Tesla Model 3 vs Tesla Model Y - Which Should You Get?
video description
Date: 2023-11-14
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 16
Michael
My family just bought a Model Y yesterday. We looked at Lexus and Jeep options for more size and clearance, but the dealer experience is just so bad. It brought back PTSD, lol, from our last dealership experiences. I will never buy from an automaker that doesn't allow online-only purchase. Tesla has the best purchase experience. Financing through Tesla at 6% for 72 was also the best offer with the fed's current anti worker stance. So with the tax credit, the Y was just too good of price to pass up, not to mention fuel saving and higher safety rating. We even both liked other vehicles more. In the end, the dealership model lost Lexus and Jeep customers.
reply
My family just bought a Model Y yesterday. We looked at Lexus and Jeep options for more size and clearance, but the dealer experience is just so bad. It brought back PTSD, lol, from our last dealership experiences. I will never buy from an automaker that doesn't allow online-only purchase. Tesla has the best purchase experience. Financing through Tesla at 6% for 72 was also the best offer with the fed's current anti worker stance. So with the tax credit, the Y was just too good of price to pass up, not to mention fuel saving and higher safety rating. We even both liked other vehicles more. In the end, the dealership model lost Lexus and Jeep customers.
reply
Chris
I owned both a '20 Y Performance and a '21 3 Performance at the same time. We liked both cars, but got tired of waiting on the Cybertruck to launch so the choice was to sell the Y. It was nice, but the 3 is a lot more fun to drive, gets better range and doesn't eat through tires like the staggered setup on the Y Performance. If we didn't end up getting a truck to replace the Y, then it would have made more sense to sell the 3 for it's increased storage capacity, even though it wasn't as enjoyable to drive.
reply
I owned both a '20 Y Performance and a '21 3 Performance at the same time. We liked both cars, but got tired of waiting on the Cybertruck to launch so the choice was to sell the Y. It was nice, but the 3 is a lot more fun to drive, gets better range and doesn't eat through tires like the staggered setup on the Y Performance. If we didn't end up getting a truck to replace the Y, then it would have made more sense to sell the 3 for it's increased storage capacity, even though it wasn't as enjoyable to drive.
reply
autos
The upgraded 2024 model 3 that apparently is out now in Europe - saw a review of - supposedly has a bit softer ride which I would be interested in. Nothing said about the Y getting the same upgrades? Also, I am single and don't qualify for rebates. Could my son buy(who qualifies for credits) and then sell to me. I know Alex has commented in teh past about getting rebates via leases, but fear there will be a penalty built in - how about a in depth video on pluses and minuses?
reply
The upgraded 2024 model 3 that apparently is out now in Europe - saw a review of - supposedly has a bit softer ride which I would be interested in. Nothing said about the Y getting the same upgrades? Also, I am single and don't qualify for rebates. Could my son buy(who qualifies for credits) and then sell to me. I know Alex has commented in teh past about getting rebates via leases, but fear there will be a penalty built in - how about a in depth video on pluses and minuses?
reply
JSFBay
Wow, what a useful video! Thank you! A comfort suspension option is something I'd want. One other thing that would be good to know is just how loud is it going 60 mph on the freeway with that big glass roof? I wish there was an option for a smaller moon roof to quiet things down (and in a place like FL, to moderate the heat)
reply
Wow, what a useful video! Thank you! A comfort suspension option is something I'd want. One other thing that would be good to know is just how loud is it going 60 mph on the freeway with that big glass roof? I wish there was an option for a smaller moon roof to quiet things down (and in a place like FL, to moderate the heat)
reply
Ti-NrS
Yep, I have a GC Overland (got a Good deal on it) but I also own a Midsize car for driving around. I Like what Travis said at the end as to why he choose his. I would get a similar model to his when i get an EV. I am Single. No animals and dont drive far, But rarely. I dont need all the extra room.
reply
Yep, I have a GC Overland (got a Good deal on it) but I also own a Midsize car for driving around. I Like what Travis said at the end as to why he choose his. I would get a similar model to his when i get an EV. I am Single. No animals and dont drive far, But rarely. I dont need all the extra room.
reply
James
A lot of talk about the tax credit but keep in mind it is income limited also. Many people who can afford these electric vehicles aren t eligible because they have gross income in excess of the allowable limit, so it s not an incentive - and buyers like us look at a wide array of other vehicles.
reply
A lot of talk about the tax credit but keep in mind it is income limited also. Many people who can afford these electric vehicles aren t eligible because they have gross income in excess of the allowable limit, so it s not an incentive - and buyers like us look at a wide array of other vehicles.
reply
TeslaPhan
My 2023 rwd m3 is way softer than the original model 3. I don't have any regrets of going with a sedan. Point A - B car and a great charging network and second car for the family. Compliments our van perfectly for everyday use. Bye-bye gas station!
reply
My 2023 rwd m3 is way softer than the original model 3. I don't have any regrets of going with a sedan. Point A - B car and a great charging network and second car for the family. Compliments our van perfectly for everyday use. Bye-bye gas station!
reply
Bert
Big point the biodefence filter is what nailed my purchase of the model Y, especially here in BC with all that forest fire smoke during the warmer months! Everyone was hoping the refreshed model 3 would have it but such is not the case!
reply
Big point the biodefence filter is what nailed my purchase of the model Y, especially here in BC with all that forest fire smoke during the warmer months! Everyone was hoping the refreshed model 3 would have it but such is not the case!
reply
CrazyWeeMonkey
The Camry/Accord comparison is interesting given that the cabin dimensions (& exterior dimensions) of the Model 3 are almost identical to compacts like the Civic, Elantra, and Jetta.
reply
The Camry/Accord comparison is interesting given that the cabin dimensions (& exterior dimensions) of the Model 3 are almost identical to compacts like the Civic, Elantra, and Jetta.
reply
autos
Geez, that opening 20 seconds with the cars coming into frame. Just reminded me how bad Tesla styling is. I love Tesla's mission, hate their turtle-faced, jelly-bean cars.
reply
Geez, that opening 20 seconds with the cars coming into frame. Just reminded me how bad Tesla styling is. I love Tesla's mission, hate their turtle-faced, jelly-bean cars.
reply
Roger
You men both make a great team to comment on all phases of the Model 3 and Y. Really excellent review. Thank you as your comments are of value for a decision to purchase.
reply
You men both make a great team to comment on all phases of the Model 3 and Y. Really excellent review. Thank you as your comments are of value for a decision to purchase.
reply
CFG
Crossovers destroyed choice in the car market, that's a big reason I'll never consider one. So many great coupes and sedans are already dead because of those awful blobs.
reply
Crossovers destroyed choice in the car market, that's a big reason I'll never consider one. So many great coupes and sedans are already dead because of those awful blobs.
reply
Enthusiast
Depends on what you need it for. There is no worse or better. I like my Model Y I recently reviewed. For our family the Model 3 would not work as well.
reply
Depends on what you need it for. There is no worse or better. I like my Model Y I recently reviewed. For our family the Model 3 would not work as well.
reply
Winston
This video is poorly timed. With the Highland 3 coming, the assertions about comfort, NVH, ride quality, etc are no longer relevant or accurate.
reply
This video is poorly timed. With the Highland 3 coming, the assertions about comfort, NVH, ride quality, etc are no longer relevant or accurate.
reply
Arch
I think it's important to mention that you get tax credits on these vehicles. I'm in Colorado and i get 7500 federal plus 5000 state credits
reply
I think it's important to mention that you get tax credits on these vehicles. I'm in Colorado and i get 7500 federal plus 5000 state credits
reply
Right
Alex and Travis, I salute the camera operator. There was more panning in this video than in a typical month's production.
reply
Alex and Travis, I salute the camera operator. There was more panning in this video than in a typical month's production.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
