• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if America Never Exported its Industry?

What if America Never Exported its Industry?

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if America Never Exported its Industry? Ryan: US manufactures far more now than ever before, just with fewer jobs, is a good thing it means higher productivity. We manufacture fewer low-value consumer goods like what China specializes in this is also good, we make things we have a comparative advantage in and are competitive globally like jet engines and food. Manufacturing is a smaller part of the % of the economy yes, but who cares? That just means the service economy is larger, that's also good. Even when things are largely manufactured in say China the vast majority of the profit is made by Americans who make the designs, own the brands, and make the software all of which are higher productivity industries on average. If America still manufactured all of our low-value consumer goods our goods would cost more, and we would have far fewer people to do services, software etc.
You will also see over time as labor costs increase in China manufacturing moving to Vietnam and eventually Africa before it comes back with far high automation in America when cheap labor abroad runs out.
It's similar to farming in America at one time it was 95% of the economy and employed almost everyone and now it is less than 1% of GDP, does that mean America makes less food and Americans are worse off? Not at all we made hundreds of times the amount we used to make, its safer and cheaper as % of the average American's income than ever, people in farming (myself being one) have a high standard of living and are far more productive.
Every industry over time should become lower and lower % of the economy and employ a smaller % of the population this means it's becoming far more productive and products are becoming commodities and competition drives down margins making it affordable to the masses.

Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


Continued.
US: Prices of goods would of been anywhere from 2x-10x more expensive, though economics would be more balanced amongst different classes. The people would live with more harmony, seen at the times of Clinton years. As society move slower, people will have the finance and the political power to add new monetary safety nets for the upcoming transformation into the tech age. Think of nationalized healthcare, higher corporate taxes, and more importance on education, something like Switzerland.
China would continue to develop through farming, lagging behind it's neighbors allied to the US. Remember, even if the US didn't globalize, it would still depend on Japan, Korea and Taiwan to produce technologies. Only Taiwan wouldn't of been robbed of it's CPU golden age this time around, as the prices of cpus and gpus would be 2x-10x higher. Taiwan would develop a sizable navy to safely deal with piracy. Workers in China would supply the rest of the world with cheap labor, and China would go the direction of Korea, where most young workers are overseas or on their way out. Xi would still come to power, though this time around he would stand with Hong Kong, as their specialized position in the world would be 2x-10x more profitable. The country might even vote to adopt Cantonese as their national language to better facilitate business from Hong Kong. Economic development would be dependent on and spread from Hong Kong.

reply

Maybe, too many years of excessive well-being lead to confusing the useful with the superfluous and this behavior favors the emergence of social classes disconnected with reality and therefore unable to govern economic and social processes because these people tend to elect politicians who are unable in fact but very skilled to use words.
For example: politicians talk about the opportunities of globalization in economic forums and universities of economics but who has to vote for them, year after year, are people who stood up to do poorly paid jobs, with no long-term prospects and if they graduated from college probably with a lot of debt.
Worse than them but perhaps with less anxiety are those who worked in factories and are sinking into misery but who are now used to dealing with this fact.
Economic data often describe a dynamic and rapidly expanding economy but are numbers that concern companies and those who manage them, much less those who work there.
I believe that the crisis of the homeless, the urban disaster of the old industrial cities and the advent of business models such as wal mart and amazon that instead of stimulating competition are scorching earth around themselves, ultimately impoverishing economically the consumers their self, is a fairly eloquent figure.

reply

Many of America's products was top notch. Until regulatory side of things. Began forcing unattainable demands upon companies. And punishing taxes. If these regulations was not met. And one of my favorite asshole republican's of all time. Mr. I'm not a crook, himself. Opened up relations with China and third world countries. So that these companies could flee. We gave China new age manufacturing process. And China, in turn! Taught Communism and state ran capitalism to these American companies. Who now! Would chew off their own arms. To shake the hand of communism. And worst of all! Have adopted China's form of conservativism. And has caused us to adopt, the worst form isolationism. And there is nothing wrong with tightening of our border policy's. But what we have done. Is to stop, educated and trained individuals. From coming over. And in staid opted, to only open our borders to. Untrained low value labor. So now we have a large class none doer's. And ever larger class of poverty class workers. So America can sweep them aside. When ever they want to. And for what ever reason.
reply

Deindustrialization has and is destined to occur in all major western economies. It is simply not feasible for these economies to compete in wages with other poorer countries and therefore to increase their own wages and continue to be economically viable these countries must switch to tertiary and quartenary sectors of the economy.
There are many who think they can get their cushy union life back and have a sort of grand view of the 50s and 60s. Therefore they either vote for socialists who promise that deindustrialization was completely neoliberalisms fault or vote right-wing populist who blames the entire fiasco on immigration and outsiders. In reality the world has just moved on and what was viable in one era is no longer viable as poorer countries develop to compete with the US.

reply

As a non American and pro democracy Korean that supports the US (Even with all its contradictions. I wholeheartedly agree with what is stated here. It was a strategically huge error and now they have created an authoritarian monster to deal with. all for some decades of low quality cheap goods and the naive belief that they would democratize. If not in the 80s, the key mistake was letting China into the WTO in the early 2000s. Just look at their GDP from the year 2000 and how it skyrockets past the European powers and Japan. As Napoleon warned, China was awakened, and this was done by the USA. China looks at things in terms of decades and centuries. Very unfortunately, the US erred with its shortsightedness and moral decline.
reply

I get what a lot of these comments are saying but 2021 isn't 1970. A big cause of income inequality today is the divide in labor. You see, manufacturing jobs provided a stable middle class job. When those went away, you had low skill jobs and high skill jobs. A big reason for high income inequality is the fact that many jobs either pay very little or require a college degree. With the ever rising costs of college tuition, many have to select the former. This is why many millennials are worse off than their parents. Many people are working low wage jobs when there's a shortage in high skill labor. I think we can restore the middle class without having to wage a trade war.
reply

we will just have to see if America de-industrializing was the dumbest idea TBH I think it was inevitable because your society has to improve itself from high end manufacturing jobs to higher education jobs, but doing this process so fast and essentially having a fire sale on US industry while forcing the population to make a run for the upper class or get left behind was absolute horrible idea for the middle class and possibly for the the future of America. the income inequality has brought down Empires before. i also want to add that this did make things cheaper for the middle class too but the fact they had less jobs available to them is the down fall there
reply

Its just geopolitical entropy. Just like hot air next to cold air will tend to an equilibrium state, unless a massive amount of energy is expended to prevent it, so too extreme wealth inequality between first and third world countries creates a gradient that would prove increasingly harder to sustain since all nature, uninhibited, tends towards an equilibrium state. If true then it logically follows that free and fair trade will, over time, undermine inequalities and naturally bring forth a state that Communists tried to bring forth by force (though free and fair are tough to achieve and the time horizon may be centuries.
reply

America is the biggest waster of gas in the world
its a big problem
In its relentless pursuit of oil, the shale industry burns more and more gas into the air. This wasted gas exceeds the yearly demand of nations such as Colombia.
The rate of flaring in the Permian basin reached a record high in the first three months of this year, averaging 661 million cubic feet per day (MMcfd, according to Rystad Energy. That is more than double the amount of flaring for the same period from a year earlier.
boycott usa until they stop wasting all the gas we have
boycott usa today

reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos