We Were Wrong About Black Holes
video description
Date: 2023-11-26
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 25
JCGreene
When you say -we were wrong- I'm assuming the -we- is the general public and not the scientific community. Because the latter never thought black holes sucked anything up like a vacuum cleaner. That's just a common misconception people wrongfully intuit.
A lot of the other facts described here are only -wrong- or -not entirely true- as a matter of semantics. For insurance, you say that it's not actually true that nothing can escape a black hole's gravity because Hawking radiation does. That's not technically accurate in the strict sense. While Hawking radiation and gravitational waves both carry away a black hole's mass, neither technically escape a black hole's gravity. At least not from within the event horizon where that becomes impossible. Hawking radiation is what it is precisely because of the fact that nothing can escape a black hole's gravity. Particle/anti-particle pairs sometimes spontaneously generate as a product of the -noise- of certain fields. But they almost always mutually annihilate almost immediately, cancelling each other out. However, if a pair generates right at the edge of the event horizon of a black hole and 1 of the particles crosses the event horizon, that particle is lost to the universe outside the event horizon. This effectively saves it from annihilation with its entangled partner. From out here, this would appear like single particles are just spontaneous generating randomly into our universe without being cancelled back out. But mass has to come from somewhere, and it turns out that the mass used for these particles come from the black hole itself. Hence the -radiation- part. But the particle itself was never in the event horizon and, so, didn't escape it.
reply
When you say -we were wrong- I'm assuming the -we- is the general public and not the scientific community. Because the latter never thought black holes sucked anything up like a vacuum cleaner. That's just a common misconception people wrongfully intuit.
A lot of the other facts described here are only -wrong- or -not entirely true- as a matter of semantics. For insurance, you say that it's not actually true that nothing can escape a black hole's gravity because Hawking radiation does. That's not technically accurate in the strict sense. While Hawking radiation and gravitational waves both carry away a black hole's mass, neither technically escape a black hole's gravity. At least not from within the event horizon where that becomes impossible. Hawking radiation is what it is precisely because of the fact that nothing can escape a black hole's gravity. Particle/anti-particle pairs sometimes spontaneously generate as a product of the -noise- of certain fields. But they almost always mutually annihilate almost immediately, cancelling each other out. However, if a pair generates right at the edge of the event horizon of a black hole and 1 of the particles crosses the event horizon, that particle is lost to the universe outside the event horizon. This effectively saves it from annihilation with its entangled partner. From out here, this would appear like single particles are just spontaneous generating randomly into our universe without being cancelled back out. But mass has to come from somewhere, and it turns out that the mass used for these particles come from the black hole itself. Hence the -radiation- part. But the particle itself was never in the event horizon and, so, didn't escape it.
reply
Captain
Not many people agree, but I've always thought -black holes- are a conduit to another universe.
It does sound like a reach, but consider that.
The birth of the universe it a huge explosion of matter. Now matter doesn't just appear from nowhere and it has to be reconstituted/recycled, so what if the big bang is the birth of a -black hole, - resulting in the birth of a new universe?
What if the matter from that big bang is material the black hole, that has been consumed from from planets, stars etc, and reconstituted into the universe created by the -black hole? -
The cycle continuing infinitum, which also lends credence to the many worlds theory.
A black hole imploding is the big crunch, the death of that universe.
Since there are so many black holes, it means that the material it being passed down through each black hole, and in turn through each black hole is countless black holes that form, continuing forever which again the multiverse theory, with the hypothesis that it consists of an infinite universe with infinite earths.
I hope I've been able to explain it well enough as to not confuse anyone.
But the similarities of the life and behaviour of black holes and the life and behaviour of universes are unnervingly paralleled and kind of match up.
reply
Not many people agree, but I've always thought -black holes- are a conduit to another universe.
It does sound like a reach, but consider that.
The birth of the universe it a huge explosion of matter. Now matter doesn't just appear from nowhere and it has to be reconstituted/recycled, so what if the big bang is the birth of a -black hole, - resulting in the birth of a new universe?
What if the matter from that big bang is material the black hole, that has been consumed from from planets, stars etc, and reconstituted into the universe created by the -black hole? -
The cycle continuing infinitum, which also lends credence to the many worlds theory.
A black hole imploding is the big crunch, the death of that universe.
Since there are so many black holes, it means that the material it being passed down through each black hole, and in turn through each black hole is countless black holes that form, continuing forever which again the multiverse theory, with the hypothesis that it consists of an infinite universe with infinite earths.
I hope I've been able to explain it well enough as to not confuse anyone.
But the similarities of the life and behaviour of black holes and the life and behaviour of universes are unnervingly paralleled and kind of match up.
reply
Sam
What If video ideas:
What if Pandora was our Moon? That would be really good and really interesting to see especially that it technically is a moon.
What if Minecraft existed in real life? Dont have to do blocks. Some block items can exsist just not make them block shaped.
What if the Hollow Earth from the Monsterverse existed, but if you did do that, you'd have to wait until next year because we barley explored the hollow earth so you'd have to add Godzilla x Kong: The new empire. Add the comics too for more in depth.
What if a black hole the size of a penny was on earth. I just want to see the aftermath of it all.
What if Godzilla went to Pandora?
What if Gamera existed?
reply
What If video ideas:
What if Pandora was our Moon? That would be really good and really interesting to see especially that it technically is a moon.
What if Minecraft existed in real life? Dont have to do blocks. Some block items can exsist just not make them block shaped.
What if the Hollow Earth from the Monsterverse existed, but if you did do that, you'd have to wait until next year because we barley explored the hollow earth so you'd have to add Godzilla x Kong: The new empire. Add the comics too for more in depth.
What if a black hole the size of a penny was on earth. I just want to see the aftermath of it all.
What if Godzilla went to Pandora?
What if Gamera existed?
reply
Nimz
What if our scientists can discover an equipment which can stretch and regain the shape once the gravitational pull is completed keeping the passengers untouched. For this they should know the strength and time of this gravitational pull. Seems like one day those experiments in Area 51 will give answers. With available metals or materials in earth this mayn-t be possible. But if scientists can reengineer those UFO vehicles they will have the answer. Cigarette shaped cylinderical UFO structures from witnesses making sense now.
reply
What if our scientists can discover an equipment which can stretch and regain the shape once the gravitational pull is completed keeping the passengers untouched. For this they should know the strength and time of this gravitational pull. Seems like one day those experiments in Area 51 will give answers. With available metals or materials in earth this mayn-t be possible. But if scientists can reengineer those UFO vehicles they will have the answer. Cigarette shaped cylinderical UFO structures from witnesses making sense now.
reply
Die
Yes, nuclear energy can do that. except there's a chance for events from your past to re-occur, like Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and most recently Fukushima Daiichi.
Don't even bother exploring the solar system where the planet you exist on resides. Instead try focusing development of technologies that will make your planet a more pleasant place to exist on. Also, please consider working on yourselves and strive to become a utopian society.
reply
Yes, nuclear energy can do that. except there's a chance for events from your past to re-occur, like Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and most recently Fukushima Daiichi.
Don't even bother exploring the solar system where the planet you exist on resides. Instead try focusing development of technologies that will make your planet a more pleasant place to exist on. Also, please consider working on yourselves and strive to become a utopian society.
reply
Dr.
3 things that BH emit - you only said about Hawking Radiation. What are the other two?
Nuclear energy is clean. What about the nuclear waste? Is it clean also?
Phoenix A is the largest BH, not Ton 618.
A BH is visible only if it had an Accretion Disk, not all of them have it and so not all B Holes are visible.
reply
3 things that BH emit - you only said about Hawking Radiation. What are the other two?
Nuclear energy is clean. What about the nuclear waste? Is it clean also?
Phoenix A is the largest BH, not Ton 618.
A BH is visible only if it had an Accretion Disk, not all of them have it and so not all B Holes are visible.
reply
Millionaire
These videos are so interesting! It's so much fun to imagine the possibilities for the future as technology improves and science discovers new possibilities. It's not my personal area of expertise, but I do enjoy learning about the possible applications of theories and technologies as we make improvements.
reply
These videos are so interesting! It's so much fun to imagine the possibilities for the future as technology improves and science discovers new possibilities. It's not my personal area of expertise, but I do enjoy learning about the possible applications of theories and technologies as we make improvements.
reply
CineMarTiN
Black holes are one of the most sinister and mysterious sights of space known to us. It's always interesting to learn something new about them. Although I knew a lot before this, some things turned out to be a discovery for me. For example, the fact that Rosen's bridges are actually deadly-
reply
Black holes are one of the most sinister and mysterious sights of space known to us. It's always interesting to learn something new about them. Although I knew a lot before this, some things turned out to be a discovery for me. For example, the fact that Rosen's bridges are actually deadly-
reply
Michael
None of this is new to the theory of black holes. Example, Hawkin's radiation was discovered by stephen hawkins in the 70s. Comments suggesting researchers should watch this video are pretty awkward since they've produced all this information decades ago
reply
None of this is new to the theory of black holes. Example, Hawkin's radiation was discovered by stephen hawkins in the 70s. Comments suggesting researchers should watch this video are pretty awkward since they've produced all this information decades ago
reply
-Choco-s-land-
Spaghetti-fication: me: eating spaghetti
Kid: i want to be an astronaut! Mom: wants kid to be a docter. Mom: wow such a good video! Look at this video of what if! Mom: shows video-. Kid: NOOO DOCTER ----
reply
Spaghetti-fication: me: eating spaghetti
Kid: i want to be an astronaut! Mom: wants kid to be a docter. Mom: wow such a good video! Look at this video of what if! Mom: shows video-. Kid: NOOO DOCTER ----
reply
Aviation
If something goes wrong in solar panels and wind turbines, it can be repaired or demloshed. But if something goes wrong in nuclear powerplant, the whole STATE will be filled with radiation -, like Chernobyl.
reply
If something goes wrong in solar panels and wind turbines, it can be repaired or demloshed. But if something goes wrong in nuclear powerplant, the whole STATE will be filled with radiation -, like Chernobyl.
reply
what
Dear What if team. Please make a video about What if the largest asteroid known to existence gets swallowed by Jupiter. What will happen to it considering it's a gas giant. Make a video about this please.
reply
Dear What if team. Please make a video about What if the largest asteroid known to existence gets swallowed by Jupiter. What will happen to it considering it's a gas giant. Make a video about this please.
reply
winx
Black holes are actually shortcuts for angels from one place to another and we can't take it we will not be able to survive the force because our bodies flesh skin muscle nothing is capable of handling it
reply
Black holes are actually shortcuts for angels from one place to another and we can't take it we will not be able to survive the force because our bodies flesh skin muscle nothing is capable of handling it
reply
sam
Spaghettification is really crazy. You'd be able to see the back of your own head I heard. But also, if you go straight through the center you won't suffer from spaghettification
reply
Spaghettification is really crazy. You'd be able to see the back of your own head I heard. But also, if you go straight through the center you won't suffer from spaghettification
reply
What
I love how this video breaks down complex scientific concepts in a way that's easy for anyone to understand. It's great to see science being made accessible to everyone!
reply
I love how this video breaks down complex scientific concepts in a way that's easy for anyone to understand. It's great to see science being made accessible to everyone!
reply
-----
Does word comeback is correct when particles of howaking radiation is newly made one outside of black hole? Am I missing something I'm not physician or something
reply
Does word comeback is correct when particles of howaking radiation is newly made one outside of black hole? Am I missing something I'm not physician or something
reply
DriftedDiamond
Isn-t there a theory that a black hole-s gravity is so strong that it bends time, and if you got sucked into one you-d see the universe die with you?
reply
Isn-t there a theory that a black hole-s gravity is so strong that it bends time, and if you got sucked into one you-d see the universe die with you?
reply
Jack
There's no way were going to be carbon neutral by 2050 how are going to change all of are manufacturing and industry in 30 years no chance especially worldwide
reply
There's no way were going to be carbon neutral by 2050 how are going to change all of are manufacturing and industry in 30 years no chance especially worldwide
reply
Silver
I knew every thing that he said. This isnt a -THERES SO MUCH MORE STUFF TO BLACKHOLES THAN WE THOUGHT- its a -basic blackhole tutorial
reply
I knew every thing that he said. This isnt a -THERES SO MUCH MORE STUFF TO BLACKHOLES THAN WE THOUGHT- its a -basic blackhole tutorial
reply
Kirk
You had me onboard for everything. until you tried justifying nuclear power being a good thing. keep thr rich in power, great idea fool
reply
You had me onboard for everything. until you tried justifying nuclear power being a good thing. keep thr rich in power, great idea fool
reply
Frastytake
They don't suck up everything in there way. They so have strong gravity but there gravitational field is very small
reply
They don't suck up everything in there way. They so have strong gravity but there gravitational field is very small
reply
DG
Blackhole doesn't bend light, it makes space-time curved and everything exist in space-time that's why light bends.
reply
Blackhole doesn't bend light, it makes space-time curved and everything exist in space-time that's why light bends.
reply
----
So you suggest that we will disarm all the nuclear weapon to make clean energy? It doesn't make sense, LOL.
reply
So you suggest that we will disarm all the nuclear weapon to make clean energy? It doesn't make sense, LOL.
reply
Kiran
This is a very good video, but this is the most misleading title I have come across in past few years.
reply
This is a very good video, but this is the most misleading title I have come across in past few years.
reply
Gary
Wait if Black Holes are gateways to other universes is that where UFOs and possibly aliens come from?
reply
Wait if Black Holes are gateways to other universes is that where UFOs and possibly aliens come from?
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
