VehiclesFashionRecipesBlogsHuntTravelsSportFunHandmadeITEducation
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Historical films
Alexander the Great IN ANCIENT GREEK!

Alexander the Great IN ANCIENT GREEK!

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
Massive thanks to Barefaced Greek for their expert help in making this video. Find out about their films in Ancient Greek ChubbyGoomba: The Erasmian Pronunciation is the ugliest thing i've ever heard. It literally pains the ears of a Greek, its extremely wrong and i would literally bet to cut my right hand in the fact that it is completely false. Its so tiring to hear all the time British people, Germs etc. defend this shit. It sounds like someone that speaks Latin or smth tries to mock the Hellenic Language. Languages may change a bit in the pronunciation aspect depending time and area but this shit is just not possible and i can even adress several points that even defend what i say, completely WRONG rythm, a TON of words are 'streched' in wrong syllabes and generally everything is mangled in such an awful way, and such a heavy change simply cant happen. Theres a ton of words that just not make sense if they get pronunced by the Erasmian way, just because of the way Hellenic words and language work, as it is a whole code and not just a simple language like English for example. i really dont understand how this shit hasnt been completely debunked by now and why so many people from completely foreign places to Hellas, defend this pronunciation with such a passion. Greek may be extremely hard to foreigners as i have never heard even a single person that tried to learn Greek, having the right 'accent', even if he studies for years on end. So i really cant understand why other Europeans defend it in such a passionate confident way, that this is the correct way that they were speaking back then, while they cant even speak Greek or even say the most basic and easy of words the correct way.
Date: 2022-09-12

Comments and reviews: 19


5: 34
Apinte pantes! Ke apelthontes oikoi, apangelate oti ton Basileon umon Alexandron:
Nikonta men Persas ke Medus ke Bactrius ke Sakas
Kektemenon ke Parthius ke Corasmius ke Herkanius este epi ten thalassa ten Caspia.
Hyperbantate ton Caucaso ke epiresanta ton Oxon ton potamon ke Tanae
Et ide ton Indo potamon. Udeni allo oti me Dionuso perathenta
Ke ton Huphasi diaperesanta an, emexume apogmesate.
Ke este Megalen Thalassa ta ampotera tu Indu ta stomata ebalonta ke tes Gedrosias tes remus elthonta. e ude pu pros sesu stratia ethe
Ke Carmania prosktesamenon, peripepleukotos de ede auto tu nauticu tin apidin gis es Persas thalassan.
Os es Susa epanegagate, apolipontes oikesthe. paradontes pulasen tis nenikemenis Barbarois
Tauta u min kai pros anthropon isos euklea. ke pros theon hosia depu este appageltheta. Apite!
(I pronounced kai as ke)

reply

Alexander is a MYTH; he never existed.
There was a Persian general who was the Satrap(governor) of Macedonia named Iskandar who revolted against the Persian emperor(Darius the Third) & took over the power by killing Darius the Third. Iskandar always dressed like Persians, spoke Persian language & he behaved like Persian culture, because he was a Persian. After conquering the Persian empire & killing the Persian emperor (Darius the Third) Iskandar was assassinated in Babylonia by the Greeks whom he had trusted by putting poison in his wine cup. Wine drinkers were Persians; so was Iskandar (Alexander.
And after assassinating Iskandar (Alexander) the Greeks took over the former Persian empire, & created the Helenostic empire(which was a mix of Persian philosophy & Greek philosophy, the origin of Christianity.

reply

Dude that hits so different hearing it in his own language. Being amongst those men bearing the weight of his words would have surely brought them all to their knees begging for forgiveness. In my opinion a top three leader of troops in history at least, if not the greatest. And he accomplished that in a fraction of the time men of his caliber ever did dying at 32 having completed all he said in his speech. One would be hard pressed to find a more accomplished battle commander at 32. Imagine if he had lived to his 50s or 60s this world might not be anything like what it is today.
reply

Look, ok. As much as I'm grateful that this video exists and these people put this much effort on creating something like this for the world for free, I thinking fellow Greeks will agree that the pronunciation is butchered to the bone marrow. Its almost as if the narrator doesn't speak Greek at all, his way of speech is almost, too thick and raw, like a raw piece of wood in a forest waiting yet to be carved into something smooth and elegant. Again, I'm not attacking the narrator, I'm just expressing how it sounds like, not only on this video, but on lots of others around.
reply

I saw the pinned comment regarding the pronunciation changes. I am well aware of them, and of the different pronunciation systems. That is not the issue. I am sorry to say that you do not pronounce it according to any system at all. The stress for example, the easiest thing to nail, is all over the place: MA-ke-do-NON. PA-tros. ME-ga-la. It is the same as me saying in English: MA-ke-do-ni-ANS, fa-THER, ma-SSI-ve. This is happening in almost half of the words.
reply

Most horrible butchering of Greek that I have encountered yet. I speak and read ancient Greek and this was the most horrific narration I have heard. Almost sounds like Norwegian.
The phonetics are horrible. Why not leave the Greek to the Greeks and scholars who pracrice it. English professors not only butchered this video but have bastardized the english translation of Alexander.

reply

I like the English version more. While I don't know Greek, it did sound more like this was read off a script than placing emphasis on certain words like the English version had, losing the emotional charge of the English version. Someone that knows Greek will have to confirm my opinion though since phrase stress might work differently in Greek.
reply

I really appreciate your effort to make more and more accurate but the actor sounds like he is reading sounds rather than reading the actual speech. And the erasmian accent really make it annoying. No matter the result of the sound in the video I am gonna thumbs up it. I really enjoy your efforts to place us next to his soldiers.
reply

macedonians like the rest of greeks: had greek names, spoke greek, worshipped the same greek gods, named their placenames with greek names, participated in greek olympic games, traced their originis in greek mythical heroes, spread everywhere the greek language and culture, used coins written in greek
reply

Great video! Great effort. Ancient Greek language is the Grandfather of modern Greek but essentially still the same language; the accent is understandably not very good, so it makes it difficult to follow/understand everything; i would love it hear the narration made by a Greek, like Alexander was.
reply

Although I admire the effort, next time, please, please for the love of god use a greek speaking person to say this, not a british one. He killed all the words and its impossible to understand. I speak ancient greek, and that was not even close 1%
reply

Macedonia never saw an army capable of confronting the great Achaemenid Empire. The Achaemenid Empire disintegrated in a civil war. You needed a hero to hide your humiliation behind it, and who better than Alexander, who had won the Civil War.
reply

Alexander was originally an Iranian who won the civil war against the Achaemenid Empire, and Greek historians falsely portrayed Alexander as Macedonian in order to alleviate some of the humiliation of Xerxes' conquest of Athens.
reply

great video, well done for your creativity and the work you have done. But you don't stress the words correctly when pronouncing them. So the text for a Greek who knows Ancient Greek is incomprehensible. Yours sincerely
reply

Holy shit that was great. Thank you so much. I was so shocked when I saw the video pop up. I thought you renamed the other version, then it dawned on me. What an amazing accomplishment. Thank you so much!
reply

you have to wqork in your accent, you can not sound as English but Greek speaking, its redicilous, I appreciate your try but it is wrong, I am Greek and i can not underst; and even one letter, a letter
reply

Which Alexander? The biggest lie in the history of Alexander the Great, directed and written by Greek historians. Do not be quick to judge, do a little research to find out what lies we are being told
reply

please let a greek utter alexander the great's speech. not only is the dialect wrong but the pronunciation is completely wrong. very misleading! suddenly everyone thinks they can speak greek. sad.
reply

Seeing Alexander the Great speaking in his native Ancient Greek language has always been my dream! It should have been cool to hire a native Greek actor! Greetings from Mexico!
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos