
Explaining Russian Civilization
video description
Date: 2024-04-10
Comments and reviews: 20
s. novozhilov1856
Krauts video was still better justified than this one. Geography determinists should suck cocks. I can give at least 3 economic and political reasons for expansion rather than subconscious paranoia or steppes Nomad threat died with Kazan, Astrakhan and Crimea. Reasons of serfdom are many other besides yearn for repression and actually have Byzantine and Kievan roots. Same with Caesaropapism. Saying Poland was better alternative is like stating that lost fighter was actually better. Local Slavic elite was never replaced with Mongolian. Relationship wasn't colonial, it was tributary. So theory about Mongol roots of elite is a nonsense, or at least bias. Where did you take it For Polish Asking their opinion or opinion of Americans during Cold War is like asking your hater for fair analysis of your content Social science in comparison with fundamental science is very closely tied to contemporary political agenda. Aren't you the one who complained on incursion of feminism and social justice into science So, vid is bs, redo.
reply
Krauts video was still better justified than this one. Geography determinists should suck cocks. I can give at least 3 economic and political reasons for expansion rather than subconscious paranoia or steppes Nomad threat died with Kazan, Astrakhan and Crimea. Reasons of serfdom are many other besides yearn for repression and actually have Byzantine and Kievan roots. Same with Caesaropapism. Saying Poland was better alternative is like stating that lost fighter was actually better. Local Slavic elite was never replaced with Mongolian. Relationship wasn't colonial, it was tributary. So theory about Mongol roots of elite is a nonsense, or at least bias. Where did you take it For Polish Asking their opinion or opinion of Americans during Cold War is like asking your hater for fair analysis of your content Social science in comparison with fundamental science is very closely tied to contemporary political agenda. Aren't you the one who complained on incursion of feminism and social justice into science So, vid is bs, redo.
reply
themanfromerf
The thing is, that in decisive situations like company leadership or war, Authoritarianism is the best social model
Are you telling me that running a civilization is not a decisive situation THIS is why America needs a king, btw. This is why our government and economy and society are all such a catastrophic mess. Nobody is steering the ship. All of the bad incentives and free-riders and slippery slopes are just allowed to breed endlessly, and literally nobody has the power to actually say no. Authoritarianism is the best social model period, end of discussion. A command driven organization is simply superior to a process driven one on all counts.
This is not the 20th century. There never needs to be another Stalin or moustache man, but there does need to be an actual ruler. If you're still controlled by the democratic parasite the state has so thoroughly driven into your brain and nourished, you're (a small) part of the problem. Read some reactionary literature and join us in the future. It's great.
reply
The thing is, that in decisive situations like company leadership or war, Authoritarianism is the best social model
Are you telling me that running a civilization is not a decisive situation THIS is why America needs a king, btw. This is why our government and economy and society are all such a catastrophic mess. Nobody is steering the ship. All of the bad incentives and free-riders and slippery slopes are just allowed to breed endlessly, and literally nobody has the power to actually say no. Authoritarianism is the best social model period, end of discussion. A command driven organization is simply superior to a process driven one on all counts.
This is not the 20th century. There never needs to be another Stalin or moustache man, but there does need to be an actual ruler. If you're still controlled by the democratic parasite the state has so thoroughly driven into your brain and nourished, you're (a small) part of the problem. Read some reactionary literature and join us in the future. It's great.
reply
ChrisSeltzer
Geographic determinism ala Guns, Germs, and Steel was a product of 1960s intellectual backlash against the ideas of manifest destiny, American exceptionalism, the white man's burden, etc.
If you want to dismiss these ideas you have to confront that fact that Europe did in fact conquer the world. It postulates, essentially, that geography is destiny - culture makes no difference in the fate of civilizations.
Nobody denies that geography influences the decision making of nations but to pretend, like Diamond does, that it's the only influence on history is outright silly.
reply
Geographic determinism ala Guns, Germs, and Steel was a product of 1960s intellectual backlash against the ideas of manifest destiny, American exceptionalism, the white man's burden, etc.
If you want to dismiss these ideas you have to confront that fact that Europe did in fact conquer the world. It postulates, essentially, that geography is destiny - culture makes no difference in the fate of civilizations.
Nobody denies that geography influences the decision making of nations but to pretend, like Diamond does, that it's the only influence on history is outright silly.
reply
Eltipoquevisteayer
You should make a video about Chile, you can see as one of the countries that foretells what may happen in the future (in part thanks to a very organized and mobilized left) to the rest of the west, they also have some weird oriental elements in the society structure (we are shy guys as a whole in times of peace, we have only been lucky because we HAD a decent ruling class.
reply
You should make a video about Chile, you can see as one of the countries that foretells what may happen in the future (in part thanks to a very organized and mobilized left) to the rest of the west, they also have some weird oriental elements in the society structure (we are shy guys as a whole in times of peace, we have only been lucky because we HAD a decent ruling class.
reply
VonDecken97
big four civilisations in history without any African empire how americans always disconnected from reality, y'all are known for being like that. And he say westerners respect life way more than anybody oh no man wake up it's sad. You're lost in a false narrative, you even lie about Africa structure and political ideology, what's wrong with you man why you lie that much
reply
big four civilisations in history without any African empire how americans always disconnected from reality, y'all are known for being like that. And he say westerners respect life way more than anybody oh no man wake up it's sad. You're lost in a false narrative, you even lie about Africa structure and political ideology, what's wrong with you man why you lie that much
reply
dangingerich2559
Oddly, the origin and operation of the USSR actually makes sense in this context. They allowed the enslavement of the entire country to the ruling elite Soviets because it was what they'd always had before that time, just with new leaders. Weird to think of it that way. I still think the Soviet communists were absolute evil, though.
reply
Oddly, the origin and operation of the USSR actually makes sense in this context. They allowed the enslavement of the entire country to the ruling elite Soviets because it was what they'd always had before that time, just with new leaders. Weird to think of it that way. I still think the Soviet communists were absolute evil, though.
reply
CW-bw7pv
Peter the great is such a fascinating leader, a practical guy who loved building ships, who rather liked sleeping in sheds than a palace and went on a tour of the Netherlands and Britain. He organised the construction of Saint Petersburg and knew that he couldn’t beat the Turks and so made peace with them despite setting his conquests back.
reply
Peter the great is such a fascinating leader, a practical guy who loved building ships, who rather liked sleeping in sheds than a palace and went on a tour of the Netherlands and Britain. He organised the construction of Saint Petersburg and knew that he couldn’t beat the Turks and so made peace with them despite setting his conquests back.
reply
xWEPx
In poland, as the king was elected by vote, prospectibe kings promised the nobility more and more privileges. Weakening the power of the king and worsening the situation of the farmers.
As mostly foreign nobels were elected as kings, most of them weren't interested in the country and let the nobility do as it pleased.
reply
In poland, as the king was elected by vote, prospectibe kings promised the nobility more and more privileges. Weakening the power of the king and worsening the situation of the farmers.
As mostly foreign nobels were elected as kings, most of them weren't interested in the country and let the nobility do as it pleased.
reply
fdaugherty7083
What Your conclusion is baffling. Esoteric organizations like the Masons think the next great civilization will come from Eastern Europe What on earth are you referring to Who says this, where Do you view the masons as still a vibrant, relevant organization
reply
What Your conclusion is baffling. Esoteric organizations like the Masons think the next great civilization will come from Eastern Europe What on earth are you referring to Who says this, where Do you view the masons as still a vibrant, relevant organization
reply
whatifalthist
So many videos, you're gonna kill me with all the brain uploading I'm doing. I just crammed for and took 2 exams today, and watched your last video over lunch. Now I'm supposed to watch this for homework after
You're a harsh but generous teacher.
reply
So many videos, you're gonna kill me with all the brain uploading I'm doing. I just crammed for and took 2 exams today, and watched your last video over lunch. Now I'm supposed to watch this for homework after
You're a harsh but generous teacher.
