
Neurosurgeon Answers Brain Surgery Questions From Twitter Tech Support
video description
Date: 2023-02-07
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 15
David
Not to be too critical, but the answer about which is harder, brain surgery or rocket science, is an enormous cop-out. It sounds impressive but doesn t actually answer the question. Do rocket scientists have to consider how many stars there are to build a rocket, or even plan to reach a single one of them? Does a neurosurgeon have to consider how many neurons make up a brain when performing a surgery, or even operate on the cellular level? A proper answer would involve discussing the relevant skills involved in each discipline, but granted that s something a neurosurgeon who is not also a rocket scientist wouldn t be qualified to do. It would be more insightful to see a debate against a team of neurosurgeons versus a team of rocket scientists.
reply
Not to be too critical, but the answer about which is harder, brain surgery or rocket science, is an enormous cop-out. It sounds impressive but doesn t actually answer the question. Do rocket scientists have to consider how many stars there are to build a rocket, or even plan to reach a single one of them? Does a neurosurgeon have to consider how many neurons make up a brain when performing a surgery, or even operate on the cellular level? A proper answer would involve discussing the relevant skills involved in each discipline, but granted that s something a neurosurgeon who is not also a rocket scientist wouldn t be qualified to do. It would be more insightful to see a debate against a team of neurosurgeons versus a team of rocket scientists.
reply
Edwin
Appreciate the answers and practiced craft but lol'ed when he said neurosurgery is without a doubt more complicated than rocket science. You're not managing each nervous connection, you're doing surgery on mass sections at a time, and ignoring that scientists in practice are planning their extremely complicated maneuvers days to years in advance often without any way to fix things in the moment if they go wrong. It'd be like saying being an engine mechanic is harder because of the sheer magnitude/unknowability of how each atom will interact during any single combustion reaction. The fields are just fundamentally different in skill set, not ranked.
-non-NSGY MD
reply
Appreciate the answers and practiced craft but lol'ed when he said neurosurgery is without a doubt more complicated than rocket science. You're not managing each nervous connection, you're doing surgery on mass sections at a time, and ignoring that scientists in practice are planning their extremely complicated maneuvers days to years in advance often without any way to fix things in the moment if they go wrong. It'd be like saying being an engine mechanic is harder because of the sheer magnitude/unknowability of how each atom will interact during any single combustion reaction. The fields are just fundamentally different in skill set, not ranked.
-non-NSGY MD
reply
Michael
Rocket science is much more complicated, no offense. Brain surgery is challenging for sure but the amount of mathematics and science that goes into landed rockets in space, the physics of movement, movement of planets, and their effects on gravity on said rocket, among other topics renders brain surgery child play. You don't necessarily need to be extremely intelligent to do brain surgery, its more committed to learning techniques and all the areas and compartments of the brain/skull. Its kind of like learning an instrument in the way technique and commitment are paramount to advancing.
reply
Rocket science is much more complicated, no offense. Brain surgery is challenging for sure but the amount of mathematics and science that goes into landed rockets in space, the physics of movement, movement of planets, and their effects on gravity on said rocket, among other topics renders brain surgery child play. You don't necessarily need to be extremely intelligent to do brain surgery, its more committed to learning techniques and all the areas and compartments of the brain/skull. Its kind of like learning an instrument in the way technique and commitment are paramount to advancing.
reply
Bobby
I ve had brain surgery a total of five times to deal with a tumor that was crushing my optic nerves. A hard to eliminate cyst developed with the tumor and after the first surgery it swelled in size, also crushing my optic nerves. The most invasive one I had is a craniotomy, and the other four were minimally invasive. Surgeries one and two were done through my nose trans-sphenoidal, meaning they cut through my sphenoid sinus. As a result of the optic nerve damage, I have permanently lost about 75% of my sight
reply
I ve had brain surgery a total of five times to deal with a tumor that was crushing my optic nerves. A hard to eliminate cyst developed with the tumor and after the first surgery it swelled in size, also crushing my optic nerves. The most invasive one I had is a craniotomy, and the other four were minimally invasive. Surgeries one and two were done through my nose trans-sphenoidal, meaning they cut through my sphenoid sinus. As a result of the optic nerve damage, I have permanently lost about 75% of my sight
reply
Eric
Man, the editing at the end there was brutal.
If the brain has no pain receptors how do I get headaches
. that relaxation. stimulates the pain receptors. and causes pain
The neurosurgeon certainly knows and explained that the pain happens in structures outside and around the brain and addressed this in his tweet. It would have been nice if the editor here did him the courtesy of leaving the bit of the answer central to the actual question in the audio.
reply
Man, the editing at the end there was brutal.
If the brain has no pain receptors how do I get headaches
. that relaxation. stimulates the pain receptors. and causes pain
The neurosurgeon certainly knows and explained that the pain happens in structures outside and around the brain and addressed this in his tweet. It would have been nice if the editor here did him the courtesy of leaving the bit of the answer central to the actual question in the audio.
reply
Vera
Veterinary science is hardest.
Anything you can do for depression? I'm ready to die.
How close are we to wire heading? Electrical stimulation of pleasure.
(Larry Niven wrote sf novels and short stories about this idea)
Had to chuckle. . decades upon decades. Read in a journal once that someday we'll be able to click on a word on the computer screen and lots of info will come up. Writer said. maybe in 500 years. Sometimes I wish I'd kept the article.
reply
Veterinary science is hardest.
Anything you can do for depression? I'm ready to die.
How close are we to wire heading? Electrical stimulation of pleasure.
(Larry Niven wrote sf novels and short stories about this idea)
Had to chuckle. . decades upon decades. Read in a journal once that someday we'll be able to click on a word on the computer screen and lots of info will come up. Writer said. maybe in 500 years. Sometimes I wish I'd kept the article.
reply
TooManyAnimation
I've had a craniectomy to relieve pressure after swelling after my aneurysm was coiled so it was cool to hear him talk about it, though, I didn't keep my bone flap, I had a cranioplasty later where they put a titanium plate in, until then I had to wear a custom made helmet whenever I stood up because oft he soft spot
reply
I've had a craniectomy to relieve pressure after swelling after my aneurysm was coiled so it was cool to hear him talk about it, though, I didn't keep my bone flap, I had a cranioplasty later where they put a titanium plate in, until then I had to wear a custom made helmet whenever I stood up because oft he soft spot
reply
Tinderbox
Is it ever possible to get through one of these without questioners dropping F-bombs?
It's a shame how the inferior quality of education today has left multiple generations with subpar vocabulary. And it's not me being prude, it's people unable to express themselves verbally beyond the lowest common denominator.
reply
Is it ever possible to get through one of these without questioners dropping F-bombs?
It's a shame how the inferior quality of education today has left multiple generations with subpar vocabulary. And it's not me being prude, it's people unable to express themselves verbally beyond the lowest common denominator.
reply
Vineet
For a single person, rocket science would certainly be harder, considering there's just so much stuff to do. Now, if you have access to an infinite number of people and the only differentiator is the amount of skill required by the people actually doing anything, brain surgery is probably harder.
reply
For a single person, rocket science would certainly be harder, considering there's just so much stuff to do. Now, if you have access to an infinite number of people and the only differentiator is the amount of skill required by the people actually doing anything, brain surgery is probably harder.
reply
Geralt
The answer about rocket science vs brain surgery is not valid. If you estimate the complexity of something based on the number of things in it, astrophysicists could say they have to deal with atoms and that would be as an inaccurate answer. A bit disappointing even if the rest was cool.
reply
The answer about rocket science vs brain surgery is not valid. If you estimate the complexity of something based on the number of things in it, astrophysicists could say they have to deal with atoms and that would be as an inaccurate answer. A bit disappointing even if the rest was cool.
reply
Alex
1: 21 for 'what is harder Rocket science or brain Surgery? ' The answer is they are two different things so can't be compared. However if we were to do so, simply the minimum to be become a rocket scientist is a bachelors degree a brain surgeon needs a minimum of a doctorate.
reply
1: 21 for 'what is harder Rocket science or brain Surgery? ' The answer is they are two different things so can't be compared. However if we were to do so, simply the minimum to be become a rocket scientist is a bachelors degree a brain surgeon needs a minimum of a doctorate.
reply
Letizia
rocket science isnt a thing guys. Many different fields and even more different people are involved in bringing a vessel to space. No single person does that. Not even 5 people, no surgical staff would be big enough. It takes hundreds of people. I would know.
reply
rocket science isnt a thing guys. Many different fields and even more different people are involved in bringing a vessel to space. No single person does that. Not even 5 people, no surgical staff would be big enough. It takes hundreds of people. I would know.
reply
education
7: 00 if you're interested in lobotomies, read My Lobotomy by Howard Dully. Incredible, heartbreaking read.
Lobotomies are horrible. To say they were net positive ignores the truly unthinkable pain that the victims of that torture have gone through.
reply
7: 00 if you're interested in lobotomies, read My Lobotomy by Howard Dully. Incredible, heartbreaking read.
Lobotomies are horrible. To say they were net positive ignores the truly unthinkable pain that the victims of that torture have gone through.
reply
Prasad
1: 42 I beg to disagree. It's neither hard not easier than the brain surgery. It's just that one is very high risk and time sensitive issue.
Just like a bypass surgery. Is it easy? Sure. Happens all the time. But that thing sure is risky.
reply
1: 42 I beg to disagree. It's neither hard not easier than the brain surgery. It's just that one is very high risk and time sensitive issue.
Just like a bypass surgery. Is it easy? Sure. Happens all the time. But that thing sure is risky.
reply
Bart omiej
I don't understand how the amount of neurons is even an argument. I might be biased cuz myself I'm a physics student but I'm honestly curious if he's ever studied rocket science/physics/maths before. Wouldn't be so quick to judge.
reply
I don't understand how the amount of neurons is even an argument. I might be biased cuz myself I'm a physics student but I'm honestly curious if he's ever studied rocket science/physics/maths before. Wouldn't be so quick to judge.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















