
Can you solve the Tricky Logical Puzzle The Clever Commuter
video description
Date: 2023-11-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 22
Devon
I think it is easier, if you assume that she leaves at a specific time each day, such as 5 pm to reach him at 6 pm, so a 120 minute trip each day, 60 minutes to go and 60 minutes to return (since her speed is constant. Then the day he began to walk at 5 pm (normally he waits at the station at 6 pm, but that day he was there at 5 pm and immediately began to walk), she was leaving to pick him up, did so, then both arrived at home 10 minutes earlier than normal. So the to and from trip was 110 minutes. Therefore it took her 55 minutes to go and 55 minutes to return. So her husband walked for 55 minutes. Answer 55 minutes
reply
I think it is easier, if you assume that she leaves at a specific time each day, such as 5 pm to reach him at 6 pm, so a 120 minute trip each day, 60 minutes to go and 60 minutes to return (since her speed is constant. Then the day he began to walk at 5 pm (normally he waits at the station at 6 pm, but that day he was there at 5 pm and immediately began to walk), she was leaving to pick him up, did so, then both arrived at home 10 minutes earlier than normal. So the to and from trip was 110 minutes. Therefore it took her 55 minutes to go and 55 minutes to return. So her husband walked for 55 minutes. Answer 55 minutes
reply
Jessica
Love it, but no, no, no. women don't typically time things to the minute like this. I bet Jack's wife usually waits for his train coming in and is sitting there already. Maybe she doesn't come directly from home but from work/shopping/Mark's house (ooh la la) to pick him up. Also, important detail. why the heck is he an hour early? DID YOU GET FIRED JACK? Got to schedule in the awkward 'whoa, what's happened? ' conversation! Maybe she drove home ultra slow or super fast because she was upset about the change to schedule. and she nearly got caught out with Mark! :D
reply
Love it, but no, no, no. women don't typically time things to the minute like this. I bet Jack's wife usually waits for his train coming in and is sitting there already. Maybe she doesn't come directly from home but from work/shopping/Mark's house (ooh la la) to pick him up. Also, important detail. why the heck is he an hour early? DID YOU GET FIRED JACK? Got to schedule in the awkward 'whoa, what's happened? ' conversation! Maybe she drove home ultra slow or super fast because she was upset about the change to schedule. and she nearly got caught out with Mark! :D
reply
War_Reimon
I Would appreciate a system of equation to understand your point of view. It is stood that both arrive ten minutes earlier that the usual time.
Your solution stands that she is the only person to save 10 minutes and it means change the original initial premise.
Here we have 3 variables, time only car, time walking and time by car after walking. 2 known things initial time driving, and initial time walking. As one can see the system is incomplete.
reply
I Would appreciate a system of equation to understand your point of view. It is stood that both arrive ten minutes earlier that the usual time.
Your solution stands that she is the only person to save 10 minutes and it means change the original initial premise.
Here we have 3 variables, time only car, time walking and time by car after walking. 2 known things initial time driving, and initial time walking. As one can see the system is incomplete.
reply
Raj
According to me the answer should be 50 minutes, because you have mentioned that his wife will move through constant speed. So of all the time that will be saved will before reaching the station because after that she would take normal time to reach there. So if she would met 10 minutes earlier, then only they would reach ten minutes earlier. Please check and reply.
reply
According to me the answer should be 50 minutes, because you have mentioned that his wife will move through constant speed. So of all the time that will be saved will before reaching the station because after that she would take normal time to reach there. So if she would met 10 minutes earlier, then only they would reach ten minutes earlier. Please check and reply.
reply
Quadratic4mula
I got the same answer. BTW. Just wanted to share. However, my only concern is, he got to the train station 1 hour early + walked for 55 minutes but only saved 10 minutes? Something about that really doesn't seem right. It's almost as if he really should have just stayed at the train station.
reply
I got the same answer. BTW. Just wanted to share. However, my only concern is, he got to the train station 1 hour early + walked for 55 minutes but only saved 10 minutes? Something about that really doesn't seem right. It's almost as if he really should have just stayed at the train station.
reply
SIDDHARTH
NOTE: THIS HOLDS TRUE ONLY IF THE SPEED OF CAR AND SPEED OF JACK IS SAME!
I think that 50 min is more appropriate answer as it was never mentioned that his wife drove from home to station. they save 10 min from station to home.
reply
NOTE: THIS HOLDS TRUE ONLY IF THE SPEED OF CAR AND SPEED OF JACK IS SAME!
