• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if Nuclear Bombs Never Existed?

What if Nuclear Bombs Never Existed?

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if Nuclear Bombs Never Existed? Lord: Your timeline already starts with an innacuracy. Operation downfall wasn't really neccecary because the Japanese government in OTL was already looking for a way to surrender before they even knew what a nuclear bomb was. Essentially, the government was scared that the americans would remove or even execute Hirohito (which would have been in line with the wishes of 90% of americans, and they could have been very easily convinced to surrender if the Americans offered a surrender with the sole condition of Hirohito's continued reign. In fact, the bombs changed very little in this regard, since the Americans essentially did just that, despite their official undonditional surrenders only policy (the Japanese unconditionally surrendered on the condition that the imperial family go unmolested, and the Americans accepted on the condition that the Japanese acknowledge that the Americans weren't accepting their condition, but that the Japanese were accepting the American offer of that same condition. The only threat to peace at this point would have been an army coup, just as was abortively attempted in OTL, but if Hirohito had made an official proclamation that he suppourted surrender like he did in our timeline (which would be, as it was in our timeline primarily motivated by him being able to keep his and his famiy's position) then there wouldn't have been much suppourt for a coup.
The tragic reality is that the Nuclear bombs actually had remarkably little effect on the end of world war two, since they didn't actually represent a real change in the status quo. Practially speaking, the americans were no more able to destroy a city from the air than they already were, and the brutal deaths of a few more civilians didn't actually have any impact on any of the bastards actually making the country's decisions.

Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


I disagree with this video. If there was going to be a war between the Soviets and Americans in the early 50s, the Soviets would have definitely won. If the Soviets attacked the same time America was bogged down in Korea, the Soviets would have achieved nearly total surprise. And also, the American plan wouldn't be to just fall back to the Rhine, why would they give up all of that population, industry, etc to the Soviets? That means the Soviets could use their surprise and numerical advantage to simply crush most of Americas units in Germany. And by the time they would reach the Rhineland, the American army would be basically destroyed. Also, you can't just say The Soviets would run out of their supply lines They could push literally the Nazis to a much greater distance than this all the way to Berlin. That means the Soviets could easily cross the Rhine and beat what remains of the American forces, seizing the Rhineland and Benelux then defeating France. After the defeat of France, the Soviets could just conquer Italy, Iberia, Scandinavia, and basically all of Europe besides the UK.
reply

You call the atomic bomb the worst invention of the 20th century in another video of yours. And yet in this video you describe how without that invention we'd actually lose even more lives and prolong human suffering. Invention of the atomic bomb is the best ting that could happen to an average citizen, since it forced people in power to to hold back their bottomless appetites and stop treating citizens as their property. Especially ever since wars stopped being about autonomous armies that moved on foot and fed themselves and started being about the infrastructure, industrial power, supply lines & logistics etc, therefore making carpet bombing of cities more important than whatever happened on the battlefield proper, i. e. incentivizing mass murder of civilians. The fear of mutual annihilation is a good thing, because it forces nations to cooperate, and drastically decreases chances of an average person dying in some unnecessary war for the elites.
reply

It is a major historical fallacy that Mary Curie was the be-all end-all of nuclear and radiation technological development and the springboard for nuclear weapons. She actually did no real work in and of herself. After her husband died of radiation poisoning when he was doing the primary Research into such things she later after his death continued his research and published it in her name later she died of the same radiation poisoning that killed her husband. It was actually her husband who did the bulk of the research into what today would be referred to as the groundwork for nuclear physics.
You would have to find some method of killing off her husband before they ever met and before he started his research. Without him she would have been nothing more than another housewife.

reply

Well, the Nukes didn't make Japan surrender
It was a short man with a bushy moustache in Moscow called Stalin
Neither atomic bomb had an effect on the diplomacy between the US and Japan in August
In fact, the Japanese opted to have their capital city nuked instead of surrendering, but the Japanese surrendered on the 15th of August because of Stalin's invasion of Manchuria on the 9th that lasted until the 20th
If there is anything scarier than an Atomic Bomb, it's Stalin
This is confirmed by the Japanese government as well as the military of the US
So, no nukes means basically no change for the war or it's outcome for the fate of Japan
The cold war is also more stable

reply

The development of nuclear weapons has always more or less been an inevitability as human society always advances towards technological development. There's simply no way that no one would ever NOT come along who would notice the possibility of it, baring an extinction-level event occurring first. For nuclear weapons to not exist it would take something like the electrostatic force not existing, meaning it simply wouldn't be physically possible but without said fundamental force the universe as we know it would not exist or at least not in any recognizable form.
reply

Poor calculation. By the end of the WW2 USSR have had more tanks, plains and seasoned manpower then the whole Western Europe combined because it went full War-Economy. If not for the nukes, USSR would've conquered the entire Europe in no time. The main goal for the US to nuke Japan was to show Stalin what's gonna happen to Moscow should he decide to pass Alba.
I'm not a USSR admirer, quite opposite in fact. Just looking at this possibility realistically.

reply

12: 47 I feel like you underestimate Pakistan's position in this era and the Indo-Pakistani wars. While not being able to outright conquer all of Kashmir, Pakistan would be able to slow to the Indians down even alone, and with much of Kashmir being pro Pakistan they would be able to even further slow India. Pakistan has a good position in Kashmir and would be able to defend it just as India would in the same situation.
reply

Since you touched upon Indo-Pak situation, I kind of disagree that there would be more wars. Like Koreas, though we have a shared history, but there is zero will amongst the governments or people for a reunification. Too much hate for that. There still might be skirmishes over Kashmir, but full scale invasions may not occur. Not to say N bombs are not a deterrent right now, but may not be so different. Just my opinion.
reply

11: 00 Actually o believe the reason why Germany has been forgiven for WW2 but not Japan is cultural
Western culture is very pro-forgiveness while this is a foreign concept to Asian culture which is very shame-based
Therefore Japan can never be forgiven unless it stops existing. this is why S. Korea, which geopolitically is in it's best interest to reconcile with Japan, refuses to do so

reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos