What Life Under China's Social Credit System Could Be Like
video description
Date: 2023-12-14
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 25
-notanhartmann430
As a person lived in China for 23 years I must say this is complete nonsense. In China, you will not obtain any punishment if you say something disagree with government unless you are stay in large scale public place. The only crime that might be relevant to your theory is -Disturb social order-, this act basically played same rule with Smith Act of 1940. The punishment is much milder, most people are only fined short term detention since you actually caused clear and present danger to social stability. Social credit system is actually a banking and utilities related policy, you only get penalized if you default on debt for a long time or damage infrastructure. Generally, a person who loses social credit cannot use public transportation or borrow money until he pays off all loans or waits after bankruptcy
reply
As a person lived in China for 23 years I must say this is complete nonsense. In China, you will not obtain any punishment if you say something disagree with government unless you are stay in large scale public place. The only crime that might be relevant to your theory is -Disturb social order-, this act basically played same rule with Smith Act of 1940. The punishment is much milder, most people are only fined short term detention since you actually caused clear and present danger to social stability. Social credit system is actually a banking and utilities related policy, you only get penalized if you default on debt for a long time or damage infrastructure. Generally, a person who loses social credit cannot use public transportation or borrow money until he pays off all loans or waits after bankruptcy
reply
reallifelore
-Could- be like.
Except it never actually happened.
The thing about the China government is that Central will give a vague edict then provincial arms will try out different things.
Things reported are pieced together to form one form one single story.
In reality, nothing happened. There is no national wide roll-out. The only thing that actually happened is a financial credit score that is similar to Credit Ratings in the West.
reply
-Could- be like.
Except it never actually happened.
The thing about the China government is that Central will give a vague edict then provincial arms will try out different things.
Things reported are pieced together to form one form one single story.
In reality, nothing happened. There is no national wide roll-out. The only thing that actually happened is a financial credit score that is similar to Credit Ratings in the West.
reply
-FrecklesAviation
I struggle to understand how anybody can think that this is a remotely good idea! The government should never have that much surveillance on you. In theory, maybe a good idea, but any government will abuse it and turn it into a -if you promote x, your score will decrease. - Western governments are already trying to restrict our privacy and it must be stopped ASAP!
reply
I struggle to understand how anybody can think that this is a remotely good idea! The government should never have that much surveillance on you. In theory, maybe a good idea, but any government will abuse it and turn it into a -if you promote x, your score will decrease. - Western governments are already trying to restrict our privacy and it must be stopped ASAP!
reply
-RaHeemBaines
This reminds me of that crime a coefficient thing from that one anime, were people would get arrested for crimes they may commit based off there crime coefficient; but haven't just yet.
It's crazy cuz it was essentially a computer; integrated with human brains that measured a person's crime coefficient through some kind of sensor you could point at the person.
reply
This reminds me of that crime a coefficient thing from that one anime, were people would get arrested for crimes they may commit based off there crime coefficient; but haven't just yet.
It's crazy cuz it was essentially a computer; integrated with human brains that measured a person's crime coefficient through some kind of sensor you could point at the person.
reply
-junchen9582
As a Chinese, I love how when I want to discuss something with a foreigner, they just play the social credit score meme and act exactly like the ccp-brainwashed Chinese they say they are. (+1000 social credit)
reply
As a Chinese, I love how when I want to discuss something with a foreigner, they just play the social credit score meme and act exactly like the ccp-brainwashed Chinese they say they are. (+1000 social credit)
reply
-vios1682
This system is truly amazing! Imagine how much work was put to implement it for such a big amount of people. Great work, I think this should be adopted worldwide and the world will be a better place!
reply
This system is truly amazing! Imagine how much work was put to implement it for such a big amount of people. Great work, I think this should be adopted worldwide and the world will be a better place!
reply
-ozqdiac9050
-Bro why are you spamming -I love Xi Jinping! - in the chat-
-I-m farming credits bro leave me alone-
Also rip to the sweaty fortnite gamers and hackers in China
reply
-Bro why are you spamming -I love Xi Jinping! - in the chat-
-I-m farming credits bro leave me alone-
Also rip to the sweaty fortnite gamers and hackers in China
reply
-dude8223
It redefines what is moral or immoral. If you commit acts they deem immoral, you get a low score and loose rights. It forces you to violate your conscience, it is evil.
reply
It redefines what is moral or immoral. If you commit acts they deem immoral, you get a low score and loose rights. It forces you to violate your conscience, it is evil.
reply
-jaredhanson1232
A credit score in America is like this except your ranked on how good of a capitalist you are instead of being ranked on how good of a citizen you are.
reply
A credit score in America is like this except your ranked on how good of a capitalist you are instead of being ranked on how good of a citizen you are.
reply
-cdntrooper3078
Honestly the video game cheater one, not visiting your parents and ordering/making an appointment and not showing up are actually great ideas.
reply
Honestly the video game cheater one, not visiting your parents and ordering/making an appointment and not showing up are actually great ideas.
reply
-LittleDuck426
This sounds incredibly inhumane; prioritizing people with higher scores in terms of medical care is not only inhumane, it's unacceptable.
reply
This sounds incredibly inhumane; prioritizing people with higher scores in terms of medical care is not only inhumane, it's unacceptable.
reply
-orbitalpotato9940
Cool video on what life COULD be like if such a system even existed lol. As of 2023, no nationwide social credit system exists
reply
Cool video on what life COULD be like if such a system even existed lol. As of 2023, no nationwide social credit system exists
reply
-ggang191
there is no such thing in china. western media constantly proves to me that free media=chaotic fake media. just go to china yourself
reply
there is no such thing in china. western media constantly proves to me that free media=chaotic fake media. just go to china yourself
reply
-user-yu9ih6bq5m
They should add the social credit to fast food and other businesses like they are planning but not to anything/anyone else
reply
They should add the social credit to fast food and other businesses like they are planning but not to anything/anyone else
reply
-bilelsendi9402
The fact that you can get less waiting time in a hospital is absurd i thought all hospitals treat stuff based on severity
reply
The fact that you can get less waiting time in a hospital is absurd i thought all hospitals treat stuff based on severity
reply
-ddable.
There's Bound to be some ppl who got their credit score lowered by annoyed rich ppl that doesnt like then or want competition.
reply
There's Bound to be some ppl who got their credit score lowered by annoyed rich ppl that doesnt like then or want competition.
reply
-toxic_gamer1
Man people who live in china need help. They can-t even say their own opinion about the country without being punished.
reply
Man people who live in china need help. They can-t even say their own opinion about the country without being punished.
reply
-jessicapatton2688
This would be my personal hell. A social credit score.
They have no real freedom and are reduced to a number
reply
This would be my personal hell. A social credit score.
They have no real freedom and are reduced to a number
reply
-zastronomer7592
-Usa is better than China-
-999, 999, 999, 999, 999 social credit
your execution date is today see you soon
reply
-Usa is better than China-
-999, 999, 999, 999, 999 social credit
your execution date is today see you soon
reply
-ozqdiac9050
At least it takes all the sweaty Chinese kids out of games by reducing their points and giving them a slow internet
reply
At least it takes all the sweaty Chinese kids out of games by reducing their points and giving them a slow internet
reply
-timothy1949
would chinese kids be randomly shot to pieces at schools? if not then at least they still have some human rights.
reply
would chinese kids be randomly shot to pieces at schools? if not then at least they still have some human rights.
reply
-TheHypnoticShot
Stop that BS. Social credit is only on the financial side. Western media really like to demonize everything-
reply
Stop that BS. Social credit is only on the financial side. Western media really like to demonize everything-
reply
-acayette
In simple words:
If you're a puppet they control = good citizen
If you have mind of your own = bad citizen
reply
In simple words:
If you're a puppet they control = good citizen
If you have mind of your own = bad citizen
reply
-hoffinger636
As a Chinese, i-ve never heard of so-called social credit score system- don-t take the memes seriously
reply
As a Chinese, i-ve never heard of so-called social credit score system- don-t take the memes seriously
reply
-Birch37
The higher the score = more corrupt you are. How does that calculate your integrity and honestly? ---
reply
The higher the score = more corrupt you are. How does that calculate your integrity and honestly? ---
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
