Top 10 Glee Songs That Should've Been Sung By Other Cast Members
video description
Date: 2023-11-20
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 30
Moreand
Wide Awake, Superbass, Dance Again, Chandelier, and My Lovin' (Never Gonna Get It) were perfect, I don't think any other cast would do justice.
Wide Awake: Quinn does have a beautiful soft voice, suited for slow and emotional songs. But I think her voice is too soft for this song, it needs some strong vocals at some lines too. Kitty and Tina are versatile, they can soften their voice but also can belt.
Superbass: Mercedes is great, but Sue's rendition of Superbass is perfection. She has lower voice like Nicki Minaj, while Mercedes has higher voice. If Mercedes sing Superbass, they might need to do it in a higher key to get the same vibes (Like they did for Rachel's Baby One More Time, it's in higher key. And I don't think Superbass in a higher key is as pleasant.
Dance Again: Brittany? She's a great dancer but she can't sing this song as good as Cassandra. This song is quite vocal demanding (in Gaga's part. She would struggle to belt the notes. Cassandra's voice is perfect for this. If anyone to sing this song other than her, I can only imagine Santana or Tina.
Chandelier: Rachel might be good, but Kurt? He can sing high, but not for this belty songs. He rarely belt, he's more of a head voice singer. I can't imagine this song being sung in head voice.
My Lovin': Warblers just because they mostly do Acapella? New Directions could've done Acapella too. Artie and Tina are perfect for this song, and the music arrangement is good. Warblers barely had any type of sassy singer, only Sebastian.
And Santana is not a soprano, her voice is too deep to be classified as a soprano. She's a Mezzo. She actually had one of the lowest female voice among the cast.
reply
Wide Awake, Superbass, Dance Again, Chandelier, and My Lovin' (Never Gonna Get It) were perfect, I don't think any other cast would do justice.
Wide Awake: Quinn does have a beautiful soft voice, suited for slow and emotional songs. But I think her voice is too soft for this song, it needs some strong vocals at some lines too. Kitty and Tina are versatile, they can soften their voice but also can belt.
Superbass: Mercedes is great, but Sue's rendition of Superbass is perfection. She has lower voice like Nicki Minaj, while Mercedes has higher voice. If Mercedes sing Superbass, they might need to do it in a higher key to get the same vibes (Like they did for Rachel's Baby One More Time, it's in higher key. And I don't think Superbass in a higher key is as pleasant.
Dance Again: Brittany? She's a great dancer but she can't sing this song as good as Cassandra. This song is quite vocal demanding (in Gaga's part. She would struggle to belt the notes. Cassandra's voice is perfect for this. If anyone to sing this song other than her, I can only imagine Santana or Tina.
Chandelier: Rachel might be good, but Kurt? He can sing high, but not for this belty songs. He rarely belt, he's more of a head voice singer. I can't imagine this song being sung in head voice.
My Lovin': Warblers just because they mostly do Acapella? New Directions could've done Acapella too. Artie and Tina are perfect for this song, and the music arrangement is good. Warblers barely had any type of sassy singer, only Sebastian.
And Santana is not a soprano, her voice is too deep to be classified as a soprano. She's a Mezzo. She actually had one of the lowest female voice among the cast.
reply
Victoria
My absolute top pick if I could change any Glee song, would have been for Kurt to sing Baby It's You in S6 - either by himself or as a duet with Mercedes (who did sing it beautifully and a third Kurtcedes duet would have been more than welcome too. From a plot perspective, it would have fit where he was in his relationship with Blaine at the time perfectly, as well as allowing him to be part of the effort to encourage Rachel back to Broadway (and really it made no sense that Kurt was absent from that particular storyline completely.
Added to the fact that I loved Chris singing A House Is Not A Home in S1 and had been hoping he'd cover another Burt Bacharach song before the show ended, I was really disappointed to finally get a whole episode of Bacharch covers without Kurt being properly featured on any of them.
reply
My absolute top pick if I could change any Glee song, would have been for Kurt to sing Baby It's You in S6 - either by himself or as a duet with Mercedes (who did sing it beautifully and a third Kurtcedes duet would have been more than welcome too. From a plot perspective, it would have fit where he was in his relationship with Blaine at the time perfectly, as well as allowing him to be part of the effort to encourage Rachel back to Broadway (and really it made no sense that Kurt was absent from that particular storyline completely.
Added to the fact that I loved Chris singing A House Is Not A Home in S1 and had been hoping he'd cover another Burt Bacharach song before the show ended, I was really disappointed to finally get a whole episode of Bacharch covers without Kurt being properly featured on any of them.
reply
Rebecca
Plot lines from Glee that should have been about another Glee character:
1: It should have been Mercedes who had a crush on Mr. Schuester, not Rachel.
2: It should have been Santana who came out as a trans man, not Beiste. (His new name could have been Santiago)
3. It should have been Beiste who (since she would still be a woman) got pregnant and raised a baby on her own, not Sue; especially considering that Sue mentioned a few times in Season 1 that shed had a hysterectomy.
4. It should have been Mike who Tina got back together with, not Artie.
reply
Plot lines from Glee that should have been about another Glee character:
1: It should have been Mercedes who had a crush on Mr. Schuester, not Rachel.
2: It should have been Santana who came out as a trans man, not Beiste. (His new name could have been Santiago)
3. It should have been Beiste who (since she would still be a woman) got pregnant and raised a baby on her own, not Sue; especially considering that Sue mentioned a few times in Season 1 that shed had a hysterectomy.
4. It should have been Mike who Tina got back together with, not Artie.
reply
Emma
I think misery should have been sung by Kurt and Rachel instead of Blaine and the Warblers as the way the Warblers sing doesnt feel right for this song as a piano version wouldve been better and I could see Kurt singing this about not belonging with the Warblers and wanting to go back to McKinley and rejoining the New Directions and Rachel could sing this about wanting to get back together with Finn and feeling sad about him dating Quinn
reply
I think misery should have been sung by Kurt and Rachel instead of Blaine and the Warblers as the way the Warblers sing doesnt feel right for this song as a piano version wouldve been better and I could see Kurt singing this about not belonging with the Warblers and wanting to go back to McKinley and rejoining the New Directions and Rachel could sing this about wanting to get back together with Finn and feeling sad about him dating Quinn
reply
Emma
How about doing a video of songs on glee that shouldve been sung more than once I mean I could see Rachel singing get it right during the election and wanting to fix things with Kurt and when her tv show failed and I wouldve loved it if Kurt and Rachel sang for good again like when they were coaching new directions and the new directions shouldve sung keep holding in season 2 for Kurt
reply
How about doing a video of songs on glee that shouldve been sung more than once I mean I could see Rachel singing get it right during the election and wanting to fix things with Kurt and when her tv show failed and I wouldve loved it if Kurt and Rachel sang for good again like when they were coaching new directions and the new directions shouldve sung keep holding in season 2 for Kurt
reply
Elle
Chandelier should sung by melissa benoist,
whatever happened to saturday night should sung by finn or puck.
Call me maybe should be solo by tina or quinn.
Theres a worst that i could do should be solo of santana
Newyork state of mind should be solo performance by marley
Diva should be the duet of santana and mercedes
Thousand miles more suits on sam and quinn
reply
Chandelier should sung by melissa benoist,
whatever happened to saturday night should sung by finn or puck.
Call me maybe should be solo by tina or quinn.
Theres a worst that i could do should be solo of santana
Newyork state of mind should be solo performance by marley
Diva should be the duet of santana and mercedes
Thousand miles more suits on sam and quinn
reply
Georgia
I swear to God I got so bored when 70% of the solos go to Rachel. Honestly Lea's voice is only okay for certain songs and not good in so many songs like Chicago, Maria just to name a few. Should have given some of the songs to Quinn, Mercedes and Santana. It is such a waste and I am not even joking about this. Lea/Rachel's vocal ability is very overrated in my perspective.
reply
I swear to God I got so bored when 70% of the solos go to Rachel. Honestly Lea's voice is only okay for certain songs and not good in so many songs like Chicago, Maria just to name a few. Should have given some of the songs to Quinn, Mercedes and Santana. It is such a waste and I am not even joking about this. Lea/Rachel's vocal ability is very overrated in my perspective.
reply
Elaina
I will never forgive the directors for having Santana and Rachel sing I kissed a girl after Santana was outed. It SHOULD have been Santana and Britney as they were together and it would have made so much more sense for them to sing it together. Santana and Rachel weren't even really friends so it made no sense for them to sing it together.
reply
I will never forgive the directors for having Santana and Rachel sing I kissed a girl after Santana was outed. It SHOULD have been Santana and Britney as they were together and it would have made so much more sense for them to sing it together. Santana and Rachel weren't even really friends so it made no sense for them to sing it together.
reply
Vara
Rachel had a powerhouse of a voice, but that doesn't make it any better than Santana's, or Mercedes'. Finn's voice was completely overrated, especially compared to Puck's. Several of the voices on the show were eclipsed, and not for the better. When the show gave up good story for shoe-horning in recent hits, it all fell apart.
reply
Rachel had a powerhouse of a voice, but that doesn't make it any better than Santana's, or Mercedes'. Finn's voice was completely overrated, especially compared to Puck's. Several of the voices on the show were eclipsed, and not for the better. When the show gave up good story for shoe-horning in recent hits, it all fell apart.
reply
Christian
Yesterday, I was watching season 3, the episode where the Troubletones and New Direction merge again and they finish the episode singing We are young, I just thought that since Quinn brought them back together and then they cut to the song, it wouldve been better for her to carry the song, not Rachel and Finn.
reply
Yesterday, I was watching season 3, the episode where the Troubletones and New Direction merge again and they finish the episode singing We are young, I just thought that since Quinn brought them back together and then they cut to the song, it wouldve been better for her to carry the song, not Rachel and Finn.
reply
Emma
The song cool kids performed in season 6 shouldve been performed by Artie, Kurt, Mercedes, Rachel and Tina as they were outcasts and they couldve sung it to the rest of glee club telling them that they wanna be popular like them and I wouldve like to see more song by them since they were the 5 original members
reply
The song cool kids performed in season 6 shouldve been performed by Artie, Kurt, Mercedes, Rachel and Tina as they were outcasts and they couldve sung it to the rest of glee club telling them that they wanna be popular like them and I wouldve like to see more song by them since they were the 5 original members
reply
Showman87
Rachel and Finn definitely would've been better choices for A Thousand Years. I often find myself thinking many songs Artie sang would've been better sung by Finn including Michael Jackson's Bad, Elton John's Your Song and I'm Still Standing (having students in wheelchairs sing that one was very awkward.
reply
Rachel and Finn definitely would've been better choices for A Thousand Years. I often find myself thinking many songs Artie sang would've been better sung by Finn including Michael Jackson's Bad, Elton John's Your Song and I'm Still Standing (having students in wheelchairs sing that one was very awkward.
reply
Marlo
I'm glad bamboleo/hero was just an honorable mention because sam did great on that song and Finn. would've been Finn and added yet another solo probably sung to Rachel for the millionth time. It was a good plot point between Sam to show Mercedes how much he could be there for her in a relationship.
reply
I'm glad bamboleo/hero was just an honorable mention because sam did great on that song and Finn. would've been Finn and added yet another solo probably sung to Rachel for the millionth time. It was a good plot point between Sam to show Mercedes how much he could be there for her in a relationship.
reply
Emma
I think that hopelessly devoted to you shouldve been sung by Kurt I mean Blaine is the one who cheated so why is he singing about being fully committed to the relationship and I think it wouldve been perfect for Kurt to sing about the heartbreak since we only got to see Blaines side of the break up
reply
I think that hopelessly devoted to you shouldve been sung by Kurt I mean Blaine is the one who cheated so why is he singing about being fully committed to the relationship and I think it wouldve been perfect for Kurt to sing about the heartbreak since we only got to see Blaines side of the break up
reply
Emma
Kurt and Rachel shouldve gotten more duets I mean its not fair that season 2 is the only season where they get more than one duet, also how great would it be if they did their NYADA audition together and instead of Rachel singing a solo at nationals they did a duet
reply
Kurt and Rachel shouldve gotten more duets I mean its not fair that season 2 is the only season where they get more than one duet, also how great would it be if they did their NYADA audition together and instead of Rachel singing a solo at nationals they did a duet
reply
Emma
I think rather be shouldve been sung by the alumni I mean I love the season 6 new directions vocals but they still were just getting to know each other and the alumni have been through so much with each other and it wouldve been a great way to show their bond
reply
I think rather be shouldve been sung by the alumni I mean I love the season 6 new directions vocals but they still were just getting to know each other and the alumni have been through so much with each other and it wouldve been a great way to show their bond
reply
Emma
How many people wouldve liked it if during nut-bush city limits instead of the cheerleaders Santana sang with Kurt, Mercedes and Rachel? I mean it wouldve been perfect considering it was the diva episode and the four of them were the divas of new directions
reply
How many people wouldve liked it if during nut-bush city limits instead of the cheerleaders Santana sang with Kurt, Mercedes and Rachel? I mean it wouldve been perfect considering it was the diva episode and the four of them were the divas of new directions
reply
JD
(Commenting before the video is done) Rachel did a solo on a Britney Spears song that sounded really bad in her voice. Lea Michelle can do lots of things, but that was pretty bad. I hope it's on this list, but I'm going in with doubt.
reply
(Commenting before the video is done) Rachel did a solo on a Britney Spears song that sounded really bad in her voice. Lea Michelle can do lots of things, but that was pretty bad. I hope it's on this list, but I'm going in with doubt.
reply
John
I thought it was well known that the producers didnt get along with Diana Agron. I always thought that was why Quinn didnt get more solos or even camera exposure. It always seemed like she was in the scene but only shown in passing.
reply
I thought it was well known that the producers didnt get along with Diana Agron. I always thought that was why Quinn didnt get more solos or even camera exposure. It always seemed like she was in the scene but only shown in passing.
reply
Valerie
my lovin wouldve worked perfectly when finn and santana were fighting, wouldve been amazing to hear them sing it together because we all know cory could do such an amazing job, and naya wouldve killed those high notes
reply
my lovin wouldve worked perfectly when finn and santana were fighting, wouldve been amazing to hear them sing it together because we all know cory could do such an amazing job, and naya wouldve killed those high notes
reply
June13girl
Personally I believe that when Marley and Ryder were singing the final song in Greece (I forgot the song name) it should've stayed with those two singing the whole time instead of Rachel and Finn taking over
reply
Personally I believe that when Marley and Ryder were singing the final song in Greece (I forgot the song name) it should've stayed with those two singing the whole time instead of Rachel and Finn taking over
reply
Emma
You know I think a thousand years should be sung by Kurt, Rachel and Santana, I mean they could sing this to Blaine, Brittany and Finn telling that even though theyre broken up theyll always love them.
reply
You know I think a thousand years should be sung by Kurt, Rachel and Santana, I mean they could sing this to Blaine, Brittany and Finn telling that even though theyre broken up theyll always love them.
reply
Billie
Rachel and Finn do not need extra songs than what they already had, Chandelier was perfect for the 3 girls in New Directions it was the only real solo Madison McCarthy/Laura Dreyfuss sang
reply
Rachel and Finn do not need extra songs than what they already had, Chandelier was perfect for the 3 girls in New Directions it was the only real solo Madison McCarthy/Laura Dreyfuss sang
reply
Brandon
Tina, Quinn, Mercedes, and Mike deserved so much more.
But Rachel and Jesse shouldve never touched Rolling in the Deep. A handful of other characters couldve did that so much better.
reply
Tina, Quinn, Mercedes, and Mike deserved so much more.
But Rachel and Jesse shouldve never touched Rolling in the Deep. A handful of other characters couldve did that so much better.
reply
Emma
I wish we had gotten more of the quartet of Kurt, Mercedes, Rachel and Santana I mean I love them singing How Will I Know and I wish we had gotten to hear Kurt, Rachel and Santana as a trio
reply
I wish we had gotten more of the quartet of Kurt, Mercedes, Rachel and Santana I mean I love them singing How Will I Know and I wish we had gotten to hear Kurt, Rachel and Santana as a trio
reply
megannwalsh
I feel so bad that Dianna Agron didnt get to sing as much bc her dream was being in a musical. Also, I think Naya shouldve sang more. Her voice was incredible and better than Leas.
reply
I feel so bad that Dianna Agron didnt get to sing as much bc her dream was being in a musical. Also, I think Naya shouldve sang more. Her voice was incredible and better than Leas.
reply
BeachBoysfan4ever
quinn was ROBBED the entire show. she's my favorite character and i really really wish we got to hear her sing more and that she got better development and storylines
reply
quinn was ROBBED the entire show. she's my favorite character and i really really wish we got to hear her sing more and that she got better development and storylines
reply
The
my top 10 if toby Richards on glee what Relationships he have
10. Tina Cohen - Chang
9. Holly Holliday
8. Sue Sylvester
7. Marley Rose
6. Kitty Wilde
Fabray
reply
my top 10 if toby Richards on glee what Relationships he have
10. Tina Cohen - Chang
9. Holly Holliday
8. Sue Sylvester
7. Marley Rose
6. Kitty Wilde
Fabray
reply
Annie
I would have loved Santana and Brittany singing A Thousand Years in season 5 when they got back together because they loved each other from the very beginning and never stopped.
reply
I would have loved Santana and Brittany singing A Thousand Years in season 5 when they got back together because they loved each other from the very beginning and never stopped.
reply
Emma
I think we all can agree that candles shouldve been sung by Finn and Rachel as it doesnt make sense for Blaine and Kurt to sing a break up song as their first duet as a couple
reply
I think we all can agree that candles shouldve been sung by Finn and Rachel as it doesnt make sense for Blaine and Kurt to sing a break up song as their first duet as a couple
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
