• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Logically Yours
Riddle: How many coins do you need to measure height of Burj Khalifa Think out of the box

Riddle: How many coins do you need to measure height of Burj Khalifa Think out of the box

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
Riddle: How many coins do you need to measure height of Burj Khalifa -- Think out of the box Richard: I go on a tour of the Burj Khalifa. At the end of the tour, I ask the guide how tall it is and then offer a tip of one coin in thanks.
Or I tie a coin to a fishing rod with a very large reel. Then I lower the coin to the ground from the top and measure the fishing line.
Or I throw a coin out horizontally at a known speed from the top and measure how far away it lands. If it is dense enough then it will describe a parabola so I can work out the height. Although this assumes a constant acceleration due to gravity, which is not entirely correct. So, instead. -
. I tie a very dense coin (krugerand) to a very thin piece of cotton. Then I put it in an evacuated box. I let the coin swing back and forth like a pendulum at ground level and at the top. I check the period, and work out the acceleration due to gravity in each case. Assuming the Earth is spherical and the mass of the Burj Khalifa is negligible compared to the Earth then the acceleration due to gravity is inversely proportional to the square of the period. Gravity is also inversely proportional to the square of the distance to the centre of the Earth. So the didtance to the centre is proportional to the period. So we can work out the height of Burj Khalifa as a fraction of the radius of the Earth.

Date: 2023-11-15

Comments and reviews: 29


I'll tell you what I think and then look at your solution. all these need just 1 coin
Solution 1. If you know the circumfrence of the coin simply roll it up the side of the building and count how many 'turns' it took. completely impractical, of course!
Solution 3. Drop the coin off the top and time how long it takes to hit the ground and then use whatever formula you need to work out what the height is. as long as there is no wind.
Solution 3. Hold up the coin infront of you so that it exactly 'covers' the tower. there must be a formula that you can use if you know the size of the coin, how far you are away from the tower and how far away from you the coin is.

reply

The kink in the coin drop solution is 2 factors: air resistance and absolute time recording. The time problem could be solved by using electronic devices that would reduce human error to nil. The air resistant would be totally random and impossible to account for. I have dropped coins from tall bridges and the time to hit the water was somewhat random. Some coins actually seemed to spin so fast that the curvature of their path was amazing. The spinning actually seemed to cause lift. Even with great care to drop the coin perpendicular the coin still started to spin.
reply

What about terminal velocity of a coin?
I'm not really sure this would give you precise solution. And you could drop anything other than coin, so you could use 0 coins.
I know that this is a way to see if someone is creative, but asking this question in such a way it suggest that we should use coin dimensions.
If on other hand it would be -You only have unlimited number of coins, how would you measure Burj Khalifa, and how many would you need- is much better and does not suggest that we need to use dimensions of a coin.

reply

Wrong.
1. You're assuming that you can somehow drop a coin from the top of the tower without it hitting the sides? How?
2. You're assuming the coin will accelerate smoothly, and will not reach it's terminal velocity and stop accelerating. Can you support this assumption?
3. You're using other equipment to time the fall, this wasn't specified in the question.
If you can use other equipment, the answer is cleary, 0 coins.
No-one in the world of surveying uses coins to calculate height.

reply

You would get a much more accurate value by counting the windows without any coins. Each floor is about 10 ft. Timing the fall with a stopwatch (especially with one person starting and another stopping) will easily have 2-3 floors worth of error. Additionally, a coin dropped from the top will experience significant air resistance before reaching the ground making your model invalid. You could use your finger at arm's length to estimate the height of the superstructure in units of floors.
reply

One coin. Say to the architect, -I will give you this coin if you let me look at the blueprint of the Burj Khalifa. - OR: one coin. Place the coin on its edge and compare the diameter of the coin to the length of its shadow. Then measure the length of the shadow of the Burj Khalifa Tower. Multiply the diameter of the coin by the length of the tower shadow and then divide the product obtained by the length of the coin's shadow. The quotient is the height of the tower.
reply

I'm wondering how only 10% should come to this solution. It was the first thing that came to my mind after a second. I was wondering if this is correct and start thinking further. Also think about stacking them but as you said its not practical.
My solutions would: Taking a camera and put a coin in front of it so it covers exactly the hight of the building. Measure the distance to the coin and to the building and geometry does the rest.

