
What if the Cotton Gin Was Never Invented?
video description
The Southern planters, including especially Jefferson, never had the slightest intention to do away with slavery, though some pretended the contrary so as to reassure Europe. Some had the intention to do away with chattel slavery as it was found that identured labour (which is also forced labour) enabled the planter to extract more plus-value, but that was all. On the very contrary, the American revolution could happen so easily because the financial oligarchy had the intention to extend the plantation system onto more territory (they even tried to apply serfdom to Whites in the Hudson valley) while slavery which was in the process of being forbidden by all codes of european law. Please don't repeat like a parrot your lessons of capitalism. Circa 1790 there was absolutely no sign that savery or some equivalent forced labour was to be phased out. Washington DC was planned as a city to be operated by abundant slave power from nearby Virginia, that was one major reason for its foundation rather than keeping Philadelphia.
Please stop parrotting self-evident falsehoods: the drying of the sea of Aral didn't happen because of communism. Quite the contrary the Soviets feared for such a danger and brought water from more northern latitudes to try to prevent it. The drying up of that sea started seriously in the 1990's when gangster capitalists took over the region as your own maps show quite well, though the main reason why it occurred is global warming which in that region has resulted in temperatures climbing by 5C and precipitations cut by half.
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
Tomas
(Commment is not directly aimed at yhe content of the video)
I always question the premises of Black History Month for two reasons.
The more common one and bot as relevant. Why is this not covered as part of world history in most places.
And secondly. Why is Black Slavery in the Americas the only topic that isbever mentioned.
What about Ancient Egypt? What about old Namibians? The atrocities that went on is South Africa? The architecture of Africa?
There is really a lot more to cover when looking specifically into history surrounding black people groups and hearing just about the slavery makes it seem like there is nothing more than slavery to black History.
reply
(Commment is not directly aimed at yhe content of the video)
I always question the premises of Black History Month for two reasons.
The more common one and bot as relevant. Why is this not covered as part of world history in most places.
And secondly. Why is Black Slavery in the Americas the only topic that isbever mentioned.
What about Ancient Egypt? What about old Namibians? The atrocities that went on is South Africa? The architecture of Africa?
There is really a lot more to cover when looking specifically into history surrounding black people groups and hearing just about the slavery makes it seem like there is nothing more than slavery to black History.
reply
Caleb
1. Read the entirety of the cornerstone speech. It list half a dozen reasons for the secession of the confederacy. When it comes to confederate documents people hit cntrl f and type in slavery and ignore everything else.
2. If it wasnt for Nat Turners rebellion, in 1831 a lot more slave states would have just freed their slaves. It didnt help that puritians to the north were constantly trying to cause slave revolts. You see this escalate over the years with bloody kansas, and harpers ferry. Its not hard to find documents showing that until 1831 more and more slaves were getting set free but nat turners rebellion put that to a stop.
reply
1. Read the entirety of the cornerstone speech. It list half a dozen reasons for the secession of the confederacy. When it comes to confederate documents people hit cntrl f and type in slavery and ignore everything else.
2. If it wasnt for Nat Turners rebellion, in 1831 a lot more slave states would have just freed their slaves. It didnt help that puritians to the north were constantly trying to cause slave revolts. You see this escalate over the years with bloody kansas, and harpers ferry. Its not hard to find documents showing that until 1831 more and more slaves were getting set free but nat turners rebellion put that to a stop.
reply
Eric
I very much enjoy watching all of these videos, so thank you for making them, however.
12: 14 So the loss of the Aral sea was a result of Communism rather than a result of 20th century ignorance and over usage of scarce water resources?
The eventual disappearance of the Dead Sea in Israel also the work of Communism?
Is the fact that the American Great Plains, has lost over 50 miles of farmlands, to the Central Desert, a result of Communist conspiracies, as well?
I like your videos but your knee jerk reaction to blame everything on Communism tends to feel a bit like a crutch.
reply
I very much enjoy watching all of these videos, so thank you for making them, however.
12: 14 So the loss of the Aral sea was a result of Communism rather than a result of 20th century ignorance and over usage of scarce water resources?
The eventual disappearance of the Dead Sea in Israel also the work of Communism?
Is the fact that the American Great Plains, has lost over 50 miles of farmlands, to the Central Desert, a result of Communist conspiracies, as well?
I like your videos but your knee jerk reaction to blame everything on Communism tends to feel a bit like a crutch.
reply
Caleb
dude, just read the entire cornerstone speech sometime. Theres like three paragraphs about how the south was paying for industrial equipment from europe, but they paid a tarriff on it, that went to help the north buy their industrial equipment. So basiclly for every factory they built in the south they paid for a factory inthe north to be built. Its frustrating when you point out a phrase in a document when you clearly havent read it. You have just read about it.
reply
dude, just read the entire cornerstone speech sometime. Theres like three paragraphs about how the south was paying for industrial equipment from europe, but they paid a tarriff on it, that went to help the north buy their industrial equipment. So basiclly for every factory they built in the south they paid for a factory inthe north to be built. Its frustrating when you point out a phrase in a document when you clearly havent read it. You have just read about it.
reply
Bigbo
The Americans annexed the Southwest because it was the only way to build a railroad to the pacific without going straight through the Rockies, so I dont really see them not annexing it in this timeline, not to mention that america just wanted a shit ton of land to the west, despite whether it was useful or not, manifest destiny and all, I mean look at Alaska, which looked like nothing but a useless ice patch at the time, but the Americans bought it anyways.
reply
The Americans annexed the Southwest because it was the only way to build a railroad to the pacific without going straight through the Rockies, so I dont really see them not annexing it in this timeline, not to mention that america just wanted a shit ton of land to the west, despite whether it was useful or not, manifest destiny and all, I mean look at Alaska, which looked like nothing but a useless ice patch at the time, but the Americans bought it anyways.
reply
Paul
The notion that Communism destroyed the Aral Sea is laughable. 1) Nothing about Communism makes it inherently more anti-environmental than other economic systems. 2) To the extent it was government action that destroyed the Aral Sea, it was totalitarianism, not the economic system of Communism. 3) Look at the world around us, can you say with a straight face that Capitalism would not destroy the environment in the pursuit of its short term economic goals?
reply
The notion that Communism destroyed the Aral Sea is laughable. 1) Nothing about Communism makes it inherently more anti-environmental than other economic systems. 2) To the extent it was government action that destroyed the Aral Sea, it was totalitarianism, not the economic system of Communism. 3) Look at the world around us, can you say with a straight face that Capitalism would not destroy the environment in the pursuit of its short term economic goals?
reply
Iain
Sorry man, the idea that the majority of the founders were against slavery in any serious sense just doesn't hold water. I love your stuff, but unfortunately for the first time, going to have to give you a thumbs down for this one. Were some uneasy about it? Maybe. Conflicted? Sure. But willing to do what any sane person would do these days - ban it immediately - how many of those?
Love your stuff though! It's great. Just had to make this point.
reply
Sorry man, the idea that the majority of the founders were against slavery in any serious sense just doesn't hold water. I love your stuff, but unfortunately for the first time, going to have to give you a thumbs down for this one. Were some uneasy about it? Maybe. Conflicted? Sure. But willing to do what any sane person would do these days - ban it immediately - how many of those?
Love your stuff though! It's great. Just had to make this point.
reply
Jade
Blacklisted by The Left as horrifying monsters seems like a pretty drastic statement. Its not a big thing to say that they werent good people because they owned slaves, and its not like they just didnt realize that it was bad, especially since had been arguments against slavery made by numerous people before they were even alive, and the abolitionist movement as a whole really started around the time many of them were young or middle aged.
reply
Blacklisted by The Left as horrifying monsters seems like a pretty drastic statement. Its not a big thing to say that they werent good people because they owned slaves, and its not like they just didnt realize that it was bad, especially since had been arguments against slavery made by numerous people before they were even alive, and the abolitionist movement as a whole really started around the time many of them were young or middle aged.
reply
Burgermeister1836
It's possible that the blacks would have been sent to Liberia in this timeline rather than be kept in America, pretty much solving the entire race issue. Additionally, I don't think the 5 Civilized Tribes would have survived forever if the Union's behavior towards tribes in the later 19th century holds true, and a Trail of Tears type situation would probably still happen, just later on or more gradually.
reply
It's possible that the blacks would have been sent to Liberia in this timeline rather than be kept in America, pretty much solving the entire race issue. Additionally, I don't think the 5 Civilized Tribes would have survived forever if the Union's behavior towards tribes in the later 19th century holds true, and a Trail of Tears type situation would probably still happen, just later on or more gradually.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















