• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if the West Never Rose to World Dominance? Part 1

What if the West Never Rose to World Dominance? Part 1

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if the West Never Rose to World Dominance? Part 1 education: I think the reason for european dominance is much deeper than the reasons you mentioned here. Everything you mentioned are much more like symptoms of a much deeper reason and hence can't be gotten rid of that easily. The main reason for european dominance was the lack of europe's ability to form massive armies like the other three civilisations. All the other three civilisations became conservative cuz' they could. Europe didn't cuz' it couldn't. The lack of a large unified empire and a general lack of any super-fertile soil didn't help. Before the mongols and black death europe could just barely do it, but after that europe really didn't have any other choice. Since the traditional methods of beating your enemy with a big army didn't work for europe it had to find alternative routes and the explorations and renaissance are a result of that. Everybody wants security in their lives and the europeans weren't any exception. In every civ someone or the other was always trying something new. The reason those new things were welcomed more in europe is because the old ways weren't effective anymore. If some odd monarchy or lord still decided to go the traditional route they would be quickly crushed by anyone who didn't or the ottomans and the revolutions would still happen. If you want europe to not rise to dominance, give europe some super-fertile region like egypt or the hwang-ho river valley, make anything like the black death either not happen or happen so often from a super early time that most of europe can deal with it, maybe increase its size a bit more. Without at least two of these europe rises to dominance no matter what you change.
Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


If the West never did, then we would never have Muslims in the comments slighting European societies (for their supposed indignities); we wouldnt have insecure, nationalistic Indians commenting: Love from India, and just constantly berating anyone from a western nation more powerful than theirs; we would not have Chinese persons targeting America for the very fact that the CCP sucks, and them [the Americans] calling the CCP out for it, further its [CCP] apologetics; we would also not have leftists calling out the West for its injustices and hypocrisies, and that they would need new tactics for the others (as they arent white, to scrutinize)then, maybe we would have all these westerners remarking of how they were exploited and them making a fuss about it. So how about we all just have a calm down and stop being a big crybaby, okay?
reply

Why call it the West, instead of Christendom or Europe?
Also, you might want to take a look at a book called IQ and the Wealth of Nations, by Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen. Perhaps Europeans were much smarter then than everyone else but have been outsmarted by East Asians in recent times? Man is not a blank slate.
Also, you overestimate the benefits of Reformation. Protestantism only took off and expanded a century after the West, as you call it, was already dominating.

reply

Some say the world would be better if the west never existed because it would ( and true so ) remove a lot of suffering like colonialism. They say this meanwhile they write it on there computers in there ventilated heated homes. I find it so ironic and ignorant to judge something based on it's negatives without a thought about the posetives.
reply

I remember the rise of Europe. I lived in what is now called Libya at the time. Europeans were a unkempt lot, the rise of the west was as shocking then as it as now.
Take it from someone who experienced a lot of history first hand. The only constant is change. The west and it's capitalism will fade like so many empires did before them

reply

One reason thats completely overlooked by West including USA is that after Mehmed the Conquerer conquered Constantinople and Crimea(which controls the Silk Road) and other Muslim empires conquered the places for the Pepper Road, Europeans didnt want to negotiate with them and searched for alternative ways.
reply

It sounds racist but what if Europeans never existed? When would Native American, Middle Eastern or African cultures send radio waves into space? Nothing against their intelligence but the West on Earth has created an anomaly, so we should consider that when searching for radio signals in space.
reply

_The world without being colonized-. like HALF OF THE WORLD. _ well uh. unfortunately europeans. unknown peoples might counter attack or unknown tribesmen would attack europeans. meaning other people groups or as such others would kill anything unknown to themselves
reply

whenever this guy talks about indian social history, it sounds like he got it from a chapter in a white-guy text book
always has the Best premises, and interesting logical leaps, but with the worst research on althistorytube

reply

Also europeans are a faustian people with a bloodline you can trace back to thousands of years of explorers and innovators. Europeans are a race of people destined to change the world through intellectual and physical development.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos