2020 Porsche Macan Turbo vs Range Rover Velar SVAutobiography review - the best fast SUV? - Autocar
video description
Date: 2022-04-17
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 10
Nikolai
Don't think these are comparable. You can compare the Macan to F-Pace SVR, Stelvio QV. you know - SUVs made for taking corners fast. The Velar SVAD? Don't think there is much to compare it to. Bigger top of the line MBs and BMWs and Audis, but these come as the RRS competitors, not the Velar.
I own the V6 diesel Velar, my only regret is I missed the V6 petrol engine (they've stopped selling it some time ago) and I couldn't wait for JLR to release the hybrid V6 petrol that is somewhere on the 2021-2022 lists.
reply
Don't think these are comparable. You can compare the Macan to F-Pace SVR, Stelvio QV. you know - SUVs made for taking corners fast. The Velar SVAD? Don't think there is much to compare it to. Bigger top of the line MBs and BMWs and Audis, but these come as the RRS competitors, not the Velar.
I own the V6 diesel Velar, my only regret is I missed the V6 petrol engine (they've stopped selling it some time ago) and I couldn't wait for JLR to release the hybrid V6 petrol that is somewhere on the 2021-2022 lists.
reply
Trubshaw2
Take me through why they are making a video of two 4 x 4-s that are supposedly very capable off road and then just driving them around the road? It would really help if the so-called professional people could actually pronounce Porsche properly as well. It makes them seem very uneducated. It-s a bit like saying Madjorca instead of majorca! DULL.
reply
Take me through why they are making a video of two 4 x 4-s that are supposedly very capable off road and then just driving them around the road? It would really help if the so-called professional people could actually pronounce Porsche properly as well. It makes them seem very uneducated. It-s a bit like saying Madjorca instead of majorca! DULL.
reply
geoffk777
SUVs aren't really my speed. But, between these two, the Porsche is cheaper, more economical and drives better on-road. And, since it's a Range Rover, the Velar will be a garage queen that causes you no end of grief. I understand that AutoCar wants to wave the flag and hates to dump on the Range Rover, but it's really an easy choice.
reply
SUVs aren't really my speed. But, between these two, the Porsche is cheaper, more economical and drives better on-road. And, since it's a Range Rover, the Velar will be a garage queen that causes you no end of grief. I understand that AutoCar wants to wave the flag and hates to dump on the Range Rover, but it's really an easy choice.
reply
Steve
Has to be the Porsche. I-ve had a Velar and they are just not as well made as the Germans. You get electrical faults, screens not firing up, door handles not popping out etc. And they always seem to break down. I would never own any Land Rover/Jaguar product that wasn-t under full manufacturers warranty put it that way.
reply
Has to be the Porsche. I-ve had a Velar and they are just not as well made as the Germans. You get electrical faults, screens not firing up, door handles not popping out etc. And they always seem to break down. I would never own any Land Rover/Jaguar product that wasn-t under full manufacturers warranty put it that way.
reply
Dove
RANGE ROVER. GUARANTEE TO BREAK.
( guys you know that, their reliability is rubbish. NEVER BUY A RANGE ROVER (
PORCHES NEVER A PROBLEM WITH MY 7 YEAR OLD CAYENNE. ( I'm changing to the new skoda soon )
reply
RANGE ROVER. GUARANTEE TO BREAK.
( guys you know that, their reliability is rubbish. NEVER BUY A RANGE ROVER (
PORCHES NEVER A PROBLEM WITH MY 7 YEAR OLD CAYENNE. ( I'm changing to the new skoda soon )
reply
loukas
I dont think many mention that macan is actually a pretty good offroader, i would definately option in with airsprings for more comfort and offroad capability, though the rover is better offroader
reply
I dont think many mention that macan is actually a pretty good offroader, i would definately option in with airsprings for more comfort and offroad capability, though the rover is better offroader
reply
Andy
Bigger fuel loads more weight less performance more fuel used. Never run my car at full tank. why add extra 25 kilo for no reason other than cant be bothered to get out once to fill up again.
reply
Bigger fuel loads more weight less performance more fuel used. Never run my car at full tank. why add extra 25 kilo for no reason other than cant be bothered to get out once to fill up again.
reply
Shihabuddin
Range Rover was ruined the day they were bought by TATA.
TaTa failed to manage the brands name and quality.
They only focused on increasing sales. It is very disappointing.
reply
Range Rover was ruined the day they were bought by TATA.
TaTa failed to manage the brands name and quality.
They only focused on increasing sales. It is very disappointing.
reply
autos
Thank you for your review. So many complaints about the drivers. then turn if off if you don-t like it. geez! Do you keep eating something that you think tastes bad?
reply
Thank you for your review. So many complaints about the drivers. then turn if off if you don-t like it. geez! Do you keep eating something that you think tastes bad?
reply
geoffk777
The Porsche is no Toyota in terms of reliability, but a Range Rover with air springs is going to be a disaster. So I'd go for the Porsche.
reply
The Porsche is no Toyota in terms of reliability, but a Range Rover with air springs is going to be a disaster. So I'd go for the Porsche.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
4:54