I think that 50 min is more appropriate answer as it was never mentioned that his wife drove from home to station. they save 10 min from station to home.
reply
Don
For many days I got the answer 55 and was thinking how to calculate the distance, without looking entire video or comments. But I was screwed.
You could have just mentioned how much time, instead of how long.
reply
For many days I got the answer 55 and was thinking how to calculate the distance, without looking entire video or comments. But I was screwed.
You could have just mentioned how much time, instead of how long.
reply
education
Jack's wife normally leaves to pick him up at 5-59 and returns home at 6-01 - this day Jack walks 51 min and arrives home at 5-51 and catches her in bed with the pizza delivery boy. Poor Jack.
reply
Jack's wife normally leaves to pick him up at 5-59 and returns home at 6-01 - this day Jack walks 51 min and arrives home at 5-51 and catches her in bed with the pizza delivery boy. Poor Jack.
reply
nathan
The -clever commuter- walks for 55 minutes to get home 10 minutes early; that's not so clever. Hey Jack, go to the bar across from the station for an hour and get picked up at the usual time-
reply
The -clever commuter- walks for 55 minutes to get home 10 minutes early; that's not so clever. Hey Jack, go to the bar across from the station for an hour and get picked up at the usual time-
reply
Roger
Puzzle doesn't say Jack -immediately- began walking home at 5 o'clock. Maybe he hung around Green Valley a little trying to figure out what to do. had a drink. and then started walking.
reply
Puzzle doesn't say Jack -immediately- began walking home at 5 o'clock. Maybe he hung around Green Valley a little trying to figure out what to do. had a drink. and then started walking.
reply
William
I thought we were being asked the distance he walked not the duration. If its the time he walked should we not be asked how long did he walk -for-
reply
I thought we were being asked the distance he walked not the duration. If its the time he walked should we not be asked how long did he walk -for-
reply
Tech
It is not mentioned in the question that, she comes daily from home to pick him up. I thought she comes from somewhere else on another road
reply
It is not mentioned in the question that, she comes daily from home to pick him up. I thought she comes from somewhere else on another road
reply
Nada
Wow how environment really affect a riddle.
In my town, its common for the wife to pick up her husband on the way home from her work.
reply
Wow how environment really affect a riddle.
In my town, its common for the wife to pick up her husband on the way home from her work.
reply
newbie1234
If they both get back home 10 minutes earlier would jack not be walking for 50 mins since they got home both of them 10 mins early
reply
If they both get back home 10 minutes earlier would jack not be walking for 50 mins since they got home both of them 10 mins early
reply
Adi
this is for readers of this comment -
in this question The time period Jack has walked in is asked (not distance as I thought earlier)
reply
this is for readers of this comment -
in this question The time period Jack has walked in is asked (not distance as I thought earlier)
reply
Dipak
What if his wife didn't notice him on walking besides the road. I think he has to tell earlier so that, 1 hour could've been saved.
reply
What if his wife didn't notice him on walking besides the road. I think he has to tell earlier so that, 1 hour could've been saved.
reply
saadman
in up downs wife saves 5+5 =10 min bcz he peregrinates - constant speed between home & green valley.
so there is no way out!
reply
in up downs wife saves 5+5 =10 min bcz he peregrinates - constant speed between home & green valley.
so there is no way out!
reply
Prasad
It's a bit confusing. How long did Jack walk doesn't clear the fact that whether you are asking for distance or time. Isn't it?
reply
It's a bit confusing. How long did Jack walk doesn't clear the fact that whether you are asking for distance or time. Isn't it?
reply
ratoim
55 minutes of walking to save 10 minutes of driving. Ugh, I think I'll just sit in the station and play on my phone.
reply
55 minutes of walking to save 10 minutes of driving. Ugh, I think I'll just sit in the station and play on my phone.
reply
weckar
The puzzle never says she CAME from home when picking him up. I assumed she picked him up on the way from her work!
reply
The puzzle never says she CAME from home when picking him up. I assumed she picked him up on the way from her work!
reply
Amit
Incorrect riddle question but good question for to identify data inadequacy as many people made good point above
reply
Incorrect riddle question but good question for to identify data inadequacy as many people made good point above
reply
MAXIM
No, Jack walked for 5 minutes
Since she saved 5 minutes each way, it means that Jack walked those 5 minutes
reply
No, Jack walked for 5 minutes
Since she saved 5 minutes each way, it means that Jack walked those 5 minutes
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















