of changing technology and constant innovation, it's quite healthy to watch these opinion pieces: hopefully, the two companies are humble enough to watch the video and concur that maybe the comparisons are quite legitimate. Open minded companies can benefit greatly when provided with constructive criticism. When they respond with innovations (at a faster and faster pace I might add) we all win. All we really need in this evolution is that continued focus on time saving simplification (hence AI.
In the world of digital cameras, look at how many people have converted to Sony's products! You can bet that the master of sensor technology is really shaking up the older, long time players. I can't imagine what we'll see in terms of future mirrorless cameras because of the increased competition, but in addition to unlimited resolution, wouldn't it be great to see exposure latitude issues as a thing of the past! It's gonna happen. some day.
Keep comparing Unmesh - we all win.
reply
Library
I just wanted to dispel some concepts some people have that if the edit does not take a really long time, it kills creativity. Of course, if longer editing time is a great part of your creative fun, you should definitely stick with it. When you have a greater toolbox, you have a CHOICE. You can do this the long way or the easy way. Neither had anything to do with creativity. You are still the captain of the creative direction you want to take for the photo. The Luminar toolbox had some 60 main tools with hundreds of sliders each of which has an extensive adjustment range. Mathematically, this gives you millions of creative combinations and possibilities. Talking about UNLEASHING creativity. Of course, Photoshop will always remain the unrivaled toolbox out there but it comes with a more complex learning curve.
reply
I just wanted to dispel some concepts some people have that if the edit does not take a really long time, it kills creativity. Of course, if longer editing time is a great part of your creative fun, you should definitely stick with it. When you have a greater toolbox, you have a CHOICE. You can do this the long way or the easy way. Neither had anything to do with creativity. You are still the captain of the creative direction you want to take for the photo. The Luminar toolbox had some 60 main tools with hundreds of sliders each of which has an extensive adjustment range. Mathematically, this gives you millions of creative combinations and possibilities. Talking about UNLEASHING creativity. Of course, Photoshop will always remain the unrivaled toolbox out there but it comes with a more complex learning curve.
reply
Blue
Great video! I've got both, I go back and forth. It's easy to get lazy and just use one or the other, but my best results are from using both for different things. IMHO, Luminar is great for certain photos, but it certainly does not replace Photoshop. To me it's more like a tool to enhance what I can do in Photoshop. Thanks for all your videos! PS I got Luminar with your link: )
reply
Great video! I've got both, I go back and forth. It's easy to get lazy and just use one or the other, but my best results are from using both for different things. IMHO, Luminar is great for certain photos, but it certainly does not replace Photoshop. To me it's more like a tool to enhance what I can do in Photoshop. Thanks for all your videos! PS I got Luminar with your link: )
reply
Bogdan
Yes Luminar it looks pretty good, but is more far away from lanscape pro 3 from Anthropics. Landscape pro had sky replacement from the first version like 5 years ago. Now on the last version it will permit fully manually control combined with AI intellgence. Also you can mask each element of the picture and have the control of every component.
reply
Yes Luminar it looks pretty good, but is more far away from lanscape pro 3 from Anthropics. Landscape pro had sky replacement from the first version like 5 years ago. Now on the last version it will permit fully manually control combined with AI intellgence. Also you can mask each element of the picture and have the control of every component.
reply
Harmony
When Luminar came on the scene Photoshop die hard supporters went bonkers but This is what happened when Photoshop came on the scene and guess what after Luminar more softwares will come up i believe its a matter of embracing change because its a natural process of life. AYOBA!
reply
When Luminar came on the scene Photoshop die hard supporters went bonkers but This is what happened when Photoshop came on the scene and guess what after Luminar more softwares will come up i believe its a matter of embracing change because its a natural process of life. AYOBA!
reply
Knyght
I think one of the dangers of Luminar, is that it's so easy and so seamless that it's going to funnel a lot of different people into all basically getting the same result. If it catches on, I suspect there will be an identifiable 'Luminar look' to certain photographs.
reply
I think one of the dangers of Luminar, is that it's so easy and so seamless that it's going to funnel a lot of different people into all basically getting the same result. If it catches on, I suspect there will be an identifiable 'Luminar look' to certain photographs.
reply
Gabriella
Thank you so much for this video! I just purchased luminar IA, and use it as a Photoshop plugin, it is really amazing! especially the sky replacement! Thanks to you I learned a few more features i wasn't aware of!
reply
Thank you so much for this video! I just purchased luminar IA, and use it as a Photoshop plugin, it is really amazing! especially the sky replacement! Thanks to you I learned a few more features i wasn't aware of!
reply
Christie
I absolutely LOVE Luminar. unfortunately, now I can't get into it due to an opengl3. 3 error message. it's frustrating! :( It hurts even more when I see all of the wonderful things it can do.
reply
I absolutely LOVE Luminar. unfortunately, now I can't get into it due to an opengl3. 3 error message. it's frustrating! :( It hurts even more when I see all of the wonderful things it can do.
reply
Keval
Hello,
Sky Replacement feature in the older version of Luminar didn't worked when we first rotate the image and then apply a new sky. Is that issue now solved in this version?
reply
Hello,
Sky Replacement feature in the older version of Luminar didn't worked when we first rotate the image and then apply a new sky. Is that issue now solved in this version?
reply
Asesh
Hallo.
Is it(Luminar Ai) applicable with windows 10. I can't understand how differentiate it for purchasing windows user. Please help me with you suggestion. Thank you.
reply
Hallo.
Is it(Luminar Ai) applicable with windows 10. I can't understand how differentiate it for purchasing windows user. Please help me with you suggestion. Thank you.
reply
Darrin
You are super biased towards Iluminar in this supposed comparison LOL I guess all I have to do is just look at what youre sponsoring down below before I watch your videos
reply
You are super biased towards Iluminar in this supposed comparison LOL I guess all I have to do is just look at what youre sponsoring down below before I watch your videos
reply
Anthony
Ive just downloaded the A. i however you have more features on yours than I do on mine? I don't have reflections or the ability to see the sky in the menu
reply
Ive just downloaded the A. i however you have more features on yours than I do on mine? I don't have reflections or the ability to see the sky in the menu
reply
Ste
Hi, download ai but when i do sky replacement it misses bottom 3rd of my sky everytime and also misses the see fru car windows, any suggestions please
reply
Hi, download ai but when i do sky replacement it misses bottom 3rd of my sky everytime and also misses the see fru car windows, any suggestions please
reply
David
Also Luminar's AI Bokeh saves you thousands in wide opening prime lenses, LOL So just get a 28-70/24-85 at 2. 8 or 3. 5 and Bob's your uncle.
reply
Also Luminar's AI Bokeh saves you thousands in wide opening prime lenses, LOL So just get a 28-70/24-85 at 2. 8 or 3. 5 and Bob's your uncle.
reply
Bhupender
just purchased this Luminar AI with the help of link given below. However I did not get any column to enter my GST NO. Kindly advice
reply
just purchased this Luminar AI with the help of link given below. However I did not get any column to enter my GST NO. Kindly advice
reply
Shane
Wow! Dude, you are awesome. What a great head-to-head comparison. Your videos are very professional and concise. I'll be following you.
reply
Wow! Dude, you are awesome. What a great head-to-head comparison. Your videos are very professional and concise. I'll be following you.
reply
Nobody
Sky AI and Bokeh AI works the best together. I just tried it now and with bokeh, it increases the effect and makes it more realistic
reply
Sky AI and Bokeh AI works the best together. I just tried it now and with bokeh, it increases the effect and makes it more realistic
reply
Rodolfo
I purchase the software but, I was not able to get your discount and I can't even login to the software, is very sad but oh well.
reply
I purchase the software but, I was not able to get your discount and I can't even login to the software, is very sad but oh well.
reply
One
Photoshop has all these cool features but they're feeling incomplete and almost always bested by other situational programs.
reply
Photoshop has all these cool features but they're feeling incomplete and almost always bested by other situational programs.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
