Vimy Ridge: Canada's Unsung Victory Over The Kaiser Battle Of Vimy Ridge Timeline
video description
Date: 2022-07-19
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 20
LittleFluffy
When I was at Vimy Ridge I was walking along the trenches and noticed a white pebble. I picked it up and realized it wasn't stone, but bone. The ball of a human humerus (upper arm) bone. I put it back as I found it. Many bodies are still in the Belgian and French soil. I drove around the other side of Vimy, away from the preserved trenches and the monument, and needed to take a pee. Parking up I walked into some trees. As I walked I noticed the ground was very uneven, and there were indentations everywhere, inches apart. It took a minute for the penny to drop. They were shell holes. So many of them that there were no gaps. With the darkness of the tree canopy it was quite spooky when I realized this was where many had lost their lives.
reply
When I was at Vimy Ridge I was walking along the trenches and noticed a white pebble. I picked it up and realized it wasn't stone, but bone. The ball of a human humerus (upper arm) bone. I put it back as I found it. Many bodies are still in the Belgian and French soil. I drove around the other side of Vimy, away from the preserved trenches and the monument, and needed to take a pee. Parking up I walked into some trees. As I walked I noticed the ground was very uneven, and there were indentations everywhere, inches apart. It took a minute for the penny to drop. They were shell holes. So many of them that there were no gaps. With the darkness of the tree canopy it was quite spooky when I realized this was where many had lost their lives.
reply
Olz
I have watched a lot of WW1 documentaries and they are usually very good but this one is outstanding. The attention to detail and the realism stand out amongst other things. This is not merely a celebration of the Canadian soldier but an in depth analysis of why the Vimy ridge offensive was a success. WW1 was a chaotic war and this is the first Documentary that has helped me to understand the mechanics of the command whilst also bringing home sharply the terrible experiences of the troops who fought there. Brilliant and highly recommended to the serious Military History student.
reply
I have watched a lot of WW1 documentaries and they are usually very good but this one is outstanding. The attention to detail and the realism stand out amongst other things. This is not merely a celebration of the Canadian soldier but an in depth analysis of why the Vimy ridge offensive was a success. WW1 was a chaotic war and this is the first Documentary that has helped me to understand the mechanics of the command whilst also bringing home sharply the terrible experiences of the troops who fought there. Brilliant and highly recommended to the serious Military History student.
reply
castlerock58
It's not unsung. It's sung out of proportion to it's effect on the outcome of the war. It is treated as one of the most important events in Canadian history and it is an important victory in WW I because of the application of new artillery and infantry tactics. Any serious student of military history knows of this battle and any Canadian knows about it from school. It was seen as a major victory at the time so it was not unsung then. If anything it is more famous than more important battles in the allied counterattack in 1918. Those are unsung battles.
reply
It's not unsung. It's sung out of proportion to it's effect on the outcome of the war. It is treated as one of the most important events in Canadian history and it is an important victory in WW I because of the application of new artillery and infantry tactics. Any serious student of military history knows of this battle and any Canadian knows about it from school. It was seen as a major victory at the time so it was not unsung then. If anything it is more famous than more important battles in the allied counterattack in 1918. Those are unsung battles.
reply
John
In my collection I have an original WW1 German trench map from Vimy Ridge in 1917, marked Geheim (Secret) and showing the disposition of Allied and German troops and artillery just before the final attack which kicked the Germans off the ridge. Its really very cool. Back in 2017 I approached the Canadian embassy and asked them off they would be interested in buying it, but they said they had a few similar ones, so no thank you! I was quite surprised! If youre a Canadian WW1 enthusiast and youre interested, hit me up.
reply
In my collection I have an original WW1 German trench map from Vimy Ridge in 1917, marked Geheim (Secret) and showing the disposition of Allied and German troops and artillery just before the final attack which kicked the Germans off the ridge. Its really very cool. Back in 2017 I approached the Canadian embassy and asked them off they would be interested in buying it, but they said they had a few similar ones, so no thank you! I was quite surprised! If youre a Canadian WW1 enthusiast and youre interested, hit me up.
reply
Douglas
While the British and French (and Germans) were still struggling out of Napoleonic Era tactics (despite being innovators in war technology) it was people like the Canadians, insisting on meritocracy and thinking about what was possible, who showed the way. I am thankful to all my forefathers for fighting for freedom (WW1 gained the vote for all men in Britain) and democracy. That we are gradually surrendering both freedom and democracy nowadays does not diminish their sacrifice.
reply
While the British and French (and Germans) were still struggling out of Napoleonic Era tactics (despite being innovators in war technology) it was people like the Canadians, insisting on meritocracy and thinking about what was possible, who showed the way. I am thankful to all my forefathers for fighting for freedom (WW1 gained the vote for all men in Britain) and democracy. That we are gradually surrendering both freedom and democracy nowadays does not diminish their sacrifice.
reply
Henry
Although a relatively minor engagement in the scheme of things, the capture of Vimy Ridge was notable for some inspired staff work by a series of highly competent British regulars, and a brilliant artillery plan devised by the future CIGS, Lord Alanbrooke.
Of course, the battle was won by the overwhelming superiority of the British and Canadian artillery, and the use of the newly developed 106 fuse.
reply
Although a relatively minor engagement in the scheme of things, the capture of Vimy Ridge was notable for some inspired staff work by a series of highly competent British regulars, and a brilliant artillery plan devised by the future CIGS, Lord Alanbrooke.
Of course, the battle was won by the overwhelming superiority of the British and Canadian artillery, and the use of the newly developed 106 fuse.
reply
RayRobinson0311
Well. I'll never view Canada/Canadians again. Big respect.
It makes me wonder why if we're not all suppose to get along and be 'one big global village' we don't learn about stuff like this in US schools?
Just imagine how different Americans would view Canada if these were the stories they were introduced to in school instead of banalities about maple syrup, moose and fur trading.
reply
Well. I'll never view Canada/Canadians again. Big respect.
It makes me wonder why if we're not all suppose to get along and be 'one big global village' we don't learn about stuff like this in US schools?
Just imagine how different Americans would view Canada if these were the stories they were introduced to in school instead of banalities about maple syrup, moose and fur trading.
reply
Doree
As a woman, perhaps not like men in the regard of killing, I don't get how millions could become murderers from one day to the next. No matter the justification why didn't more choose to serve in other capacities like conscientious objectors did? This video says there were work groups that did that alone. according to videos blacks were not allowed rifles in the Civil War
reply
As a woman, perhaps not like men in the regard of killing, I don't get how millions could become murderers from one day to the next. No matter the justification why didn't more choose to serve in other capacities like conscientious objectors did? This video says there were work groups that did that alone. according to videos blacks were not allowed rifles in the Civil War
reply
Prairie
Both of my parents immigrated to Canada in the 1950's. I am a first generation Canadian. I don't know if I have the right to, but this is part of my identity as a proud Canadian. What these men did for us cannot be overstated, and I intend to honour every one of them for the rest of my life.
To the soldiers of the CEF and Allied Forces in The Great War - thank you.
reply
Both of my parents immigrated to Canada in the 1950's. I am a first generation Canadian. I don't know if I have the right to, but this is part of my identity as a proud Canadian. What these men did for us cannot be overstated, and I intend to honour every one of them for the rest of my life.
To the soldiers of the CEF and Allied Forces in The Great War - thank you.
reply
tom
Along with the Aussies the best soldiers the brits had in ww1. Unfortunately the were murdered by haig and the most incompetent commanders of the war( plumer excepted. Currie was quite possibly the best allied officer of the war, but because he was considered an amateur colonial, the brits never listened to him. Monash for the aussies was pretty competent also
reply
Along with the Aussies the best soldiers the brits had in ww1. Unfortunately the were murdered by haig and the most incompetent commanders of the war( plumer excepted. Currie was quite possibly the best allied officer of the war, but because he was considered an amateur colonial, the brits never listened to him. Monash for the aussies was pretty competent also
reply
Stergios
Failure of strategy and a death wish from mediocre generals resulted in a catastrophe for the Allies. As Paton remarked for wrong strategy, You dont go in a wasr to die, but to kill the enemy, otherwise you have wrong strategy. I recomend the film of Stanley Kubrik THE PATH OF GLORY to understand what aristocracy did against its own peoples.
reply
Failure of strategy and a death wish from mediocre generals resulted in a catastrophe for the Allies. As Paton remarked for wrong strategy, You dont go in a wasr to die, but to kill the enemy, otherwise you have wrong strategy. I recomend the film of Stanley Kubrik THE PATH OF GLORY to understand what aristocracy did against its own peoples.
reply
Fran
My grandfather James Sullivan was a Sgt Major and a part of the 4th division in taking Vimy Ridge and had previously fought in the Boar War. I was told later he was never the same after that final siege for Hill 145. He passed very early in my life. I so wish I had gotten to know him. #LestWeForget #VimyRidge
reply
My grandfather James Sullivan was a Sgt Major and a part of the 4th division in taking Vimy Ridge and had previously fought in the Boar War. I was told later he was never the same after that final siege for Hill 145. He passed very early in my life. I so wish I had gotten to know him. #LestWeForget #VimyRidge
reply
Jah
Looking at Canada today? I would tell my forebearers that its a waste of time. I'd give them the nanes of the ones in charge now, my story. They would'nt have wasted their lives for the 5 or si decades of 'Canada' we got for their sacrifice.
Most of you should be ashamed of yourselves.
reply
Looking at Canada today? I would tell my forebearers that its a waste of time. I'd give them the nanes of the ones in charge now, my story. They would'nt have wasted their lives for the 5 or si decades of 'Canada' we got for their sacrifice.
Most of you should be ashamed of yourselves.
reply
Benjamin
My wifes great-great grandfather was a Canadian soldier of Mohawk descent who was wounded charging a machine gun nest at Vimy Ridge. He had lied about his age on his enlistment papers, and it turned out he was only 15 years old when he was injured. Mohawk warriors, am I right?
reply
My wifes great-great grandfather was a Canadian soldier of Mohawk descent who was wounded charging a machine gun nest at Vimy Ridge. He had lied about his age on his enlistment papers, and it turned out he was only 15 years old when he was injured. Mohawk warriors, am I right?
reply
scott
God what a terrible war. I feel people overlook how terrible the first war was. Maybe because alot of people new grandparents that were in ww2 idk but the more I'm learning I'm starting to think ww1 was worse because of trenches. I. Can't that horror
reply
God what a terrible war. I feel people overlook how terrible the first war was. Maybe because alot of people new grandparents that were in ww2 idk but the more I'm learning I'm starting to think ww1 was worse because of trenches. I. Can't that horror
reply
Chadrach
Great video. At 30 minutes though they talking about using a machine gun as indirect fire, really? Mortar and artillery yes, but a machine gun is used for whats called suppressing fire. Am I missing something from my infantry training or what?
reply
Great video. At 30 minutes though they talking about using a machine gun as indirect fire, really? Mortar and artillery yes, but a machine gun is used for whats called suppressing fire. Am I missing something from my infantry training or what?
reply
StarletShadow
DAMM! The fallen soldier giving his all to his fellow soldiers to pass the torch on knowing he can rest in peace knowing he's already won / because his brother's in army's will carry his spirit and will never stop until victory is theirs.
reply
DAMM! The fallen soldier giving his all to his fellow soldiers to pass the torch on knowing he can rest in peace knowing he's already won / because his brother's in army's will carry his spirit and will never stop until victory is theirs.
reply
Scott
Good men always get wasted by the vile scum that rule us and play at war. May the gullible but noble volunteer and conscripted soldiers live forever and the bankers, politicians and professional war pigs and generals rot below where they belong.
reply
Good men always get wasted by the vile scum that rule us and play at war. May the gullible but noble volunteer and conscripted soldiers live forever and the bankers, politicians and professional war pigs and generals rot below where they belong.
reply
Pjing
As a russo-Canadian, I am proud of my homeland, we fought for the Freedoms and what we thought in, sure, they could of mass conscripted us, but an army of morale is better than no morale, we chose to fight, and that is what matters.
reply
As a russo-Canadian, I am proud of my homeland, we fought for the Freedoms and what we thought in, sure, they could of mass conscripted us, but an army of morale is better than no morale, we chose to fight, and that is what matters.
reply
David
I wouldn't say say unsung, it's a quite a famous epic from the Great War, certainly in recent decades.
Though it is fair to say, other battles have been overshadowed by the Somme, Verdun, Passchendaele
and Gallipoli
reply
I wouldn't say say unsung, it's a quite a famous epic from the Great War, certainly in recent decades.
Though it is fair to say, other battles have been overshadowed by the Somme, Verdun, Passchendaele
and Gallipoli
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
