Sci-Fi Short Film: Hiraeth - DUST - Online Premiere
video description
Date: 2024-04-01
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 35
janhorak8024
Sci-fi short comments by Jan
Beware of spoilers!
Hiraeth by Ryan Andrews
Plot: Woman on a mission to Europa, with sad and heavy past. The story to be told has two lines: the past of the woman astronaut, connected to a girl murdered by her own mother and a mission to Europa. The story is told in a well pacing manner, there is lot of switching between the two lines. Unfortunately, I have two problems with that: 1) confusion it is not clear what exactly happened and to whom; 2) support for the main story. Sometimes, less info does not matter there are plenty of DUST shorts with lack of background info, which still tell a full story and missing info is not disturbing the experience with movie. This is not the case. Second problem is linked to it: what other purpose does this for the story than knowing, that she has a difficult past. It can bring another layer to her personality, but, it does not influence the space story, at least, I did not see it. And the space line: was it even the main line I mean, it could be just a family drama as well with a side note, that she is an astronaut. It also has an open end: there is a solar flare, something is wrong with the spaceship, then she is floating in space Maybe in went wrong, she is waiting for death in space and the whole sad past is enabling her to say those things, while awaiting death. Also: there are two competing topics in a plot: the murder and the solar flare
Negatives: 1) the plot: it produces too much confusion which works against the movie; 2) detail: I generally do not like the flashback scenes, they usually (sorry) feel lame. Everybody can imagine, that a murder is horrible thing scenes with stares into landscape, sunshine, flowers etc. do not support it. In these usually, the less, the better. I often criticise this also due to that it steels time from your movie, which could be used for developing the main story; 3) the lightning (no no no no no)
Positives: 1) acting; 2) characters written. Yes, au contraire to what I have written. In many movies, the characters with sad history or in dramatic situations on spaceship react un-appropriately, overreact and so on not here. Both woman and man were written well and their dialogs, even short ones, were good and fitted well into situations; 3) scene and setting; 4) pacing of the movie
Personal note: I dissected the movie more than I usually do, but this is not because I think it is bad I just want to give as much feedback as I can, because I genuinely think, that the movie is better. It just lacks something in the most important part: storytelling.
Summary: Not that bad movie, but it loses due to trying to tell too much two competing stories combined with confusing storytelling of one of them
reply
Sci-fi short comments by Jan
Beware of spoilers!
Hiraeth by Ryan Andrews
Plot: Woman on a mission to Europa, with sad and heavy past. The story to be told has two lines: the past of the woman astronaut, connected to a girl murdered by her own mother and a mission to Europa. The story is told in a well pacing manner, there is lot of switching between the two lines. Unfortunately, I have two problems with that: 1) confusion it is not clear what exactly happened and to whom; 2) support for the main story. Sometimes, less info does not matter there are plenty of DUST shorts with lack of background info, which still tell a full story and missing info is not disturbing the experience with movie. This is not the case. Second problem is linked to it: what other purpose does this for the story than knowing, that she has a difficult past. It can bring another layer to her personality, but, it does not influence the space story, at least, I did not see it. And the space line: was it even the main line I mean, it could be just a family drama as well with a side note, that she is an astronaut. It also has an open end: there is a solar flare, something is wrong with the spaceship, then she is floating in space Maybe in went wrong, she is waiting for death in space and the whole sad past is enabling her to say those things, while awaiting death. Also: there are two competing topics in a plot: the murder and the solar flare
Negatives: 1) the plot: it produces too much confusion which works against the movie; 2) detail: I generally do not like the flashback scenes, they usually (sorry) feel lame. Everybody can imagine, that a murder is horrible thing scenes with stares into landscape, sunshine, flowers etc. do not support it. In these usually, the less, the better. I often criticise this also due to that it steels time from your movie, which could be used for developing the main story; 3) the lightning (no no no no no)
Positives: 1) acting; 2) characters written. Yes, au contraire to what I have written. In many movies, the characters with sad history or in dramatic situations on spaceship react un-appropriately, overreact and so on not here. Both woman and man were written well and their dialogs, even short ones, were good and fitted well into situations; 3) scene and setting; 4) pacing of the movie
Personal note: I dissected the movie more than I usually do, but this is not because I think it is bad I just want to give as much feedback as I can, because I genuinely think, that the movie is better. It just lacks something in the most important part: storytelling.
Summary: Not that bad movie, but it loses due to trying to tell too much two competing stories combined with confusing storytelling of one of them
reply
yosemitedan7457
I know it has been pointed out about the time taken for messaging to travel being wrong as well as the implausibility of someone with her backstory being on the mission in the first place, but three other things jumped out at me.
Early on it says three people have died in space. I beg to defer. Reentry still counts as being in space for one thing.
The second thing is even more harrowing really. Over 800 days on this mission. Alone. Far from anyone else. And even with that background she sounds relatively sane. I think if you had discussed that likelihood with any psychologist they would not sign off on the screen play as written.
The third thing is picking at nits, but the accent. Clearly British or one of them. And please tell me exactly when the British got a space program going There are currently two private enterprises in the US that are among the top 4 space programs in the world. So that puts the Brits behind Musk and Bezos even. I know that is a small detail, but the devil is in the details. At least maybe next time ask your actors to fake an accent that would better reflect reality.
reply
I know it has been pointed out about the time taken for messaging to travel being wrong as well as the implausibility of someone with her backstory being on the mission in the first place, but three other things jumped out at me.
Early on it says three people have died in space. I beg to defer. Reentry still counts as being in space for one thing.
The second thing is even more harrowing really. Over 800 days on this mission. Alone. Far from anyone else. And even with that background she sounds relatively sane. I think if you had discussed that likelihood with any psychologist they would not sign off on the screen play as written.
The third thing is picking at nits, but the accent. Clearly British or one of them. And please tell me exactly when the British got a space program going There are currently two private enterprises in the US that are among the top 4 space programs in the world. So that puts the Brits behind Musk and Bezos even. I know that is a small detail, but the devil is in the details. At least maybe next time ask your actors to fake an accent that would better reflect reality.
reply
thaska6106
That recondite and infinite mantle that surrounds us, full of light, color, movement and silence. That immense space that everything witnesses without valuing it, that inert dance that the sky illuminates without preventing it. Alien to the beauty of the unique, unaware of the extraordinary of the whole. That celestial vault that does not cry or feel. That endless map to the capacity of our mind. That brilliant night of the finished and the pending.
Congratulations to Ryan Andrews and his talented team. So much pain, so much effort, so much technique, so much sensibility, so much know-how, so much communication, so much photography, so much performance, so much dedication, so much love. How difficult must be analize the human being and it's enviroment, all the rest.
Sorry for the comments, I don't know about production or filming, but I know what touches me deep inside.
Thank You UST
reply
That recondite and infinite mantle that surrounds us, full of light, color, movement and silence. That immense space that everything witnesses without valuing it, that inert dance that the sky illuminates without preventing it. Alien to the beauty of the unique, unaware of the extraordinary of the whole. That celestial vault that does not cry or feel. That endless map to the capacity of our mind. That brilliant night of the finished and the pending.
Congratulations to Ryan Andrews and his talented team. So much pain, so much effort, so much technique, so much sensibility, so much know-how, so much communication, so much photography, so much performance, so much dedication, so much love. How difficult must be analize the human being and it's enviroment, all the rest.
Sorry for the comments, I don't know about production or filming, but I know what touches me deep inside.
Thank You UST
reply
ianrayner7522
Here's how I understood the story, I am probably way off, but here goes. The woman on the mission is the girl being killed by her mother. We know the girl murdered was obsessed with Jupiter. We also hear the narrator describe what happens to the body/mind in a frenzy-attack - the mind takes the victim to another place (perhaps their happy place - Jupiter in this case) senses blink out one by one. We see her move from a full environment to just floating in space.
So that's how I read it. The victim of the frenzy-attack, a young girl obsessed with traveling to Jupiter, goes on that journey in her mind.
If you have ever read Pincher Martin by William Golding, you will know how I am seeing this. He is a sailor drowning at sea, but in his mind, he washes up on an island and constructs a survival story. But reality chips away at the fantasy as he gets closer to death.
reply
Here's how I understood the story, I am probably way off, but here goes. The woman on the mission is the girl being killed by her mother. We know the girl murdered was obsessed with Jupiter. We also hear the narrator describe what happens to the body/mind in a frenzy-attack - the mind takes the victim to another place (perhaps their happy place - Jupiter in this case) senses blink out one by one. We see her move from a full environment to just floating in space.
So that's how I read it. The victim of the frenzy-attack, a young girl obsessed with traveling to Jupiter, goes on that journey in her mind.
If you have ever read Pincher Martin by William Golding, you will know how I am seeing this. He is a sailor drowning at sea, but in his mind, he washes up on an island and constructs a survival story. But reality chips away at the fantasy as he gets closer to death.
reply
ryanandrews2977
Hi Sci Fi friends, I’m Ryan Andrews the director of Hiraeth. We would really appreciate your constructive comments and any questions regarding the story telling and technical aspects related to the film. The films narrative works on multiple time lines with themes such as grief, abuse and obsession. Technically, we shot on super 16mm film, used fluid work, in camera tricks and a small amount of VFX. We hope you connect with the film on an emotional level and we look forward to your feedback and any questions. A big thank you to our cast for compelling performances and the crew who pulled this off on a modest budget. On behalf of writer Stephen Laughton, producer Liv Edmunds, Actress Olivia Ross and myself, I would like to thank Dust for giving our film a platform for an audience to enjoy.
reply
Hi Sci Fi friends, I’m Ryan Andrews the director of Hiraeth. We would really appreciate your constructive comments and any questions regarding the story telling and technical aspects related to the film. The films narrative works on multiple time lines with themes such as grief, abuse and obsession. Technically, we shot on super 16mm film, used fluid work, in camera tricks and a small amount of VFX. We hope you connect with the film on an emotional level and we look forward to your feedback and any questions. A big thank you to our cast for compelling performances and the crew who pulled this off on a modest budget. On behalf of writer Stephen Laughton, producer Liv Edmunds, Actress Olivia Ross and myself, I would like to thank Dust for giving our film a platform for an audience to enjoy.
reply
dust
FOR F SAKE DUST SORT YOUR RIDICULOUSLY QUIET AUDIO OUT! Nearly went deaf when normal volume resumed WITHOUT WARNING DURING END CREDITS!
Production quality is great but pointless as what was going on other than, Oh, Jupiter! and, Cue big explosion
Garbled plot, no idea why, what or how the astronaut was controversial choice. Not sure what the people other than the guy in, presumably, command centre had to do with anything. no explanation on why an unexpectedly powerful) aurora would cause such a planet sized explosion from such a small object as a spaceship or how an astronaut could possibly get far enough away to survive it or what the point of surviving the explosion is when she's now just going to experience slow lonely & painful death
reply
FOR F SAKE DUST SORT YOUR RIDICULOUSLY QUIET AUDIO OUT! Nearly went deaf when normal volume resumed WITHOUT WARNING DURING END CREDITS!
Production quality is great but pointless as what was going on other than, Oh, Jupiter! and, Cue big explosion
Garbled plot, no idea why, what or how the astronaut was controversial choice. Not sure what the people other than the guy in, presumably, command centre had to do with anything. no explanation on why an unexpectedly powerful) aurora would cause such a planet sized explosion from such a small object as a spaceship or how an astronaut could possibly get far enough away to survive it or what the point of surviving the explosion is when she's now just going to experience slow lonely & painful death
reply
SynthoidSounds
Potentially compelling story, but the audio was difficult to interpret at times. The backstory hinted at various things, but it seemed like a jigsaw puzzle with a few too many pieces missing. I get that this is supposed to be an emotionally gripping story, but between the sometimes iffy audio, and a bit too much jumping around trying to tell what the backstory actually consisted of, it was hard to get that emotionally involved with the character. The camera work and so on was fine. There is a good story here, but it could have been a bit more decipherable, especially at the end (was she killed by the incoming lightning bolt or whatever, or was it some form of suicide. In any case, nicely done.
reply
Potentially compelling story, but the audio was difficult to interpret at times. The backstory hinted at various things, but it seemed like a jigsaw puzzle with a few too many pieces missing. I get that this is supposed to be an emotionally gripping story, but between the sometimes iffy audio, and a bit too much jumping around trying to tell what the backstory actually consisted of, it was hard to get that emotionally involved with the character. The camera work and so on was fine. There is a good story here, but it could have been a bit more decipherable, especially at the end (was she killed by the incoming lightning bolt or whatever, or was it some form of suicide. In any case, nicely done.
reply
jimsmith556
Great graphics and acting. However not really believable. The purpose of this mission could have been accomplished, and would be done, without a human. Simple measurements that would be done more efficiently with a robotic rover or satellite. Science fiction can get away with a lot of things, but we've long passed sending humans for measuring things like magnetic fields in favor of cheaper, safer robotic missions. This seemed like a venue for the poetic script rather than a story with any substance. Only reinforced with the statement about not knowing she was being attacked and that it would be like wind was flowing through her body. I have to call BS. This is unwatchable for anyone with a brain.
reply
Great graphics and acting. However not really believable. The purpose of this mission could have been accomplished, and would be done, without a human. Simple measurements that would be done more efficiently with a robotic rover or satellite. Science fiction can get away with a lot of things, but we've long passed sending humans for measuring things like magnetic fields in favor of cheaper, safer robotic missions. This seemed like a venue for the poetic script rather than a story with any substance. Only reinforced with the statement about not knowing she was being attacked and that it would be like wind was flowing through her body. I have to call BS. This is unwatchable for anyone with a brain.
reply
andreiistrate2214
The story was really confusing.
Also, wouldn't it make more sense to show our main character actually doing space captain stuff Nothing serious, just press a sequence of buttons while reading the results off the screen and perform an equipment check (and this can be easily researched, and also has the benefit of getting the NASA nerds on your side. Seeing her simply lounge around and say captain's log like she was on a vacation made me think that the whole sequence is actually some sort of simulation to get her to access some repressed memories about her mother or some such.
Again, really confusing, could be better.
reply
The story was really confusing.
Also, wouldn't it make more sense to show our main character actually doing space captain stuff Nothing serious, just press a sequence of buttons while reading the results off the screen and perform an equipment check (and this can be easily researched, and also has the benefit of getting the NASA nerds on your side. Seeing her simply lounge around and say captain's log like she was on a vacation made me think that the whole sequence is actually some sort of simulation to get her to access some repressed memories about her mother or some such.
Again, really confusing, could be better.
reply
EndUser-yu7gg
After watching this one I can honestly say I have no clue what the heck happened or was going on.
That big a ship and only a single person onboard.
Jupiter and Europa looking for life we do that stuff with probes as it's cheaper and more realistic.
They got a solar flare that triggered a lightning strike which destroys the ship. but honestly was in the radiation belt of Jupiter which is one of the most nasty. I cannot see our space agency sending a human into that even in the next 20 years to the timeline of this.
reply
After watching this one I can honestly say I have no clue what the heck happened or was going on.
That big a ship and only a single person onboard.
Jupiter and Europa looking for life we do that stuff with probes as it's cheaper and more realistic.
They got a solar flare that triggered a lightning strike which destroys the ship. but honestly was in the radiation belt of Jupiter which is one of the most nasty. I cannot see our space agency sending a human into that even in the next 20 years to the timeline of this.
reply
bannerman100
Impossible to understand the plot. Stories told in intermittent flashbacks are just plain annoying. Who was murdered and why What were the fish tanks for Where did the lightning come from Why did the ship have insufficient radiation protection
(I could go on)
If you have a story to tell, start at the beginning, go on till you came to the end, then stop.
Then we can understand the story and enjoy it.
(However, if its just a suicidaly miserable depressing story like this, don't bother)
reply
Impossible to understand the plot. Stories told in intermittent flashbacks are just plain annoying. Who was murdered and why What were the fish tanks for Where did the lightning come from Why did the ship have insufficient radiation protection
(I could go on)
If you have a story to tell, start at the beginning, go on till you came to the end, then stop.
Then we can understand the story and enjoy it.
(However, if its just a suicidaly miserable depressing story like this, don't bother)
reply
nicolepoulin3477
Victorious Earth for which I was named: Nicole Rhea pales in comparison to this Novelle or Cinematic Short (noted error, enjoying more of my names. .. .. .. God I regret making over 70 email addresses just for the fun of it since 2008, but; who am I Only Babylon. Up, .. .. . . But, where it's at Neptune! Neptune don't be stealing my MRE's while u be heating up The Artic & Antarctica. Mad props to Michael Salla, may u be still, exist Michael Scalla. Microphone drop. But in real life, just a shy grrl.
reply
Victorious Earth for which I was named: Nicole Rhea pales in comparison to this Novelle or Cinematic Short (noted error, enjoying more of my names. .. .. .. God I regret making over 70 email addresses just for the fun of it since 2008, but; who am I Only Babylon. Up, .. .. . . But, where it's at Neptune! Neptune don't be stealing my MRE's while u be heating up The Artic & Antarctica. Mad props to Michael Salla, may u be still, exist Michael Scalla. Microphone drop. But in real life, just a shy grrl.
reply
barrahart
Beautiful script, beautiful visuals, beautiful execution, a beautiful, beautiful, beautiful story! Frankly, I'm astonished by a lot of comments criticizing the non-linear narrative style and unanswered questions. When the hell did respecting our audience's intelligence become a bad thing You can enjoy a story and use your head at the same time. I for one had no problem following this.
Much love to the cast and crew from a fellow sci-fi storyteller. Olivia killed it. You all did!
reply
Beautiful script, beautiful visuals, beautiful execution, a beautiful, beautiful, beautiful story! Frankly, I'm astonished by a lot of comments criticizing the non-linear narrative style and unanswered questions. When the hell did respecting our audience's intelligence become a bad thing You can enjoy a story and use your head at the same time. I for one had no problem following this.
Much love to the cast and crew from a fellow sci-fi storyteller. Olivia killed it. You all did!
reply
toujourslamour7573
Hi, i really wanted to connect with this story, but just couldn't. I write sci-fi (and other genres) and have read lots - so my mind is very open to a story, no matter how far out there it is. Lots of great imagery in this short, and a hint at some kind of grief over a killing. but so many unanswered questions. and just couldn't follow it. I realize, it can be hard to tell a full story in just a few minutes, which is why the story should be kept simpler. Just sayin'.
reply
Hi, i really wanted to connect with this story, but just couldn't. I write sci-fi (and other genres) and have read lots - so my mind is very open to a story, no matter how far out there it is. Lots of great imagery in this short, and a hint at some kind of grief over a killing. but so many unanswered questions. and just couldn't follow it. I realize, it can be hard to tell a full story in just a few minutes, which is why the story should be kept simpler. Just sayin'.
reply
danielolson437
It's like 2 different movies (or a miniseries) edited into 10 minutes. While the unclear backstory just got more complicated, it was interesting and well directed. The science side of the mission was too sketchy and needed a serious rewrite. It was just too ambitious >multiple time lines with themes such as grief, abuse and obsession< for a 10 minute project. Pare it down so we know who and what we are supposed to engage with.
reply
It's like 2 different movies (or a miniseries) edited into 10 minutes. While the unclear backstory just got more complicated, it was interesting and well directed. The science side of the mission was too sketchy and needed a serious rewrite. It was just too ambitious >multiple time lines with themes such as grief, abuse and obsession< for a 10 minute project. Pare it down so we know who and what we are supposed to engage with.
reply
top10attractions81
Ryan, I did not connect on an emotional level.
Because you did not (KISS) and wrote the story too complex and confusing to follow.
There is enough confusion and distortion in this world today that freaks people out!
Keeping the story simple helps people to escape the realities of our society today that
they have to deal with.
Bottom line, this story was too complex to do as a short.
reply
Ryan, I did not connect on an emotional level.
Because you did not (KISS) and wrote the story too complex and confusing to follow.
There is enough confusion and distortion in this world today that freaks people out!
Keeping the story simple helps people to escape the realities of our society today that
they have to deal with.
Bottom line, this story was too complex to do as a short.
reply
irena4545
I'm afraid that this felt like two completely different stories slapped together via a highly implausible connection of sending someone with a huge trauma in her past on a mission requiring emotional stability. The camera work was good, as far as I can tell, and the flashbacks worked well to figure out the story, but I am not sure about the blurred scenes of the murder, there were too many of them.
reply
I'm afraid that this felt like two completely different stories slapped together via a highly implausible connection of sending someone with a huge trauma in her past on a mission requiring emotional stability. The camera work was good, as far as I can tell, and the flashbacks worked well to figure out the story, but I am not sure about the blurred scenes of the murder, there were too many of them.
reply
Alex-kp3hr
I agree with Florida Man, it should not have been a solo mission regardless of the back story. And, what happened to the emergency escape pod Every technically advanced ship should have at least 2 more than the number of crew members. Only 2 people in mission control The cinematography is good and the audio was good as well. I would rate the effort a B- but do keep at it.
reply
I agree with Florida Man, it should not have been a solo mission regardless of the back story. And, what happened to the emergency escape pod Every technically advanced ship should have at least 2 more than the number of crew members. Only 2 people in mission control The cinematography is good and the audio was good as well. I would rate the effort a B- but do keep at it.
reply
gerstmanndavid
There's a lot of potential for this story. However, it felt like you were trying to pack way too much into a very short film to the point that it was confusing. I would also seriously question the judgment of a space agency that would send a psychologically damaged person on a mission like this, let alone all by her self. Trauma and isolation are not a good mix.
reply
There's a lot of potential for this story. However, it felt like you were trying to pack way too much into a very short film to the point that it was confusing. I would also seriously question the judgment of a space agency that would send a psychologically damaged person on a mission like this, let alone all by her self. Trauma and isolation are not a good mix.
reply
ColleenBeaty
Very lovely shots and great acting. I thought it was interesting how you borrowed the Europa Clipper, an actual (unmanned) probe in development that will look at Europa, and adjusted it for your story. A solo mission of that length would never be feasible, though - she would almost certainly go mad from the prolonged isolation.
reply
Very lovely shots and great acting. I thought it was interesting how you borrowed the Europa Clipper, an actual (unmanned) probe in development that will look at Europa, and adjusted it for your story. A solo mission of that length would never be feasible, though - she would almost certainly go mad from the prolonged isolation.
reply
ketselatekle2939
On the power On El Shaddai Elohim Adoni Ahcad Shama Israel El Roi
On the power On St Gabriel
On the power On St Michael
On the power On Virgin Mary
On the power On St. George
All the ufo and bad gad witchcraft will be in the middle in the volcano forever and ever Amen
reply
On the power On El Shaddai Elohim Adoni Ahcad Shama Israel El Roi
On the power On St Gabriel
On the power On St Michael
On the power On Virgin Mary
On the power On St. George
All the ufo and bad gad witchcraft will be in the middle in the volcano forever and ever Amen
reply
montanateri6889
so her sister was murdered by their mother thats all I got and that may not be right
whys she floating in space what about the solar storm what was mission for
very confusing kinda like my post with no punctuation and no cap letters just stuff missing and you dont know what
reply
so her sister was murdered by their mother thats all I got and that may not be right
whys she floating in space what about the solar storm what was mission for
very confusing kinda like my post with no punctuation and no cap letters just stuff missing and you dont know what
reply
ladonnabrown8402
I couldn't get to enjoy the movie, too much cursing. I don't understand the point of all that, even having the kid curse. I stopped half way, it's just too much for me, do better, it doesn't take all of that to get a point across about anything. DO BETTER PLEASE. Thank you.
reply
I couldn't get to enjoy the movie, too much cursing. I don't understand the point of all that, even having the kid curse. I stopped half way, it's just too much for me, do better, it doesn't take all of that to get a point across about anything. DO BETTER PLEASE. Thank you.
reply
rolandmine6693
1 quick thing I notice how the centrifuge is spinning relative to the 2 stations placed that are spinning with it. But the way the moving would not actually create a downward force for the crew, instead pushing them to the side inside the ship.
reply
1 quick thing I notice how the centrifuge is spinning relative to the 2 stations placed that are spinning with it. But the way the moving would not actually create a downward force for the crew, instead pushing them to the side inside the ship.
reply
pegefounder
Faster than light radio transmission Light needs more than 1/2 hour from Jupiter to Earth.
Solar flares in the Jupiter distance from the sun have only 1/25 the power of here in Earth distance from the sun.
reply
Faster than light radio transmission Light needs more than 1/2 hour from Jupiter to Earth.
Solar flares in the Jupiter distance from the sun have only 1/25 the power of here in Earth distance from the sun.
reply
wrlord
Terrific visuals, but just too damn precious. And the idea that someone with that much psychological baggage could get approved for space travel is just asking too much suspension of disbelief.
reply
Terrific visuals, but just too damn precious. And the idea that someone with that much psychological baggage could get approved for space travel is just asking too much suspension of disbelief.
reply
johnmarengo3919
Good, yet I agree with several comments about the back story. I also thought that on a modern spacecraft we'd see more touch screen technology and less analog controls, switched etc.
reply
Good, yet I agree with several comments about the back story. I also thought that on a modern spacecraft we'd see more touch screen technology and less analog controls, switched etc.
reply
asc_missions3080
Great concept, perfect visuals, wasted behind third-rate sound mixing. Bummer. Suggestion: when there's speech, it should be foremost in volume, and clear. Else why is it there
reply
Great concept, perfect visuals, wasted behind third-rate sound mixing. Bummer. Suggestion: when there's speech, it should be foremost in volume, and clear. Else why is it there
reply
vintageguitarz1
HORRIBLY CONFUSING video, more interested in being ARTSY FARTSY than trying to make a good story. This is entirely too much the case with the CRAP on Dust.
reply
HORRIBLY CONFUSING video, more interested in being ARTSY FARTSY than trying to make a good story. This is entirely too much the case with the CRAP on Dust.
reply
robertevans8010
Hiraeth The longing for your Homeland language Brythonic Celtic, Cymric or Welsh as the English call it. a Ancient word from before the Birth of Christ
reply
Hiraeth The longing for your Homeland language Brythonic Celtic, Cymric or Welsh as the English call it. a Ancient word from before the Birth of Christ
reply
Omegavision79
This wasn't SciFi. This was some psychological tragedy with space attached. Not sure I'd have followed it if it was in chronological order. Did not like.
reply
This wasn't SciFi. This was some psychological tragedy with space attached. Not sure I'd have followed it if it was in chronological order. Did not like.
reply
tomcayne
I never understand WHY you woud make movies with ONE person on a mission. It shows you and humanity will NEVER learn that a TEAM is better than SOLO missions.
reply
I never understand WHY you woud make movies with ONE person on a mission. It shows you and humanity will NEVER learn that a TEAM is better than SOLO missions.
reply
rjwarrier
It was just a series of images of which some was good to look at. The story Part was null. Couldnot understand what was going on overall a thumbs down
reply
It was just a series of images of which some was good to look at. The story Part was null. Couldnot understand what was going on overall a thumbs down
reply
jackwise3367
Absolutely OUTSTANDING film! My only comment/question is. do you actually think dropping the F-bomb so many times added anything to the story line
reply
Absolutely OUTSTANDING film! My only comment/question is. do you actually think dropping the F-bomb so many times added anything to the story line
reply
CyberStew
Production value was good but honestly the story didn't make a lot of sense and seemed disjointed. Not my cup of tea, but that's just my opinion.
reply
Production value was good but honestly the story didn't make a lot of sense and seemed disjointed. Not my cup of tea, but that's just my opinion.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
