
Sci-Fi Short Film Exo Sapien - DUST
video description
Date: 2024-04-01
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 35
TM-cf9ek
Dear James C. Williamson (writer/director, thank you and your team for the great effort you put in this short. With your permission I will rate from 1 to 5 the following:
Story: well, the ideea is good, but it looks confusing as the storyline is not very fluid and while some scenes are slow without telling anything others are abrupt bringing information from nowhere. The memories ideea is brilliant, like being trapped inside someone universe. The creature on the other hand is poor and childish. A more unseen monster would have done better. 3 stars
Lights on set: 5 stars. Great lighting.
Sound: 3 stars, could have been better on all aspects.
Camera: 5 stars. Beside the running from the monster scene, which was quite static camera was superb. Thumbs up for the camera operator.
Color grading: 5 stars, fabulous colouring and good editing.
Actors: well here we have big ups and downs. While the two main characters were overall not bad at all, the running from the monster scene was one of the worst I ever saw. Good actors don't have tons of Drama and Acting school degrees or being members of Actors Guild, they are natural and convincing. In the aforementioned scene they were supposed to run for their lives, instead they were doing some early morning jogging. After the male character is stuck in the doors yelling for help, the female character was so bad in acting. Her body language was well, ok. ah. I will help you 'cause I don't have what to do anyway. Acting for that scene receives a 1 star, overall 3 stars for the entire movie.
Costumes: 4 stars
Vfx & makeup: 4 stars
reply
Dear James C. Williamson (writer/director, thank you and your team for the great effort you put in this short. With your permission I will rate from 1 to 5 the following:
Story: well, the ideea is good, but it looks confusing as the storyline is not very fluid and while some scenes are slow without telling anything others are abrupt bringing information from nowhere. The memories ideea is brilliant, like being trapped inside someone universe. The creature on the other hand is poor and childish. A more unseen monster would have done better. 3 stars
Lights on set: 5 stars. Great lighting.
Sound: 3 stars, could have been better on all aspects.
Camera: 5 stars. Beside the running from the monster scene, which was quite static camera was superb. Thumbs up for the camera operator.
Color grading: 5 stars, fabulous colouring and good editing.
Actors: well here we have big ups and downs. While the two main characters were overall not bad at all, the running from the monster scene was one of the worst I ever saw. Good actors don't have tons of Drama and Acting school degrees or being members of Actors Guild, they are natural and convincing. In the aforementioned scene they were supposed to run for their lives, instead they were doing some early morning jogging. After the male character is stuck in the doors yelling for help, the female character was so bad in acting. Her body language was well, ok. ah. I will help you 'cause I don't have what to do anyway. Acting for that scene receives a 1 star, overall 3 stars for the entire movie.
Costumes: 4 stars
Vfx & makeup: 4 stars
reply
davidursin2150
The problems I had with this story was that it didn't answer all of the 4 main questions:
1 - Who is the main character/protagonist
I thought it was the dying astronaut but at the end that was confused with the implication it was Alex dwelling in her
2 - What is the main character trying to accomplish
I wasn't sure initially then I then heard the astronaut say she wanted get off this rock and back to where ( I never learned.
3 - Who's trying to stop the main character
I never got a solid answer to that. Initially I thought it was the liquid/blob monster, then I thought it was the additional characters that were added when she suddenly woke up in a building basement. But they turned out not to be antagonists and the blob monster returned to attack them too so. back to the monster Then the end of story discussion amongst the added characters about Alex being trapped in the astronaut's mind to figure a way out confused my understanding of what had been happening all along - very frustrating. Maybe that was intended as a reversal, but still, it left me feeling frustrated not intrigued.
4 - What happens if they fail
I guess if they fail, they remain stuck on this rock since that was repeated by the additional characters at the end, as well.
If I watched this a few more times I would likely get a better understanding of what's going on, but not being able to understand it the first time around, IMO, points to a need for some rewriting.
reply
The problems I had with this story was that it didn't answer all of the 4 main questions:
1 - Who is the main character/protagonist
I thought it was the dying astronaut but at the end that was confused with the implication it was Alex dwelling in her
2 - What is the main character trying to accomplish
I wasn't sure initially then I then heard the astronaut say she wanted get off this rock and back to where ( I never learned.
3 - Who's trying to stop the main character
I never got a solid answer to that. Initially I thought it was the liquid/blob monster, then I thought it was the additional characters that were added when she suddenly woke up in a building basement. But they turned out not to be antagonists and the blob monster returned to attack them too so. back to the monster Then the end of story discussion amongst the added characters about Alex being trapped in the astronaut's mind to figure a way out confused my understanding of what had been happening all along - very frustrating. Maybe that was intended as a reversal, but still, it left me feeling frustrated not intrigued.
4 - What happens if they fail
I guess if they fail, they remain stuck on this rock since that was repeated by the additional characters at the end, as well.
If I watched this a few more times I would likely get a better understanding of what's going on, but not being able to understand it the first time around, IMO, points to a need for some rewriting.
reply
dust
When the countdown reaches zero, Cass’s memories come flooding back and she realizes the terrible truth that the device was trying to protect her from.
Not exactly clear on what this terrible truth that the device was trying to protect her from. really is
Reading books or watching films is escapism. Sci fi fans are no different except their 'escape' is on another planet, in another time, or another dimension.
We are not super high IQ academics, just fans with outlandish imaginations. However you as the author should leave a few breadcrumbs that we can follow.
reply
When the countdown reaches zero, Cass’s memories come flooding back and she realizes the terrible truth that the device was trying to protect her from.
Not exactly clear on what this terrible truth that the device was trying to protect her from. really is
Reading books or watching films is escapism. Sci fi fans are no different except their 'escape' is on another planet, in another time, or another dimension.
We are not super high IQ academics, just fans with outlandish imaginations. However you as the author should leave a few breadcrumbs that we can follow.
reply
dust
Interesting concept, terrible delivery. Its poorly expressed or not expressed to be precise, that the blood monster is the fractured consciousness of Cass trying to regain control of her body and that Alex consciousness is stuck and lost her memory from things going bad during the procedure and is now mixing bits she actually remembered up but the build up should've been actually discovering what Cass was doing on the planet and what went wrong and relaying it to her team before slowly starting to forget things. Just my 2 cent.
reply
Interesting concept, terrible delivery. Its poorly expressed or not expressed to be precise, that the blood monster is the fractured consciousness of Cass trying to regain control of her body and that Alex consciousness is stuck and lost her memory from things going bad during the procedure and is now mixing bits she actually remembered up but the build up should've been actually discovering what Cass was doing on the planet and what went wrong and relaying it to her team before slowly starting to forget things. Just my 2 cent.
reply
auroraglacialis
So, that fractured ghost was presumably Cass, or what remained of her, but how did it affect the guys in real life rather than just Alex who is in that body of Cass. I also assume now that Alex was in that bunker in a coma because her consciousness was in the Cass body and this was prolonged everytime she plugged in - so in the end it means Alex should have woken up but for some reason instead she went into some other place, maybe stuck inside Cass mind.
reply
So, that fractured ghost was presumably Cass, or what remained of her, but how did it affect the guys in real life rather than just Alex who is in that body of Cass. I also assume now that Alex was in that bunker in a coma because her consciousness was in the Cass body and this was prolonged everytime she plugged in - so in the end it means Alex should have woken up but for some reason instead she went into some other place, maybe stuck inside Cass mind.
reply
captainjj7184
Good production nevertheless and I will be watching any sequels to this, I understand first hand how hard it is to shoot these considering all the limitations and this picture ends up pretty amazing. Just a script note maybe her over the top Manga attitude as a captive could be toned down a bit (unless it's part of the story, dunno I haven't watched this story's prequel) - but who am I to complain after that ending: )
reply
Good production nevertheless and I will be watching any sequels to this, I understand first hand how hard it is to shoot these considering all the limitations and this picture ends up pretty amazing. Just a script note maybe her over the top Manga attitude as a captive could be toned down a bit (unless it's part of the story, dunno I haven't watched this story's prequel) - but who am I to complain after that ending: )
reply
joustingdude
I mean. it was interesting But I can only speculate on the story as it remained disjointed throughout. And the vague resolution was not at all resolved. But it had great production value and reasonably good acting, but the dialogue was unhelpful and vague. I think it deserves more time to actually tell a story, this felt loike there was a LOT of story being compressed into a tiny window of time.
reply
I mean. it was interesting But I can only speculate on the story as it remained disjointed throughout. And the vague resolution was not at all resolved. But it had great production value and reasonably good acting, but the dialogue was unhelpful and vague. I think it deserves more time to actually tell a story, this felt loike there was a LOT of story being compressed into a tiny window of time.
reply
cheesewilliamson
Hey everyone! This is James C. Williamson, writer/director. Thank you so much for taking the time to check out our short!
I'm sure you all have a few questions - please fire away and I will endeavour to give the most non-specific and obtuse answers I can think of!