reply

How about a parallax-style method. You could stand, say, a mile away from the building, then measure how close you have to hold the coin to your eye in order for the diameter of the coin appear to be the same as the height of Khalifa. This may differ slightly on the height of the coin from the coin, height of the observer and the vertical angle of your gaze. Draw the relevant diagram and solve for the height.
reply

Well, why does the video last for 3: 51 minutes if the answer is given at 1: 20? The riddle is -how many coins. - so the answer is one. Anything else what is explained is not part of the riddle.
And even if we calculate this - do we know that g=9. 8. Is the the true value at Burj Khalifa, or it is a bit different? Not to mention air resistance etc

reply

I'd actually use one coin and drop it off and look up the terminal velocity of the coin and then calculate the height. The other way I'd do it is to at high noon measure the angle from the end of the shadow to the top and then use trigonometry to easily figure out the height since the 2nd angle has to be 90 degrees. No coins needed.
reply

this solution is wrong. there is air drag and the coin will easily reach terminal velocity. Even the no coin answer(look in the wiki) is better. But we can use the coin and use it to cover our vision of the building from a fixed distance. measure the distance from my eye to the coin then use some trigonometric formula to solve it.
reply

What I would do uses these formulas:
v-2 - u-2 = 2as
v = u + at
s = vt - 0. 5at-2 = ut + 0. 5at-2
s = 0. 5t(u+v)
s= distance (height of BK)
u= initial velocity (here 0)
v= final velocity
a= gravitational force
t= time of flight
Finally, s= 0. 5gt-2. Plug in time of flight, and s= height.

reply

How can you drop it straight down from the top?
It is very difficult to drop the coin straight down from the top when the Burj Khalifa is build with more and more cylinders on each side as the coin travels down. It will hit one of those cylinders and not fall straight down: (

reply

If the coin is valuable, give it to the caretaker of the Khalifa in exchange for telling you the height of the building. If you are already at the top, use the coin as a weight and attach it to some string. Lower the string till the coin touches the ground, measure string.
reply

That isn't the right answer since you didn't include the weight of coin and shape, in free fall the shape and weight of the material are matter because there is air resistance. so i recommend to recalculate and consider those parameters that i mentioned.
b3st regards

reply

bro air resistence left the chat becouse in real world accleration due to gravity decreases with time and will be zero after around 50 60 meter so there must be a huge calculation error as you calculate you get the height 2. 5 km which is far far away from actual height
reply

Actually we don't need coins, we need some measuring instruments, TS or theodolite and tape, yaa for making payment to those engineer, u may need some, if the engineer is like me, commenting and wasting time u dont even need any
reply

Here you need one huge coin, with a diameter equal to the height of the tower. This is not practical at all, but it will give absolute accuracy. It remains only to find the pants in the pocket of which this coin lies.
reply

Since the base of the tower is far larger than the top chances are that the coin will land and/or bounce on one of the lower levels instead of the ground. You'll need a lot more than one coin to get it right! :D
reply

I need 0 coins to measure the height of Burj Khalifa as the height is already known. Had there been any other unknown building's height to be measured, then, would have analyzed other options.
reply

I was considering one coin, walk away from the tower to a point where the coin at arms length is the same height as the building and triangulate measuring the coin and the distance traveled.
reply

No no. drop a coin from the top it will land on the below floors. are you nuts. Also gravity is weaker as height increases. Not to mention the drag from air and it's generally windy at the top.
reply

What about air resistance and winds? You have to specify hypothesis or conventions (such as -ignore resistance- and -there is no wind- in question, otherwise it's not clever, it's cheating.
reply

Approach the doorman. Say -sir I will pay you this coin if you will tell me the height of this building. - It-s a famous building so he probably gets asked all the time and will tell you.
reply

another solution for this,
ans: 1 coin
like we can messure hieght by falling it from top of that, calculate time, when coin hit the ground, so simple physics behid it

reply

It didn't work for me. I used up all my coins on the vending machine, so I dropped a bill. Afterwards I divided the distance by 10, as the bill was worth 10 coins
reply

Presented solution is wrong unless you have very long hands like Monkey D Luffy. If you drop coin from the top of the tower it will hit tower wall.
reply

Ammar, i think the friction due to air is still not considered. That would impact the calculation (although to quite a small extent)
reply

You may hang around the tower and ask everyone coming out of it -hey man I can give you a coin if you tell me the height of the tower-
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos