VehiclesFashionRecipesBlogsHuntTravelsSportFunHandmadeITEducation
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Blogs and People » Truly
Both Our Kids Knew They Were Trans Age 4 & 7 - MY EXTRAORDINARY FAMILY

Both Our Kids Knew They Were Trans Age 4 & 7 - MY EXTRAORDINARY FAMILY

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 3.5; Vote: 2
PARENTS of two transgender children say they are not pushing an agenda, but instead supporting their kids with acceptance and love. James, 11, and Olivia, 7, live with their parents, Ben and Sara, in Berkeley, California. The family are sharing their story with the hope of normalising the narrative surrounding trans children. Videographer: Elie Khadra Producers: Kim Nguyen, Martha Hewett, James Thorne Editor: Helen McKee If you have an amazing story and want to appear on the show, please email trulycastingfuturenet. com and the team will be in touch! Truly is on TikTok! Click here to
Date: 2024-08-12

Comments and reviews: 20


Whatever happened to tomboys I know so many women who went through that phase who are now mothers. By blocking her puberty they’re are sterilizing her. She’s way too young to make that type of decision. And the older one is clearly influencing the younger one. I got a little defensive because I thought it was my thing. It’s clear the younger is doing it for the attention he saw the older sibling getting from the parents. Loving your child is also about setting healthy boundaries and not allowing your children to make irreversible decisions about their health before they’re even old enough to vote.
reply

So, when some children who transitioned only to find out later, that is not who they were, they were permanently changed, damaged in their eyes and in some cases sterile when they tried to, de-transition. The question is, are you will to risk their repocutive systems, voices and other areas on the word of someone whom isn't old enough to make those decisions. Or is too young to understand the processes and risks involved Base all that risk on the thought processes of childre That is a massive risk. I think some people want their child or caldron to feel so special they go this route.
reply

I think the older one went through a mental breakdown/ trauma due to feelin unwanted so she resorted to dressing like a guy to kinda shield that and the younger one just copied that’s what I think happened, a coworker of mines made a triggering joke saying that my crush could never want me and that no man will ever want me and even tho he was just joking it brought back painful childhood memories to the point I completely felt powerless and had to walk away crying a lot, all I ever wanted in my life was to feel accepted.
reply

Look, I’m all about love but imo they’re still too young for these permanent changes (say if they were to have second thoughts about it later)
I understand parents feel they want to be supportive and show love etc. but, I feel parents can be supportive by allowing changes like their name; or wearing their hair or clothes in certain styles would be alright for starters. But the ultimate decision has to come from them when they’re more mature at 16-18.

reply

I was around 6 years old and I asked my mom shouldn't I have been a boy I feel like I should have been a boy! I like boy stuff. I like boy clothes! My mom said it's perfectly fine to do boyish things while you are a girl. She wasn't a good mother but I'm still thankfull for what she said at that moment. I'm still a woman that enjoys doing boy things and that is fine! Imagine the damage a transition would have done! Children shouldn't go though this at this age.
reply

This is grooming. Gender is very complex and there is no way in hell a 4 and 7 year old would understand. Making a medical decision that will affect the rest of their life is insane. As a preteen I would’ve chosen not to go into puberty too. It sucks! Get that child some therapy. If at 17/18 they feel that way then so be it.
reply

At age 4 and 7 i was making mud pies playing with no shoes on wanted to wear boy clothes and while playing with dolls and hunting with my dad and fighting my brothers and i was a little girl and now i have kids and a husband. Why can't kids be kids. .
reply

What the hell is she doing to her kids with brainwashing them. They didn't even know what the words were until they were introduced somehow to it and thought it was a great idea. child abuse and neglect is what this is and so much more.
reply

As a mother of a child who originally wanted to change from male to female i can't say anything bad but i honestly will say that a child should be a child till they hit a certain age 13 through 18 is a fine age to know for sure
reply

Ok from me let the kids be happy and there isn't anything wrong with the kids being transgender there is so many kids now a days let be who they are meet to be transgender I'm part of LGBTQ community and I also love to watch I am jazz
reply

Yes you may have support now but there could be a time in the near future when the government makes this illegal so don’t get too comfortable. Not everyone agrees but it’s your family so you know what’s best. Vote.
reply

I don’t even remember if I understood gender norms or rolls at 4 years old. And I’m sceptical that these kids do as well. Not saying they are wrong, just saying it’s a bit strange and I feel a concern about this.
reply

4: 40 that is exactly what is happening ma'am. So you have educated yourself and you still decided to ig ore the fact that it may be a copycat situation and do what you felt you wanted to do.
reply

it’s just unfortunate because they genuinely think they’re doing right by their kids. parenting doesn’t come with a handbook and the media and society have clearly effected them heavily
reply

I knew from a young age that I was trans and I did NOT have accepting parents. And that was before trans was a common knowledge thing! Kids know themselves. It’s not brainwashing.
reply

And there are children who are taken away by social services only because their families are poor.
These parents are damaging their children because of their selfishness.

reply

It’s sad parents are the main ones who fail their children! they should be having fun and being kids! not worried about their damn gender at this young age!
reply

What are feelings that are masculine and feelings that are feminine I feel like we put so many weird terms that don't really mean anything I'm so confused
reply

Don't worry kids, when Trump gets back in the office, he will make sure that your parents can't give you puberty blockers.
This is wrong on so many levels

reply

Im all for people doing what they feel. when they're old enough to make tgise decisions. doing this when theyre under the age of 10 is DELUSIONAL
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos