
What if the Spanish never funded Columbus?
video description
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
John
If King Ferdinand of Aragon and Queen Isabella of Castile didn't fund the voyage, Columbus would have easily got approval from France's King Charles VIII as he was known for being an adventurous monarch.
With the Portuguese having considerable control over the West African, Southeastern African, and Eastern trade routes to India as a result of the Treaty of Alcacovas which bans the Spanish from most African trade routes except for the Canary Islands, and the French having control over the westward routes as well as the Americas, Spain would have been bankrupt as a result of lost trade routes as well as a drained treasury from the War of the Reconquista with the Moors.
In its wake, France would have become a colonial superpower with considerable control over the Americas with Montreal being the centre of Western Power as opposed to New York, most of Latin America would still be called Latin America with French being the main language as opposed to Spanish or Portuguese without worrying about the Treaty of Tordesillas.
reply
If King Ferdinand of Aragon and Queen Isabella of Castile didn't fund the voyage, Columbus would have easily got approval from France's King Charles VIII as he was known for being an adventurous monarch.
With the Portuguese having considerable control over the West African, Southeastern African, and Eastern trade routes to India as a result of the Treaty of Alcacovas which bans the Spanish from most African trade routes except for the Canary Islands, and the French having control over the westward routes as well as the Americas, Spain would have been bankrupt as a result of lost trade routes as well as a drained treasury from the War of the Reconquista with the Moors.
In its wake, France would have become a colonial superpower with considerable control over the Americas with Montreal being the centre of Western Power as opposed to New York, most of Latin America would still be called Latin America with French being the main language as opposed to Spanish or Portuguese without worrying about the Treaty of Tordesillas.
reply
njb11
I wonder if when you described how Spanish colonial possessions turned out bad if that can describe decolonization. In the same way that the central Spanish government pulled out of Mexico the Europeans pulled out of Africa without firmly establishing centralized states or respecting ethno-tribal affiliations. I know Im a few years late on this video but if you see it would you consider talking about some African post colonial history, alternate scenarios, or more geopolitical analyses?
reply
I wonder if when you described how Spanish colonial possessions turned out bad if that can describe decolonization. In the same way that the central Spanish government pulled out of Mexico the Europeans pulled out of Africa without firmly establishing centralized states or respecting ethno-tribal affiliations. I know Im a few years late on this video but if you see it would you consider talking about some African post colonial history, alternate scenarios, or more geopolitical analyses?
reply
Henrique
The portuguese and the english would discover america at the same time, like the portuguese and the spanish did it in our world.
The real question is: how the competition between english and portuguese would affect the Anglo-Portuguese Alliance, oldest Alliance in the world today.
Wold the Charles II marry Catherine of Portugal? Withou English suport would Spain continue fighting to keep Portugal and all its colonies?
reply
The portuguese and the english would discover america at the same time, like the portuguese and the spanish did it in our world.
The real question is: how the competition between english and portuguese would affect the Anglo-Portuguese Alliance, oldest Alliance in the world today.
Wold the Charles II marry Catherine of Portugal? Withou English suport would Spain continue fighting to keep Portugal and all its colonies?
reply
NaZe
it was not an invasion they already had portugal after uncle of sebastian died, the portuguese nobles were on the side of spain and spain fought basicly rebels not an army and those rebels were not nobility, spain did not invade portugal they secured their loyalty because the nobles thought it was a good ideia to be spannish, and spain did not said we want portugal we invade no, they already had them in an dynastic union
reply
it was not an invasion they already had portugal after uncle of sebastian died, the portuguese nobles were on the side of spain and spain fought basicly rebels not an army and those rebels were not nobility, spain did not invade portugal they secured their loyalty because the nobles thought it was a good ideia to be spannish, and spain did not said we want portugal we invade no, they already had them in an dynastic union
reply
JT
IF ENGLAND DISCOVERD AMERICA Americas be united into one country and there be a very wealthy north central south America and a very very wealthy Caribbean.
ANGLO-SPHERE would be the largest population and territorial power in the world. imagine a American British union for a parliament federal democracy after ww2 uniting into the Anglo-sphere republic no one could challenge there power not even a Sino-soviet union.
reply
IF ENGLAND DISCOVERD AMERICA Americas be united into one country and there be a very wealthy north central south America and a very very wealthy Caribbean.
ANGLO-SPHERE would be the largest population and territorial power in the world. imagine a American British union for a parliament federal democracy after ww2 uniting into the Anglo-sphere republic no one could challenge there power not even a Sino-soviet union.
reply
Shane
I love your videos. My philosophy works like this. If I totally disagree with you, Id move on. If I totally agreed with you, Id move on. Needless to say, I dont have many friends. Lol thank you for being very objective. You identify past injustices without thr silly theatrics that some try to prove that serve no purpose. I know that hitting that balance isnt easy but I wanted to say thanks! Keep up the amazing work.
reply
I love your videos. My philosophy works like this. If I totally disagree with you, Id move on. If I totally agreed with you, Id move on. Needless to say, I dont have many friends. Lol thank you for being very objective. You identify past injustices without thr silly theatrics that some try to prove that serve no purpose. I know that hitting that balance isnt easy but I wanted to say thanks! Keep up the amazing work.
reply
Bertalan
Sorry, but the map around 9: 13 is totally wrong when it comes to the religious composition of Hungary. Eastern Orthodoxy was waaay far from being the dominant religion in the Hungarian-inhabited areas, most notably the Great Plain. In fact, this was the start of Protestant Reformation and the struggle with Catholics. Orthodoxy was mostly restricted to the Romanian and Serbian inhabited areas.
reply
Sorry, but the map around 9: 13 is totally wrong when it comes to the religious composition of Hungary. Eastern Orthodoxy was waaay far from being the dominant religion in the Hungarian-inhabited areas, most notably the Great Plain. In fact, this was the start of Protestant Reformation and the struggle with Catholics. Orthodoxy was mostly restricted to the Romanian and Serbian inhabited areas.
reply
100w
The spanish likely colonized northern south america and argentina. Ah come on, so close. Cant we have have some of that mexican fun? I mean, a chance to eventually have a country that knows how to govern itself, and not having to waste 200 plus years learning to do so. still learning to do so. I'd give both my surnames and names for something bland like john smith lol.
reply
The spanish likely colonized northern south america and argentina. Ah come on, so close. Cant we have have some of that mexican fun? I mean, a chance to eventually have a country that knows how to govern itself, and not having to waste 200 plus years learning to do so. still learning to do so. I'd give both my surnames and names for something bland like john smith lol.
reply
ivan
most of this wars were failures, excuse me what are you talking about, spain dominated europe and won almost every battle/war in the 16th century, they revolucionized warfare and the tercios were seemengly incencible for a century.
I would kile the source were you got this missinformation because it stuns me how you could claim something that inaccurate.
reply
most of this wars were failures, excuse me what are you talking about, spain dominated europe and won almost every battle/war in the 16th century, they revolucionized warfare and the tercios were seemengly incencible for a century.
I would kile the source were you got this missinformation because it stuns me how you could claim something that inaccurate.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















