
Dodge Grand Caravan P2308 - Case Study Part III
video description
Date: 2020-08-05
Comments and reviews: 10
Bryan
The word you are looking for is 'ringing'.
My guess is that the original problem was the spark breaking down the rubber, which caused heat where it didn't belong, which degraded the enamel on the secondary, which then shorted internally. I believe that it was in fact making a spark, it just was occurring entirely inside the coil, which is why you couldn't see excessive ringing on the primary side.
I agree with your assessment that an open in the secondary would result in garbage on the primary side.
I don't know what drivers they selected in the ECM but a lot of them are overload protected, and I suppose it is possible that the collision impact broke a solder joint or cracked a resistor or capacitor or some such thing. It is entirely possible that the last guy damaged it when he forgot to take the probes on his meter out of the current jacks.
I always go with the idea that there is more than one thing wrong with it. It would actually be nice to build a coil and injector tester so you could look at them on the bench.
reply
The word you are looking for is 'ringing'.
My guess is that the original problem was the spark breaking down the rubber, which caused heat where it didn't belong, which degraded the enamel on the secondary, which then shorted internally. I believe that it was in fact making a spark, it just was occurring entirely inside the coil, which is why you couldn't see excessive ringing on the primary side.
I agree with your assessment that an open in the secondary would result in garbage on the primary side.
I don't know what drivers they selected in the ECM but a lot of them are overload protected, and I suppose it is possible that the collision impact broke a solder joint or cracked a resistor or capacitor or some such thing. It is entirely possible that the last guy damaged it when he forgot to take the probes on his meter out of the current jacks.
I always go with the idea that there is more than one thing wrong with it. It would actually be nice to build a coil and injector tester so you could look at them on the bench.
reply
David
I know this is an old video but I have a theory
Maybe theres a coding error in the pcm, maybe the pcm can see misfires and will activly attempt to remedy a worn spark plug misfire buy double firing the coil in order to induce more current to make the spark jump longer gap of the worn spark plug to get a stronger spark(or to double fire the plug. Perhaps when coding the pcm they got the spark order wrong on that program/strategy.
reply
I know this is an old video but I have a theory
Maybe theres a coding error in the pcm, maybe the pcm can see misfires and will activly attempt to remedy a worn spark plug misfire buy double firing the coil in order to induce more current to make the spark jump longer gap of the worn spark plug to get a stronger spark(or to double fire the plug. Perhaps when coding the pcm they got the spark order wrong on that program/strategy.
reply
Lawrence
a spark leak can confuse ecm into that the spark in a cylinder hasn't reach satisfied spark target so the ecm may send a secondary fire to that cylinder to attempt reach spark target. also being that was on cylinder 6 and causing spark leak it could of cause a disruption in the cylinder 4 signal due to energy shorted out to through the metal surrounding it.
reply
a spark leak can confuse ecm into that the spark in a cylinder hasn't reach satisfied spark target so the ecm may send a secondary fire to that cylinder to attempt reach spark target. also being that was on cylinder 6 and causing spark leak it could of cause a disruption in the cylinder 4 signal due to energy shorted out to through the metal surrounding it.
reply
Kent
At 30 minutes, it is no surprise that the no. 6 coil waveform looks ok. The no. 6 coil is doing its job fine. The problem is that the spark is not making it to the plug. And yes, the double pulse looks like a strategy. If the plug doesn't fire, the computer tries to fire it again. If this is a design feature it should be in the manual.
reply
At 30 minutes, it is no surprise that the no. 6 coil waveform looks ok. The no. 6 coil is doing its job fine. The problem is that the spark is not making it to the plug. And yes, the double pulse looks like a strategy. If the plug doesn't fire, the computer tries to fire it again. If this is a design feature it should be in the manual.
reply
Don
I was wondering why you didn't check out the miss on number 6 after you found the bad computer. If it turned out to be an engine problem, it might not have been worth repairing. If you had cured the miss on number 6, the engine would have run smoothly when you changed the computer and you wouldn't have looked at the waveforms.
reply
I was wondering why you didn't check out the miss on number 6 after you found the bad computer. If it turned out to be an engine problem, it might not have been worth repairing. If you had cured the miss on number 6, the engine would have run smoothly when you changed the computer and you wouldn't have looked at the waveforms.
reply
Steve
Just watched the 3 back to back - best whodunnit I have seen in years. Would I be correct in thinking the diagnosis would have been a lot simpler if the coils had not been moved? The bad coil would be on the burnt circuit of the ECM so easy to trace cause and effect? Anyway, inspiring stuff to watch - I am hooked!
reply
Just watched the 3 back to back - best whodunnit I have seen in years. Would I be correct in thinking the diagnosis would have been a lot simpler if the coils had not been moved? The bad coil would be on the burnt circuit of the ECM so easy to trace cause and effect? Anyway, inspiring stuff to watch - I am hooked!
reply
Gerald
My guess is that the ECM double fires the cylinder 2 positions in front of the bad one (not sure how its detecting the misfire) to compensate for it (maybe it increases crank speed just enough to work around the misfire) i don't know, this is all a guess.
reply
My guess is that the ECM double fires the cylinder 2 positions in front of the bad one (not sure how its detecting the misfire) to compensate for it (maybe it increases crank speed just enough to work around the misfire) i don't know, this is all a guess.
reply
Chris
Your Crisis Corporation minivan marathon was very enlightening and just plain down to earth satisfying to watch. Where do all these clusters come from? Rarely do I ever see madness like this at my job. Kudos to all your efforts. Thanx.
reply
Your Crisis Corporation minivan marathon was very enlightening and just plain down to earth satisfying to watch. Where do all these clusters come from? Rarely do I ever see madness like this at my job. Kudos to all your efforts. Thanx.
reply
Jesse
I love watching you troubleshoot problems. I bet the coil was fine. I think the insulated tube between the plug and coil was the problem. You said the boot was torn and you saw a black mark on the tube wall, that's data enough for me.
reply
I love watching you troubleshoot problems. I bet the coil was fine. I think the insulated tube between the plug and coil was the problem. You said the boot was torn and you saw a black mark on the tube wall, that's data enough for me.
reply
Cuba's
Wow! That's a heck of a run! O would've never thought the double fire on the coil to be some sort of strategic ECM process. never on one cylinder. At the end of this case, you certainly opened my eyes to some weird anomalies!
reply
Wow! That's a heck of a run! O would've never thought the double fire on the coil to be some sort of strategic ECM process. never on one cylinder. At the end of this case, you certainly opened my eyes to some weird anomalies!
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















