
Who Would Win in a Chess Match, Someone Who Can See the Future or Someone Who Can Read Minds? Puzzle
video description
Person B - See the future
First we have to identify if it make sense that the future can or cannot be changed.
Person B: Looks into the future quickly and sees who wins. If he wins, he won't look into the future. If he loses, he basically gives up. That is if we assume that the future can be changed. Because if he gives up, then he can change the future.
If person B sees the future and whatever he sees means that he has to perform the action. That will bring him a different mode of thought, and might change the future. That is if Person B cannot change the future.
So, if we assume that the future can change, then the mind reader will win because everything that Person B can see can be nullified by the mind reader. The mind reader can see what Person B sees but Person B cannot see what the mind reader see in his mind.
The best thing to do to increase the chances of winning is for Person B not to use his powers. But, Person B will still think. So he would lose. While Person B is thinking for his move, Person A can analyze the way of thinking, Person B has. Therefore, he knows Person B's goal for his moves. Once Person A understand Person B's goal, then he can use that to his advantage. He does not need to know which move Person B will do, he only needs his intention why Person B moves in such a way. And he can use that to win. If ever Person B uses his power, since chess games are long, Person A can think for his moves while he frequently sees if Person B is looking at the future. If he does, then he can nullify that. And he can identify whether or not Person B is just thinking or actually looking into the future because if he is just thinking attempting to deceive Person A, Person B will know because visualizing positions is obscure and if ever Person B do that, it will affect his performance, so he won't. Person A can win the game. under such conditions.
Whatever Person B sees Person A can see and nullify, and whatever Person A can read or see, Person B cannot. Person A can use Person B's power for his own advantage. That is, again, if the future can be changed. IF it does, Person B cannot trust what he sees, leaving his power useless.
But, if the future can't be changed. They would be obligated to play and we will not know who will win. Because, if Person B sees himself winning and Person A sees it as well, then whatever Person A does is futile. But, if Person B sees himself losing, Person A will inevitably win. It means that we do not have the ability to know who wins in such condition. Because, all forms of strategy is useless if the future can't change.
But, the possibilities change depending on the conditions.
Date: 2023-11-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 29
RoyVsTheWorld
(This is copied and pasted from a TikTok comment section I posted. That's why it's numbered like that)-
I got two versions. A Spiritual version and a Technological version. Here they are: -
[1] V1: Spiritual version --
[2] The F. S. practices magic or witchcraft or whatever and so the F. S. ends up allowing demons or spirits to possess him for each of his turns. -
[3] As the spirit possesses his body, the spirit controls his arm movement as the F. S. gets into a meditative state where he's not thinking about. -
[4] His arm moving at all during his turn to prevent the M. R. to read his thoughts on his movements. -
[Final] The F. S. also prepared before this and picked a spirit who can ALSO see into the future as well. So the F. S. wins. Debate is over now. -
[Honest realization] I just realized mine is kinda flawed too just now tbh LOL. But I wanna know what y'all think about this first. I'm curious-
I'll update y'all-
[1] V2: The Technological version --
[2] This time the F. S. utilizes his Neurolink by using a clever strategy to finesse the game off of the M. R. And this is how it works. -
[3] Once it's the F. S. 's turn, instead of the F. S. using his raw brain to move a piece (because obviously, doing so would be vulnerable for. -
[4] the M. R. to read his thoughts) The F. S. instead will communicate to his Neurolink Consciously, for making the next move, but he does so in a way. -
[5] where he tells it what to do, and then the Neurolink will record his thoughts, download it, and then the Neurolink will control his hands to. -
[6] make his moves for him. -
[7] NOW, you're probably thinking -Well that just means the M. R. can read his mind on what he's communicating to his Neurolink- and yes. -
[8] you are correct. But now here's where the finesse comes in. -
[9] In the Neurolink's software, there is a feature called -smart desync-. What this software A. I. technology does for him, it collects his. -
[10] personality and his SUBCONSCIOUS mind. So every time he communicates to his Neurolink, the M. R. will read it, yeah but, once the desync HAPPENS-
[11] the Neurolink will desync away from what the F. S. actually and what he originally told it to do and it will play out a RNG, shuffle up his. -
[12] possibilities and then play out his move each turn-
[13] Making the Mind Reader unable to read his mind. Case closed. -
[1] -Forgot to mention for #6- And just like in the previous version I made. when the -smart desync- happens. He put himself in a meditative state. -
[2] Or the Neurolink does it for him. So that way he can think of no thoughts as the Neurolink plays out his moves for him
reply
(This is copied and pasted from a TikTok comment section I posted. That's why it's numbered like that)-
I got two versions. A Spiritual version and a Technological version. Here they are: -
[1] V1: Spiritual version --
[2] The F. S. practices magic or witchcraft or whatever and so the F. S. ends up allowing demons or spirits to possess him for each of his turns. -
[3] As the spirit possesses his body, the spirit controls his arm movement as the F. S. gets into a meditative state where he's not thinking about. -
[4] His arm moving at all during his turn to prevent the M. R. to read his thoughts on his movements. -
[Final] The F. S. also prepared before this and picked a spirit who can ALSO see into the future as well. So the F. S. wins. Debate is over now. -
[Honest realization] I just realized mine is kinda flawed too just now tbh LOL. But I wanna know what y'all think about this first. I'm curious-
I'll update y'all-
[1] V2: The Technological version --
[2] This time the F. S. utilizes his Neurolink by using a clever strategy to finesse the game off of the M. R. And this is how it works. -
[3] Once it's the F. S. 's turn, instead of the F. S. using his raw brain to move a piece (because obviously, doing so would be vulnerable for. -
[4] the M. R. to read his thoughts) The F. S. instead will communicate to his Neurolink Consciously, for making the next move, but he does so in a way. -
[5] where he tells it what to do, and then the Neurolink will record his thoughts, download it, and then the Neurolink will control his hands to. -
[6] make his moves for him. -
[7] NOW, you're probably thinking -Well that just means the M. R. can read his mind on what he's communicating to his Neurolink- and yes. -
[8] you are correct. But now here's where the finesse comes in. -
[9] In the Neurolink's software, there is a feature called -smart desync-. What this software A. I. technology does for him, it collects his. -
[10] personality and his SUBCONSCIOUS mind. So every time he communicates to his Neurolink, the M. R. will read it, yeah but, once the desync HAPPENS-
[11] the Neurolink will desync away from what the F. S. actually and what he originally told it to do and it will play out a RNG, shuffle up his. -
[12] possibilities and then play out his move each turn-
[13] Making the Mind Reader unable to read his mind. Case closed. -
[1] -Forgot to mention for #6- And just like in the previous version I made. when the -smart desync- happens. He put himself in a meditative state. -
[2] Or the Neurolink does it for him. So that way he can think of no thoughts as the Neurolink plays out his moves for him
reply
Lexx-o-
As always, the problem is in the formulation of the problem. While the words Oracle and Telepath seem to be intuitive, they don't really provide any specifics about how their powers work. That does not allow to draw any conclusions about the outcome of the game.
But if you theorize on coffee grounds, then.
1) if the oracle freely looks at every second of the game and can see all possible outcomes (like a supercomputer with an unlimited resource, then after each opponent's move it can re-select the winning sequence of moves - after all, it changes with each move. Then reading thoughts will not give anything, because after each move it will be another game, which each time develops in favor of the oracle.
To simplify, then for any move of a telepath, the oracle always has a sequence of moves leading to victory. And it doesn't matter if the telepath spied this move from the opponent or played the game himself.
But, let's say that the telepath is the same supercomputer as the oracle. Then, while the seer is looking through the options, choosing the path leading to victory, the mind reader can have time to peek and choose the sequence of moves leading to the defeat of the oracle. It turns out, as if one person plays an ideal game with himself. But. the oracle uses -its own power-, while the telepath tries -someone else's power-, at the level of the original user - here I think to give a point to the soothsayer.
2) Let's remove all these supercomputers from our thoughts and now we will assume that the opponents' forces work within 1 move.
Then, at the moment of HIS turn, the Oracle already knows the answer of the opponent. While the telepath, at the time of the OPPONENT's move, knows what move is expected of him. There's a paradox here.
3) The classic fantasy oracle sees the future fragmentarily. He does not control his power, but only uses small hints. Then, suppose that the predictor does not see the moves of the opponent, but only periodically can find out the outcome of the game. Here in this option the logic of the author of the video works perfectly. And all the bonuses go to the Telepath.
We get the following result: the outcome of the game largely depends on how the oracle's power works, as well as how well he himself can use it. Then stronger the oracle is, the less useful the Telepath is and vice versa.
reply
As always, the problem is in the formulation of the problem. While the words Oracle and Telepath seem to be intuitive, they don't really provide any specifics about how their powers work. That does not allow to draw any conclusions about the outcome of the game.
But if you theorize on coffee grounds, then.
1) if the oracle freely looks at every second of the game and can see all possible outcomes (like a supercomputer with an unlimited resource, then after each opponent's move it can re-select the winning sequence of moves - after all, it changes with each move. Then reading thoughts will not give anything, because after each move it will be another game, which each time develops in favor of the oracle.
To simplify, then for any move of a telepath, the oracle always has a sequence of moves leading to victory. And it doesn't matter if the telepath spied this move from the opponent or played the game himself.
But, let's say that the telepath is the same supercomputer as the oracle. Then, while the seer is looking through the options, choosing the path leading to victory, the mind reader can have time to peek and choose the sequence of moves leading to the defeat of the oracle. It turns out, as if one person plays an ideal game with himself. But. the oracle uses -its own power-, while the telepath tries -someone else's power-, at the level of the original user - here I think to give a point to the soothsayer.
2) Let's remove all these supercomputers from our thoughts and now we will assume that the opponents' forces work within 1 move.
Then, at the moment of HIS turn, the Oracle already knows the answer of the opponent. While the telepath, at the time of the OPPONENT's move, knows what move is expected of him. There's a paradox here.
3) The classic fantasy oracle sees the future fragmentarily. He does not control his power, but only uses small hints. Then, suppose that the predictor does not see the moves of the opponent, but only periodically can find out the outcome of the game. Here in this option the logic of the author of the video works perfectly. And all the bonuses go to the Telepath.
We get the following result: the outcome of the game largely depends on how the oracle's power works, as well as how well he himself can use it. Then stronger the oracle is, the less useful the Telepath is and vice versa.
reply
Steve
I disagree wholehearteldy.
First, assumptions:
Mind Reader (MR) Future Seer (FS)
I am presuming FS sees possible outcomes of the future, based on a PROBABILITY of them occurring. Otherwise, it is meaningless. Any other way, then the MR can simply NOT play the move he knows the FS has seen him play. It must be probablity of play, otherwise you have a paradox.
With these assumptions, the FS will contantly have his probabilities updated as the MR reads his thoughts and inserts his own calculation. Therefore the FS will gain, through the updating of probable states, the insight of the MR. The FS will also have his -miscalculation- corrected by the rise of probable futures that he considered were bad. There is an information loop here, where what the MR knows and FS knows gets constantly updated, which in turn, updates the probable states of the future. However.
The FS will have the advantage, since the FS, say he looks 3 moves in advance, and sees a variety of board states. His knowledge might look like
1. FS
2. MR
3. FS
Where 1 move is made by FS, a response by MR, and a response by FS. On his turn, the FS gains information on 3 moves in advance, and has the feedback loop mentioned in the assumptions to adjust the strength of the position from the updating probabilies of the MR's influence on his thoughts.
After the FS makes a move, the FS can simply stop thinking. Therefore, the MR is only given knowledge of
2. MR
3. FS
He only gets super knowledge of 2 ply.
Conversely, after the MR has moved, the FS turns his power on again, and gains knowledge of
3. FS
4. MR
5. FS
Therefore, the FS is always having the advantage of one more ply. In other words, in your min/max tree, the FS controls the power on his move, which is one ply less than the information the MR has on his move. The FS's power works independent of the MR. The MR's power is dependent upon the FS. Therefore, the control of information is soley in the FS's hands (mind.
Other neat little trick.
The futrue seer can presumably see what opening will be played the day before, allowing him to prepare only the lines of refutation, and none else, therefore giving the FS an information advantage.
reply
I disagree wholehearteldy.
First, assumptions:
Mind Reader (MR) Future Seer (FS)
I am presuming FS sees possible outcomes of the future, based on a PROBABILITY of them occurring. Otherwise, it is meaningless. Any other way, then the MR can simply NOT play the move he knows the FS has seen him play. It must be probablity of play, otherwise you have a paradox.
With these assumptions, the FS will contantly have his probabilities updated as the MR reads his thoughts and inserts his own calculation. Therefore the FS will gain, through the updating of probable states, the insight of the MR. The FS will also have his -miscalculation- corrected by the rise of probable futures that he considered were bad. There is an information loop here, where what the MR knows and FS knows gets constantly updated, which in turn, updates the probable states of the future. However.
The FS will have the advantage, since the FS, say he looks 3 moves in advance, and sees a variety of board states. His knowledge might look like
1. FS
2. MR
3. FS
Where 1 move is made by FS, a response by MR, and a response by FS. On his turn, the FS gains information on 3 moves in advance, and has the feedback loop mentioned in the assumptions to adjust the strength of the position from the updating probabilies of the MR's influence on his thoughts.
After the FS makes a move, the FS can simply stop thinking. Therefore, the MR is only given knowledge of
2. MR
3. FS
He only gets super knowledge of 2 ply.
Conversely, after the MR has moved, the FS turns his power on again, and gains knowledge of
3. FS
4. MR
5. FS
Therefore, the FS is always having the advantage of one more ply. In other words, in your min/max tree, the FS controls the power on his move, which is one ply less than the information the MR has on his move. The FS's power works independent of the MR. The MR's power is dependent upon the FS. Therefore, the control of information is soley in the FS's hands (mind.
Other neat little trick.
The futrue seer can presumably see what opening will be played the day before, allowing him to prepare only the lines of refutation, and none else, therefore giving the FS an information advantage.
reply
Somewhat
So, assume both people are -rational-. Then, even if we assume that, ideally, the person who can read minds can read all the stuffs accurately and quickly, it doesn't mean that the person is able to counter each goal. For instance, one knows that the other wants to achieve goal X or knows information Y, but given what that person currently have, he/she don't necessarily know how to conceive a combination of moves that allow him/her to prevent the goals of the other person from happening. However, if one can see the future, and that -seeing- the future at some interval of time can potentially change the outcome within this interval (if the person takes a different course of action presently, that person can see maybe at any time to 1000000 years ahead, and if Chess has be solved, then that person can just use that combination of moves that won't make him/her lose (maybe even see how Aliens play this game lol. In this case, AT MOST, it leads to the tie for both people. But assuming the one who can see the future can follow each move perfectly, he/she never loses. Also, since that person who sees the future plays either Black or White, he doesn't have to check the move set that leads the opponent (Black or White) to always win; hence, the other one doesn't necessarily know what to play even if he/she is able to see what the dude will play. So, in this case, the other side has -high possibility- of losing. But even if Chess isn't solved, that person who sees the future can just pick the moves from the future games played by professionals or A. Is that allow him/her to get through each turn, and to win ultimately without caring much about how the opponent plays. So, even if the other is able to read mind, he/she doesn't even know what to play. So, there's a way higher chance of winning for the one who sees the future. But all of that is assuming that both sides are aware of how to exploit their power as much as possible.
reply
So, assume both people are -rational-. Then, even if we assume that, ideally, the person who can read minds can read all the stuffs accurately and quickly, it doesn't mean that the person is able to counter each goal. For instance, one knows that the other wants to achieve goal X or knows information Y, but given what that person currently have, he/she don't necessarily know how to conceive a combination of moves that allow him/her to prevent the goals of the other person from happening. However, if one can see the future, and that -seeing- the future at some interval of time can potentially change the outcome within this interval (if the person takes a different course of action presently, that person can see maybe at any time to 1000000 years ahead, and if Chess has be solved, then that person can just use that combination of moves that won't make him/her lose (maybe even see how Aliens play this game lol. In this case, AT MOST, it leads to the tie for both people. But assuming the one who can see the future can follow each move perfectly, he/she never loses. Also, since that person who sees the future plays either Black or White, he doesn't have to check the move set that leads the opponent (Black or White) to always win; hence, the other one doesn't necessarily know what to play even if he/she is able to see what the dude will play. So, in this case, the other side has -high possibility- of losing. But even if Chess isn't solved, that person who sees the future can just pick the moves from the future games played by professionals or A. Is that allow him/her to get through each turn, and to win ultimately without caring much about how the opponent plays. So, even if the other is able to read mind, he/she doesn't even know what to play. So, there's a way higher chance of winning for the one who sees the future. But all of that is assuming that both sides are aware of how to exploit their power as much as possible.
reply
Joel
I jumped to the solution. If a mind reader played Magnus Carlsen and the mind reader is a 1000 elo player (or any substantially weaker chess player) that person will be expected to lose obviously. Even if you could read minds, you'd have to understand the lines you were reading in Magnus's brain and then assess the position at the end of those lines to know which moves you should play in response to Magnus's planned moves. Otherwise you'll just pick one of the moves Magnus worked through in deciding how to move and since you're not good at chess chances you're not going to pick the same move a super GM would pick and thus you'll lose, almost all of the time. If you assume Magnus always thinks about the best move for his opponent then you'll have a better chance to draw but I'm not sure why you'd assume that your opponent, Magnus in my example, will always be thinking that such and such move is the optimal move for his opponent. Perhaps sometimes he does, but often I'm guessing he's assessing several possibilities and positions aren't perfectly clear and multiple moves might seemingly have some merit. In sum, I don't think this is a good logic problem, although it still might be fun to debate.
reply
I jumped to the solution. If a mind reader played Magnus Carlsen and the mind reader is a 1000 elo player (or any substantially weaker chess player) that person will be expected to lose obviously. Even if you could read minds, you'd have to understand the lines you were reading in Magnus's brain and then assess the position at the end of those lines to know which moves you should play in response to Magnus's planned moves. Otherwise you'll just pick one of the moves Magnus worked through in deciding how to move and since you're not good at chess chances you're not going to pick the same move a super GM would pick and thus you'll lose, almost all of the time. If you assume Magnus always thinks about the best move for his opponent then you'll have a better chance to draw but I'm not sure why you'd assume that your opponent, Magnus in my example, will always be thinking that such and such move is the optimal move for his opponent. Perhaps sometimes he does, but often I'm guessing he's assessing several possibilities and positions aren't perfectly clear and multiple moves might seemingly have some merit. In sum, I don't think this is a good logic problem, although it still might be fun to debate.
reply
James
the future is not yet determined so to -see the future- indeed means to change the future. everyone already has the ability to -change- the future simply by the choices we make. so you are certainly wrong on that point
. for example if he sees a future of him losing the game he can just stop playing Lol he changed the future didn-t he. (any future he sees he could do the complete opposite and change it so yeah he can change the future if he can see the future. so. the mind reader could never ever ever win the game if the future seer doesn-t want him to- if he sees that the mind reader is gonna lose then they play that future out. if he sees that the mind reader wins then they don-t play- the end oh wait -nobody wins because the mind reader can read the mind of the future seer and thus also see the future so same thing from his perspective as the future seers. they never play and nobody wins because they both can see and change the future. as I described from the first perspective. and thus whoever sees the other guy winning decides not to play so they can never and will never play and no by an ever win
reply
the future is not yet determined so to -see the future- indeed means to change the future. everyone already has the ability to -change- the future simply by the choices we make. so you are certainly wrong on that point
. for example if he sees a future of him losing the game he can just stop playing Lol he changed the future didn-t he. (any future he sees he could do the complete opposite and change it so yeah he can change the future if he can see the future. so. the mind reader could never ever ever win the game if the future seer doesn-t want him to- if he sees that the mind reader is gonna lose then they play that future out. if he sees that the mind reader wins then they don-t play- the end oh wait -nobody wins because the mind reader can read the mind of the future seer and thus also see the future so same thing from his perspective as the future seers. they never play and nobody wins because they both can see and change the future. as I described from the first perspective. and thus whoever sees the other guy winning decides not to play so they can never and will never play and no by an ever win
reply
Rajat
I think it will always end in a draw regardless of who is weaker/stronger of the two. The reasoning is as follows. First, I will assume that the oracle not only sees the very next move, but he can see as far into the future as the end of the game. Second, the mind-reader can read the oracle's mind, and the oracle can see into the future, so essentially, the mind-reader can also see into the future. So this game can be -simplified- as one that is being played between two oracles. Call them A and B. Suppose that B wins the game. Then both A and B can see all the steps that lead to B's victory. However, assuming that each player is playing to win, A would want to change his moves after seeing the future in which B is victorious. But if A changes his moves, then we would have a different future than the one which he saw initially. So there is a contradiction. Similar argument holds for a future in which A is victorious instead of B, leading us to a place of contradiction. Therefore, we must have a future in which neither A nor B is victorious. And hence there can only be a draw.
reply
I think it will always end in a draw regardless of who is weaker/stronger of the two. The reasoning is as follows. First, I will assume that the oracle not only sees the very next move, but he can see as far into the future as the end of the game. Second, the mind-reader can read the oracle's mind, and the oracle can see into the future, so essentially, the mind-reader can also see into the future. So this game can be -simplified- as one that is being played between two oracles. Call them A and B. Suppose that B wins the game. Then both A and B can see all the steps that lead to B's victory. However, assuming that each player is playing to win, A would want to change his moves after seeing the future in which B is victorious. But if A changes his moves, then we would have a different future than the one which he saw initially. So there is a contradiction. Similar argument holds for a future in which A is victorious instead of B, leading us to a place of contradiction. Therefore, we must have a future in which neither A nor B is victorious. And hence there can only be a draw.
reply
Hedon
Chess is a 2dimensional game played by 3dimensional beings. The Oracle would likely win since, he would also be able to know what the mind reader will likely do in the future. One lives in the future the other in the present.
Example, if I know the 2012 economy will not return to regular, I would choose an outcome that will lead to success despite the majority anti factors; like becoming a visual artist despite all the unlikely success rates. A mind reader would just be able to know my moves without any understanding of what it all leads to.
However, what about higher dimensional beings playing the 5th and lower dimensions like civilizations vs chess. Imagine, jumping in and out of different realities. Imagine your body being a coded asset in different realities. That is how I imagine higher dimensional beings. If you ever programmed a video game from scratch then, you should know about reuasble assets and how the same asset class can exist in different game versions.
reply
Chess is a 2dimensional game played by 3dimensional beings. The Oracle would likely win since, he would also be able to know what the mind reader will likely do in the future. One lives in the future the other in the present.
Example, if I know the 2012 economy will not return to regular, I would choose an outcome that will lead to success despite the majority anti factors; like becoming a visual artist despite all the unlikely success rates. A mind reader would just be able to know my moves without any understanding of what it all leads to.
However, what about higher dimensional beings playing the 5th and lower dimensions like civilizations vs chess. Imagine, jumping in and out of different realities. Imagine your body being a coded asset in different realities. That is how I imagine higher dimensional beings. If you ever programmed a video game from scratch then, you should know about reuasble assets and how the same asset class can exist in different game versions.
reply
daniel
Depends on how the powers work. Let-s say that the Oracle will see every possible future and their are no limits. The mind reader will be able to -read- the Oracles mind even if there-s a language barrier and their are no limits. Then it will always be a draw. The mind reader will know every possible game just like the Oracle. Resulting in perfect chess. Which always ends in a draw. The mind reader and the Oracle both know every possible outcome and they will both know what the following moves are that the opponent plays for the rest of the game. It-s basically putting Stockfish 15. 1 against Stockfish 15. 1 which almost always ends in a draw. Sometimes it-s a win for either side because of the speed at which their playing combined with the color of each player. Out of a 1000 games I-d say like 996 would be draws and 2 wins for the mind reader and 2 wins for the Oracle.
reply
Depends on how the powers work. Let-s say that the Oracle will see every possible future and their are no limits. The mind reader will be able to -read- the Oracles mind even if there-s a language barrier and their are no limits. Then it will always be a draw. The mind reader will know every possible game just like the Oracle. Resulting in perfect chess. Which always ends in a draw. The mind reader and the Oracle both know every possible outcome and they will both know what the following moves are that the opponent plays for the rest of the game. It-s basically putting Stockfish 15. 1 against Stockfish 15. 1 which almost always ends in a draw. Sometimes it-s a win for either side because of the speed at which their playing combined with the color of each player. Out of a 1000 games I-d say like 996 would be draws and 2 wins for the mind reader and 2 wins for the Oracle.
reply
Taryth
The question seems fundamentally flawed without defining the powers of the Oracle. The example of 1. e4 is terrible since White goes first anyways. There is no difference seeing the opponent play e4 first or knowing he will play it. The real kicker is what happens after e4. Does the Oracle know for instance that white will play 2. Nc3 no matter what? If the Oracle can see the next opponent move, and that move cannot be changed, then it becomes easy to set traps that would lead to the Oracle winning every time, at long as the Oracle has sufficient skill level. It essentially gives the Oracle 2 consecutive moves since no move can perfectly defend against every move. If the move can be changed, then the Oracle effectively has no superpower.
Either way, the question seems completely one sided depending on the details of the powers.
reply
The question seems fundamentally flawed without defining the powers of the Oracle. The example of 1. e4 is terrible since White goes first anyways. There is no difference seeing the opponent play e4 first or knowing he will play it. The real kicker is what happens after e4. Does the Oracle know for instance that white will play 2. Nc3 no matter what? If the Oracle can see the next opponent move, and that move cannot be changed, then it becomes easy to set traps that would lead to the Oracle winning every time, at long as the Oracle has sufficient skill level. It essentially gives the Oracle 2 consecutive moves since no move can perfectly defend against every move. If the move can be changed, then the Oracle effectively has no superpower.
Either way, the question seems completely one sided depending on the details of the powers.
reply
Klimbo93
I don't agree with your logic. It seems you are not considering the interaction of their abilities rather than comparing one to the other. Also we should specify how seeing future works. In my hypothesis, the oracle can see different potential futures and by taking actions, he engages into one, while everyone else is destined to obey his choice.
