Porsche 911 v AMG GT v Aston Vantage v BMW M8: 0-60mph, 1/4-mile & REVIEW
video description
Date: 2025-04-11
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 20
exoroxx
Mat, please be gentle to that well-aged BMW. It's the last BMW of its kind: Good design, almost perfect iDrive system with real buttons, nice materials, decent performance without any electrification and overall good design (I just have to mention it once more.
But the M8 is not a sports car like all three other competitors want to be: It's a Gran Turismo. You don't celebrate the speed - you celebrate that you don't get a clue of it while you're speeding on the Autobahn.
reply
Mat, please be gentle to that well-aged BMW. It's the last BMW of its kind: Good design, almost perfect iDrive system with real buttons, nice materials, decent performance without any electrification and overall good design (I just have to mention it once more.
But the M8 is not a sports car like all three other competitors want to be: It's a Gran Turismo. You don't celebrate the speed - you celebrate that you don't get a clue of it while you're speeding on the Autobahn.
reply
berwynluxe2751
The M8 is the best. very sad it's being stopped. Love Matt, but you wrong. On everything you say about the M8. I agree with most of your stuff for ten years. But the M8 is a gem. That Aston is a Merc, with a dire complicated ugly probably faulty dash. The 911 gear stick is a memory stick. How did they think would look good I will miss the M8. But not any of the others, when they stop. But probably not the 911 which you did own. recently So no biased views
reply
The M8 is the best. very sad it's being stopped. Love Matt, but you wrong. On everything you say about the M8. I agree with most of your stuff for ten years. But the M8 is a gem. That Aston is a Merc, with a dire complicated ugly probably faulty dash. The 911 gear stick is a memory stick. How did they think would look good I will miss the M8. But not any of the others, when they stop. But probably not the 911 which you did own. recently So no biased views
reply
johnmuzic3475
for the price that aston wants, it should be a mid 2 second car, not 3. 55. although here in the USA it sounds so much better and breathes freer and hits 60 in 2. 7 seconds, that's what some owners have gotten. British cars are a good bit slower and more quiet than the US versions.
reply
for the price that aston wants, it should be a mid 2 second car, not 3. 55. although here in the USA it sounds so much better and breathes freer and hits 60 in 2. 7 seconds, that's what some owners have gotten. British cars are a good bit slower and more quiet than the US versions.
reply
clubsobri
You should do the videos like this more. Because istead of dragging, you just run them yourself and really get the best time of the car, and that is what is fastest. Versus getting people who can't drive for crap doing bad launches and making the cars look slower.
reply
You should do the videos like this more. Because istead of dragging, you just run them yourself and really get the best time of the car, and that is what is fastest. Versus getting people who can't drive for crap doing bad launches and making the cars look slower.
reply
jjohur
The interiors are crazy busy with way too many buttons/dials. The Porsche has too much high-tech technology. There's a lot to go wrong and the maintenance has to be horrendous for these cars. Thank you but I'll keep my EV after dumping my MB AMG, Audi RS5/S6.
reply
The interiors are crazy busy with way too many buttons/dials. The Porsche has too much high-tech technology. There's a lot to go wrong and the maintenance has to be horrendous for these cars. Thank you but I'll keep my EV after dumping my MB AMG, Audi RS5/S6.
reply
carwow
So much hate for the m8. It looks the best there, despite me being a porsche fan, the m8 looks the best there. The interior is much better than benz. I would rather have a simpler interior yet beautiful than a interior full of cheap plastics (benz)
reply
So much hate for the m8. It looks the best there, despite me being a porsche fan, the m8 looks the best there. The interior is much better than benz. I would rather have a simpler interior yet beautiful than a interior full of cheap plastics (benz)
reply
carwow
It's such a shame there isn't any real manuals anymore. Speed isn't everything
Matt you guys should host a drag racing competition at that air strip. It would be massive. So the public can bring their cars and race the quarter mile.
reply
It's such a shame there isn't any real manuals anymore. Speed isn't everything
Matt you guys should host a drag racing competition at that air strip. It would be massive. So the public can bring their cars and race the quarter mile.
reply
kevinjekyll1521
I love the Porsche just not those front grills, they just to my mind not flow with the looks of the car. And that Aston, wow as always a looker. BMW and Mercedes, just why, I own both older ones. great thought provoking clip.
reply
I love the Porsche just not those front grills, they just to my mind not flow with the looks of the car. And that Aston, wow as always a looker. BMW and Mercedes, just why, I own both older ones. great thought provoking clip.
reply
Drs4432
For me the merc has the worst infotainment system mainly bcs of that HUGE bezel, like c'mon we're in 2025 and they can't even trim down a bezel If we're still in 2014-2016 i'm okay with it bcs phone, tablets etc has massive bezel too
reply
For me the merc has the worst infotainment system mainly bcs of that HUGE bezel, like c'mon we're in 2025 and they can't even trim down a bezel If we're still in 2014-2016 i'm okay with it bcs phone, tablets etc has massive bezel too
reply
Superzesh101
I would genuinely struggle to choose which one I'd have. They all look stunning, perform brilliantly and have their unique points.
If I had to drop one, it would be the Merc because of the interior. It looks so good though.
reply
I would genuinely struggle to choose which one I'd have. They all look stunning, perform brilliantly and have their unique points.
If I had to drop one, it would be the Merc because of the interior. It looks so good though.
reply
itaholic902
The Aston is by far the best looking car, both inside and out. No idea why people like the 911 so much: it looks boring, sounds awful and is full of cheap plastic, especially the front splitter and rear diffuser.
reply
The Aston is by far the best looking car, both inside and out. No idea why people like the 911 so much: it looks boring, sounds awful and is full of cheap plastic, especially the front splitter and rear diffuser.
reply
mikedawkins346
I disagree. The Porsche seems like the Lexus of the bunch meaning it does EVERYTHING well. I feel like you should be a hooligan in one of these cars and the Aston seems to have hooliganism in spades.
reply
I disagree. The Porsche seems like the Lexus of the bunch meaning it does EVERYTHING well. I feel like you should be a hooligan in one of these cars and the Aston seems to have hooliganism in spades.
reply
DIVEnSOME
That 911 is a real leap forward for porsche, can’t wait for the hybrid tech to trickle down to the base bare bones car the plain carrera, because that’s all you need, in guards red with a sunroof
reply
That 911 is a real leap forward for porsche, can’t wait for the hybrid tech to trickle down to the base bare bones car the plain carrera, because that’s all you need, in guards red with a sunroof
reply
ykx777
The M8 actually has the best sounding exhaust here but idk what's up with your guys' BMWs in europe with soft limiters. We dont have these in the states the M8 COMP burbles and gurgles hard
reply
The M8 actually has the best sounding exhaust here but idk what's up with your guys' BMWs in europe with soft limiters. We dont have these in the states the M8 COMP burbles and gurgles hard
reply
Reko_89
The Aston Martin steals my heart and is my #1 choice but the 911 is simply the greatest sports car of all time! Will ALWAYS be valedictorian of the segment. Porsche just gets it RIGHT!
reply
The Aston Martin steals my heart and is my #1 choice but the 911 is simply the greatest sports car of all time! Will ALWAYS be valedictorian of the segment. Porsche just gets it RIGHT!
reply
kidkaos3
Would you please stop putting adults in the backseats! Good grief, those seats are for kids. Get a 11 & 5 year old so we have a realistic practicality sense of the rear seat room.
reply
Would you please stop putting adults in the backseats! Good grief, those seats are for kids. Get a 11 & 5 year old so we have a realistic practicality sense of the rear seat room.
reply
haniaboudi1218
I watched the video till he reached the interior ranking, thr Porsche is by the far the ugliest and most cheap feeling on the interior, it's the one with the most plastic
reply
I watched the video till he reached the interior ranking, thr Porsche is by the far the ugliest and most cheap feeling on the interior, it's the one with the most plastic
reply
gileshorton8282
Porsche. All day. Every day. I have a turbo S and this is close! I love Astons but and as for the Merc and BMW: god no. Peak BMW and Merc was years and years ago.
reply
Porsche. All day. Every day. I have a turbo S and this is close! I love Astons but and as for the Merc and BMW: god no. Peak BMW and Merc was years and years ago.
reply
carwow
The Aston is great, but that amg is the first amg gt that i think looks complete. Previous versions just looked meh, soft, not it. This one is just so damn hot.
reply
The Aston is great, but that amg is the first amg gt that i think looks complete. Previous versions just looked meh, soft, not it. This one is just so damn hot.
reply
mholmes9262
I agree 100% about the front end of the Porsche. Great car, but the front is less attractive than the base version. Overall, though, the one I'd take home.
reply
I agree 100% about the front end of the Porsche. Great car, but the front is less attractive than the base version. Overall, though, the one I'd take home.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
