• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if China was a Colonial Superpower?

What if China was a Colonial Superpower?

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if China was a Colonial Superpower? Eric: If China became a colonial power from the 16th century then she'd probably colonized the entire Asia (except the Middle East, Siberia, the western coast of the American continent and East Africa. Mandarin would become the dominant language in the world and Confucianism, Daoism and Zen Buddhism would become the most populated religion in the world thanks to Chinese colonialism however there'll be a great colonial wars between China and other European colonial powers like Spain, Portugal, France and England much worst than the Opium Wars and the two World Wars!
Yes it'll had a good side on Chinese colonialism in the Age of Colonialism and Discovery however there'll be a huge consequence on it and that is a bloody and costly colonial wars all over the world when it happens. Probably World War I would had started somewhere in the 17th century instead of 1914. And yes it is safe to say that Chinese colonialism didn't happened and she just want to be a gentle giant.

Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


Wow. Starting with that title this went bass-ackwards down a hole lined with fundamental ahistorical delusions. Imperial China (so-called) has militarily colonized, politically annexed, and culturally absorbed neighboring polities in an almost ineluctable pulsating series of expansions over more than two millennia. Hanicization has been, for twenty-two centuries, the most significant mode of Chinese Imperialism. Applied gradually over long periods of time, Hanicization was so effective that it was the predominant means by which the Chinese reversed the situation in the two periods, Yuan and Ching, during which China was a subordinate part of someone elses empire.
reply

Quite possibly one of your most fascinating videos of all. I do, however think that you are underestimating Spain. I highly doubt the Spanish would idly stand by and allow the Chinese and the Japanese to just have their way with the continent. I think that the threat of these two rivals from Asia would keep them on their toes and prevent the decadence of the 17th and 18th centuries that led to the downfall of that empire. It also would not be stretched so thinly because it wouldnt have to be worrying about managing the Philippines. All of those forces and resources would be concentrated in North America. (you do know Mexico is in North America, right)
reply

Actually the Taiping Rebellion was a far worse atrocity than the Mongol Conquest, at Nearly 30 million total deaths it was worse even than the first world war (but not the second) which is impressive for a pre-modern society.
It's something of a poor contest to win, but the majority of the world's deadliest wars were Chinese civil conflicts, even Europe fails to live up to this legacy, the Napoleonic wars fall short of most Chinese conflicts and only WW1 and 2 really put us in the same league

reply

The tributary system that China used starting with the legendary Silk Road 2000 years ago achieved more or less the same as the colonial powers. Instead of military allies, China only wanted trade and one can see the large Chinese diaspora in South East Asia since the Ming dynasty followed by massive migration during the industrial revolution in the 19th century. Today the China influence can be seen all over the world with the existence of Chinatown in all continents.
reply

I think what you have said in 6: 20 was the opposite of the true situation. The Ming dynasty had a very strong army, and it had a navy which very few nations did at that time. The Qing dynasty's navy was no match for the British and was arguably even weaker than the Ming dynasty's. During the Ming dynasty, foreign powers (Iran, Portugal) also tried to invade China but both failed.
reply

Actually Zheng He's navy did mount naval cannons on board with a maximum range of 800-900 feet. In your timeline of a more expansionist China, its safe to assume its navy would have made a lot more naval technological advancements from Zheng He's day so by the time they come into contact with Europeans, European ships would not only have been outsized, but outgunned.
reply

Many things about the original time line are not right in this video, like Manchus equiped western military technology better. In fact they are much less known to western military technology than the Ming, they relied on cavalry and more importantly by chance and defection of Han Chinese troops, because it was exactly a time when Ming was destroyed by peasent rebellion.
reply

China didn't colonize anything? LOL They have never been a global colonial power, but they have always been a colonial power within East Asia. They had countries in the region giving them offerings and how did they go from the Yellow River region to its territorial reach today, if they never expanded? The Manchurian Empire was much bigger too.
reply

If China discovered America they would introduce Afro-Eurasian diseases killing 90% of the population, but would be so slow to actually invade that by the time either the Chinese or the Europeans attempt to attack America the native populations would have recovered their numbers and wouldn't be able to be easily conquered anymore.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos