
What if the Huguenot Colonies Worked?
video description
-There was a Gold deposit in the brazilian state of Minas Gerais (part of huguenot control) and that would likely have caused a lot of conflict in the timeline, since either France would've tried to tax it and piss off the miners, or the French-brazilians would've gotten really rich and either way, it would change the timeline a lot.
-Also, the region gobbled up by the french in this timeline include the Southeast and South of Brazil, by far the richest regions in our timeline, combined making up 70% of modern brazil's economy, the areas left with the portuguese, the Caatinga and Amazon are not very useful for agriculture, or most economic activities for that matter, the only suitable part would be a thin strip of fertile rainforest along the coast, whatever colony was left for the portuguese would be significantly poorer than our timeline's brazil and would likely crumble as soon as it lost direct portuguese support.
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
Billie
WWI: You forget that a significant number of North American immigrants were from German states. (Thanks to the Thirty Years War. Also to William Penn, who founded Pennsylvania based on religious freedom and invited the Quakers, Shakers, Presbyterians, Baptists, Lutherans, Catholics, Jews, Anabaptists, Amish & Mennonites to come to Pennsylvania. And the farmland was rich & fertile) Pennsylvania was founded mostly by people of German ancestry. I've heard that German was almost the national language. Even in our time line, there were questions on whether the German farm boys of Pennsylvania (and across the west) would be willing to fight against their German cousins in Germany. Getting the USA into the war, on the English side, was not a sure thing. Mostly the German politicians & diplomats were really jerks.
reply
WWI: You forget that a significant number of North American immigrants were from German states. (Thanks to the Thirty Years War. Also to William Penn, who founded Pennsylvania based on religious freedom and invited the Quakers, Shakers, Presbyterians, Baptists, Lutherans, Catholics, Jews, Anabaptists, Amish & Mennonites to come to Pennsylvania. And the farmland was rich & fertile) Pennsylvania was founded mostly by people of German ancestry. I've heard that German was almost the national language. Even in our time line, there were questions on whether the German farm boys of Pennsylvania (and across the west) would be willing to fight against their German cousins in Germany. Getting the USA into the war, on the English side, was not a sure thing. Mostly the German politicians & diplomats were really jerks.
reply
bladefox2298
I think that the USA would win in North America, the central powers in Europe and the French Brazilian nation would win in South America. I think that while the Heugenoet North America had industrialsed they would still have the after affects of slavery and would have a discontented black minority that could rebel and would cause significant problems for the Huegenoets. French Brazil would win because honestly their competition wasnt that great and Germany would win because I dont think any American nation would be able to support the entente with them focusing on their own part of the war and the Americans intervention basically winning the entente the war (even if their forces werent decisive, their intervention at least solved the morale and desertion problem.
reply
I think that the USA would win in North America, the central powers in Europe and the French Brazilian nation would win in South America. I think that while the Heugenoet North America had industrialsed they would still have the after affects of slavery and would have a discontented black minority that could rebel and would cause significant problems for the Huegenoets. French Brazil would win because honestly their competition wasnt that great and Germany would win because I dont think any American nation would be able to support the entente with them focusing on their own part of the war and the Americans intervention basically winning the entente the war (even if their forces werent decisive, their intervention at least solved the morale and desertion problem.
reply
Franklin
The industrial revolution with big textile(turning cotton into clothing) would not happened in the north if it wasn't for the potato famine! A blithe that attack the single type of potatoes grow throughout Europe but especially Ireland! Ireland who population exploded years before because of the potato being able to grow in poor rocky soil which was the land of the poor! The population explosions feed the rising industrial revolution in Europe and led to Europe abolishing slavery! You poor you go into debt you be sold or you sell your children into sevebt instrumental 70 sherbet he's a servant
reply
The industrial revolution with big textile(turning cotton into clothing) would not happened in the north if it wasn't for the potato famine! A blithe that attack the single type of potatoes grow throughout Europe but especially Ireland! Ireland who population exploded years before because of the potato being able to grow in poor rocky soil which was the land of the poor! The population explosions feed the rising industrial revolution in Europe and led to Europe abolishing slavery! You poor you go into debt you be sold or you sell your children into sevebt instrumental 70 sherbet he's a servant
reply
Hazel
The Spanish a bunch of scatterbrains! For your information, no one achieved more with less resources than the New World Spaniards. Almost always outnumbered on land, and almost always outgunned at sea, they at times accomplished the impossible. From defeating powerful tribes like the Aztecs, Incas and Mayas; to successfully defending the bulk of their territories from the British, French, Dutch and Portuguese; to fighting off the Spanish Peninsular and gaining independence. Scatterbrains, not really. The Spanish in the New World are more like the most underrated warriors in history.
reply
The Spanish a bunch of scatterbrains! For your information, no one achieved more with less resources than the New World Spaniards. Almost always outnumbered on land, and almost always outgunned at sea, they at times accomplished the impossible. From defeating powerful tribes like the Aztecs, Incas and Mayas; to successfully defending the bulk of their territories from the British, French, Dutch and Portuguese; to fighting off the Spanish Peninsular and gaining independence. Scatterbrains, not really. The Spanish in the New World are more like the most underrated warriors in history.
reply
John
The Huguenot nation in North America should surely be called _Outremer. _
There are enough whackos who believe that when the Knights Templar spoke of Outremer, they meant the New World, not Palestine.
An interesting question is, if the French colony in South America retained its original name of France Antarctique, what would the continent at the South Pole be called when it was eventually discovered? My suggestion: New America, since it is clearly the third continent of the New World.
reply
The Huguenot nation in North America should surely be called _Outremer. _
There are enough whackos who believe that when the Knights Templar spoke of Outremer, they meant the New World, not Palestine.
An interesting question is, if the French colony in South America retained its original name of France Antarctique, what would the continent at the South Pole be called when it was eventually discovered? My suggestion: New America, since it is clearly the third continent of the New World.
reply
Ours
Very interesting. As someone who grew up in Quebec, our history teachers never told us about those attempts by the Huguenots to make colonies. We learn about Jacques Cartier's 3 expeditions in Canada between 1534 and 1541 and his failed attempt to settle permanently in 1541, but then we go straight to Champlain in the 1600's. Maybe because the school dont want to talk about protestants. Also, I think Brazilian and Florida colonies would've made France even more rich and powerful in the 1600's.
reply
Very interesting. As someone who grew up in Quebec, our history teachers never told us about those attempts by the Huguenots to make colonies. We learn about Jacques Cartier's 3 expeditions in Canada between 1534 and 1541 and his failed attempt to settle permanently in 1541, but then we go straight to Champlain in the 1600's. Maybe because the school dont want to talk about protestants. Also, I think Brazilian and Florida colonies would've made France even more rich and powerful in the 1600's.
reply
Francisco
There's a very big hole here, and it is assuming that the 7 years war, assuming it happens, would result in Britain obtaining the lands of New France, and the United States inheriting it.
That makes almost no sense when a strong French nation just sitting there in the South, controlling the mouth of the Mississippi. If the Huguenots didn't get New France from France when declaring independence, they'd get it from the Brits even the US declares independence.
reply
There's a very big hole here, and it is assuming that the 7 years war, assuming it happens, would result in Britain obtaining the lands of New France, and the United States inheriting it.
That makes almost no sense when a strong French nation just sitting there in the South, controlling the mouth of the Mississippi. If the Huguenots didn't get New France from France when declaring independence, they'd get it from the Brits even the US declares independence.
reply
Caleb
Its such a pain every time someone says the south didnt want to industrilize. Look I know yall have heard of the cornerstone speach, go read it sometime. The very first complaint in the speach was that the south bought industrial machinery from europe, and they were taxed on it, only for the tax to go north to help build northern industry, so no the south wasnt anti industry, the south was anti paying for northern industry at the cost of their own.
reply
Its such a pain every time someone says the south didnt want to industrilize. Look I know yall have heard of the cornerstone speach, go read it sometime. The very first complaint in the speach was that the south bought industrial machinery from europe, and they were taxed on it, only for the tax to go north to help build northern industry, so no the south wasnt anti industry, the south was anti paying for northern industry at the cost of their own.
reply
David
What you described is exactly what happened, with the south/southeast of Brazil becoming industrialised, and the north/northeast suffering the aftermath of colonial era. The difference is that our southeast had a huge slave population and legacy. Brazilian, here. The other thing that you forgot to factor is the huge wealth of gold and diamond reserves in Minas Gerais, that probably would change the dynamic between France and the Brazilian colony.
reply
What you described is exactly what happened, with the south/southeast of Brazil becoming industrialised, and the north/northeast suffering the aftermath of colonial era. The difference is that our southeast had a huge slave population and legacy. Brazilian, here. The other thing that you forgot to factor is the huge wealth of gold and diamond reserves in Minas Gerais, that probably would change the dynamic between France and the Brazilian colony.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















