• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if Goliath Killed David?

What if Goliath Killed David?

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if Goliath Killed David? Surfing: I can tell you read Wikipedia for some of this. OT Judaism was not polytheistic. That does not mean that Jews didn't worship other gods, the OT itself basically says they did this over and over. However, saying that OT Judaism was polytheistic because people went against the religion and worshipped other gods would be like someone saying that Christians worship Mary because some Catholics take it too far. Wikipedia is a terribly slanted source for anything political or religious.
Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


4: 56 what about the Assyrians and Armenians then? Why are you not surprised that these survived? I understand the Armenians, being hardy mountain people, but is there a particular reason why Assyrians remained?
Also, you love to always shove Mithraism into every christianity machine broke scenario, but do you think there is a chance that the Greeks would invent a monotheistic religion out of Platonism, in a way similar to how Brahmanism came to be in India?

reply

I disagree with the whole humanity being less technologically developed, like you said beyond the Mediterranean empire they carve out it's entirely unknown what could happened, but plenty of races have contributed to advancing humanities technology, it's all about sharing ideas, and an empire that big happening so much earlier then it did in our timeline means ideas could spread around much earlier then it does in our timeline.
reply

C'mon, none of them were really powerful, probabilly the Assyrians would have conquered them easily, and the various state cities in the Mediterranean weren't a match for Rome, look at Syracuse, they destroied an Athenian' s army but the romans mopped the floor with them, while fighting Hannibal!
reply

A good sequel to this video.
What if David had remained a mercenary with the Philistines? (The King wanted him to stay but the military leadership didn't trust him. Or, what if Saul had killed David (He tried to impale David with a spear but missed?

reply

6: 01 There were definitely a lot, but can you really be certain that there were more outside the Greek homeland than in it? I can't really imagine that being the case until the Hellenistic period since their colonies usually didn't go to far inland.
reply

although you could argue egypt was screwed from the. start the preists controled the country the pharophs depended on it too much and they did not have any charlgmanes or any other type of good leader.
reply

Wrong depiction of the encient Hebrews ( not the modern day European Jews who are converts ) but interesting story. But hey Whitewashing History is what they do the Victors get to rewrite History.
reply

hehe, if this was to be the case, the moral triumph of wisdom over physical strength becomes null and void. Which in a morbid turn of events seems to be whats happenign in the modern world right now
reply

Abrahamic religions would still exist but vastly different. Just without the tale of David and by extension all narrative trees derived from this person.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos