
What if America Went Full Colonial?
video description
Date: 2022-07-15
Comments and reviews: 9
Gareth
The US was, and still is, a colonial power, the only hegemonic world power of our age. It however chose to rule its empire indirectly through economic and ideological power, keeping the application of military might as a reserve for specific wars it couldnt avoid or where it sought to make an object lesson. Direct rule is costly and only the most ham fisted, or desperate, US leaders have relied on it. The history of its empire is the history of proxy wars, creating ideological fifth columns and economic blackmail. It learned its lessons from the British and took it to the next step and beyond. The USAs colonialism is such that it has colonised its allies and its self ultimately.
The US is a propositional empire though what that proposition is, and in whose benefit it will be in the end, is disputed.
reply
The US was, and still is, a colonial power, the only hegemonic world power of our age. It however chose to rule its empire indirectly through economic and ideological power, keeping the application of military might as a reserve for specific wars it couldnt avoid or where it sought to make an object lesson. Direct rule is costly and only the most ham fisted, or desperate, US leaders have relied on it. The history of its empire is the history of proxy wars, creating ideological fifth columns and economic blackmail. It learned its lessons from the British and took it to the next step and beyond. The USAs colonialism is such that it has colonised its allies and its self ultimately.
The US is a propositional empire though what that proposition is, and in whose benefit it will be in the end, is disputed.
reply
education
0: 04 close but you forgot Puerto Rico and American Samoa. and Alabama and Alaska and Arizona and Arkansas and California and Colorado and Connecticut and Delaware and Florida and Georgia and Hawaii and Idaho and Illinois and Indiana and Iowa and Kansas and Kentucky and Louisiana and Maine and Maryland and Mass and Michigan and Minnesota and Mississippi and Missouri and Montana and Nebraska and Nevada and New Hampshire and New Jersey and New Mexico and New York and North Carolina and North Dakota and Ohio and Oklahoma and Oregon and Pennsylvania and Rhode Island and South Carolina and South Dakota and Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin and Wyoming
reply
0: 04 close but you forgot Puerto Rico and American Samoa. and Alabama and Alaska and Arizona and Arkansas and California and Colorado and Connecticut and Delaware and Florida and Georgia and Hawaii and Idaho and Illinois and Indiana and Iowa and Kansas and Kentucky and Louisiana and Maine and Maryland and Mass and Michigan and Minnesota and Mississippi and Missouri and Montana and Nebraska and Nevada and New Hampshire and New Jersey and New Mexico and New York and North Carolina and North Dakota and Ohio and Oklahoma and Oregon and Pennsylvania and Rhode Island and South Carolina and South Dakota and Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin and Wyoming
reply
Caleb
The first states to seceed in the south did so when it was clear that the morrill tarriff was going to pass. The rest seceeded after the battle of fort sumter, because they felt any state that wanted to had the right to secession. The north definitly did not want new slave states since that meant that slave states got more senate seats, but they liked the idea of keeping the number of slave states the same. Just look up the corwin amendment sometime.
Its annoying that so many people look at the secession war through modern eyes instead of 1860 eyes.
reply
The first states to seceed in the south did so when it was clear that the morrill tarriff was going to pass. The rest seceeded after the battle of fort sumter, because they felt any state that wanted to had the right to secession. The north definitly did not want new slave states since that meant that slave states got more senate seats, but they liked the idea of keeping the number of slave states the same. Just look up the corwin amendment sometime.
Its annoying that so many people look at the secession war through modern eyes instead of 1860 eyes.
reply
Colin
They went all but full colonial. They have military bases all over the world. They've waged war directly in several different countries, indirectly in countless more, and meddled politically and militarily in any that wanted to go socialist. US style capitalism and culture is ubiquitous, if not always dominant, in pretty much every country. They're full neo-colonial. As in as colonial as you can possibly be in the modern world, in which, say, British style colonialism isn't possible anymore.
reply
They went all but full colonial. They have military bases all over the world. They've waged war directly in several different countries, indirectly in countless more, and meddled politically and militarily in any that wanted to go socialist. US style capitalism and culture is ubiquitous, if not always dominant, in pretty much every country. They're full neo-colonial. As in as colonial as you can possibly be in the modern world, in which, say, British style colonialism isn't possible anymore.
reply
Cali
If the USA had gone more colonial in Liberia and actively pushed much more resettlement of freed slaves there, wouldn't the British done the same thing with Sierra Leone, which was also a place for emancipated slaves, Freetown being its capital? Or even the French, for that matter? I could see the UK and France using their westernized Caribbean Africans the same way in an earlier Scramble For Africa.
reply
If the USA had gone more colonial in Liberia and actively pushed much more resettlement of freed slaves there, wouldn't the British done the same thing with Sierra Leone, which was also a place for emancipated slaves, Freetown being its capital? Or even the French, for that matter? I could see the UK and France using their westernized Caribbean Africans the same way in an earlier Scramble For Africa.
reply
Lord
I feel like in this alternate timeline, Mexico, if our influence didnt help them enough, would likely try to join America as a state, or America, being greedy for more land and power, might try to strike up a deal with Mexico to get them to join. At least it would clean up the territory of the bridge-lands between the North and South Americas.
reply
I feel like in this alternate timeline, Mexico, if our influence didnt help them enough, would likely try to join America as a state, or America, being greedy for more land and power, might try to strike up a deal with Mexico to get them to join. At least it would clean up the territory of the bridge-lands between the North and South Americas.
reply
Kshaku
I don't think America would make Spanish an official language beyond the state level because English isn't an official language on the Federal level. At best though, it would become an accepted administrative language and there would be efforts to ensure that Spanish is equally acceptable alongside English in the public sector.
reply
I don't think America would make Spanish an official language beyond the state level because English isn't an official language on the Federal level. At best though, it would become an accepted administrative language and there would be efforts to ensure that Spanish is equally acceptable alongside English in the public sector.
reply
Jorge
France has more land elsewhere than some European countries. The US should annex The Yucatan. Yucatecans have nothing in common with the rest of Mexico. mexico has destroyed many areas and the original infrastructure the rail road destroyed many companies Mexico has never worked for the Yucatan. Help us please!
reply
France has more land elsewhere than some European countries. The US should annex The Yucatan. Yucatecans have nothing in common with the rest of Mexico. mexico has destroyed many areas and the original infrastructure the rail road destroyed many companies Mexico has never worked for the Yucatan. Help us please!
reply
Steven
USA is a colony. All its states are colonies. All its territories before were colonies. Colonies for settlers. Colonies for resources. Colonies for security. Just because they are not called colonies doesnt mean they arent. The only difference is Europe gave most of them back to their inhabitants.
reply
USA is a colony. All its states are colonies. All its territories before were colonies. Colonies for settlers. Colonies for resources. Colonies for security. Just because they are not called colonies doesnt mean they arent. The only difference is Europe gave most of them back to their inhabitants.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