Also, if your question is: Was X an Evangelion reference, the answer is automatically yes.
reply
Hey everyone! This is James C. Williamson, writer/director. Thank you so much for taking the time to check out our short!
I'm sure you all have a few questions - please fire away and I will endeavour to give the most non-specific and obtuse answers I can think of!
Also, if your question is: Was X an Evangelion reference, the answer is automatically yes.
reply
dust
Love it. Great production values. Great cast and acting. The 'entity' is freaky. The end scene is awesome and totally unexpected. It seems they 'borrowed her' (the one guy said 'she would be on auto pilot') and then when they all died she went back to her original body where they had found her. And she has to go from there - the only survivor. or maybe not
reply
Love it. Great production values. Great cast and acting. The 'entity' is freaky. The end scene is awesome and totally unexpected. It seems they 'borrowed her' (the one guy said 'she would be on auto pilot') and then when they all died she went back to her original body where they had found her. And she has to go from there - the only survivor. or maybe not
reply
martyschrader
You know, it would be nice if pieces like this could actually tell a story instead of mashing together little bits and pieces of a story and leaving the whole as an incomprehensible jumble. Never leave the audience wondering what the heck just happened. Y'all violated that rule.
reply
You know, it would be nice if pieces like this could actually tell a story instead of mashing together little bits and pieces of a story and leaving the whole as an incomprehensible jumble. Never leave the audience wondering what the heck just happened. Y'all violated that rule.
reply
manfrommoon552
This film is not to my taste. A tangled story that spins around a technical device. Why does one want to escape from this planet at all The astronaut wakes up in a worked field and there are factory ruins. All this does not fit together properly
reply
This film is not to my taste. A tangled story that spins around a technical device. Why does one want to escape from this planet at all The astronaut wakes up in a worked field and there are factory ruins. All this does not fit together properly
reply
SynthoidSounds
Interesting, but there's a lot of missing pieces, can't really see the entire picture or even enough of a major portion of it from which to extract a potential interpretation. Meanwhile, couldn't help but notice Cass's interesting hair.
reply
Interesting, but there's a lot of missing pieces, can't really see the entire picture or even enough of a major portion of it from which to extract a potential interpretation. Meanwhile, couldn't help but notice Cass's interesting hair.
reply
someguydino6770
I hate it when within the first minute or so the writers test your gullibility.
There's no way in hell that girl would ever be able to put on that helmet with those beautiful, long, kinky, Bob Marley braids!
NO WAY!
reply
I hate it when within the first minute or so the writers test your gullibility.
There's no way in hell that girl would ever be able to put on that helmet with those beautiful, long, kinky, Bob Marley braids!
NO WAY!
reply
christadauria4362
There was the new species of Exo- Sapiens as only one female exo- sapien on the super Earth in her encounter with other human beings as the astronauts from our Earth in our Solar System in our Milky Way Galaxy.
reply
There was the new species of Exo- Sapiens as only one female exo- sapien on the super Earth in her encounter with other human beings as the astronauts from our Earth in our Solar System in our Milky Way Galaxy.
reply
JameyAston
First the positive. I enjoyed the acting and the directing seemed ok. The score supported the suspense idea. The negative. All the points raised. Confusing story, bad audio engineering, unsatisfying finish.
reply
First the positive. I enjoyed the acting and the directing seemed ok. The score supported the suspense idea. The negative. All the points raised. Confusing story, bad audio engineering, unsatisfying finish.
reply
shawnerz98
3: 30 reminded me of a middle school joke:
Q: What's gross
A: Biting in to an apple and finding a worm.
Q: What's grosser than gross
A: Biting in to an apple and finding half a worm!
reply
3: 30 reminded me of a middle school joke:
Q: What's gross
A: Biting in to an apple and finding a worm.
Q: What's grosser than gross
A: Biting in to an apple and finding half a worm!
reply
user-wf5co6ct7l
When I was at school I was taught that stories needed a beginning, a middle and an end. None of here. Or perhaps you could’ve started at the end and worked backwards. Just my opinion.
reply
When I was at school I was taught that stories needed a beginning, a middle and an end. None of here. Or perhaps you could’ve started at the end and worked backwards. Just my opinion.
reply
lisanidog8178
I’m hooked on Dust. These films are amazing! Great story lines, top notch acting. Kudos to these filmmakers and their actors. Dust is a very safe addiction and every day I need my fix.
reply
I’m hooked on Dust. These films are amazing! Great story lines, top notch acting. Kudos to these filmmakers and their actors. Dust is a very safe addiction and every day I need my fix.
reply
ieatcaribou7852
Another visually brilliant confusing mess that could’ve been saved with less than a minute of exposition. Definitely a reason why over 100k views has garnered a mere 3k likes.
reply
Another visually brilliant confusing mess that could’ve been saved with less than a minute of exposition. Definitely a reason why over 100k views has garnered a mere 3k likes.
reply
auroraglacialis
I wish we would have gotten at least some clues as to who Cass was and what vessel and why she crashed and what the others were doing there, apparently being somehow trapped.
reply
I wish we would have gotten at least some clues as to who Cass was and what vessel and why she crashed and what the others were doing there, apparently being somehow trapped.
reply
Windrider6
Yet another DUST video that has a start, and we will probably never see the end. I weary of DUST videos that are boosters for writers and directors, but are not for Sci Fi fans.
reply
Yet another DUST video that has a start, and we will probably never see the end. I weary of DUST videos that are boosters for writers and directors, but are not for Sci Fi fans.
reply
sydneyperry8703
Still confused on what the terrible truth the device was trying to protector her from is. Regardless I loved it, very unique and the lead actress was incredible.
reply
Still confused on what the terrible truth the device was trying to protector her from is. Regardless I loved it, very unique and the lead actress was incredible.
reply
Wanelmask
The way some scenes are shot certains soundtrack reminded me of an lsd/ketamine trip I had back then.
Outside of that, the fck is going on with the plot!
reply
The way some scenes are shot certains soundtrack reminded me of an lsd/ketamine trip I had back then.
Outside of that, the fck is going on with the plot!
reply
dust
Loved the side boobage at the start which cleverly foreshadowed the nude girlage at the end which was a clever way to, um, symbolise vulnerability. Yeah. Noice.
reply
Loved the side boobage at the start which cleverly foreshadowed the nude girlage at the end which was a clever way to, um, symbolise vulnerability. Yeah. Noice.
reply
fionajane56
Simple things make a short film more intense.
The young womans dreads would never be acceptable in space or under a helmet of any shipsuit.
reply
Simple things make a short film more intense.
The young womans dreads would never be acceptable in space or under a helmet of any shipsuit.
reply
dust
Due to heavy rain of my tin roof in my shack south of Cambodia, I must look at this again when rain stops.
I am little bit confuse about this all
reply
Due to heavy rain of my tin roof in my shack south of Cambodia, I must look at this again when rain stops.
I am little bit confuse about this all
reply
MrSky084
Pretty sure the opening drone sequence was reversed as the
'smoke is going back into the damaged items on the ground. First thing I noticed.
reply
Pretty sure the opening drone sequence was reversed as the
'smoke is going back into the damaged items on the ground. First thing I noticed.
reply
MathewWalls
Can't hear shit towards the end, but I get the impression it doesn't actually make any sense or explain anything anyway. Utterly pointless.
reply
Can't hear shit towards the end, but I get the impression it doesn't actually make any sense or explain anything anyway. Utterly pointless.
reply
alanfindlay3233
My take: 16 minutes of incomprehensible nonsense that is a set-up for a New-Eve waking up on a New-Earth and looking for New-Adam.
reply
My take: 16 minutes of incomprehensible nonsense that is a set-up for a New-Eve waking up on a New-Earth and looking for New-Adam.
reply
raphlvlogs271
starting from 15: 02 the way it was filmed makes you feel like your high on psychedelics but with a high tech looking twist
reply
starting from 15: 02 the way it was filmed makes you feel like your high on psychedelics but with a high tech looking twist
reply
sonovivo1247
I especially loved the final images it's a small relief to the sick shyness of most American (short and long) movies: -)
reply
I especially loved the final images it's a small relief to the sick shyness of most American (short and long) movies: -)
reply
BARDAKABRAMA
it is a Predator. Since when the gangsta became the spacemen Stop re-write the human history, you fakers
reply
it is a Predator. Since when the gangsta became the spacemen Stop re-write the human history, you fakers
reply
ncox001
Let me get this right. You wake up on an alien planet and the first thing you do is REMOVE YOUR HELMET
reply
Let me get this right. You wake up on an alien planet and the first thing you do is REMOVE YOUR HELMET
reply
bennaustin6632
It would be nice to be able to hear the dialogue without excessively loud music drowning it out
reply
It would be nice to be able to hear the dialogue without excessively loud music drowning it out
reply
Oliviakhouk
This is probably the first film that I want crazy about Because I still have no idea what happened
reply
This is probably the first film that I want crazy about Because I still have no idea what happened
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















