
How 'Wild' was the Wild West Documentary
video description
Date: 2022-07-19
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 20
Johnathan
This video got several major things wrong. It mentions that the main violence against natives were between the natives and the federal government. This was only true during the plain wars, and when many died when being settled in reservations. . However, in California and other places it was the new American locals who were the biggest threats to natives. If you've traveled up and down California, you would see memorials to different tribes who were murdered by American mobs for minor reasons (the tribes in California were not even that violent. In Humboldt County, there are several monuments to entire tribes who were murdered just because the locals didn't like them. It was so bad that the federal government housed troops specifically to protect the natives in the area. But they were not successful. Local state governments offered bounties for the heads of natives in Northern California, even children
reply
This video got several major things wrong. It mentions that the main violence against natives were between the natives and the federal government. This was only true during the plain wars, and when many died when being settled in reservations. . However, in California and other places it was the new American locals who were the biggest threats to natives. If you've traveled up and down California, you would see memorials to different tribes who were murdered by American mobs for minor reasons (the tribes in California were not even that violent. In Humboldt County, there are several monuments to entire tribes who were murdered just because the locals didn't like them. It was so bad that the federal government housed troops specifically to protect the natives in the area. But they were not successful. Local state governments offered bounties for the heads of natives in Northern California, even children
reply
Paul
While this may be true of most of the 'wild west' it really doesn't mention the general 'lawlessness' of 'Indian Country' which didn't have the jurisdiction of the legal authorities that you mentioned and was therefore used by criminals as a place to escape to up until later on when the Federal government decided to crack down. it took a while and the 'hanging judge' just over the border in Arkansas had quite a few guests. Interestingly, despite the horrible mistreatment that the native americans often recieved, they generally didn't see the US Marshals as a downgrade considering that the judicial system of the tribes at the time consisted of circuit riding officers who would show up and decide matters like judges out of the old testament. Let's just say that if he said you were guilty you wouldn't be visiting a courtroom and the circuit rider would be visiting a store to purchase more ammo.
reply
While this may be true of most of the 'wild west' it really doesn't mention the general 'lawlessness' of 'Indian Country' which didn't have the jurisdiction of the legal authorities that you mentioned and was therefore used by criminals as a place to escape to up until later on when the Federal government decided to crack down. it took a while and the 'hanging judge' just over the border in Arkansas had quite a few guests. Interestingly, despite the horrible mistreatment that the native americans often recieved, they generally didn't see the US Marshals as a downgrade considering that the judicial system of the tribes at the time consisted of circuit riding officers who would show up and decide matters like judges out of the old testament. Let's just say that if he said you were guilty you wouldn't be visiting a courtroom and the circuit rider would be visiting a store to purchase more ammo.
reply
Arthur
You totally missed the biggest misconception of cowboys. 60% of all cowboys were either black or Mexican, but mostly black. Think about it, the Civil War had just ended and millions of slaves had just been freed, do you think they all stayed in the South where all they knew was enslavement and continued persecution and lynching? Do you think all those millions were all able to find work, aside from working on the rail roads which occured in the heart of the West, or did many have to resort to robbing banks and rustling horses. Note, I'm not saying they robbed because they were black, they had a hard to impossible time finding work and were left no choice to commit criminal acts for survival.
reply
You totally missed the biggest misconception of cowboys. 60% of all cowboys were either black or Mexican, but mostly black. Think about it, the Civil War had just ended and millions of slaves had just been freed, do you think they all stayed in the South where all they knew was enslavement and continued persecution and lynching? Do you think all those millions were all able to find work, aside from working on the rail roads which occured in the heart of the West, or did many have to resort to robbing banks and rustling horses. Note, I'm not saying they robbed because they were black, they had a hard to impossible time finding work and were left no choice to commit criminal acts for survival.
reply
Bongobob
If you want a film that depicts life in a small wild west town realistically, I'd suggest you watch McCabe & Mrs. Miller, a film about a man opening a salloon in a small mountain town.
Life is depicted as being dirty and harsh, but also mostly uneventful. There's violence amongst the locals, but it's just drunken squables. There's prostitutes, but most of them are unattractive and they're all miserable. An outlaw gang do arrive, but they're only there because they were hired to do the dirty work of a corporation, and they're depicted as nothing more than common psychopaths.
reply
If you want a film that depicts life in a small wild west town realistically, I'd suggest you watch McCabe & Mrs. Miller, a film about a man opening a salloon in a small mountain town.
Life is depicted as being dirty and harsh, but also mostly uneventful. There's violence amongst the locals, but it's just drunken squables. There's prostitutes, but most of them are unattractive and they're all miserable. An outlaw gang do arrive, but they're only there because they were hired to do the dirty work of a corporation, and they're depicted as nothing more than common psychopaths.
reply
RennyRe
The west was wild by the contemporary definition of wild, meaning mostly unpopulated by white people and uncharted wilderness in which the local wildlife, conflicts with natives and medical conditions could pose a substantial danger to anyone settling in the west. If you think everything was so easy back then, read up on the events on the Texas frontier between the 1840s and 1870s or events like bleeding Kansas. That was in fact pretty wild. There is also quite a long list of outlaws and shootouts so there is some truth to the myth of the gunfighter.
reply
The west was wild by the contemporary definition of wild, meaning mostly unpopulated by white people and uncharted wilderness in which the local wildlife, conflicts with natives and medical conditions could pose a substantial danger to anyone settling in the west. If you think everything was so easy back then, read up on the events on the Texas frontier between the 1840s and 1870s or events like bleeding Kansas. That was in fact pretty wild. There is also quite a long list of outlaws and shootouts so there is some truth to the myth of the gunfighter.
reply
Angst1966
I heard about those TV shows and movies that always showed the ranchers and cowboys wearing their six shooters and then they would often get into a gun battle with someone. Actually guns back then were very heavy and people did not work with them on with the exception for law enforcement officers. Hollywood really blows up this whole idea of the Wild West when it really wasn't as much as it seemed.
reply
I heard about those TV shows and movies that always showed the ranchers and cowboys wearing their six shooters and then they would often get into a gun battle with someone. Actually guns back then were very heavy and people did not work with them on with the exception for law enforcement officers. Hollywood really blows up this whole idea of the Wild West when it really wasn't as much as it seemed.
reply
Ral
Cowboys exist in Mexico since the arrival of Spanish to what is now Mexican lands, and the American cowboy is originally from Mexico. It is from Northern Mexican lands, the tools and clothes were pioneer and original of Mexican people (natives and criolles) that developed the cowboys as it is now known. They didn't speaked English, they were Catholic and Mexican (not Spanish, even less Anglo)
reply
Cowboys exist in Mexico since the arrival of Spanish to what is now Mexican lands, and the American cowboy is originally from Mexico. It is from Northern Mexican lands, the tools and clothes were pioneer and original of Mexican people (natives and criolles) that developed the cowboys as it is now known. They didn't speaked English, they were Catholic and Mexican (not Spanish, even less Anglo)
reply
SailorSaturn92
as someone who was born and raised in the west around small mountain towns of Colorado, I'm quite certain there was a lot of Violence that wasn't recorded. Even today there is a lot of Shootings and violence happening. Go back a couple hundred years ago when Laws were barely established outside of large cities and towns, I wouldn't be surprised at what sort of bad I would find.
reply
as someone who was born and raised in the west around small mountain towns of Colorado, I'm quite certain there was a lot of Violence that wasn't recorded. Even today there is a lot of Shootings and violence happening. Go back a couple hundred years ago when Laws were barely established outside of large cities and towns, I wouldn't be surprised at what sort of bad I would find.
reply
Dan
Maps were wrong. The wild west was everything west of the Mississippi so the was from up in Minnesota down the California for range. Not just the small territory highlighted here. It was over half the continental US. It was also considered wild because there was a lack of law in the judicial sense. Constitutionally guaranteed rights for due process weren't always guaranteed.
reply
Maps were wrong. The wild west was everything west of the Mississippi so the was from up in Minnesota down the California for range. Not just the small territory highlighted here. It was over half the continental US. It was also considered wild because there was a lack of law in the judicial sense. Constitutionally guaranteed rights for due process weren't always guaranteed.
reply
Adam
2: 52 is factually incorrect.
Research from Ohio State reads, homicide rates in the West were extraordinarily high by todays standards and by the standards of the rest of the United States and the Western world in the nineteenth century
Dodge City adults, for example, had a homicide rate of 165/100, 000. New York was in the neighborhood of 30/100, 000.
reply
2: 52 is factually incorrect.
Research from Ohio State reads, homicide rates in the West were extraordinarily high by todays standards and by the standards of the rest of the United States and the Western world in the nineteenth century
Dodge City adults, for example, had a homicide rate of 165/100, 000. New York was in the neighborhood of 30/100, 000.
reply
watchthe1369
St. Louis was on the Mississippi river and it was the Gateway to the west for a reason. The West is everything west of the mississippi. Your map is not too accurate Deadwood, a cowtown with a wild reputation, was in the Dakota territory which is north central plains. That is in the center top third of the dark blue area.
reply
St. Louis was on the Mississippi river and it was the Gateway to the west for a reason. The West is everything west of the mississippi. Your map is not too accurate Deadwood, a cowtown with a wild reputation, was in the Dakota territory which is north central plains. That is in the center top third of the dark blue area.
reply
PNW
And also your video is very in accurate. There is countless stories that are collaborated by many witnesses. Life was pretty much normal except gangs of thieves and criminals existed much more than youre putting out in your animated video. And youre obviously not from America so take that with a little grain of salt
reply
And also your video is very in accurate. There is countless stories that are collaborated by many witnesses. Life was pretty much normal except gangs of thieves and criminals existed much more than youre putting out in your animated video. And youre obviously not from America so take that with a little grain of salt
reply
Jos
The dollar trilogy was filmed in Spain, and directed by an Italian in the late late XX century. So how accurate could it be! Morricone music was very good though. Once upon a time in the West was the same, but Claudia Cardinale loked her prime. Good entertainment, but not historical accurate.
reply
The dollar trilogy was filmed in Spain, and directed by an Italian in the late late XX century. So how accurate could it be! Morricone music was very good though. Once upon a time in the West was the same, but Claudia Cardinale loked her prime. Good entertainment, but not historical accurate.
reply
RennyRe
Based on my research I found about 250 famous gunfighters and many more lawmen in the wild west period. Each had their fair share of shootouts. Of course it wasn't like Hollywood, but I wouldn't say that the myth of the wild west is completely unfounded.
reply
Based on my research I found about 250 famous gunfighters and many more lawmen in the wild west period. Each had their fair share of shootouts. Of course it wasn't like Hollywood, but I wouldn't say that the myth of the wild west is completely unfounded.
reply
Grev
Up to 25% of cowboys were actually black, and it wasnt unusual for them to be ex slaves. On the whole black and white cowboys seem to have got on pretty well when they were out tending the herds, problems only tended to arise when they were in towns.
reply
Up to 25% of cowboys were actually black, and it wasnt unusual for them to be ex slaves. On the whole black and white cowboys seem to have got on pretty well when they were out tending the herds, problems only tended to arise when they were in towns.
reply
Fernando
Its funny how the Spanish Empire maintained the order in their lands despite gold mining too but the far west was a lawless territory. I feel sorry for Latin people, they thought independence was great and they really ended up worse
reply
Its funny how the Spanish Empire maintained the order in their lands despite gold mining too but the far west was a lawless territory. I feel sorry for Latin people, they thought independence was great and they really ended up worse
reply
Lars
A typical depiction of American society completely omitting African-Americans. The fact that towns in Texas had up to 40% slave population in the 1840ies might have played a role in the violent reality of American society.
reply
A typical depiction of American society completely omitting African-Americans. The fact that towns in Texas had up to 40% slave population in the 1840ies might have played a role in the violent reality of American society.
reply
William
Recommend the book the last gunfight by Jeff Guinn. Cowboys started as a derogatory name for cattle thieves in Texas and Arizona area, and it become name of the gang that Earp brothers fought.
reply
Recommend the book the last gunfight by Jeff Guinn. Cowboys started as a derogatory name for cattle thieves in Texas and Arizona area, and it become name of the gang that Earp brothers fought.
reply
DumbNDutch
the most famous gun fight of the wild west, the shoot out at the O. K. Corral resulted in a grand total of 3 (three) dead. current USA is so much more wild than the wild west ever was.
reply
the most famous gun fight of the wild west, the shoot out at the O. K. Corral resulted in a grand total of 3 (three) dead. current USA is so much more wild than the wild west ever was.
reply
Harrison2610
Nothing like completely ignoring the brutality the native tribes inflicted on the settlers and other tribes and choosing to just go with the whole US mean to natives view
reply
Nothing like completely ignoring the brutality the native tribes inflicted on the settlers and other tribes and choosing to just go with the whole US mean to natives view
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















