
The Un-BMW 2020 BMW 228i Gran Coupe
video description
Date: 2020-07-18
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 10
Dimitris
Well 50K+ just for the badge. I'm not snobing, I can afford a brand new BMW up to 5 series. but I like my cars reliable, cheap to maintain and run. Like Toyota, Honda, Subaru and perhaps Hyundai.
A young cousin of mine graduated university with very high marks and my uncle got her the new X2. I advised him to opt for the RAV4 or Lexus UX or NX but he insisted for a BMW, my cousin isn't a snob and frankly she doesn't really care about badge. After 3 weeks the frond LED head lights started to draw water and condescension. BMW said is completely normal for the head light assembly to get water and condescension, best they can do is to dry the assembly and if we are bothered they can offer to put humidity absorbing packs inside the assembly to stop condescension. 70K car fully loaded and the head lights come with factory fault and BMW refuses to replace them. mean while my shit box Toyota Aygo got the same issue at the driver's head light after 4 years and Toyota replaced it for free, no part or labour cost.
reply
Well 50K+ just for the badge. I'm not snobing, I can afford a brand new BMW up to 5 series. but I like my cars reliable, cheap to maintain and run. Like Toyota, Honda, Subaru and perhaps Hyundai.
A young cousin of mine graduated university with very high marks and my uncle got her the new X2. I advised him to opt for the RAV4 or Lexus UX or NX but he insisted for a BMW, my cousin isn't a snob and frankly she doesn't really care about badge. After 3 weeks the frond LED head lights started to draw water and condescension. BMW said is completely normal for the head light assembly to get water and condescension, best they can do is to dry the assembly and if we are bothered they can offer to put humidity absorbing packs inside the assembly to stop condescension. 70K car fully loaded and the head lights come with factory fault and BMW refuses to replace them. mean while my shit box Toyota Aygo got the same issue at the driver's head light after 4 years and Toyota replaced it for free, no part or labour cost.
reply
DailyRant
Countless comments proving how clueless people are about the market. as someone who doesn't appreciate this car as much as most of you, it's really not that difficult to see where the market is trending. Look at the segment, you have a brand new CLA, A-class, A3. It's obvious these companies think customers are going to buy these (and they are probably right. So you can hate it all you want.
When Porsche first came out with their SUV, they got so much hate. Now if you look at it now, they clearly made the right choice. Their Macan and Cayennes are best selling and really the only reason they can continue to make 911's.
reply
Countless comments proving how clueless people are about the market. as someone who doesn't appreciate this car as much as most of you, it's really not that difficult to see where the market is trending. Look at the segment, you have a brand new CLA, A-class, A3. It's obvious these companies think customers are going to buy these (and they are probably right. So you can hate it all you want.
When Porsche first came out with their SUV, they got so much hate. Now if you look at it now, they clearly made the right choice. Their Macan and Cayennes are best selling and really the only reason they can continue to make 911's.
reply
tatoo99999
the problem is not about been purist, the problem is this, it is really hard to find a good excuse to buy this car( a 2 grand coupe series with a FWD, other than been a badge fan. there is not reason to buy this car over a honda accord 2020 touring 2. 0 turbo. the honda is faster, more roomy, better equiped, more reliable and better priced, i think bmw did wrong here. if you are going to charge a premium price on a car, it is necesary a good justification for that price. this bmw looks like a ford fiesta or a kia forte with a bmw badge.
reply
the problem is not about been purist, the problem is this, it is really hard to find a good excuse to buy this car( a 2 grand coupe series with a FWD, other than been a badge fan. there is not reason to buy this car over a honda accord 2020 touring 2. 0 turbo. the honda is faster, more roomy, better equiped, more reliable and better priced, i think bmw did wrong here. if you are going to charge a premium price on a car, it is necesary a good justification for that price. this bmw looks like a ford fiesta or a kia forte with a bmw badge.
reply
kens97sto171
Fantastic review as always.
I just do not understand the appeal of bothering to build a four-door coupe that you can't actually put people in the backseat?
A Toyota Corolla has standard better safety equipment and crash avoidance.
And the last generation Nissan versa has More interior room and cargo?
maybe I'm just getting old but it seems to be if you build a four-door car you should at least be able to put four people in the car At least for a short drive.
reply
Fantastic review as always.
I just do not understand the appeal of bothering to build a four-door coupe that you can't actually put people in the backseat?
A Toyota Corolla has standard better safety equipment and crash avoidance.
And the last generation Nissan versa has More interior room and cargo?
maybe I'm just getting old but it seems to be if you build a four-door car you should at least be able to put four people in the car At least for a short drive.
reply
Randomness
BMW stopped being BMW years ago. This abomination is just another example - looks like generic Korean sedan from side, the rear brake lights also look like from any generic Asian sedan, the instrument panel lost traditional round speedometer and tachometer which you can't even get with digital display, no rear wheel drive, no hydraulic steering. Luckily it is still possible to find used BMW cars made in early 2010's with a relatively low mileage.
reply
BMW stopped being BMW years ago. This abomination is just another example - looks like generic Korean sedan from side, the rear brake lights also look like from any generic Asian sedan, the instrument panel lost traditional round speedometer and tachometer which you can't even get with digital display, no rear wheel drive, no hydraulic steering. Luckily it is still possible to find used BMW cars made in early 2010's with a relatively low mileage.
reply
SDav21
I don't understand how you say iDrive is more intuitive. I've used it in a friend's car. It's literally menus within menus within sub menus. It's extremely irritating. I didn't find it intuitive at all. MBUX is better laid out within functions. Like within the map part, it's much easier to enter a destination etc. In the radio part, it's much easier to navigate the options etc. Certainly much easier than BMW's menu menu menu menu submenu layout.
reply
I don't understand how you say iDrive is more intuitive. I've used it in a friend's car. It's literally menus within menus within sub menus. It's extremely irritating. I didn't find it intuitive at all. MBUX is better laid out within functions. Like within the map part, it's much easier to enter a destination etc. In the radio part, it's much easier to navigate the options etc. Certainly much easier than BMW's menu menu menu menu submenu layout.
reply
bassandtrebleclef
I'm similar in height and size to Alex and the back seat of this car looks very much like the one from my 07 328i. I would not even want to be there for a short ride. This is a VERY small car, so if you plan on carrying people, you better make sure they're 5'8 or shorter and won't get taller. A Honda Civic is bigger than this AND you can get a stick in the Civic Si. Just another needlessly expensive BMW.
reply
I'm similar in height and size to Alex and the back seat of this car looks very much like the one from my 07 328i. I would not even want to be there for a short ride. This is a VERY small car, so if you plan on carrying people, you better make sure they're 5'8 or shorter and won't get taller. A Honda Civic is bigger than this AND you can get a stick in the Civic Si. Just another needlessly expensive BMW.
reply
John
After mentioning the Cadillac and Volvo, Alex missed the most obvious alternative; the Genesis G70. The G70 is rwd/awd and also starts under 40K, while maxing out at around 55K. Only reasons to buy the 228i are you WANT a small car for urban commuting or you have to have the BMW badge. The Genesis, Caddy and Volvo all give you a much better car for similar money.
reply
After mentioning the Cadillac and Volvo, Alex missed the most obvious alternative; the Genesis G70. The G70 is rwd/awd and also starts under 40K, while maxing out at around 55K. Only reasons to buy the 228i are you WANT a small car for urban commuting or you have to have the BMW badge. The Genesis, Caddy and Volvo all give you a much better car for similar money.
reply
JBM425
For those of us in Steerage Class (to borrow a term from The Flintstones, would you compare the interior in terms of volume to the Civic and Corolla? Based on rear seat legroom, that appears less than what one would get in the Camry or Accord. That's not necessarily a deal breaker if the car is only going to carry one or maybe two people.
reply
For those of us in Steerage Class (to borrow a term from The Flintstones, would you compare the interior in terms of volume to the Civic and Corolla? Based on rear seat legroom, that appears less than what one would get in the Camry or Accord. That's not necessarily a deal breaker if the car is only going to carry one or maybe two people.
reply
SDav21
The A Class looks way better. The BMW looks blobby. The A Class looks way more sleek. The BMW looks like a 1 series hatchback that was made a sedan. It has that odd proportion towards the back whereas the A Class doesn't. You can see Mercedes was doing front wheel drive long before bmw because they actually got it to look right.
reply
The A Class looks way better. The BMW looks blobby. The A Class looks way more sleek. The BMW looks like a 1 series hatchback that was made a sedan. It has that odd proportion towards the back whereas the A Class doesn't. You can see Mercedes was doing front wheel drive long before bmw because they actually got it to look right.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















