• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » WIRED
Military Historian Breaks Down Medieval Weapons in Video Games

Military Historian Breaks Down Medieval Weapons in Video Games

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
In this episode of Game Over(analyzed, military historian Mike Loades breaks down how medieval weapons and armor are portrayed in modern video games. Watch as Mike takes a look at armor and weapons from games like Dark Souls, Mordhau, The Witcher 3, For Honor, Kingdom Come: Deliverance and more. Just how realistic are these games? Check out Mike's books here
Date: 2022-07-06

Comments and reviews: 10


It's not accurate for him to say that people never wore swords on their backs. It may have been VERY RARE but people DID do it. There's literally historical texts and tapestries that SHOW people doing it. Mainly the part hie messed up was to use the word never. That's an all inclusive word and he made an all-inclusive statement with that word and it's extremely rare for all-inclusive statements to be true. So technically he's wrong when he says that it never happened because we know that it did.
He actually makes a few of these all-inclusive statements that are technically wrong. Like when he states that you never block with a sword and instead knock it to the side. It's the never that makes it wrong. It would have been better if he stated its' better to not block with a sword or that it wasn't common to do so.
Shadivisity actually makes a reply video to this video and points these things out.

reply

Swords were already costly to make. any fine usable ones. (maybe that is why many myths treating the swords as a rare and superior weapon with magical qualities in many cultures. it sounds very epic in classical medieval. those decorative ones were probably made for the most noble VRPs and rarely ever tested in combat, for fear of damaging them. hence, provided you had enough fortune, the artistic freedom they took to decorate those was a lot wider. possible because the purpose of them blades was to impress, for awe, ceremonies and to emphasize the status of the owner. a few of those were found buried with the noble and had a much preserved condition than those found in the soil of battlefields, which were exposed to oxidizing agents like rain and bloodstains and soil acids
reply

Actually, the rate of shooting of the crossbow is not unrealistic. I counted off about five seconds for a shot. I personally, a mere amateur, could fire 5 shots in 30 seconds, so I have no doubt a properly trained professional crossbowman of the Middle Ages could do better. Sorry, I just had to say that. Although I haven't fired a crossbow in years, it still bugs me whenever I hear that old chestnut trotted out. Otherwise, I love watching videos like these with history geeks talking about obscure things I have loved ever since I first saw Robin Hood (Errol Flynn) as a wee lad.
reply

The thing that bothered me the most in the example games was the cavalry charge towards a fortified village. What on earth is the point of that? What are the horses going to do once they get to the walls, climb? Sending in horses to literally just mill about beneath manned walls is how to get all your horses killed for absolutely no reason. Horses are expensive to keep. Specially trained war horses are extremely expensive. You don't just waste them like that.
A single horse certainly won't be able to kick open the gates like that, either.

reply

Professor Loades is delightful, and I love how charitable he was with the Kingdom Come clip, and at the end of the video. I do have one question for him, and that-s: What-s the difference between between the sword blocks in Dark Souls and the sword blocks in For Honor? Other than the erroneous detail about sword blocks reducing but not eliminating damage, it sounded like direct blocks were not how blocking was done. But didn-t we see the same thing in the For Honor clip, which did fighting well? I-d love to hear the difference.
reply

Really enjoyed this guy, I know a bit more about the average person but am not at this guys level at all and when I do run into people at his level they tend to be absolute arrogant bores. This guy is so animate that he is fun to not only listen to but watch as he explains things and he does not bash the games but just takes the time to say why they are fun and why they are inaccurate without bashing the games. I hope you have him doing other videos, I really do.
reply

Wrong about crossbow in mount and blade2. it the clip it is light crossbow that can be reloaded the way like it in the game. in that same game there is heavier version of crossbows that take like 3-5 seconds to reload and there is action that figure of player r moving like it really reloading it, so its a little bit more accurate in the whole game then it taken in the clip.
reply

Oh my god. this guy was so interesting, no complaining about video games being unrealistic due to game limitations and most importantly, at the end, he really got what video games can do.
Schools should honestly invest in making educational video games like kerbal space program or something, there is no better way than that to capture a young mind.

reply

I'd argue the greatest advantage of a pollaxe is that it allows you to deal with any armor type - cutting edge, stabbing point, blunt hammer. You're set whether you're fighting an armored knight or a militia-man.
IIRC a good rate of fire for a crossbow was 2ish bolts per minute. Inexperienced users would have been far slower. It was a beast.

reply

You dont get it, so il explain it like i did to other videos where people claim they know everything about history or accidents, its all movies and fake, now what is real is the medieval age, but you must understand, its a video game, nothing in books, games, videos, movies, is real, 100 % its all to make money or entertainment.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos