
What if the Romans Conquered Germania?
video description
There's also a benefit to extending the Empire to eventually consist of an Elbe-Carpathian frontier with an assortment of civilized client states at the edges. Once the Huns sweep into the Pontic Steppe & Eastern Europe as the first of the great steppe hoardes to do so, it'd be better for Rome to have a greater depth to it's European frontiers, & less easily dislocated tribes that can be set hurtling into Roman territory. If the empire has a frontier solidly at the Elbe & the Carpathians with the capacity to easily strike into the edges of the Pontic Steppe, & Eastern Europe, then perhaps they could prevent the Gothic Kingdoms & the Sarmatians that lived in that area from being destroyed by the Huns.
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
John
An interesting video but I think it missed some important points that make it different from the Chinese example you took inspiration from. Several people already mentioned the shorter and more defensible border at the Elb. A deep river makes a good border, and a shorter border is easier to defend. That starts a butterfly effect by protecting the wealthy interior lands from raids and giving space for surplus population to settle with little risk.
But the real issue is something you briefly mentioned. Population migration and settlement on the German side would include more trade along the border and more population growth. The roman's were never good at dealing with nomadic tribes, but once settlements began to form they always were good at trade and diplomacy. A lot of the early empire was taken peacefully. In this case the roman empire doesn't want more land, it wants stable trade with buffer states it can trade with.
Give it a short defensible frontier and it can hold off raids while encouraging peaceful trade and settlement. .. and peaceful settlement is what many tribes wanted. Later in history we see entire groups entering the empire, settling down, and trying to become saviors of the empire. It's entirely possible that a more prosperous and secure empire would have encouraged germanic trade villages on the other side of the river based on fishing, hunting, farming, and yes trading goods to the Romans. They need furs, wood, minerals. .. It didn't have to be a disaster.
It really depends on the character of those mystery tribes you eventually admitted you couldn't predict. Would they peaceful or violent? Would they settle the land or try to move over the river as nomadic raiders? And I think settling down is more likely given a deep river with a solid series of defensive fortifications on the other side, but it becomes nearly certain if the roman presence also gives them an incentive, profit. .. a carrot to go with the stick you might say.
reply
An interesting video but I think it missed some important points that make it different from the Chinese example you took inspiration from. Several people already mentioned the shorter and more defensible border at the Elb. A deep river makes a good border, and a shorter border is easier to defend. That starts a butterfly effect by protecting the wealthy interior lands from raids and giving space for surplus population to settle with little risk.
But the real issue is something you briefly mentioned. Population migration and settlement on the German side would include more trade along the border and more population growth. The roman's were never good at dealing with nomadic tribes, but once settlements began to form they always were good at trade and diplomacy. A lot of the early empire was taken peacefully. In this case the roman empire doesn't want more land, it wants stable trade with buffer states it can trade with.
Give it a short defensible frontier and it can hold off raids while encouraging peaceful trade and settlement. .. and peaceful settlement is what many tribes wanted. Later in history we see entire groups entering the empire, settling down, and trying to become saviors of the empire. It's entirely possible that a more prosperous and secure empire would have encouraged germanic trade villages on the other side of the river based on fishing, hunting, farming, and yes trading goods to the Romans. They need furs, wood, minerals. .. It didn't have to be a disaster.
It really depends on the character of those mystery tribes you eventually admitted you couldn't predict. Would they peaceful or violent? Would they settle the land or try to move over the river as nomadic raiders? And I think settling down is more likely given a deep river with a solid series of defensive fortifications on the other side, but it becomes nearly certain if the roman presence also gives them an incentive, profit. .. a carrot to go with the stick you might say.
reply
Gideon
Arguably the Romans not conquering germania either through unwillingness inability or a arrogant belief that the lands were not worth conquering ensured that the region would foster future threats and raids to the empire.
Even if military conquest wasnt a option the second most practical strategy would be that of divide and rule. Establish pro Roman puppet kingdoms along the empires borders provide financial and military support in return for these romanized Germanic kings to vassal themselves to Rome that would then compete with the other barbaric Germans.
The one term effect of this would be a cultural situation similar to the Germans of alsace and lorraine. Where even though the bulk of the population was ethnic German the provinces had been integrated with France for so much of its history the people would be culturally economically and linguistically tied to France.
So in this alternate timeline the situation of alsace and lorraine but expanded to most of western Germany after the fall of Rome and the Middle Ages the people there despite being what we would call Germanic would be mostly be tied into France and Italy trade wise and culturally perhaps we would see the rise of a new language a form of Germanized Latin along with French Spanish and Italian.
Of course when the 19 and 20th centuries in the rise of nationalism this could me the creation of a cohesive German identity extremely difficult with a Protestant germanic east with a Catholic Latinized west.
reply
Arguably the Romans not conquering germania either through unwillingness inability or a arrogant belief that the lands were not worth conquering ensured that the region would foster future threats and raids to the empire.
Even if military conquest wasnt a option the second most practical strategy would be that of divide and rule. Establish pro Roman puppet kingdoms along the empires borders provide financial and military support in return for these romanized Germanic kings to vassal themselves to Rome that would then compete with the other barbaric Germans.
The one term effect of this would be a cultural situation similar to the Germans of alsace and lorraine. Where even though the bulk of the population was ethnic German the provinces had been integrated with France for so much of its history the people would be culturally economically and linguistically tied to France.
So in this alternate timeline the situation of alsace and lorraine but expanded to most of western Germany after the fall of Rome and the Middle Ages the people there despite being what we would call Germanic would be mostly be tied into France and Italy trade wise and culturally perhaps we would see the rise of a new language a form of Germanized Latin along with French Spanish and Italian.
Of course when the 19 and 20th centuries in the rise of nationalism this could me the creation of a cohesive German identity extremely difficult with a Protestant germanic east with a Catholic Latinized west.
reply
AV
Ultimately, I think conquering up to the Elbe would have been better for the longevity of the Empire. Without Frankish and Saxon hostilities, Britain probably remains a much more solid Roman province, since their German allies often emboldened them to overthrow Rome. Having a shorter border would obviously be advantageous. And perhaps being in closer proximity to Scandinavia would prompt Rome to take to the Northern and Baltic Seas to trade and combat piracy. Perhaps Viking history would have been quite different if they had been squashed by the Romans before Scandinavians had perfected longboat raiding.
Theres also the issue of Rome taking a defensive stance. It just didnt suit them. Their legions were engineered to invadenot sit back and counterattack. What would the Huns have eventually ran into when they migrated west and found the Romans who had just conquered Central Europe? Could the Romans have rode that momentum to face the Huns head on, rather than backpedaling into Gaul?
I also find the idea of Romans enlisting Scandinavians into the legions enticing. Imagine how much better Rome could have held their Eastern border with the aid of ships swiftly patrolling the Don, the Dneper, the Oder, and/or the Elbe River. Thats how they could have really checked the Huns advancement East.
reply
Ultimately, I think conquering up to the Elbe would have been better for the longevity of the Empire. Without Frankish and Saxon hostilities, Britain probably remains a much more solid Roman province, since their German allies often emboldened them to overthrow Rome. Having a shorter border would obviously be advantageous. And perhaps being in closer proximity to Scandinavia would prompt Rome to take to the Northern and Baltic Seas to trade and combat piracy. Perhaps Viking history would have been quite different if they had been squashed by the Romans before Scandinavians had perfected longboat raiding.
Theres also the issue of Rome taking a defensive stance. It just didnt suit them. Their legions were engineered to invadenot sit back and counterattack. What would the Huns have eventually ran into when they migrated west and found the Romans who had just conquered Central Europe? Could the Romans have rode that momentum to face the Huns head on, rather than backpedaling into Gaul?
I also find the idea of Romans enlisting Scandinavians into the legions enticing. Imagine how much better Rome could have held their Eastern border with the aid of ships swiftly patrolling the Don, the Dneper, the Oder, and/or the Elbe River. Thats how they could have really checked the Huns advancement East.
reply
Ashton
To be fair, the length of the frontier border would be drastically shortened and would require less garrisons in order to maintain. Germania did have forest tribes but the Britons were pretty close to that level of development. The Roman efforts for assimilation was relatively hands off, and they were good at making assimilation more appealing than the previous social paradigm.
Having a greater pool of Foedorati already somewhat assimilated into Roman culture would likely make for more loyal auxiliaries.
Again, this would most likely reduce the amount of strain on the Roman military in terms of less mutiny and greater available manpower. The Roman army was in drastic need of good cavalry and the german tribes were definitely capable of providing that.
reply
To be fair, the length of the frontier border would be drastically shortened and would require less garrisons in order to maintain. Germania did have forest tribes but the Britons were pretty close to that level of development. The Roman efforts for assimilation was relatively hands off, and they were good at making assimilation more appealing than the previous social paradigm.
Having a greater pool of Foedorati already somewhat assimilated into Roman culture would likely make for more loyal auxiliaries.
Again, this would most likely reduce the amount of strain on the Roman military in terms of less mutiny and greater available manpower. The Roman army was in drastic need of good cavalry and the german tribes were definitely capable of providing that.
reply
William
Knowing a bit more about Caesar's campaign across the Rhine than I did last time I watched this video, I have to wonder what exactly you meant by the region being largely empty. I understand Caesar himself isn't always particularly reliable in his accounting of events, but I'm fairly sure he described abandoned villages and towns in his brief time in Germania, not completely emotional lands. They had just fled in advance of his army, he wandered around for a while then went back over the river.
reply
Knowing a bit more about Caesar's campaign across the Rhine than I did last time I watched this video, I have to wonder what exactly you meant by the region being largely empty. I understand Caesar himself isn't always particularly reliable in his accounting of events, but I'm fairly sure he described abandoned villages and towns in his brief time in Germania, not completely emotional lands. They had just fled in advance of his army, he wandered around for a while then went back over the river.
reply
bat
One funny part of the roman empire history is the only country that carry their name and suposedly their legacy was practically never conquired by Rome. Today Romania is almost never on this historic maps and corect because it was incorporated in the empire for only some 50 years at its pick before it started to desintegrate. where greece and tracia was part of the empire for long long time. I wonder how those romanians got to acosiate with romans? Something fishy here.
reply
One funny part of the roman empire history is the only country that carry their name and suposedly their legacy was practically never conquired by Rome. Today Romania is almost never on this historic maps and corect because it was incorporated in the empire for only some 50 years at its pick before it started to desintegrate. where greece and tracia was part of the empire for long long time. I wonder how those romanians got to acosiate with romans? Something fishy here.
reply
Travis
As with many other comments, intriguing analysis but I've always felt that had they pushed out to the Elbe they would have still likely struggled during the 3rd-5th Centuries but likely would have held on. Justinian would have still reigned in this timeline and would have solidified things after the tense 5th Century and who knows after that. Whatever would have happened, the rest of history would have been definitely different.
reply
As with many other comments, intriguing analysis but I've always felt that had they pushed out to the Elbe they would have still likely struggled during the 3rd-5th Centuries but likely would have held on. Justinian would have still reigned in this timeline and would have solidified things after the tense 5th Century and who knows after that. Whatever would have happened, the rest of history would have been definitely different.
reply
abel
The fact that you take Britain for granted as the main colonial power when Britain literally lingered 150 years in merely begin to explore the new continent when Spain had already conquered various kingdoms in the Americas and Portugal was the one that began it. Britain is the latest colonial power and the last to grow up and leave the colonial mentality, but certanly not the main.
reply
The fact that you take Britain for granted as the main colonial power when Britain literally lingered 150 years in merely begin to explore the new continent when Spain had already conquered various kingdoms in the Americas and Portugal was the one that began it. Britain is the latest colonial power and the last to grow up and leave the colonial mentality, but certanly not the main.
reply
PremierSportingKC
Christianity would have never spread into Europe if the Western Roman Empire collapsed by 340? Arianism Christianity was already present among Germanic and Gothic tribes before 340, so I don't know why you would think that. Christianity wasn't just located within the Roman Empire; it had already spread far beyond Rome's boarders by the 4th Century
reply
Christianity would have never spread into Europe if the Western Roman Empire collapsed by 340? Arianism Christianity was already present among Germanic and Gothic tribes before 340, so I don't know why you would think that. Christianity wasn't just located within the Roman Empire; it had already spread far beyond Rome's boarders by the 4th Century
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















