Top 10 Differences Between Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Movie & Book
video description
Date: 2023-11-20
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 14
Carlos
I remember how the Devils Snare, being a plant, was exterminated when they used Incendio in the book and games. Obviously, they couldnt have a real kid playing with fire. Within the trials, there was also a troll they had to deal with, much like the one that destroyed the bathroom, but that sequence was also cut.
Speaking on Peeves, his exclusion also tied to some other moments left out. From playing the GBC game, I remember how there was the History of Magic course (left out of the films altogether, and Harry got hit by some prank courtesy of Peeves, leaving him with a strange illness. He searched for a book with the cure when it was not in the library, and Peeves gave Harry a riddle to find it. And during Christmas, the very gift of the Invisibility Cloak was stolen by Peeves, leading to Harry scurrying to get it back.
I hate to admit that I havent read the books, but thanks to the games among various other sources, Im picking up various plot threads and details and am surprised by their exclusion in the films. I suppose Hollywood would tell us to adapt every single detail would stretch the run times close to 5 hours minimum, making for a commitment of a viewing experience, and extremely high production costs.
reply
I remember how the Devils Snare, being a plant, was exterminated when they used Incendio in the book and games. Obviously, they couldnt have a real kid playing with fire. Within the trials, there was also a troll they had to deal with, much like the one that destroyed the bathroom, but that sequence was also cut.
Speaking on Peeves, his exclusion also tied to some other moments left out. From playing the GBC game, I remember how there was the History of Magic course (left out of the films altogether, and Harry got hit by some prank courtesy of Peeves, leaving him with a strange illness. He searched for a book with the cure when it was not in the library, and Peeves gave Harry a riddle to find it. And during Christmas, the very gift of the Invisibility Cloak was stolen by Peeves, leading to Harry scurrying to get it back.
I hate to admit that I havent read the books, but thanks to the games among various other sources, Im picking up various plot threads and details and am surprised by their exclusion in the films. I suppose Hollywood would tell us to adapt every single detail would stretch the run times close to 5 hours minimum, making for a commitment of a viewing experience, and extremely high production costs.
reply
CosplayCore
I just realized, I'd probably want to wreck the Mirror of Erised if I ever found it. It'd probably show me as if I was getting to study a living herd of Triceratops and I'd be so distressed at how futile it would be for that to happen that I'd try to throw the mirror somehow. Or at least punch it. Because if I didn't do any of that, I'd be very susceptible to sitting in front of it just for Triceratops. and I would have tears in my eyes.
reply
I just realized, I'd probably want to wreck the Mirror of Erised if I ever found it. It'd probably show me as if I was getting to study a living herd of Triceratops and I'd be so distressed at how futile it would be for that to happen that I'd try to throw the mirror somehow. Or at least punch it. Because if I didn't do any of that, I'd be very susceptible to sitting in front of it just for Triceratops. and I would have tears in my eyes.
reply
Jon
You all should make this a series XD. Top 10 Differences between the Harry Potter Movies and Harry Potter books. I would watch it XD. There are tons of forgotten good stuff that were in the books that were not in the movies. Best example aside from Peeves? Winky in Goblet of Fire. Or Harry and Hermione's fight in Prisoner of Askaban. Loads of stuff that could make this a series XD. Either way greater video
reply
You all should make this a series XD. Top 10 Differences between the Harry Potter Movies and Harry Potter books. I would watch it XD. There are tons of forgotten good stuff that were in the books that were not in the movies. Best example aside from Peeves? Winky in Goblet of Fire. Or Harry and Hermione's fight in Prisoner of Askaban. Loads of stuff that could make this a series XD. Either way greater video
reply
Sifilore
I can agree with the movie in Kings Cross cause the Dursleys wouldn't allow Harry to go. They would've done all they can to stop him. So only just imagining, maybe Harry and Hagrid spent the month of August together at the Leakey Cauldron's inn.
reply
I can agree with the movie in Kings Cross cause the Dursleys wouldn't allow Harry to go. They would've done all they can to stop him. So only just imagining, maybe Harry and Hagrid spent the month of August together at the Leakey Cauldron's inn.
reply
Trina
I wish that they'd included Peeves the Poltergeist in the movies. He'd have been a fun addition, and would have been apparently played by Rik Mayall. But I suppose that they could only include so many elements.
reply
I wish that they'd included Peeves the Poltergeist in the movies. He'd have been a fun addition, and would have been apparently played by Rik Mayall. But I suppose that they could only include so many elements.
reply
ZachMaster97
In the extended edition, Harry mentioned first hearing Nicholas Flammel's name on the back of the Dumbledore collector's card from the chocolate frog while on the Hogwarts Express.
reply
In the extended edition, Harry mentioned first hearing Nicholas Flammel's name on the back of the Dumbledore collector's card from the chocolate frog while on the Hogwarts Express.
reply
CosplayCore
Ya'll think Harry has had to deal with death and loss at a far younger age than most.
Me, someone who started losing pets and relatives by the time I could walk: wuuuuuuuuuut
reply
Ya'll think Harry has had to deal with death and loss at a far younger age than most.
Me, someone who started losing pets and relatives by the time I could walk: wuuuuuuuuuut
reply
Rainbow
I hope you can do the rest of the series as well! I loved watching MovieFlame's series of comparing every difference between the Harry Potter books and movies.
reply
I hope you can do the rest of the series as well! I loved watching MovieFlame's series of comparing every difference between the Harry Potter books and movies.
reply
CJ
Peeves so deserved to be in the movies. Your honorable mention of Tom Riddle was from Chamber of Secrets not Philosopher's Stone/Sorcerer's Stone.
reply
Peeves so deserved to be in the movies. Your honorable mention of Tom Riddle was from Chamber of Secrets not Philosopher's Stone/Sorcerer's Stone.
reply
Acidrain82
the Dursleys took Dudley to a private hospital in London to have the tail surgically removed before he went to Smeltings.
reply
the Dursleys took Dudley to a private hospital in London to have the tail surgically removed before he went to Smeltings.
reply
Maynard
You forgot the most obvious one: Herminey was homely in the book, not a cute and beautiful child like in the movie.
reply
You forgot the most obvious one: Herminey was homely in the book, not a cute and beautiful child like in the movie.
reply
Lil
I wish we'd seen the potion trial in the first movie. I think it would've been cool to see the multicolored flames.
reply
I wish we'd seen the potion trial in the first movie. I think it would've been cool to see the multicolored flames.
reply
Alfie
I think i like the idea that james was a seeker it shows Harry got his skills as a seeker from his father
reply
I think i like the idea that james was a seeker it shows Harry got his skills as a seeker from his father
reply
Evelyn
if your able to find more of these clips/parts, part 2 please and thank you for listening to my request
reply
if your able to find more of these clips/parts, part 2 please and thank you for listening to my request
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
