Facial Recognition: Can You Defeat it? Surprising New Risks in 2020 - Rob Braxman Tech
video description
Date: 2022-03-20
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 10
William
7: 22] This is an interesting legal question. I'm an amateur photographer, not a lawyer, but in general in the United States if you are in public, on public property you can take anyone's picture without their permission for your own use, but not for commercial use. If you take a person's photo, and they are 'recognizable, ' you cannot publish it for commercial purposes without their consent which means a model's release or a contract. So, if by definition any photo with facial recognition is 'recognizable' and it is used by a business as that 'commercial use' and legal consent required?
So, is collecting identifiable images of people [or other biometric data for that matter] with out consent, not publishing it but just holding in a database illegal?
reply
7: 22] This is an interesting legal question. I'm an amateur photographer, not a lawyer, but in general in the United States if you are in public, on public property you can take anyone's picture without their permission for your own use, but not for commercial use. If you take a person's photo, and they are 'recognizable, ' you cannot publish it for commercial purposes without their consent which means a model's release or a contract. So, if by definition any photo with facial recognition is 'recognizable' and it is used by a business as that 'commercial use' and legal consent required?
So, is collecting identifiable images of people [or other biometric data for that matter] with out consent, not publishing it but just holding in a database illegal?
reply
fred
Mrs Richards: -I paid for a room with a view! -
Basil: (pointing to the lovely view) -That is Torquay, Madam. -
Mrs Richards: -It's not good enough! -
Basil: -May I ask what you were expecting to see out of a Torquay hotel bedroom window? Sydney Opera House, perhaps? the Hanging Gardens of Babylon? Herds of wildebeest sweeping majestically past. -
Mrs Richards: -Don't be silly! I expect to be able to see the sea! -
Basil: -You can see the sea, it's over there between the land and the sky. -
Mrs Richards: -I'm not satisfied. But I shall stay. But I expect a reduction. -
Basil: -Why! Because Krakatoa's not erupting at the moment?
reply
Mrs Richards: -I paid for a room with a view! -
Basil: (pointing to the lovely view) -That is Torquay, Madam. -
Mrs Richards: -It's not good enough! -
Basil: -May I ask what you were expecting to see out of a Torquay hotel bedroom window? Sydney Opera House, perhaps? the Hanging Gardens of Babylon? Herds of wildebeest sweeping majestically past. -
Mrs Richards: -Don't be silly! I expect to be able to see the sea! -
Basil: -You can see the sea, it's over there between the land and the sky. -
Mrs Richards: -I'm not satisfied. But I shall stay. But I expect a reduction. -
Basil: -Why! Because Krakatoa's not erupting at the moment?
reply
Samantha
I don't think there is privacy for walking around that is viable IF we want many modern technologies that have very useful to you and I aspects. I would be happy for instance to never forget a name of someone I am introduced to. Of course you could do that without uploads to the cloud which are the main problematic aspect. If it stays on my own person device and on my own self-controlled cloud such as NextCloud then that is much much less worrisome.
Many techs btw are easy to get to 95% or 98% success rate but extremely hard to get closer to 100% For a long time this was true of OCR for instance.
reply
I don't think there is privacy for walking around that is viable IF we want many modern technologies that have very useful to you and I aspects. I would be happy for instance to never forget a name of someone I am introduced to. Of course you could do that without uploads to the cloud which are the main problematic aspect. If it stays on my own person device and on my own self-controlled cloud such as NextCloud then that is much much less worrisome.
Many techs btw are easy to get to 95% or 98% success rate but extremely hard to get closer to 100% For a long time this was true of OCR for instance.
reply
Steffy
CAN ANYONE recommend a book on theatrical makeup that i can use to change my looks enough to fake out facial recognition? im willing to use the new face and create different ZUCKBOOK ACCOUNTS ETC. im willing to pay to have a 3d scan of me with the new faces (would create as many as possible) so others could duplicate the image so my new faces could be photographed in many locations at the same time, maybe even committing crimes just to ZUCK with the system!
reply
CAN ANYONE recommend a book on theatrical makeup that i can use to change my looks enough to fake out facial recognition? im willing to use the new face and create different ZUCKBOOK ACCOUNTS ETC. im willing to pay to have a 3d scan of me with the new faces (would create as many as possible) so others could duplicate the image so my new faces could be photographed in many locations at the same time, maybe even committing crimes just to ZUCK with the system!
reply
The
Hmmm. Apple never claimed that they use facial recognition so they would suggest photos to friends. They use facial recognition in a closed manner (at least it looks like) to be able to tell who's in your photos to add labels and keywords to your photo collection FOR YOU, locally in iPhoto. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how I see it so far. Also, you can easily turn it off.
reply
Hmmm. Apple never claimed that they use facial recognition so they would suggest photos to friends. They use facial recognition in a closed manner (at least it looks like) to be able to tell who's in your photos to add labels and keywords to your photo collection FOR YOU, locally in iPhoto. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how I see it so far. Also, you can easily turn it off.
reply
Jason
In New Zealand we have poker machines in every bar, if you have a gambling problem you can get yourself banned, as soon as you walk in to the room a notification goes on at the bar and they come in and tell you that you can-t be in here.
reply
In New Zealand we have poker machines in every bar, if you have a gambling problem you can get yourself banned, as soon as you walk in to the room a notification goes on at the bar and they come in and tell you that you can-t be in here.
reply
James
Do you seriously think that laws against facial recognition tracking will have any effect? I don-t. We already have a lot of laws. Unfortunately what we don-t have is a lot of ways for the little guy to see those laws enforced.
reply
Do you seriously think that laws against facial recognition tracking will have any effect? I don-t. We already have a lot of laws. Unfortunately what we don-t have is a lot of ways for the little guy to see those laws enforced.
reply
Dave
The Hong Kong protestors came up with some kind of light emitter that would project some light onto their faces to bypass AI facial recognition. I wish I could find that news story. I'm sure in the future that won't even work.
reply
The Hong Kong protestors came up with some kind of light emitter that would project some light onto their faces to bypass AI facial recognition. I wish I could find that news story. I'm sure in the future that won't even work.
reply
jeff
Thank you for your videos, i just wish more people took this serious before its too late, which it probably is. Is there any hope for our privacy in the future? No i really think its too late to expect privacy.
reply
Thank you for your videos, i just wish more people took this serious before its too late, which it probably is. Is there any hope for our privacy in the future? No i really think its too late to expect privacy.
reply
Craig
LOL. how appropriate that members of congress were identified as criminals. Once they get the technology better, then maybe they will start getting more hits on light skinned members of congress as well? LOL
reply
LOL. how appropriate that members of congress were identified as criminals. Once they get the technology better, then maybe they will start getting more hits on light skinned members of congress as well? LOL
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
