
What if the Holy Roman Empire Remained United?
video description
Calling the Hungarian Kingdom primitive is a very ignorant comment. The Kingdom of Hungary was just as developed as the corresponding Medieval German states of the region and era. Trade between the East and the West flowed via Hungary, and Hungary a lynchpin in relations with the Eastern Roman Empire (several Hungarian kings had close familial ties the Constantinople. During the Renaissance, Hungary rivalled the Italian city states in the development of the arts and philosophy.
A strong German empire would also have had implications on how the Hungarians interacted with surrounding nations. Hungary was a very powerful nation under King Louis, KIng Sigismund (who was also Holy Roman emperor) and King Matthias. Hungary was only weakened after a decade's long war a succession, which probably would not have not taken place in the scenario mentioned above.
With all its size and power, the Holy Roman Empire would have had a hard time fighting wars on all fronts, so an alliance of sorts would probably have been more realistic. Conversely, the Polish nobility may have petitioned the Hungarian Crown to help them against the Holy Roman Empire. Also, the Ottomans may have been routed by a combined Hungarian-German army. The variations are endless.
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
Kensig
I love your videos, but there is one thing that is bugging me everytime you mention the HRE; it never was Germany. It was a multilingual, multicultural, multiethnic, decentralized confederacy of free cities, duchies and Kingdoms. These states had their own laws, currency, languages (even Thuringian/Saxon german wasn't inter-intelligible with Bavarian german until begining of the 19th century, tax policies and armies! It annoys me quite a lot since it's the equivalent of saying that the EU is Germany because germans are the dominant ethno-national-linguist group of the union, but everybody with some degree of education knows this isn't the case. The EU is btw more centralized than the HRE ever was!
reply
I love your videos, but there is one thing that is bugging me everytime you mention the HRE; it never was Germany. It was a multilingual, multicultural, multiethnic, decentralized confederacy of free cities, duchies and Kingdoms. These states had their own laws, currency, languages (even Thuringian/Saxon german wasn't inter-intelligible with Bavarian german until begining of the 19th century, tax policies and armies! It annoys me quite a lot since it's the equivalent of saying that the EU is Germany because germans are the dominant ethno-national-linguist group of the union, but everybody with some degree of education knows this isn't the case. The EU is btw more centralized than the HRE ever was!
reply
JHAYKHAY25
I'm not entirely sure about England and France in this timeline. The English were often aware of the balance of power on the continent thing and all it would have taken to get the English and French to magically forget their differences would have been one emperor to start throwing his weight around with England or one English or French king to be smart enough to realise if the empire swallowed up either country the other was in serious trouble. Then again, the English nobles often made a stack of cash out of wars with France so that temptation might have been just a little too much for the English to be thinking about a potential future.
reply
I'm not entirely sure about England and France in this timeline. The English were often aware of the balance of power on the continent thing and all it would have taken to get the English and French to magically forget their differences would have been one emperor to start throwing his weight around with England or one English or French king to be smart enough to realise if the empire swallowed up either country the other was in serious trouble. Then again, the English nobles often made a stack of cash out of wars with France so that temptation might have been just a little too much for the English to be thinking about a potential future.
reply
Andy
One thing that would be cool to see is that the Crusader States last longer. Frederick II was also King of Jerusalem but was defeated by John of Beirut in the War of the Lombards. With the Empire more powerful, I can see Frederick winning. And with the Crusader States in personal union with the most powerful country in Europe they probably be able to withstand the Mamluke sultanate and maybe even Conquer Egypt, making the Hohenstaufen dynasty even more wealthy and powerful. It would remarkable to see the Imperial Banner Fly over the Jordan and the Nile.
reply
One thing that would be cool to see is that the Crusader States last longer. Frederick II was also King of Jerusalem but was defeated by John of Beirut in the War of the Lombards. With the Empire more powerful, I can see Frederick winning. And with the Crusader States in personal union with the most powerful country in Europe they probably be able to withstand the Mamluke sultanate and maybe even Conquer Egypt, making the Hohenstaufen dynasty even more wealthy and powerful. It would remarkable to see the Imperial Banner Fly over the Jordan and the Nile.
reply
Stefan
And then, Adolphus II. Mussolini gets elected emperor in 1876 and ruins it all. The Inca, who had managed to remain independent due to their wealth in precious metals, became Christians in the 16th and 17th century and largely industrialised in the 19th, take over all European colonies first in South, then Central and North America during the ensuing Great Transcontinental War and emerge as the new superpower of the 20th century.
reply
And then, Adolphus II. Mussolini gets elected emperor in 1876 and ruins it all. The Inca, who had managed to remain independent due to their wealth in precious metals, became Christians in the 16th and 17th century and largely industrialised in the 19th, take over all European colonies first in South, then Central and North America during the ensuing Great Transcontinental War and emerge as the new superpower of the 20th century.
reply
Arcanite
Just because the Dutchies invaded Brazil, it doesn't means that the HRE would invade Brazil, the Dutchies just invaded because they were independent and because Portugal become one kingdom with Spain (Iberian Union, and it's possible that the Empire were still controlled by Habsburgs and Iberian Union too, so an Invasion of South America won't happen
reply
Just because the Dutchies invaded Brazil, it doesn't means that the HRE would invade Brazil, the Dutchies just invaded because they were independent and because Portugal become one kingdom with Spain (Iberian Union, and it's possible that the Empire were still controlled by Habsburgs and Iberian Union too, so an Invasion of South America won't happen
reply
Error
I can say that portuguese-brazilians would fiercly resist the occupiers, the poles-lithuanians would resist the occupiers, Italy would launch independence wars one after the other, not to mention wars in the Empire itself for control of the Imperial throne, like the Roman, the Empire would end overstretched, debilitated, and would meet its end.
reply
I can say that portuguese-brazilians would fiercly resist the occupiers, the poles-lithuanians would resist the occupiers, Italy would launch independence wars one after the other, not to mention wars in the Empire itself for control of the Imperial throne, like the Roman, the Empire would end overstretched, debilitated, and would meet its end.
reply
AMD_Fan_98
Lemme tell you somethin, if the 1st Reich conquered the Southern Hemisphere. me and many people watching this would not exist as the Germans would probably intermix with the natives of Central and South America, creating a new ancestral group of not Mestizos, but something completely different.
reply
Lemme tell you somethin, if the 1st Reich conquered the Southern Hemisphere. me and many people watching this would not exist as the Germans would probably intermix with the natives of Central and South America, creating a new ancestral group of not Mestizos, but something completely different.
reply
Vinh
Are you sure the Holy Roman Empire fell (unofficially) in 1200? I feel like after the protestant reformation and the 30 years war in the 17th century the division was very much prominent then earlier so I would say that was when the Empire at that point falls into the category of a confederation.
reply
Are you sure the Holy Roman Empire fell (unofficially) in 1200? I feel like after the protestant reformation and the 30 years war in the 17th century the division was very much prominent then earlier so I would say that was when the Empire at that point falls into the category of a confederation.
reply
Daisy
i love how people like to make it a punchline based on the words of some french guy who only described it towards the end of its existence. go back to the start of it and it was most definitely holy and and empire and arguably roman seeing how the city of rome literally declared it roman
reply
i love how people like to make it a punchline based on the words of some french guy who only described it towards the end of its existence. go back to the start of it and it was most definitely holy and and empire and arguably roman seeing how the city of rome literally declared it roman
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















