
Hyundai Genesis: Battery Goes Dead Overnight
video description
Date: 2020-08-05
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 10
South
I am seeing the question a lot in the comments, How (or did you) charge for this job? Great question. I bill by the hour on diags. If it takes 5 hrs, I bill 5hrs. I have a 1hr minimum on all diags. I don't care what the end result is, even if it is the just a fuse. Time is time. Fact is straight diagnosing is a losing proposition for shops from a business aspect. How so? If I bill 5hrs on a diag job and as in this case, no parts required I get 5hrs at 80 per/hr. that is 400 total. It takes a lot of thought, factory service info, expensive meters or equipment in some cases.
On the flip side let's say I do a full 4 wheel brake job in the same amount of time along with pads rotors and calipers. Now I have billed labor AND made profit on all of the parts. The work was easier, required less thought and made two to three times the profit for the shop.
So would a shop be right if they charged more for diagnostics? ABSOLUTELY! Fact is their diagnostic labor should be at least twice their hourly repair labor other wise they are losing money and time. Why waste time diagnosis a vehicle for half the profit you could make doing a simple brake job? As a shop owner who do you pay more, the general service tech changing brakes or the A Tech doing diags? Why do you pay him more when he makes you less profit? Food for thought. Let me know how your shop charges. I would love to hear your thoughts on this.
reply
I am seeing the question a lot in the comments, How (or did you) charge for this job? Great question. I bill by the hour on diags. If it takes 5 hrs, I bill 5hrs. I have a 1hr minimum on all diags. I don't care what the end result is, even if it is the just a fuse. Time is time. Fact is straight diagnosing is a losing proposition for shops from a business aspect. How so? If I bill 5hrs on a diag job and as in this case, no parts required I get 5hrs at 80 per/hr. that is 400 total. It takes a lot of thought, factory service info, expensive meters or equipment in some cases.
On the flip side let's say I do a full 4 wheel brake job in the same amount of time along with pads rotors and calipers. Now I have billed labor AND made profit on all of the parts. The work was easier, required less thought and made two to three times the profit for the shop.
So would a shop be right if they charged more for diagnostics? ABSOLUTELY! Fact is their diagnostic labor should be at least twice their hourly repair labor other wise they are losing money and time. Why waste time diagnosis a vehicle for half the profit you could make doing a simple brake job? As a shop owner who do you pay more, the general service tech changing brakes or the A Tech doing diags? Why do you pay him more when he makes you less profit? Food for thought. Let me know how your shop charges. I would love to hear your thoughts on this.
reply
autos
So if you checked the fuse diagram on the cover to the fuses in the box you could have figured this out in 3 minutes. Yeah armchair QB here. LOL. I couldn't get a spark plug out of a Ford 5. 4L one time and it stumped me for a whole day. My socket kept slipping off the plug so I thought someone rounded off the plug. Tried all sort of sockets, was considering welding a beater socket onto the plug as a last resort and finally got an inspection camera in there. Turns out it was a tiny pebble that had worked its way somehow alongside the plug, the socket could grab the first 1/16 of the plug hex then it would hit the pebble feeling like it bottomed out, of course because it only had the edge of the plug it would slip off when any torque was applied. Used a small hammer to tap the top of a socket and it pulverized the pebble with a few good taps, a quick vacuum of the hole and I was good to go.
reply
So if you checked the fuse diagram on the cover to the fuses in the box you could have figured this out in 3 minutes. Yeah armchair QB here. LOL. I couldn't get a spark plug out of a Ford 5. 4L one time and it stumped me for a whole day. My socket kept slipping off the plug so I thought someone rounded off the plug. Tried all sort of sockets, was considering welding a beater socket onto the plug as a last resort and finally got an inspection camera in there. Turns out it was a tiny pebble that had worked its way somehow alongside the plug, the socket could grab the first 1/16 of the plug hex then it would hit the pebble feeling like it bottomed out, of course because it only had the edge of the plug it would slip off when any torque was applied. Used a small hammer to tap the top of a socket and it pulverized the pebble with a few good taps, a quick vacuum of the hole and I was good to go.
reply
John
I love these kinds of videos. Thank you for uploading them. It's youtube gold because you didn't just shrug and sling a fuse box at it, you methodically followed it right to the dirty little 10A turd causing the parasitic draw using informed deduction. Yeah it cost the customer 400. But if they could do it faster, they would have done it themselves. And I'd guess throwing fuse/power distro boxes and modules at it until the problem (maybe) went away would have definitely cost more. The customer might not like it, but why not a 125-150% diagnostic rate after the first hour or something? Heck, I can't fix my own teeth, so I go to the dentist. If he wants to charge two hundred an hour, and he's the best dentist for miles, I'm going to pay the man.
Edit: 200-250%
reply
I love these kinds of videos. Thank you for uploading them. It's youtube gold because you didn't just shrug and sling a fuse box at it, you methodically followed it right to the dirty little 10A turd causing the parasitic draw using informed deduction. Yeah it cost the customer 400. But if they could do it faster, they would have done it themselves. And I'd guess throwing fuse/power distro boxes and modules at it until the problem (maybe) went away would have definitely cost more. The customer might not like it, but why not a 125-150% diagnostic rate after the first hour or something? Heck, I can't fix my own teeth, so I go to the dentist. If he wants to charge two hundred an hour, and he's the best dentist for miles, I'm going to pay the man.
Edit: 200-250%
reply
bob
Eric
EXCELLENT JOB OF CHASE THE ISSUE.
I HAVE MUCH RESPECT SIR.
Reading the comments, customer gets back a Vehicle, the problem having been resovled.
The cost is in the time that could have been spent on another job or time with family. So be it. The issue was found.
The only thing that can speed up the process is to check the fuses THROUGHLY first.
( ALSO I CHECK THE BATTERY CONNECTIONS FIRST, FOR LOOSE TERMINALS CONNECTED )
I find loose terminals in four out of five times. ( heat, worn, loose, broken, etc. )
reply
Eric
EXCELLENT JOB OF CHASE THE ISSUE.
I HAVE MUCH RESPECT SIR.
Reading the comments, customer gets back a Vehicle, the problem having been resovled.
The cost is in the time that could have been spent on another job or time with family. So be it. The issue was found.
The only thing that can speed up the process is to check the fuses THROUGHLY first.
( ALSO I CHECK THE BATTERY CONNECTIONS FIRST, FOR LOOSE TERMINALS CONNECTED )
I find loose terminals in four out of five times. ( heat, worn, loose, broken, etc. )
reply
moomike
The fact that you stuck with it that long and at that time of day is a testament to your professionalism. Well done. In my experience a blank fuse place on a box cover would reveal a fuse cavity with either no female connectors or only the buss side. Sure as hell that errant 10a fuse in there was unusual. Did you ever figure out what that circuit was or was it a Hyundai goof? When you find things like that after a long trial and test session you don't know whether scream or cry. Great video. thanks for the education.
reply
The fact that you stuck with it that long and at that time of day is a testament to your professionalism. Well done. In my experience a blank fuse place on a box cover would reveal a fuse cavity with either no female connectors or only the buss side. Sure as hell that errant 10a fuse in there was unusual. Did you ever figure out what that circuit was or was it a Hyundai goof? When you find things like that after a long trial and test session you don't know whether scream or cry. Great video. thanks for the education.
reply
S.
Excellent diagnosis Mr. O. For the hit & miss mechanic luck does not always show up. At least you take a logical approach to fault tracing, where you are able to track down a mystery short. Electrical fault tracing is probably the hardest part of being a technician. Charging for diagnostic time can be tricky unless one trusts the tech he is dealing with. There is a lot of room for padding. What about the tech that spends four hours on the job & DOES NOT find the problem?
reply
Excellent diagnosis Mr. O. For the hit & miss mechanic luck does not always show up. At least you take a logical approach to fault tracing, where you are able to track down a mystery short. Electrical fault tracing is probably the hardest part of being a technician. Charging for diagnostic time can be tricky unless one trusts the tech he is dealing with. There is a lot of room for padding. What about the tech that spends four hours on the job & DOES NOT find the problem?
reply
Wilton
Man, you are really gifted. Don't take that for granted. I hear you put yourself down sometimes and I wonder what the #%% is he talking about. Most ASE Mechs can't hold a candle to you. I'm not blowing smoke up your butt. I appreciate your humility. But a gift is a gift! Just saying thanks is enough sometimes. You inspire me to not give up.
reply
Man, you are really gifted. Don't take that for granted. I hear you put yourself down sometimes and I wonder what the #%% is he talking about. Most ASE Mechs can't hold a candle to you. I'm not blowing smoke up your butt. I appreciate your humility. But a gift is a gift! Just saying thanks is enough sometimes. You inspire me to not give up.
reply
MEEZY
My Dealer is trying to charge me 3800 to fix this problem. First they said it was this part, Hyundai Part No. : 95410-3M020, Then they are saying I need this part, Hyundai Part No. : 91241-3M340. The Mechnic said my radio is not going off when the car is shut off. Are those parts links to that before I pay all of this money?
reply
My Dealer is trying to charge me 3800 to fix this problem. First they said it was this part, Hyundai Part No. : 95410-3M020, Then they are saying I need this part, Hyundai Part No. : 91241-3M340. The Mechnic said my radio is not going off when the car is shut off. Are those parts links to that before I pay all of this money?
reply
Joe
You are so freaking awesome. I have a var in the shop from auction with this same issue. I skipped by that because I didnt wait long enough. I pulled the ipm fuse and lost. 5 amp. And the radio fuse inside lost 1 amp. And another fuse lost 1 amp. But couldn't find out why. I'm pretty sure when I'll be a hero in the morning.
reply
You are so freaking awesome. I have a var in the shop from auction with this same issue. I skipped by that because I didnt wait long enough. I pulled the ipm fuse and lost. 5 amp. And the radio fuse inside lost 1 amp. And another fuse lost 1 amp. But couldn't find out why. I'm pretty sure when I'll be a hero in the morning.
reply
Aaron
You have got to be the best technician I have ever seen, also extremely dedicated to finding the solution. There are a lot of guys I work with/have worked with and if they can't figure it out they call it quits and just say take it to the dealership but not you sir! I wish I was Josh to learn under you!
reply
You have got to be the best technician I have ever seen, also extremely dedicated to finding the solution. There are a lot of guys I work with/have worked with and if they can't figure it out they call it quits and just say take it to the dealership but not you sir! I wish I was Josh to learn under you!
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