reply
calebcary6661
25: 06, trans ethnic conflicts which create empires. Rome: vs Celts. I believe it should be Rome vs Carthage. Caesars conquest of Gaul is a good argument. But may not have been a thing if Rome did not win the Punic wars and the Greek conquest.
reply
25: 06, trans ethnic conflicts which create empires. Rome: vs Celts. I believe it should be Rome vs Carthage. Caesars conquest of Gaul is a good argument. But may not have been a thing if Rome did not win the Punic wars and the Greek conquest.
reply
ghost21501
The theory that slave originated from Slav is most likely a myth. It most likely comes from the Slavic term Slovo or Slava, which means word and glory, respectively. So it either stands for those who speak the same language or those of glory.
reply
The theory that slave originated from Slav is most likely a myth. It most likely comes from the Slavic term Slovo or Slava, which means word and glory, respectively. So it either stands for those who speak the same language or those of glory.
reply
badams3489
Do you have a basis for the way your are pronouncing Tartars because there is an old-world research community that has been pronouncing it as spelled Tar-tar where you seem to be injecting an extra 'eh' sound to the end of the first a.
reply
Do you have a basis for the way your are pronouncing Tartars because there is an old-world research community that has been pronouncing it as spelled Tar-tar where you seem to be injecting an extra 'eh' sound to the end of the first a.
reply
Hjnii23A
I don’t suppose you could do a remake of your what if the Soviet Union never existed Video could you That would be incredibly interesting given the what you must know now compared to what you knew back then. Love your work nonetheless.
reply
I don’t suppose you could do a remake of your what if the Soviet Union never existed Video could you That would be incredibly interesting given the what you must know now compared to what you knew back then. Love your work nonetheless.
reply
mateuszmazurek7991
hey bro, it was Koneczny (Konechnee)
Yea he also wrote that the best civilization is Latin (Western) and Poland is the highest form of it lol: D
But many people on polish right like to refer to his theories.
reply
hey bro, it was Koneczny (Konechnee)
Yea he also wrote that the best civilization is Latin (Western) and Poland is the highest form of it lol: D
But many people on polish right like to refer to his theories.
reply
smal750
5: 53 france doesnt underperform what makes you think that they have a small population and country (size of a us state) how are they supposed to compete with the us and btw the uk definitely has the best geography by far
reply
5: 53 france doesnt underperform what makes you think that they have a small population and country (size of a us state) how are they supposed to compete with the us and btw the uk definitely has the best geography by far
reply
lizardjoel
I just finished your last video, read the comments, went to the homepage and another video to watch. I respect the grind and effort in these and I am interested to see your take on Russki Mir as a Slav myself.
reply
I just finished your last video, read the comments, went to the homepage and another video to watch. I respect the grind and effort in these and I am interested to see your take on Russki Mir as a Slav myself.
reply
rumrunner1990
I know your maps are accurate because of the way Newfoundland is represented. You know your shit.
Newfoundland is definitely unfarmable for the most part, however. It’s marsh and bog and rock.
reply
I know your maps are accurate because of the way Newfoundland is represented. You know your shit.
Newfoundland is definitely unfarmable for the most part, however. It’s marsh and bog and rock.
reply
rugerdie4054
I thought this must be an old video when it autoplayed. I was pleasantly surprised when I realized that you uploaded twice in a week. No pressure of course. Take all the time you need brother.
reply
I thought this must be an old video when it autoplayed. I was pleasantly surprised when I realized that you uploaded twice in a week. No pressure of course. Take all the time you need brother.
reply
austinsmith8584
Thomas Friedman doesn’t speak Hebrew or Arabic. He will come to Jerusalem for 3 day write an article the Middle East yesterday, today and Tomorrow in the NYT and it will be Biden policy.
reply
Thomas Friedman doesn’t speak Hebrew or Arabic. He will come to Jerusalem for 3 day write an article the Middle East yesterday, today and Tomorrow in the NYT and it will be Biden policy.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















