Top 20 Unanswered How I Met Your Mother Questions
video description
Date: 2023-11-21
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 30
tessincolor
Several of these were answered.
French horn - he probably stole it again from the same restaurant. In one episode he brought pliers to steal it.
Lily's debt - Marshall stayed in high paying corporate lawer job so they can pay the debt.
The Bob Seget one was already explained in other comments.
Robin's friends - I remember that it was mentioned in one episode that those were her coworkers she didn't knew much and that is why the gang was her go to friend group
How did Marshal saved the world? He became a judge and later supreme court judge so he has more power over enforcing enviromental laws.
Pineapple - it was revealed in the last season that the Captain has a pinaple on his porch at his country house and that he also owns a house in the city where he most likely have a pineapple as well. So Ted stumbled on Captain house in the city that night
reply
Several of these were answered.
French horn - he probably stole it again from the same restaurant. In one episode he brought pliers to steal it.
Lily's debt - Marshall stayed in high paying corporate lawer job so they can pay the debt.
The Bob Seget one was already explained in other comments.
Robin's friends - I remember that it was mentioned in one episode that those were her coworkers she didn't knew much and that is why the gang was her go to friend group
How did Marshal saved the world? He became a judge and later supreme court judge so he has more power over enforcing enviromental laws.
Pineapple - it was revealed in the last season that the Captain has a pinaple on his porch at his country house and that he also owns a house in the city where he most likely have a pineapple as well. So Ted stumbled on Captain house in the city that night
reply
Rachel
Questions I still have:
1. Where did Ted's sister go?
2. Who did the pineapple belong to?
3. Why did we never meet Barney's other brother J. J?
4. What was Tracy's illness?
5. Why weren't the Erikson clan shown at Marshall and Lilly's wedding?
6. Where was Marshall's half of the rent coming from? In the beginning, Ted and Lily seem to be the only ones who have jobs, while Marshall is still in law school. I know he got a job working with Barney later, but were his parents footing the bill for everything else?
7. Why did Barney wait for so long to expose his company?
8. How did the friends not know about Robins court mandated therapy?
9. Why the hell was so Robin so mean to the NICEST person in the world, aka: Patrice?
10. Whatever happened to the letters Ted and Barney wrote after they broke up with Robin?
reply
Questions I still have:
1. Where did Ted's sister go?
2. Who did the pineapple belong to?
3. Why did we never meet Barney's other brother J. J?
4. What was Tracy's illness?
5. Why weren't the Erikson clan shown at Marshall and Lilly's wedding?
6. Where was Marshall's half of the rent coming from? In the beginning, Ted and Lily seem to be the only ones who have jobs, while Marshall is still in law school. I know he got a job working with Barney later, but were his parents footing the bill for everything else?
7. Why did Barney wait for so long to expose his company?
8. How did the friends not know about Robins court mandated therapy?
9. Why the hell was so Robin so mean to the NICEST person in the world, aka: Patrice?
10. Whatever happened to the letters Ted and Barney wrote after they broke up with Robin?
reply
Patryk
Bob Saget is the voice which is heard in Ted's head as his own. Every one of us hear himself/herself different than the others. But he tells the story to his kids and hears himself talking from his head perspective. Retrospections are kids imaginary perspective and they see and hears Ted like in real life. In last two episodes, perspective changes - it is shown from kids/third party perspective so we see Ted in normal voice. And in alternate ending, Bob Saget returns as he once again say things from Ted's head perspective.
reply
Bob Saget is the voice which is heard in Ted's head as his own. Every one of us hear himself/herself different than the others. But he tells the story to his kids and hears himself talking from his head perspective. Retrospections are kids imaginary perspective and they see and hears Ted like in real life. In last two episodes, perspective changes - it is shown from kids/third party perspective so we see Ted in normal voice. And in alternate ending, Bob Saget returns as he once again say things from Ted's head perspective.
reply
Scash
Clearly, Ted rode the bicycle, that's the reaction of someone who got laid.
Future Ted said he never found out about the pineapple, so it's logic that we never have the answer in the show, apart for that deleted scene.
As for the monkey mugger, after a lot of viewings of the episode, it's pretty obvious that Marshall wasn't mugged by a monkey. He changed the story so that Lilly doesn't buy a gun, then tells Barney and Ted he wasn't so they stop making fun of him and then he changes again once Lilly enters the room.
reply
Clearly, Ted rode the bicycle, that's the reaction of someone who got laid.
Future Ted said he never found out about the pineapple, so it's logic that we never have the answer in the show, apart for that deleted scene.
As for the monkey mugger, after a lot of viewings of the episode, it's pretty obvious that Marshall wasn't mugged by a monkey. He changed the story so that Lilly doesn't buy a gun, then tells Barney and Ted he wasn't so they stop making fun of him and then he changes again once Lilly enters the room.
reply
The
I personally think they missed a huge opportunity to do How I met your father from the Mothers perspective. How she knew each of them and how her life came about and then we could maybe get more of what happened to her after marriage. Maybe call it Why I married your father instead.
Your number 1 was answered about a year ago. He got it from a guy on steps in front of someones apartment
reply
I personally think they missed a huge opportunity to do How I met your father from the Mothers perspective. How she knew each of them and how her life came about and then we could maybe get more of what happened to her after marriage. Maybe call it Why I married your father instead.
Your number 1 was answered about a year ago. He got it from a guy on steps in front of someones apartment
reply
Mark
The tricycle did happen. You have to remember two things:
1. It was rated tv-14, meaning they couldnt go into any more detail
2. The entire shows premise was based around future Ted telling his kids the stories of his youth.
How else do you think they got away with telling us what exactly happened? It happened, just not in a lot of words. End of discussion
reply
The tricycle did happen. You have to remember two things:
1. It was rated tv-14, meaning they couldnt go into any more detail
2. The entire shows premise was based around future Ted telling his kids the stories of his youth.
How else do you think they got away with telling us what exactly happened? It happened, just not in a lot of words. End of discussion
reply
Stephen
I love HIMYM. I only got to know it a few months ago when they were showing repeats on TV, so I could only watch parts of series 7 and 8 I think and the whole of series 9. I really got into it and it became one of my favourite shows. Now I really want it from the beginning! It's so funny and always made me laugh. In some ways I wish I was a character in it
reply
I love HIMYM. I only got to know it a few months ago when they were showing repeats on TV, so I could only watch parts of series 7 and 8 I think and the whole of series 9. I really got into it and it became one of my favourite shows. Now I really want it from the beginning! It's so funny and always made me laugh. In some ways I wish I was a character in it
reply
TakatofanAgain
One of my favorite moments of HIMYM is when we see the 3rd Robin Sparkles song, an obvious Alanis Morissette parody, and we see Dave Coulier, saying it wasnt about him (You Outta Know might/might not be about him) and them says Cut it out, and Bob Saget jumps in and says I always liked that joke. - Three amazing references at once!
reply
One of my favorite moments of HIMYM is when we see the 3rd Robin Sparkles song, an obvious Alanis Morissette parody, and we see Dave Coulier, saying it wasnt about him (You Outta Know might/might not be about him) and them says Cut it out, and Bob Saget jumps in and says I always liked that joke. - Three amazing references at once!
reply
Timothy
We know that Ted gets the Pineapple from the Captains house. The better question is do most of you know the meaning for it being there? Lets just say it explains Zoe and the Captains relationship more easily. Well other than someone who married her sugar daddy, but yea its along the same lines. Here is a hint swing swing
reply
We know that Ted gets the Pineapple from the Captains house. The better question is do most of you know the meaning for it being there? Lets just say it explains Zoe and the Captains relationship more easily. Well other than someone who married her sugar daddy, but yea its along the same lines. Here is a hint swing swing
reply
cardsfanbj
Lily sold her paintings to pay off her debt. She was going to sell her stuff until the one painting they sold to the GCWOK was thrown out and picked up by a vet who found out they have a calming effect on dogs (and bums birds out) and he passed the info onto other vets in the city who bought her paintings.
reply
Lily sold her paintings to pay off her debt. She was going to sell her stuff until the one painting they sold to the GCWOK was thrown out and picked up by a vet who found out they have a calming effect on dogs (and bums birds out) and he passed the info onto other vets in the city who bought her paintings.
reply
Ryan
I'm pretty sure the delay on Ted's wedding was to show that he used to be so obsessed with finding the one and getting married, but now that he did find her everything else seemed to not matter as much. He was happy, and things were easy with Tracy, so the prize of marriage no longer held a grip on him.
reply
I'm pretty sure the delay on Ted's wedding was to show that he used to be so obsessed with finding the one and getting married, but now that he did find her everything else seemed to not matter as much. He was happy, and things were easy with Tracy, so the prize of marriage no longer held a grip on him.
reply
Leonardo
1. The bob saget thing isn't really a mystery. When we talk to ourselves or hear ourselves in our own perspective we hear our voices totally different sometimes
2. Robins girlfriends isn't a mystery. Robin was 23 at the pilot so she's still young. As we get older friends drift apart
reply
1. The bob saget thing isn't really a mystery. When we talk to ourselves or hear ourselves in our own perspective we hear our voices totally different sometimes
2. Robins girlfriends isn't a mystery. Robin was 23 at the pilot so she's still young. As we get older friends drift apart
reply
Nmcg
Marshall and Lily sold their apartment and moved into Lilys grandparents house, so we can assume they got a chunk of money then, plus no mortgage while living in the house.
Then they sold the house when they moved back into the apartment.
Thats how they paid down the debt.
reply
Marshall and Lily sold their apartment and moved into Lilys grandparents house, so we can assume they got a chunk of money then, plus no mortgage while living in the house.
Then they sold the house when they moved back into the apartment.
Thats how they paid down the debt.
reply
malina
Marshall save the world by being a judge, in Season 8 episode 8, Twelves Horny Women he said by becoming a judge the one behind that bench making the calls. And that's when he realized, he wanted to be a judge. Because judges are the ones who can effect real change
reply
Marshall save the world by being a judge, in Season 8 episode 8, Twelves Horny Women he said by becoming a judge the one behind that bench making the calls. And that's when he realized, he wanted to be a judge. Because judges are the ones who can effect real change
reply
Hammermantv
what is marshall and lily 3rd kid name
2nd what is the mother of barney
3rd in the episode where marshall created marshgamon they mentioned so many story's Ted cuts it out cause its inappropriate what was those inappropriate storys
reply
what is marshall and lily 3rd kid name
2nd what is the mother of barney
3rd in the episode where marshall created marshgamon they mentioned so many story's Ted cuts it out cause its inappropriate what was those inappropriate storys
reply
Shaun
Lillys dept actually wasn't as much as people think, it w as only around 15k and marshal when he was a corporate layer more than made enough money to sort it out and lily's painting job ( for the captain ) all so would have payed it.
reply
Lillys dept actually wasn't as much as people think, it w as only around 15k and marshal when he was a corporate layer more than made enough money to sort it out and lily's painting job ( for the captain ) all so would have payed it.
reply
Mariana
Sure, these are unanswered questions, but I can't say that I care about the answers.
I think some even are meant not to be answered.
Oh, and leave Bob Saget alone! No one has a problem with him being the narrator!
reply
Sure, these are unanswered questions, but I can't say that I care about the answers.
I think some even are meant not to be answered.
Oh, and leave Bob Saget alone! No one has a problem with him being the narrator!
reply
ori
15 - they wanted to give the feeling that future Ted is in a different place and has it all worked out, that hes complete, in other words- a different person; ) and personally I think it was a good idea and it actually worked
reply
15 - they wanted to give the feeling that future Ted is in a different place and has it all worked out, that hes complete, in other words- a different person; ) and personally I think it was a good idea and it actually worked
reply
tuzamodi
Honestly I dont know why people get so confused about the Bob Saget voice over thing. Im pretty sure they did that so the voices dont get mixed together. People will know for sure which version of Ted is talking
reply
Honestly I dont know why people get so confused about the Bob Saget voice over thing. Im pretty sure they did that so the voices dont get mixed together. People will know for sure which version of Ted is talking
reply
gabi
another question ive is what was the joke that barney told ted and marshall? remember in one episode there was a dirty joke, which lilly absolutely didnt like. after that she wasnt shown in the next episodes.
reply
another question ive is what was the joke that barney told ted and marshall? remember in one episode there was a dirty joke, which lilly absolutely didnt like. after that she wasnt shown in the next episodes.
reply
Christopher
Nope, I accept the deleted scene's explanation of the pineapple, otherwise I'd be up all night for the rest of my life wondering where it came from! I need that scene for my own piece of mind lol
reply
Nope, I accept the deleted scene's explanation of the pineapple, otherwise I'd be up all night for the rest of my life wondering where it came from! I need that scene for my own piece of mind lol
reply
BlackRoseZu
This show is one of my guilty pleasure shows, even have all 9 seasons on DvD. Still want to know the answer to all these questions after all these years. Mainly the infamous pineapple incident
reply
This show is one of my guilty pleasure shows, even have all 9 seasons on DvD. Still want to know the answer to all these questions after all these years. Mainly the infamous pineapple incident
reply
stacee
Love this show so much! It's my number #1 All time favorites. I still watch it constantly, today I wish we knew all the answers to these unanswered questions it would be great if we knew.
reply
Love this show so much! It's my number #1 All time favorites. I still watch it constantly, today I wish we knew all the answers to these unanswered questions it would be great if we knew.
reply
Marty
Think the biggest delay in Ted and Tracy's wedding was that he wanted it to be so perfect, such as he couldn't decide on a location because something better might come along.
reply
Think the biggest delay in Ted and Tracy's wedding was that he wanted it to be so perfect, such as he couldn't decide on a location because something better might come along.
reply
Trina
It's a shame that we never got to meet the mother of Barney's daughter Ellie, though it was sweet that Barney is still a big part of Ellie's life, as shown in the spinoff.
reply
It's a shame that we never got to meet the mother of Barney's daughter Ellie, though it was sweet that Barney is still a big part of Ellie's life, as shown in the spinoff.
reply
justin
Why werent either Marshall or Lillys family at their wedding? Ive always wondered that. We dont see Marshalls brothers at the wedding either. I found it odd.
reply
Why werent either Marshall or Lillys family at their wedding? Ive always wondered that. We dont see Marshalls brothers at the wedding either. I found it odd.
reply
stacee
MsMojo may you please do an unanswered questions about Friends? Like you did with HIMYM please? I would greatly appreciate it so much
Thank you tons
reply
MsMojo may you please do an unanswered questions about Friends? Like you did with HIMYM please? I would greatly appreciate it so much
Thank you tons
reply
Jasper
Marshall spent a big chunk of the show as a corporate lawyer. That is how they pay down the debt. And they sold their place at a good price.
reply
Marshall spent a big chunk of the show as a corporate lawyer. That is how they pay down the debt. And they sold their place at a good price.
reply
JinxySaberK
I believe its heavily heavily implied to the point of confirmation that ted did in fact ride the tricycle, its only verbally unanswered
reply
I believe its heavily heavily implied to the point of confirmation that ted did in fact ride the tricycle, its only verbally unanswered
reply
jessica
Barneys dad said that if he was ever ready, to reach out. I wanted an update on if he ever started repairing his relationship with his dad
reply
Barneys dad said that if he was ever ready, to reach out. I wanted an update on if he ever started repairing his relationship with his dad
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
