Can robots be creative? - Gil Weinberg
video description
Date: 2020-08-22
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 10
315am
I see a lot of intelligent people in the comments not really touching on the fact that humans have souls. Do people of science not believe this? Im not up to date on that. I think the question should be if humans were able to replicate a soul would it be considered an authentic pure soul? I would say no. I think the root of music and all creativity is derived from the soul. In theory I believe this is something that can not be made or replicated authentically. The creativity of a man-made soul would not be organic. So it would therefore be synthetic creativity at the heart of it. This is the one place I believe humans will always have the edge over AI and robots. We will always have organic creativity. (Im not an expert.
reply
I see a lot of intelligent people in the comments not really touching on the fact that humans have souls. Do people of science not believe this? Im not up to date on that. I think the question should be if humans were able to replicate a soul would it be considered an authentic pure soul? I would say no. I think the root of music and all creativity is derived from the soul. In theory I believe this is something that can not be made or replicated authentically. The creativity of a man-made soul would not be organic. So it would therefore be synthetic creativity at the heart of it. This is the one place I believe humans will always have the edge over AI and robots. We will always have organic creativity. (Im not an expert.
reply
Francesco
I think that we associate creativity with art, but that's not necessarely true. As the video shows, creative robots have already been made. What hasn't been made is artistic robots.
It's not that something has to be aware to make an artistic creation, but one must make such creation so that it shows an idea or a point of view.
Because a thing is creating something beatifull, but another is creating something beautifull and meaningfull.
One doesn't require awareness to develope art, one requires Ideas to transform into art to create art.
reply
I think that we associate creativity with art, but that's not necessarely true. As the video shows, creative robots have already been made. What hasn't been made is artistic robots.
It's not that something has to be aware to make an artistic creation, but one must make such creation so that it shows an idea or a point of view.
Because a thing is creating something beatifull, but another is creating something beautifull and meaningfull.
One doesn't require awareness to develope art, one requires Ideas to transform into art to create art.
reply
Fre
Well music isnt the best example I think. I mean look at skrillex, that sounds pretty random. Or even Hardstyle.
There is an AI that created a story on its own by analyzing hundreds of books. It isnt well written and the wording sometimes is quite off, but it is actually fun to watch and the story has all kind of elements. Suspends, Love, Friendship.
They even made a movie out of it with randomized characters and what not.
just gotta look for This short film is written entirely ba AI
reply
Well music isnt the best example I think. I mean look at skrillex, that sounds pretty random. Or even Hardstyle.
There is an AI that created a story on its own by analyzing hundreds of books. It isnt well written and the wording sometimes is quite off, but it is actually fun to watch and the story has all kind of elements. Suspends, Love, Friendship.
They even made a movie out of it with randomized characters and what not.
just gotta look for This short film is written entirely ba AI
reply
Serik4538
Does it really matters Who or What it created! - Answer: Yes! It matter. We are humans, we have empathy and soul. (insert here expecting question such like but what is empathy or what is a soul? Its just fake human creation and blah blah blah. Even if AI learn from 1000 books and mimic an good book, its still imitation. and you may not agree with me, but creativity NEED a human TOUCH.
reply
Does it really matters Who or What it created! - Answer: Yes! It matter. We are humans, we have empathy and soul. (insert here expecting question such like but what is empathy or what is a soul? Its just fake human creation and blah blah blah. Even if AI learn from 1000 books and mimic an good book, its still imitation. and you may not agree with me, but creativity NEED a human TOUCH.
reply
TheXInventor
What if, instead of comparing one generated piece to a prewritten standard, the program created multiple tracks with different mutations and had humans rate which ones they preferred?
I mean, that's pretty much how human art works. Creators put work out there, and audiences react to what they find appealing
reply
What if, instead of comparing one generated piece to a prewritten standard, the program created multiple tracks with different mutations and had humans rate which ones they preferred?
I mean, that's pretty much how human art works. Creators put work out there, and audiences react to what they find appealing
reply
Norma
There is no ideal melody fit to every sequence or event; if your basing your test on evolution. Evolution doesn't have the ideal biological processes it changes to what's needed. Your creativity test is fundamentally flawed not to mention most people can't come up with original ideas without using the internet.
reply
There is no ideal melody fit to every sequence or event; if your basing your test on evolution. Evolution doesn't have the ideal biological processes it changes to what's needed. Your creativity test is fundamentally flawed not to mention most people can't come up with original ideas without using the internet.
reply
pizzahot
If we make machines that feel, they'll start demanding rights. And if we're not careful these rights could be a danger to our own. After all, we are flesh and bone and they are wires and metal.
reply
If we make machines that feel, they'll start demanding rights. And if we're not careful these rights could be a danger to our own. After all, we are flesh and bone and they are wires and metal.
reply
NortheastGamer
As I was watching this I was thinking This is like, almost a decade late considering what AI does today then I checked the date. Damn, have we really come so far in so little time?
reply
As I was watching this I was thinking This is like, almost a decade late considering what AI does today then I checked the date. Damn, have we really come so far in so little time?
reply
Playful
The year now is 2020 and AI can now create a website based on what the clients want and also can make a male portrait into female and can manipulate and copy voices
reply
The year now is 2020 and AI can now create a website based on what the clients want and also can make a male portrait into female and can manipulate and copy voices
reply
Ao
That xylophone robot thing actually exists. Its called shimon. Another piece of music you hear in this video is also played by the shimis, but composed by a human
reply
That xylophone robot thing actually exists. Its called shimon. Another piece of music you hear in this video is also played by the shimis, but composed by a human
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
