• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if the Persians Conquered Greece?

What if the Persians Conquered Greece?

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if the Persians Conquered Greece? The: It wasn't the Achaemenids that broke the back of these civilizations as you stated. It was Alexander and his general's Diadochi kingdoms, along with Rome, Parthia, and the Sassanids which held such grip over the former Achaemenid Empire's territories that prevented these kingdoms from rising again. Alexander never conquered Armenia, nor did he conquer Atropatene (a Median satrap. Which these two did prosper after his death and were subsequently conquered or made satrapies or client states by Parthia, Rome, and the Sassanid Empire.
The reason we don't see a resurgent native kingdom in most of the former Achaemenid territories is because of the large powerful empires that would come to rule the region. They had no chance to remerge. No breathing room.
Also another fact you forgot to mention was that Greek democracy wouldn't die under Persia. As after the Ionian Revolt, Darius the Great and his brother; Artaphernes, Satrap of Lydia, charged Mardonius with deposing the Greek tyrants and installing democracies in the Ionian city-states. Therefore it stands to reason that Persia might have instituted a similar practice in mainland Greece as well. Darius the Great was praised for this move among many of the mainland Greek city-states that many just summitted to Persia during the 1st invasion, seeing the Persian clemency as the better choice to destruction, as no Greeks had ever defeated a Persian Army before Marathon.
That's all I can think of at the moment, but still a great video.

Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


Also, the fact that the Spartans didnt add anything to civilization is hugely incorrect. I understand that point of view, if youre not an expert on Greek history, but theres so much more here. Im not going to just mention some names of actual Spartan intellectuals, but Ill mention the most important thing for me: the Spartan way of living itself. There was a phrase in Greece, still extremely popular, which says the Spartan way is philosophy, or brevity is the source of wit. Sparta was admired as a model by many big Greek philosophers from other cities. Even the Parthenon in Acropolis of Athens is of Spartan (Doric) architecture style. They purposely avoided writing, talking or lecturing too much, following their strict moral codes. They tried to just act their philosophy without saying anything. Really difficult to explain more but you can look for it, its very interesting. Nevertheless, your videos are perfect!
reply

The Greeks were never as good fighters as the Romans? I think this is not true at all. Greeks had an amazing reputation as fighters, Spartans were the most feared people on earth by classical age. The Greeks lost the war against Rome, but this happened after the Greek world had already started declining. An incredible book on the Greek way of warfare is the The Western Way of War by Hanson. Greeks did some unbelievable things during their apex with regards to warfare, very difficult to compare with any other nation. They never had the administrative skills (or the willingness) to head towards a united empire-model like Rome, and they lacked the engineering/logistics/supply lines of Rome as well. Their culture actually was against such ventures. But overall, a fight between Greek phalanx during Greeces apex and Roman legion during its apex would end up in favor of Greece, I believe.
reply

I dont think much would been different, did much changed when greeks conquered egypt, messopotmia and persia? Expect some adaptation of greek art and way of life. Just like the anatolian greeks did adopt to some persian art and way of life. As we see firstly, there was not that big of difference since both were civilized people, built cities practiced somewhat look alike gods and had customs and arts that been combined throughout history. The only thing that would been different i think would been that romans would have adopted more of eastern style of art and engineering and customs instead of the typical greek ones since persian would have been a more successful power in the known world therefore more of its culture and art would have been adopted in eastern and southern Europe.
reply

Apart from hollywood propaganda cinema, Persians actually were great statesmen. There system of government was really great in one why or other modern US federative system is product of satrapy system which later adopted by Greeks and romans, and very late by mughal empire (subah system. Greeks crushed the empire but didn't provide any stable alternative of Persians. Persian empire was very stable & progressive in nature, they never imposed their culture and religion on subjects while Greeks imposed their culture whenever they ruled. I found hollywood cinema very biased, which always try to prove superiority of western civilization.
reply

It took the Romans 200 years to conquer Hispania and 7 years to conquer Gaul. And they conquered Gaul first.
What makes you think the Greeks would be able to subdue Hispania but not Gaul?
Also, why do the Greeks occupy everything except the Basque region? In our world it were the Celts in the Asturian region who resisted Roman occupation for longest, not the Basques.
It's called the Cantabrian Wars not the Vasconian wars.
The Basques and the Iberians got quickly subdued by the Romans. Those who posed the fiercest resistence were the Arevaci (Celtiberian, the Lusitani (Celtic) and the Cantabri (Celtic.

reply

I'm going to guess that the by the 5th centaury BC that saddled horsemen had become so epidemic to the fertile crescent and Egypt and because of thousands of years of being irrigational agriculturalists, living in larges societies controlled by a priestly elite, they had a stunted warrior culture. Their warrior elite could no longer protect them against raiding and pastoralizing of their fields by barbarians, so essentially the Persians broke their backs and forced them to accept being conquered people treated generally well by foreign empires in exchange for protection.
reply

In our timeline persia was like you said as well it is roman empire of the east. most of middle eastern cultures have some persian factor integrated in them actually caliphate that you mentioned were themselves run by persian nobles like barmakids and were influenced by persian culture and persian govermental and empiral organization known as diwan was essential part of running any eastern empires up until even ottomans
reply

300 was brilliant 100% accurate propaganda. If you watch carefully, you will notice that the narrarator is telling the story around a campfire. (A campfire story, aka a big fish story) His exaggerations and lies are tailored to the environment. The events where the narrator was not present are the most ridiculous. But public events such as the arrival of the Persian emissaries are only exaggerated a little.
reply

Even if the Persians conquered Greece, there's no guarantee they'd actually HOLD it. Persian had trouble just putting down the Ionian Revolts BEFORE the invasion of Greece. They probably face that on a larger scale in Greece proper. Sparta for one, would NEVER have accepted Persian rule, and literally would have fought to the bitter end. Greece may well have proved too costly for Persia.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos