
3 Children Ages Puzzle Brilliant puzzle
video description
. K started doing some tb ing else. so i was making the table later and got tiredm
. them decided to watch the table. when i saw only 12 amswers i got upset i didnt finish as i got 10. i just didnt even stop to think if I'll had a lot or few options. then i added them. but not alll. unsire u watched the video, yes ot was correct to add them. i decoded to finish thw addition. the i thiught, althiugh no idea how to interpret the last clue, that i should eliminate the ones are nort repeated. i got 6 amswers. i continue the video amd so thw answer were only 2. i though perhaps i have the multiplication table incomplete. then i realized the worst. i added wrong. just 2 options gave me the same number. i twice added wrong, having twice an equal resilt to another one. what a shame. mistake at additions.
Then i continue the video. no idea what the eldest could clu me into. nut as soon as th ey curcled numbwr 8 before explaining, i knew. slthiugh they could say one of the twins was born a minute earlier. but welll
I could have done this but i kept stioping and looking the answer before funishing. tjay is because from the begining i knew o could do the table but nk ot know how long it was and i knew i had no clue on the last part and wondered if il had to do something more difficult. and keep watching the video after every step. perhaps of mot i would have gonw longer tryong to get more data on the table bwfore eliminatimg ot
Date: 2023-11-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 28
Houssem
I solved by my own, very easy with my approach. Don-t begin with writing all combinations but try to use all the informations that you have,
1 - he already knows the sum of product 72 but he can-t figure out the exact age.
2 - the word -eldest- gave him the answer.
So we can understand that he found 2 corrects answers for the problem (product = 72 and sum = x, he know x but not me!
So => here I tried to figure out the first answer ( child 1 and 2 has the same age)
Than I tried with cube
From the highest 8-8 not good, 7 - 7 not good 6 - 6 good 5 - 5 not good, .
the only good answer is 6 - 6 - 2 = 72
But for me now, I know the sum that is 14.
I just try 72 / 3 = 24, (to begin with 3 for the youngest cause 2 can-t be possible )
24 is 6 - 4 ( sum of all Is 6 + 4 + 3 = 13) not good, Than I tried 8 - 3 - 3 sum = 14
==> the good answer.
Please tell me if my approach Is good or only solved with chance, thank you
reply
I solved by my own, very easy with my approach. Don-t begin with writing all combinations but try to use all the informations that you have,
1 - he already knows the sum of product 72 but he can-t figure out the exact age.
2 - the word -eldest- gave him the answer.
So we can understand that he found 2 corrects answers for the problem (product = 72 and sum = x, he know x but not me!
So => here I tried to figure out the first answer ( child 1 and 2 has the same age)
Than I tried with cube
From the highest 8-8 not good, 7 - 7 not good 6 - 6 good 5 - 5 not good, .
the only good answer is 6 - 6 - 2 = 72
But for me now, I know the sum that is 14.
I just try 72 / 3 = 24, (to begin with 3 for the youngest cause 2 can-t be possible )
24 is 6 - 4 ( sum of all Is 6 + 4 + 3 = 13) not good, Than I tried 8 - 3 - 3 sum = 14
==> the good answer.
Please tell me if my approach Is good or only solved with chance, thank you
reply
Devon
34And the eldest child is 'singular ' meaning 'one' child (not children) so as said below 3, 3 8 and 66 2 are the only two with same sum from looking at 1 x 2 x 2 x 2 x 3 x 3 as you get two pairs of '3' and two pairs of '3 x 2'.
The point is if his house number was 18 then his friend would have known that the children ages are: 8 9, and 1 since only sum of the these three ages gives 18 yet 8 x 9 x 1 =72. And if the house number was 19 (given that the friend knows this) then the friend would have known that their ages are 1, 6 and 12 since no other combination besides 1 6 and 12 has a sum of 19 the same is true for 13: (3 x 4 x 6) as 3 +4 +5=13 15: (4 x 2 x 9) as 4+2+9=15 17: 3 x 2 x 12 as 3+2 +12 =17 (which are sum of the product, 72. So the goal should be to find 2 combinations with similar sum and those are course 3, 3 8 and 6, 6 2, both have 14 as sum.
reply
34And the eldest child is 'singular ' meaning 'one' child (not children) so as said below 3, 3 8 and 66 2 are the only two with same sum from looking at 1 x 2 x 2 x 2 x 3 x 3 as you get two pairs of '3' and two pairs of '3 x 2'.
The point is if his house number was 18 then his friend would have known that the children ages are: 8 9, and 1 since only sum of the these three ages gives 18 yet 8 x 9 x 1 =72. And if the house number was 19 (given that the friend knows this) then the friend would have known that their ages are 1, 6 and 12 since no other combination besides 1 6 and 12 has a sum of 19 the same is true for 13: (3 x 4 x 6) as 3 +4 +5=13 15: (4 x 2 x 9) as 4+2+9=15 17: 3 x 2 x 12 as 3+2 +12 =17 (which are sum of the product, 72. So the goal should be to find 2 combinations with similar sum and those are course 3, 3 8 and 6, 6 2, both have 14 as sum.
reply
Garryplaysapex
So David knew the sum but was confused between if there was eldest child or eldest children (coz he got clarified by the eldest child sentence) so both the combinations had same sum. Now in 3, 3, 2, 2, 2 only 6, 6, 2 had same age of eldest children( which is wrong combination but sum is equal to the right one) then directly we can figure out (2x2x2, 3, 3 will be the right one coz it equals to 14. no need of all the calculations. P. S. I thought this in the waiting time and skipped to the end to see the answer. Not bragging or anything but I think its a simpler approach while the end conclusion is same that they had same sum!
reply
So David knew the sum but was confused between if there was eldest child or eldest children (coz he got clarified by the eldest child sentence) so both the combinations had same sum. Now in 3, 3, 2, 2, 2 only 6, 6, 2 had same age of eldest children( which is wrong combination but sum is equal to the right one) then directly we can figure out (2x2x2, 3, 3 will be the right one coz it equals to 14. no need of all the calculations. P. S. I thought this in the waiting time and skipped to the end to see the answer. Not bragging or anything but I think its a simpler approach while the end conclusion is same that they had same sum!
reply
MrMousley
So.
I got a piece of paper out and wrote down every way that there was to get 72 from the product of three numbers. and then I went through the list and added those three numbers up to see which ones gave the same answer (because if they all had different answers then David would know the answer if he knew the house number). and then I looked to see which of those answers came from three different numbers (because one child had to be older). and then I thought, so that was the long way to do it, let's see the quick way. and that was the way to do it!
reply
So.
I got a piece of paper out and wrote down every way that there was to get 72 from the product of three numbers. and then I went through the list and added those three numbers up to see which ones gave the same answer (because if they all had different answers then David would know the answer if he knew the house number). and then I looked to see which of those answers came from three different numbers (because one child had to be older). and then I thought, so that was the long way to do it, let's see the quick way. and that was the way to do it!
reply
Oliver
tbh there is no need to make a sheet at all, david realized what their ages were when he said he has an eldest son, which means there was an option with 2 older children having the same age and a younger child, that would only leave 6 6 2 as the only choice that can be eliminated because 6 is the highest number you can make 2 of from 2 - 2 - 2 - 3 - 3 which means the sum is 6+6+2 and you just need to find the other possibility which would be 8 3 3.
reply
tbh there is no need to make a sheet at all, david realized what their ages were when he said he has an eldest son, which means there was an option with 2 older children having the same age and a younger child, that would only leave 6 6 2 as the only choice that can be eliminated because 6 is the highest number you can make 2 of from 2 - 2 - 2 - 3 - 3 which means the sum is 6+6+2 and you just need to find the other possibility which would be 8 3 3.
reply
Easy_S
Funny thing is that the parents of twins often refer to them as the eldest and the youngest. So whereas the idea behind this problem is valid the problem itself isn't. The last piece of information should have been more clear, like for instance -one kid is in 2nd grade- or -two kids don't go to elementary school yet- (for answer 3-3-8) or -the youngest doesn't have all her teeth yet- (for answer 2-6-6.
reply
Funny thing is that the parents of twins often refer to them as the eldest and the youngest. So whereas the idea behind this problem is valid the problem itself isn't. The last piece of information should have been more clear, like for instance -one kid is in 2nd grade- or -two kids don't go to elementary school yet- (for answer 3-3-8) or -the youngest doesn't have all her teeth yet- (for answer 2-6-6.
reply
Geert
Actually the logic can be applied even more elegantly. You don't have to write down any combination. Just realize that the outcome switxhes from unknown to known after mentioning 'eldest'. Then you know already you just eliminated a combination with twins as eldest, which can only be 2-6-6. Then you just have to find the other combi that has 14 as sum. No pencil and paper required.
reply
Actually the logic can be applied even more elegantly. You don't have to write down any combination. Just realize that the outcome switxhes from unknown to known after mentioning 'eldest'. Then you know already you just eliminated a combination with twins as eldest, which can only be 2-6-6. Then you just have to find the other combi that has 14 as sum. No pencil and paper required.
reply
nico
no need to write down all possible combinations. it must be 2 x 2 x 2 x 3 x 3. david assumes the older children might have the same age. this is only possible having 2x3 and 2x3, while the other child is 2. hence house number is 14. if the oldest children is 2x2x3 the sum would be already too high, so only 2x2x2 remains for the oldest and 3 / 3 for the others.
reply
no need to write down all possible combinations. it must be 2 x 2 x 2 x 3 x 3. david assumes the older children might have the same age. this is only possible having 2x3 and 2x3, while the other child is 2. hence house number is 14. if the oldest children is 2x2x3 the sum would be already too high, so only 2x2x2 remains for the oldest and 3 / 3 for the others.
reply
Joel
This one always bugged me because of the fact that two children can be the same age in years but born at different times of the year. And that twins have an older/younger sibling as well. I get it, but there are technicalities with this problem that these videos seem very good at avoiding most of the time.
reply
This one always bugged me because of the fact that two children can be the same age in years but born at different times of the year. And that twins have an older/younger sibling as well. I get it, but there are technicalities with this problem that these videos seem very good at avoiding most of the time.
reply
Aaron
Solved it a lot more quickly using the logic that David would know the kid's ages unless there were twins. Any scenario where the number was used only once he'd know their ages. it becomes a much smaller table when 2 of the 3 numbers have to match.
reply
Solved it a lot more quickly using the logic that David would know the kid's ages unless there were twins. Any scenario where the number was used only once he'd know their ages. it becomes a much smaller table when 2 of the 3 numbers have to match.
reply
Ghosh
Puzzle by Logically Yours - A person talking to another person regarding his children's age and house number.
Same puzzle by Ted-Ed - 3 of you have to save the world. If you can't identify the pass code, you'll be feeded to giant salamanders-
reply
Puzzle by Logically Yours - A person talking to another person regarding his children's age and house number.
Same puzzle by Ted-Ed - 3 of you have to save the world. If you can't identify the pass code, you'll be feeded to giant salamanders-
reply
Rnk
If two of their ages are 6, it doesnt mean they are twins, one may born are january and the other on december and there are many possibilties of both born on same year so there is a logical error but the solution is awesome
reply
If two of their ages are 6, it doesnt mean they are twins, one may born are january and the other on december and there are many possibilties of both born on same year so there is a logical error but the solution is awesome
reply
Night
I got the eldest child thing, but there's no guarantee that they were twins. One could be 6 years and 1 month and the other just turned 6 meaning the former child would be older hence still considered the -eldest child-.
reply
I got the eldest child thing, but there's no guarantee that they were twins. One could be 6 years and 1 month and the other just turned 6 meaning the former child would be older hence still considered the -eldest child-.
reply
Michael
I assumed that the children were minors, so I ignored sets with 18 or higher. Fortunately I still got the solution. The dude with a 72 year old and 1 year old twins must have an interesting story.
reply
I assumed that the children were minors, so I ignored sets with 18 or higher. Fortunately I still got the solution. The dude with a 72 year old and 1 year old twins must have an interesting story.
reply
Sewing
Love this puzzle, but I prefer to end with the question, -what was the door number? -. There is a much higher chance that they have understood the whole presentation if they can calculate this.
reply
Love this puzzle, but I prefer to end with the question, -what was the door number? -. There is a much higher chance that they have understood the whole presentation if they can calculate this.
reply
Harker
That's not exactly right as just because two children are the same age does not always mean they're twins - I know.
I was born in January and my brother in December of the same year.
reply
That's not exactly right as just because two children are the same age does not always mean they're twins - I know.
I was born in January and my brother in December of the same year.
reply
Joe
I got the answer but it is just dumb that the oldest twin can't be the oldest. Also know people that are born about 10 months apart and Alex can also have different baby mamas.
reply
I got the answer but it is just dumb that the oldest twin can't be the oldest. Also know people that are born about 10 months apart and Alex can also have different baby mamas.
reply
blargg
Two of the children could have the same age when rounded to years yet have been born 9 months apart. Also sometimes one twin is considered older when it was born first.
reply
Two of the children could have the same age when rounded to years yet have been born 9 months apart. Also sometimes one twin is considered older when it was born first.
reply
Rob
I have twins. My son was born 15 mins before my daughter. He is my eldest child. Therefore there still is not enough info unless David knows Alex does not have twins
reply
I have twins. My son was born 15 mins before my daughter. He is my eldest child. Therefore there still is not enough info unless David knows Alex does not have twins
reply
Mahesh
I thought it was 2, 4, 9. because children aged more than 6 are interested in solving puzzles (including the hard ones. so I thought they might be the answers
reply
I thought it was 2, 4, 9. because children aged more than 6 are interested in solving puzzles (including the hard ones. so I thought they might be the answers
reply
Sharat
Who is such a friend who is so close to know your -door number- but doesn't know since when you might have had children and what their ages could be?
reply
Who is such a friend who is so close to know your -door number- but doesn't know since when you might have had children and what their ages could be?
reply
Kevin
Love your stuff but this just isn't true. There is an eldest even with twins.
Especially there is an eldest if they were 10-11 months apart.
reply
Love your stuff but this just isn't true. There is an eldest even with twins.
Especially there is an eldest if they were 10-11 months apart.
reply
Douglas
You said that 2 children with the same age 6 must be twins, this is not necessary the case. One could be just 6 and the other nearly 7.
reply
You said that 2 children with the same age 6 must be twins, this is not necessary the case. One could be just 6 and the other nearly 7.
reply
Mr
And what about 2, 3, 12 and 2, 4, 9 having sum of 15? i prefer the solution 2, 3, 12, as 12 is more realistic age to enjoy puzzles than 8.
reply
And what about 2, 3, 12 and 2, 4, 9 having sum of 15? i prefer the solution 2, 3, 12, as 12 is more realistic age to enjoy puzzles than 8.
reply
Devon
only 3 x 3 x 8 and 6 x 6 x 2 have the same sum, 14. the eldest is 8 when he said, 'the eldest love playing puzzle answer = 3, 3 and 8
reply
only 3 x 3 x 8 and 6 x 6 x 2 have the same sum, 14. the eldest is 8 when he said, 'the eldest love playing puzzle answer = 3, 3 and 8
reply
savitri
This is sooo easy, the answer is No, because he asked can you tell the three ages not what is the age of the three lol
reply
This is sooo easy, the answer is No, because he asked can you tell the three ages not what is the age of the three lol
reply
William
A bit misleading. I thought that David only knew the house number from the facts not that he knew it beforehand
reply
A bit misleading. I thought that David only knew the house number from the facts not that he knew it beforehand
reply
Krzysztof
I missed the option of one of the children being 1year old. Lucky for me, this didn't change the answer
reply
I missed the option of one of the children being 1year old. Lucky for me, this didn't change the answer
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