Nontheless, since his mind is read by the other player, the latter gains knowledge on the future and present of his opponent. Then, the oracle loses the power to chose a future, since if that future makes the mind reader lose, he will know it and change it. Therefore the only future the oracle could see (chose from, is the one he would lose.
But I see we differ on how these powers are defined, which I guess is why mathematics doesn't mix well with magic: D
reply
I don't agree with your logic. It seems you are not considering the interaction of their abilities rather than comparing one to the other. Also we should specify how seeing future works. In my hypothesis, the oracle can see different potential futures and by taking actions, he engages into one, while everyone else is destined to obey his choice.
Nontheless, since his mind is read by the other player, the latter gains knowledge on the future and present of his opponent. Then, the oracle loses the power to chose a future, since if that future makes the mind reader lose, he will know it and change it. Therefore the only future the oracle could see (chose from, is the one he would lose.
But I see we differ on how these powers are defined, which I guess is why mathematics doesn't mix well with magic: D
reply
ChillMode
Your answer is a mistake. Neither PErson A or Person B will have all the moves they plan inside their head. The only time Person A will know the entire moves of Person B is when the game has ended. Person A has to rely on the intentions and patterns behind Person B is thinking. Person A does not have to waste his time and create his own moves alone. He can use Person B as a basis. Once he understands the system of thought Person B has and his goals then he can use that to win. Instead of countering each of his moves, he can counter the goal itself. And he will know whenever those goals change.
But, yeah, it depends on which one is better. Person A's power is useless if he does not know how to react to what he reads.
reply
Your answer is a mistake. Neither PErson A or Person B will have all the moves they plan inside their head. The only time Person A will know the entire moves of Person B is when the game has ended. Person A has to rely on the intentions and patterns behind Person B is thinking. Person A does not have to waste his time and create his own moves alone. He can use Person B as a basis. Once he understands the system of thought Person B has and his goals then he can use that to win. Instead of countering each of his moves, he can counter the goal itself. And he will know whenever those goals change.
But, yeah, it depends on which one is better. Person A's power is useless if he does not know how to react to what he reads.
reply
Maladict
Not thinking about this clearly. The ability to see the future entails the ability to process the inputs otherwise it's fairly generic as all people can do this it's called predicting the future not reading the future. The person who can read minds only has the strength of a normal human mind. Future reader wins easily as the person who can read minds mind blows up as he's used to at most following a few human minds. All the fluff that given is really basic and amounts to logically assuming perfect sets of data, not actually considering how the world works. This isn't a logic puzzle and trying to explain it as some sort of math problem shows a lack of understanding.
reply
Not thinking about this clearly. The ability to see the future entails the ability to process the inputs otherwise it's fairly generic as all people can do this it's called predicting the future not reading the future. The person who can read minds only has the strength of a normal human mind. Future reader wins easily as the person who can read minds mind blows up as he's used to at most following a few human minds. All the fluff that given is really basic and amounts to logically assuming perfect sets of data, not actually considering how the world works. This isn't a logic puzzle and trying to explain it as some sort of math problem shows a lack of understanding.
reply
pcnote
Mind reader will read the mind of the oracle, and will win the game for sure, because if you think that way mind reader will be able to handle both ability.
But Oracle can see the future, so he will be able to play all possible games in his mind to find witch one he will win. SO the game will end in DRAW, thats the logicall.
BUT will win the game who is a better player because has no computer able to play all possible games it will take longer than time in universe.
And for sure the Oracle not even arrive for the game if he can predict, he will not win considering mind reader cant read a mind that he dosen't know ho is.
reply
Mind reader will read the mind of the oracle, and will win the game for sure, because if you think that way mind reader will be able to handle both ability.
But Oracle can see the future, so he will be able to play all possible games in his mind to find witch one he will win. SO the game will end in DRAW, thats the logicall.
BUT will win the game who is a better player because has no computer able to play all possible games it will take longer than time in universe.
And for sure the Oracle not even arrive for the game if he can predict, he will not win considering mind reader cant read a mind that he dosen't know ho is.
reply
sorsocksfake
The mindreader wins. This is because they must have agreed to the match, else it wouldn't happen. Now, the oracle already knew the outcome, and the mindreader then read the outcome and agreed to it anyway.
Someone, therefore, chose to lose. Now, there's no reason to assume the mindreader would do so. But there's every reason to believe the oracle would, because he does so all the time. Every bad decision he makes, he knows it's a bad decision. He just never challenges fate. So it's entirely plausible that he looked to see if he'd win, found he would lose, and then followed that fate anyway.
reply
The mindreader wins. This is because they must have agreed to the match, else it wouldn't happen. Now, the oracle already knew the outcome, and the mindreader then read the outcome and agreed to it anyway.
Someone, therefore, chose to lose. Now, there's no reason to assume the mindreader would do so. But there's every reason to believe the oracle would, because he does so all the time. Every bad decision he makes, he knows it's a bad decision. He just never challenges fate. So it's entirely plausible that he looked to see if he'd win, found he would lose, and then followed that fate anyway.
reply
Cringe
The mind reader would need to go through much more effort to actually read the future person-s mind. The mind reader also can only read the opponent-s mind AFTER the oracle decides its move, so faster games with blitz and bullet would have oracle on top.
Although the game would almost always end up in a draw, if the oracle sees a future in which he wins, then fate can-t change who wins or loses.
If the oracle can see the future it should just follow a line that ties/wins in the shortest possible amount of moves, it never specified how far the oracle could see into the future
reply
The mind reader would need to go through much more effort to actually read the future person-s mind. The mind reader also can only read the opponent-s mind AFTER the oracle decides its move, so faster games with blitz and bullet would have oracle on top.
Although the game would almost always end up in a draw, if the oracle sees a future in which he wins, then fate can-t change who wins or loses.
If the oracle can see the future it should just follow a line that ties/wins in the shortest possible amount of moves, it never specified how far the oracle could see into the future
reply
Sandy
The oracle would win. Since he can see the future, he would likely become aware that he is playing someone who can read minds. Therefore, he can come up with a game plan to confuse the mind reader by thinking about multiple moves all at once and deciding how to move from there. Additionally, just because the mind reader can read minds does not mean that he knows how to play chess. Also, Oracle would have already played the game since he can already see it and change the game if he sees a future where he loses. He has the power of hindsight which the mind reader would not.
reply
The oracle would win. Since he can see the future, he would likely become aware that he is playing someone who can read minds. Therefore, he can come up with a game plan to confuse the mind reader by thinking about multiple moves all at once and deciding how to move from there. Additionally, just because the mind reader can read minds does not mean that he knows how to play chess. Also, Oracle would have already played the game since he can already see it and change the game if he sees a future where he loses. He has the power of hindsight which the mind reader would not.
reply
Rohit
I'd say that the game won't even start because it's a paradox as both will know each other's next move & whatever they do, it will change the future outcome which had been earlier seen & that's where a paradox comes.
Oracle sees all the moves which will be used by him & other opponent but as soon as he sees that in brain, the mind-reader will also know this & to change the outcome, he'll be changing his move but if he would change his move then it's the violation of the events which oracle saw as a future. Therefore, The game won't be possible because of the paradox
reply
I'd say that the game won't even start because it's a paradox as both will know each other's next move & whatever they do, it will change the future outcome which had been earlier seen & that's where a paradox comes.
Oracle sees all the moves which will be used by him & other opponent but as soon as he sees that in brain, the mind-reader will also know this & to change the outcome, he'll be changing his move but if he would change his move then it's the violation of the events which oracle saw as a future. Therefore, The game won't be possible because of the paradox
reply
Bhuvan
If oracle sees himself losing in the game, he can change the future? But then if he saw the future and changed it, what future was it?
If oracle sees himself winning, does it mean future was already predetermined?
So combining the 2 scenarios, if Oracle sees the future, irrespective of whether he is winning or losing in the future, the predetermined future can be changed.
But if it can be changed, it is predetermined anymore.
So, this scenario itself is a flaw. And it is wrong to assume whether Oracle won or not
reply
If oracle sees himself losing in the game, he can change the future? But then if he saw the future and changed it, what future was it?
If oracle sees himself winning, does it mean future was already predetermined?
So combining the 2 scenarios, if Oracle sees the future, irrespective of whether he is winning or losing in the future, the predetermined future can be changed.
But if it can be changed, it is predetermined anymore.
So, this scenario itself is a flaw. And it is wrong to assume whether Oracle won or not
reply
Freid
Any problem that involves time travel or seeing the future is going to be swamped by paradox unless the rules for seeing the future are exhaustively specified.
If the oracle can see every moment of the future, then he can see for example that the mind reader will take his queen if he castles, which gives him the opportunity to move his queen instead of castling.
He can also see the future created by moving his queen, along with every other possible move he could make, and every subsequent response by the mind reader.
reply
Any problem that involves time travel or seeing the future is going to be swamped by paradox unless the rules for seeing the future are exhaustively specified.
If the oracle can see every moment of the future, then he can see for example that the mind reader will take his queen if he castles, which gives him the opportunity to move his queen instead of castling.
He can also see the future created by moving his queen, along with every other possible move he could make, and every subsequent response by the mind reader.
reply
Kippe
Hm, i dont think you can call it the Future if you can change it.
But id say the Oracle wins as he would be able to choose random moves the other guy cant predict/read, but the Oracle would already know if it leads to victory, because the future is not just the next couple of moves.
There needs to be alot more explaining about what the guy can read, can he also see what the Oracle sees? And how does looking into the future look like? Can you hold a chesspiece over a field and see how it affects the future?
reply
Hm, i dont think you can call it the Future if you can change it.
But id say the Oracle wins as he would be able to choose random moves the other guy cant predict/read, but the Oracle would already know if it leads to victory, because the future is not just the next couple of moves.
There needs to be alot more explaining about what the guy can read, can he also see what the Oracle sees? And how does looking into the future look like? Can you hold a chesspiece over a field and see how it affects the future?
reply
shiva
Oracle will win. since he has taken white coin, he makes the first move. assuming both are equal in chess skills. so both the opponents first move no coin can be eliminated. then oracle starts 2nd move striking 1st black coin. then mindreader starts to strike oracle's white coins. finally oracle is left with 2 coins and mind reader one coin i. e king. so oracle makes the final move who sees the future which coin to use to defeat the king. finally he wins. who makes the first move matters here the most.
reply
Oracle will win. since he has taken white coin, he makes the first move. assuming both are equal in chess skills. so both the opponents first move no coin can be eliminated. then oracle starts 2nd move striking 1st black coin. then mindreader starts to strike oracle's white coins. finally oracle is left with 2 coins and mind reader one coin i. e king. so oracle makes the final move who sees the future which coin to use to defeat the king. finally he wins. who makes the first move matters here the most.
reply
Naihrritya
Clearly it's Oracle who will win the game. Just think that the mind reader knows all best calculations in the game and also knows that what move is in the mind of Oracle best or worst and for the best calculation there is only one best reply otherwise any low move will make mind reader lose, it's completely right till here. Butttt Oracle is the person who knows the whole game he has not visualised the calculations but has completely seen the whole game which he can easily make in his handss.
reply
Clearly it's Oracle who will win the game. Just think that the mind reader knows all best calculations in the game and also knows that what move is in the mind of Oracle best or worst and for the best calculation there is only one best reply otherwise any low move will make mind reader lose, it's completely right till here. Butttt Oracle is the person who knows the whole game he has not visualised the calculations but has completely seen the whole game which he can easily make in his handss.
reply
Sridhar
Infact i had a small question when I gave some random questions to my daughter who is in 7th class and while explaining simple interest. I gave a random question and finding it difficult to explain
One person is having 1000 and deposit money in some proportion in 2 different banks. The bank 1 is giving 10% interest and he deposited for 2 years and other bank is giving 20% and he kept for 1 year. After 2 years he got total simple interest of 20k together. How much he kept in each bank
reply
Infact i had a small question when I gave some random questions to my daughter who is in 7th class and while explaining simple interest. I gave a random question and finding it difficult to explain
One person is having 1000 and deposit money in some proportion in 2 different banks. The bank 1 is giving 10% interest and he deposited for 2 years and other bank is giving 20% and he kept for 1 year. After 2 years he got total simple interest of 20k together. How much he kept in each bank
reply
Gabriel
It is always a draw, the Oracle can just play moves that lead to draws or wins, and the mind reader having access to the same information will play only responses that lead to draws, the key is that when you can see the future then you can pick the perfect moves. But if he can't change the possible outcomes he is able to see, the question is kinda pointless because the game will be already determined from the beginning and the mind reader will know the result as well.
reply
It is always a draw, the Oracle can just play moves that lead to draws or wins, and the mind reader having access to the same information will play only responses that lead to draws, the key is that when you can see the future then you can pick the perfect moves. But if he can't change the possible outcomes he is able to see, the question is kinda pointless because the game will be already determined from the beginning and the mind reader will know the result as well.
reply
srki22
You have a mistake in your reasoning when mind reader is weaker. In that case he would lose the game. How?
Ok let say that mind reader is weak and that he can read 2 moves in advance while Oracle can read 15 moves. Now when Oracle plays he can read 15 moves in advance and plays the best move according to that and then he stops thinking. Mind reader will only know the depth of 14 while Oracle will always be able to think 15 moves ahead on his turn.
reply
You have a mistake in your reasoning when mind reader is weaker. In that case he would lose the game. How?
Ok let say that mind reader is weak and that he can read 2 moves in advance while Oracle can read 15 moves. Now when Oracle plays he can read 15 moves in advance and plays the best move according to that and then he stops thinking. Mind reader will only know the depth of 14 while Oracle will always be able to think 15 moves ahead on his turn.
reply
muskan_786
More possibility for mind reader coz he can bounce back with his ability to win and he always try to pick smarter move after analysing the opponent's move
As moslty all chess players we focused on the move to see if i put this move in this side then what will be the cause for my opponent, we don't focus on what opposite opponent will take the next step. According to our move only he will proceed so all possibilities to the mind reader majorly.
reply
More possibility for mind reader coz he can bounce back with his ability to win and he always try to pick smarter move after analysing the opponent's move
As moslty all chess players we focused on the move to see if i put this move in this side then what will be the cause for my opponent, we don't focus on what opposite opponent will take the next step. According to our move only he will proceed so all possibilities to the mind reader majorly.
reply
G-k-e
How can the oracle see the not-written-yet future? The opponent, whoever he is, will select his move according to the move played by the oracle and before that move is made, there is no future to be seen. The only future related to the chess game that the oracle can definitely see is, for example, an earthquake will occur in the middle of the chess game and the game will be interrupted. Then he can offer a draw and both can run for their lives.
reply
How can the oracle see the not-written-yet future? The opponent, whoever he is, will select his move according to the move played by the oracle and before that move is made, there is no future to be seen. The only future related to the chess game that the oracle can definitely see is, for example, an earthquake will occur in the middle of the chess game and the game will be interrupted. Then he can offer a draw and both can run for their lives.
reply
Christoph
This riddle is formulated very badly, and I don't see how the oracle wouldn't be able to change the future (Mind-Reader does a move, Oracle answers and that leads to his eventual defeat -> Oracle instead chooses to play differently. Also, the Mind-Reader knows that too and he updates his own strategy, so basically it's a feedback loop where possible futures get updated resulting in an inevitable draw no matter of individual player skills.
reply
This riddle is formulated very badly, and I don't see how the oracle wouldn't be able to change the future (Mind-Reader does a move, Oracle answers and that leads to his eventual defeat -> Oracle instead chooses to play differently. Also, the Mind-Reader knows that too and he updates his own strategy, so basically it's a feedback loop where possible futures get updated resulting in an inevitable draw no matter of individual player skills.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















