
What if the West Never Rose to World Dominance? Part 2
video description
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
Stefan
The Netherlands in this scenario would still be under Habsburg rule, unless it's conquered by france. It's independance depended on both protestantism and scientific warfare. Without those I'd be in the unfortunate position of being a serf in the lands bordering the german states. It'd be a far flung edge of whatever realm it'd be part of, and pretty much the first to be raided in any war. I'd also speak some kind of Diets unintelligible to anyone 100 miles away in any direction. To the north they'd speak Frisian, to the south they'd speak french. To the west they'd speak Dutch, and to the east they'd speak another German dialect. I would be better able to speak with the germans on the other side of the border than with my countrymen on the coast. Since I'm 21, I would be married and have my first child.
What a scenario.
reply
The Netherlands in this scenario would still be under Habsburg rule, unless it's conquered by france. It's independance depended on both protestantism and scientific warfare. Without those I'd be in the unfortunate position of being a serf in the lands bordering the german states. It'd be a far flung edge of whatever realm it'd be part of, and pretty much the first to be raided in any war. I'd also speak some kind of Diets unintelligible to anyone 100 miles away in any direction. To the north they'd speak Frisian, to the south they'd speak french. To the west they'd speak Dutch, and to the east they'd speak another German dialect. I would be better able to speak with the germans on the other side of the border than with my countrymen on the coast. Since I'm 21, I would be married and have my first child.
What a scenario.
reply
Andy
It seems like India potentially had the means of becoming pretty powerful, since they were also a peninsula where the several competing powers could have fueled faster advancement. I imagine East Asia could possibly have industrialized as well, the printing press had actually been invented seperatey in China a bit earlier than Gutenberg.
It's really interesting that after the plague and Ghengis khan, only the west was able to bounce back, would have loved to hear you speak more on the sociological reasons behind that. Do you think if those two events hadn't happened, the 4 powers would still be on equal grounds today, still competing?
reply
It seems like India potentially had the means of becoming pretty powerful, since they were also a peninsula where the several competing powers could have fueled faster advancement. I imagine East Asia could possibly have industrialized as well, the printing press had actually been invented seperatey in China a bit earlier than Gutenberg.
It's really interesting that after the plague and Ghengis khan, only the west was able to bounce back, would have loved to hear you speak more on the sociological reasons behind that. Do you think if those two events hadn't happened, the 4 powers would still be on equal grounds today, still competing?
reply
YaBoje
The Ottoman fleet didnt reach stagnation until the 17-18th century, like the rest of ottoman military complex, and on many occations defeated the Portuguese. but lost crucial sieges (siege of diu. This made the portuguese, and later dutch, british, fleets the main controller of important persian gulf-indian trade routes. So like with the rest of the ottoman empire i would say it wasnt particullary behind the west but more so it was overstretched within its main borders and couldent allocate needed resources from the Egyptian hearthland.
reply
The Ottoman fleet didnt reach stagnation until the 17-18th century, like the rest of ottoman military complex, and on many occations defeated the Portuguese. but lost crucial sieges (siege of diu. This made the portuguese, and later dutch, british, fleets the main controller of important persian gulf-indian trade routes. So like with the rest of the ottoman empire i would say it wasnt particullary behind the west but more so it was overstretched within its main borders and couldent allocate needed resources from the Egyptian hearthland.
reply
Rohit
Your model rests on social order in Europe being theocractic, arguing that in the real world, the social order was such that Europe was fertile for technological progress. The middle class was free, and there was darwinian competition between states.
But the social order in other parts of the world too, could have changed in unexpected ways, resulting in rise of technology and innovativeness in those parts.
_If Europe doesn't bring progress, nobody else will_ is. a weak argument.
reply
Your model rests on social order in Europe being theocractic, arguing that in the real world, the social order was such that Europe was fertile for technological progress. The middle class was free, and there was darwinian competition between states.
But the social order in other parts of the world too, could have changed in unexpected ways, resulting in rise of technology and innovativeness in those parts.
_If Europe doesn't bring progress, nobody else will_ is. a weak argument.
reply
Tall
Japan definitely would not suddenly become a colonial power in this timeline. Maybe it would be able to capture Hokkaido a bit earlier, but it wouldn't be expanding all over East Asia. China would realize that Japanese expansion increased Japanese piracy(along with probably several other East Asian nations like Vietnam, Korea, Taiwanese tribes, Filipino tribes, etc) and hand the Japanese an early defeat around Taiwan, effectively halting their colonialism.
reply
Japan definitely would not suddenly become a colonial power in this timeline. Maybe it would be able to capture Hokkaido a bit earlier, but it wouldn't be expanding all over East Asia. China would realize that Japanese expansion increased Japanese piracy(along with probably several other East Asian nations like Vietnam, Korea, Taiwanese tribes, Filipino tribes, etc) and hand the Japanese an early defeat around Taiwan, effectively halting their colonialism.
reply
Peter
This video seems like it might have benefitted from a little more research. None of the colonial powers covered themselves with glory in their treatment of the native people of the American continent but to say the Spanish were nicer seems a little bit on the 'So wrong it's painful' spectrum. If your knowledge on a subject is limited it might be wise to avoid sweeping statements about genocide.
reply
This video seems like it might have benefitted from a little more research. None of the colonial powers covered themselves with glory in their treatment of the native people of the American continent but to say the Spanish were nicer seems a little bit on the 'So wrong it's painful' spectrum. If your knowledge on a subject is limited it might be wise to avoid sweeping statements about genocide.
reply
pigtailsboy
I'm not sure you can make the comparison that North America could end up like Brazil or Mexico. They have limits that NA regions do not. Space for expansion also make it likely that people would spread out and avoid their rulers when possible. And if a choice was offered between the evil you know and the natives you don't they might choose the natives as allies.
reply
I'm not sure you can make the comparison that North America could end up like Brazil or Mexico. They have limits that NA regions do not. Space for expansion also make it likely that people would spread out and avoid their rulers when possible. And if a choice was offered between the evil you know and the natives you don't they might choose the natives as allies.
reply
kursemaster
I disagree with Muhammad Ali thing, Muhammad Ali became the governor of Egypt by taking advantage of the instability in Egypt after the Napoleon's Egypt Campaign. Without this, either we'd never hear about him at all, or he'd climb the ranks in Constantinople as an Ottoman officer. Egypt would continue being a part of Ottoman Empire either way.
reply
I disagree with Muhammad Ali thing, Muhammad Ali became the governor of Egypt by taking advantage of the instability in Egypt after the Napoleon's Egypt Campaign. Without this, either we'd never hear about him at all, or he'd climb the ranks in Constantinople as an Ottoman officer. Egypt would continue being a part of Ottoman Empire either way.
reply
Kathleen
ik this is old, but define primitive jungle tribe. the maori and indigenious australians and pacific islanders obviously weren't. hence england using 50years of homegrown indentured slaves via convicts to colonize in the 1800s after the industrial revolution and poulation boom. the dutch before them turned right back around.
reply
ik this is old, but define primitive jungle tribe. the maori and indigenious australians and pacific islanders obviously weren't. hence england using 50years of homegrown indentured slaves via convicts to colonize in the 1800s after the industrial revolution and poulation boom. the dutch before them turned right back around.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















