• Vehicles • Fashion • Recipes • Blogs • Hunt • Travels • Sport • Fun • Handmade • IT • Education
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Whatifalthist
What if Tamerlane Never Existed(ft. Al Muqahddimah?

What if Tamerlane Never Existed(ft. Al Muqahddimah?

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
What if Tamerlane Never Existed(ft. Al Muqahddimah? Philip: I frankly do not understand your fascination with the turks/ottomans. They can not be a stabilizing factor in the middle east as their current ideology is going towards a caliphate and their stance towards their closest western allies - the EU is all but openly hostile. As for their role in the middle ages. try to assess the role of the fall of the ERE for the western world and what sort of current problems are rooted in the 15th century. I know you have a special point of view from across the pond but for the peoples under ottoman rule it was worse than the slavery in the US. If you support modern or recent slavers, militaristic dictators and genocidal religious fundamentalists, just state it openly. I am sure you will find your supporters there too: )
Date: 2022-07-15

Comments and reviews: 9


he literally killed more than 95% of the Persia's whole population and turned the green and food rich Iranian plateau into a giant barren desert which made farming impossible for decades despite the fact that there was no one to farm. Just trying to imagine an empire that fed almost half the entire planet's population (Achaemenid Empire) turned into an arid rocky mountainous region as it is right now. Iran still haven't recovered from his conquest and won't for a long time as the impact was so devastating that it changed the people forever.
It makes me furious to see the west always trynna show that Iran was always a desert while they ignore so many facts here. If it was a desert why did the Aryans migrate to Iran from eastern europe anyway?

reply

Honestly it's not the number of people that are killed that makes the person the worst, it's the method. Tamerlane was operating on the mediums of his time. Hitler and Stalin at the go-to monsters not because of their results but because of their methods. The installation and maintenance of publically-run systems of slavery and genocide on an industrial scale, in an age where the technological advances hypothetically should have been accompanied by an equal advances in social consciousness, but clearly were not sufficiently so.
reply

What killed most people was not Amir Timur Kurgan but black death which swept through from China to central Asia and Europe from 1350 to 1400 and those you mention had killed are saints comparison to British, Franceh, Dutch, Portuguese, Spanish, Timur invaded Georgia Armenia these nations are small still continue to be this proves my point he was not what you describe him to be and yet the nation's the Europeans invaded have perished from north America to South America Australia and many more
reply

The Polish invasion was not really an invasion since we kinda ask them to come. The plan was after the end of the First False Dmitri to recreate Rurik in way of inviting another foreign noble to rule. Choice fell on prince Vladislav of Poland, but then he arrive we find out that he don't want to reject catholicism and accept a true faith and things went downhill from there since prince arrive with a host and has no intention of just living.
reply

hmm, tamerlane was the worst that has happened to us indeed, we do look at our history as before and after him, that's how devastating he was. always wondered how we would develop if he never invaded and perhaps you're right about us uniting with armenians. our skill in agriculture and warfare, plus their skill for trade and international connections would be hard to beat for anyone in the region.
reply

I have honestly never heard of this guy. And when i heard this name in a different video I thought it was joke based on the alt history conspiracy theory of the mud flood and the worldwide empire that supposedly existed before it was swallowed by the mud. Glad to learn something so important. Thats Tartaria not Tamerlane only heard the story a few times misremembered the name i guess.
reply

i think georgia would still be split between ottomans and sunni persians in this timeline, it just seems unlikely that they could survive as a christian nation between two major sunni powers. also if persians were sunni, ottoman-persian relations could be friendly. if the ottomans didn't need to fight persians they could be much more successful against europeans in 1600s.
reply

Other 6 of the 7 Dutch provinces: Am I a joke to you.
I feel hurt he refers to the dutch nation/empire as Holland (which was one of the seven dutch united provinces) instead of the Netherlands or Dutch republic. Partially napoleon is to blame due to instating replacing the batavian republic(successor of dutch republic) with a puppet Kingdom Holland

reply

9 out of 10 videos you mention the ''armenian genocide'' even tho i m a stounch anti kemalist and anti young turkist it still buggs me how so many people have it so hard to use the Armenian Genocide Resource Center to look for answers people rather regurgitate whatever they heard from their lokal propaganda minister. Its just sad.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos