
Critique Session 2 - Creature Concept - Proko
video description
Date: 2022-03-14
Comments and reviews: 10
Nathan
Proko reminds me of Marshall. They are great tutors but have no vision.
The original is far stronger than Stan's. Really, Stan applied his style to the character and explained why he made the choices he did. The original was quite intricate and well rendered.
I love learning fundamentals and new ways of thinking critically from Stan and Marshall. However, I find their work exhausting and bland.
Right now, across the internet and on forums, everyone is nitpicking people's fundamentals, their planes, forms, etc. But in all this analyzing, the soul of the work is being forgotten. Why is it that some of the strongest, most powerful work is distorted, blurred and breaks all the rules that folks like Stan and Marshall push.
Granted, you need to learn the rules first before breaking them. But if you are going to draw all technical like this, you will end up teaching this stuff instead of living it.
reply
Proko reminds me of Marshall. They are great tutors but have no vision.
The original is far stronger than Stan's. Really, Stan applied his style to the character and explained why he made the choices he did. The original was quite intricate and well rendered.
I love learning fundamentals and new ways of thinking critically from Stan and Marshall. However, I find their work exhausting and bland.
Right now, across the internet and on forums, everyone is nitpicking people's fundamentals, their planes, forms, etc. But in all this analyzing, the soul of the work is being forgotten. Why is it that some of the strongest, most powerful work is distorted, blurred and breaks all the rules that folks like Stan and Marshall push.
Granted, you need to learn the rules first before breaking them. But if you are going to draw all technical like this, you will end up teaching this stuff instead of living it.
reply
Lisa
So many irrelevant comments on this video. Proko stated at the very beginning that he's not so creative at concepts. I also prefer the -feel- of the original drawing but that's beside the point. This is strictly a technical critique. It's clear that the original artist had a lot to improve on in his fundamentals. If you can't see the difference between deliberate deformation and a lack of skill, then you should learn more fundamentals yourself.
It's not a choice between vision and technical correctness. It's best to have both, you know.
reply
So many irrelevant comments on this video. Proko stated at the very beginning that he's not so creative at concepts. I also prefer the -feel- of the original drawing but that's beside the point. This is strictly a technical critique. It's clear that the original artist had a lot to improve on in his fundamentals. If you can't see the difference between deliberate deformation and a lack of skill, then you should learn more fundamentals yourself.
It's not a choice between vision and technical correctness. It's best to have both, you know.
reply
Mme. Tenebrae
Good vid, personally, I would've thought the original Ork was pretty amazing and drawn very well, but everything you explained and how to change and why seemed logical.
Btw, the hair under the lower lip, I think, is supposed to be his (I guess, dunno if female Orks can have beards) beard; )
I like your, or should I say both of your versions, the unchanged one looked a bit like an oldish, a little more exhausted Ork warrior, while after the changes he's more like the 'normal', aggressive Ork
reply
Good vid, personally, I would've thought the original Ork was pretty amazing and drawn very well, but everything you explained and how to change and why seemed logical.
Btw, the hair under the lower lip, I think, is supposed to be his (I guess, dunno if female Orks can have beards) beard; )
I like your, or should I say both of your versions, the unchanged one looked a bit like an oldish, a little more exhausted Ork warrior, while after the changes he's more like the 'normal', aggressive Ork
reply
ChrCOLTChr
That's exactly my point. When I said -original is way better-, I was talking about the Art. That, independs on technical prowess. Take my fav Comics artist for an instance: Joa Madureira; his drawings are not -right-, but that doesn't matter, as it's art. Not meant to be technical, such as drawing a chair, or a car's engine. Also, if his artisctic side would improve, why can't I feel it like I do with the original piece? Again, I'm not saying he's not good at it. Just the style isn't for him.
reply
That's exactly my point. When I said -original is way better-, I was talking about the Art. That, independs on technical prowess. Take my fav Comics artist for an instance: Joa Madureira; his drawings are not -right-, but that doesn't matter, as it's art. Not meant to be technical, such as drawing a chair, or a car's engine. Also, if his artisctic side would improve, why can't I feel it like I do with the original piece? Again, I'm not saying he's not good at it. Just the style isn't for him.
reply
AtenAkaAton1
In this case I would say yes. This isn't about creating art so much as technique. Have you taken art classes at a college yet? I personally have found what is prettiest or coolest isn't usually the one that is 'right'. This is more about teaching how to do things right, not make pretty/cool art. Also when one has the techniques their art virtually always improves. I would want to see what it would look like now, done after his critique, I'm sure he would make an even better image.
reply
In this case I would say yes. This isn't about creating art so much as technique. Have you taken art classes at a college yet? I personally have found what is prettiest or coolest isn't usually the one that is 'right'. This is more about teaching how to do things right, not make pretty/cool art. Also when one has the techniques their art virtually always improves. I would want to see what it would look like now, done after his critique, I'm sure he would make an even better image.
reply
Deedra
I kinda of enjoyed that the original had asymmetrical eyes; it adds to the concept of the character for me. There are things in proko's picture that are done very well of course. However, the original's expression and gaze is wonderful. In regards to the neck beard, I've sense some Orc references with it. Both are excellent pictures the original look like a lot of time, thought, and passion was put into it. Lovely video thank you for sharing.
reply
I kinda of enjoyed that the original had asymmetrical eyes; it adds to the concept of the character for me. There are things in proko's picture that are done very well of course. However, the original's expression and gaze is wonderful. In regards to the neck beard, I've sense some Orc references with it. Both are excellent pictures the original look like a lot of time, thought, and passion was put into it. Lovely video thank you for sharing.
reply
AtenAkaAton1
Regardless Joe Mad understands the fundamentals being taught in this video, which is why he can do what he does. The original drawing is full of mistakes, not purposeful exaggeration like what Joe Mad does. The whole point of this video is to teach, Proko isn't trying to simply outdo someone, he is trying to teach a specific skill, and if you read the top two comments you will see he has helped the original artist in this regard.
reply
Regardless Joe Mad understands the fundamentals being taught in this video, which is why he can do what he does. The original drawing is full of mistakes, not purposeful exaggeration like what Joe Mad does. The whole point of this video is to teach, Proko isn't trying to simply outdo someone, he is trying to teach a specific skill, and if you read the top two comments you will see he has helped the original artist in this regard.
reply
ChrCOLTChr
I'm aware of Joe Mad's technique. What I meant by -not right- is the way he plays with the body, deforming it the way he does. Once more: Proko's drawing is technical. That's it. That doesn't stop anyone from enjoying the art more than the technique. Which was what I said. He can be the technical genius of drawing, but it will still be dead in the aspect of art by the end of the day.
reply
I'm aware of Joe Mad's technique. What I meant by -not right- is the way he plays with the body, deforming it the way he does. Once more: Proko's drawing is technical. That's it. That doesn't stop anyone from enjoying the art more than the technique. Which was what I said. He can be the technical genius of drawing, but it will still be dead in the aspect of art by the end of the day.
reply
anzatzi
Stan, great idea to on a more advanced project. While I love the motion and flair of your
revision, I disagree in part. I really like the student nose wrintkes, it is more tense and
expressive. Student appears to going for an asymetrical -squint eye wide eye-
effect. I think this could have been preserved/improved. Removing the hand is a clear
compositional win.
reply
Stan, great idea to on a more advanced project. While I love the motion and flair of your
revision, I disagree in part. I really like the student nose wrintkes, it is more tense and
expressive. Student appears to going for an asymetrical -squint eye wide eye-
effect. I think this could have been preserved/improved. Removing the hand is a clear
compositional win.
reply
AtenAkaAton1
You can feel how you want, but that's not the point of this video. It's not about which picture you like better but which one is technically right. This is about learning how to do something, and it is that something they are learning how to do that should be the focus. See my prior statement again. PS Joe Mad's drawings are most definitely technically right
reply
You can feel how you want, but that's not the point of this video. It's not about which picture you like better but which one is technically right. This is about learning how to do something, and it is that something they are learning how to do that should be the focus. See my prior statement again. PS Joe Mad's drawings are most definitely technically right
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















