
A Study of Decadence(When Societies Commit Suicide.
video description
You talked about honor, but you didn't define it. Schopenhauer did: he defined it as having value in your activities to others, in having a purpose to society. That's a good start, but understand that this is inherently a competitive endeavor, and having value to others is the basis for a class system. What happens in decadent societies is that they recognize that their class system is not completely justified - as no system ever can be - and they decide to not take them seriously. They won't impose them on people internally or externally, which makes them seem kinder in their own eyes while denying people of the playing field where they can rise and find some purpose through contribution to the whole. Basically, if they can't make it completely fair, then they refuse to take responsibility for it. They focus on pleasure and take it easy, for the sake of not bringing guilt or shame to themselves by supporting a system that can't be justified.
It comes down to institutions. INCLUDING the institutions that drive inequality. An effective society is a hierarchical system, and the ones that can't find it in themselves to accept this, that can't find a reason to accept this, let themselves fall apart. It happens partially due to the logic and partially due to the security they already know, which insulates them from fear of chaos. We believe that an unfair system is wrong and absurd, but if hierarchy doesn't qualify as moral goodness in the way we know it, then the definition of moral goodness has to change.
You said the logic of decadence and for a second I thought he got it, he figured it out but you didn't hit the bullseye, you just kept hitting the ten ring. Escaping decadence requires a new moral order that isn't afraid to assert itself. I have pretty strong political opinions - surprise, surprise - but even if I disagreed wildly with everything that a powerful new American movement would create, I would rather go down fighting it than go down watching such a powerful and beneficent civilization with such potential go to pieces from a LACK of institutional initiative.
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
ullla
Anyone ever wondered why certain hinu elements like meditation living outside socoety became so prevalent in hippies or when societal pressure were too much to bear?
I am an hindi and i have always find it fascinating
In its core hinduism lofe is divided in phase childhood where you learn and respect parents do what they say
Adolescents where you learn from teachers, aashrams in todays world have been perversed but in origanility it meams teacher and few disciples living at teachers home and a mini society where you learn everything thay is needed from war, economics, religion amd every facet of life, king or middle class ( poor at that time had no place in education system at that time ) all brought to equal placing in front of teacher
Then at young age you responsibility is to society, your kings amd government where you contribute to progression and continuity, aka where you are required to be creative and allowed to be independent without any strains
Then in middle age you have responsibilty for family and your parents, totally devoted to them
Then in late middle age or early old age you witjdraw from resonsibilites and focus on the spiritual development
And gradually withdrawn from irresponsibilities bcoz they are taken care by next gen and you focus your time on god and religion
And i think hippies and so called era took a little part of that andade it their whole life purpose to escape reality while simultaneously providing a rational to their actions thus not having to deal with mental and social pain and torture
reply
Anyone ever wondered why certain hinu elements like meditation living outside socoety became so prevalent in hippies or when societal pressure were too much to bear?
I am an hindi and i have always find it fascinating
In its core hinduism lofe is divided in phase childhood where you learn and respect parents do what they say
Adolescents where you learn from teachers, aashrams in todays world have been perversed but in origanility it meams teacher and few disciples living at teachers home and a mini society where you learn everything thay is needed from war, economics, religion amd every facet of life, king or middle class ( poor at that time had no place in education system at that time ) all brought to equal placing in front of teacher
Then at young age you responsibility is to society, your kings amd government where you contribute to progression and continuity, aka where you are required to be creative and allowed to be independent without any strains
Then in middle age you have responsibilty for family and your parents, totally devoted to them
Then in late middle age or early old age you witjdraw from resonsibilites and focus on the spiritual development
And gradually withdrawn from irresponsibilities bcoz they are taken care by next gen and you focus your time on god and religion
And i think hippies and so called era took a little part of that andade it their whole life purpose to escape reality while simultaneously providing a rational to their actions thus not having to deal with mental and social pain and torture
reply
C.
My problem with this is that frankly it feels like it's trying to create a narrative rather than necessarily seeing a historical pattern. Rome survived for centuries and even reached its greatest height after Nero and Caligula, and it wasn't the decadence of the ruling class that brought it down when it did fall; people forget just how ideologically extreme the French Revolution was (they even tried to do things like decimalise time, and the Republic never truly fell; in terms of putting socially-constructed reality above actual reality I point you to the centuries of religious chaos in Europe where countless thousands died and entire power blocs formed and wars were fought over absurd, meaningless doctrinal differences, during which European global power only increased. And during this time there plenty of ridiculous fashions and fads analogous to NFTs.
reply
My problem with this is that frankly it feels like it's trying to create a narrative rather than necessarily seeing a historical pattern. Rome survived for centuries and even reached its greatest height after Nero and Caligula, and it wasn't the decadence of the ruling class that brought it down when it did fall; people forget just how ideologically extreme the French Revolution was (they even tried to do things like decimalise time, and the Republic never truly fell; in terms of putting socially-constructed reality above actual reality I point you to the centuries of religious chaos in Europe where countless thousands died and entire power blocs formed and wars were fought over absurd, meaningless doctrinal differences, during which European global power only increased. And during this time there plenty of ridiculous fashions and fads analogous to NFTs.
reply
education
Your solution: Western civilisation should Fall in love with Faith and Honour again, and Decadence comes from when man turns away from the stars and instead drowns himself in wine? Hoo, Boy. And there are a number of clunky sentences and misspellings in your slides; question is, are they intentional (in order to seem not part of an elite? While you make refreshing observations, like that you have to read history books from before the 1960's to get any objectivity, your conclusions seem to want to want to step backwards into simplistic slogans, betraying all your reading. - Faith and Honour - in what? good ol' American McDonalds and FB? It's not enough to conjure up mirages.
reply
Your solution: Western civilisation should Fall in love with Faith and Honour again, and Decadence comes from when man turns away from the stars and instead drowns himself in wine? Hoo, Boy. And there are a number of clunky sentences and misspellings in your slides; question is, are they intentional (in order to seem not part of an elite? While you make refreshing observations, like that you have to read history books from before the 1960's to get any objectivity, your conclusions seem to want to want to step backwards into simplistic slogans, betraying all your reading. - Faith and Honour - in what? good ol' American McDonalds and FB? It's not enough to conjure up mirages.
reply
Paula
You know what I always find ludicrous? People who say that capitalism as a system and American constitutional governance is just a patriarchal system created by old dead white men don't seem to notice that Marxism and socialism etc etc were all invented by German upper middle class white guys doing the equivalent of sulking in their in-laws basement room, dreaming of a world where they can just sit and think and depend on others. from each according to their abilities, to those according to their needs, which is the equivalent of 400lb guys laying in their beds, hacking other peoples bank accounts or tweeting rude comments to other unproductive people according to their needs!
reply
You know what I always find ludicrous? People who say that capitalism as a system and American constitutional governance is just a patriarchal system created by old dead white men don't seem to notice that Marxism and socialism etc etc were all invented by German upper middle class white guys doing the equivalent of sulking in their in-laws basement room, dreaming of a world where they can just sit and think and depend on others. from each according to their abilities, to those according to their needs, which is the equivalent of 400lb guys laying in their beds, hacking other peoples bank accounts or tweeting rude comments to other unproductive people according to their needs!
reply
HH
Watching this video for the third time, I'm still confused. If decadence is the culture putting its ideas above reality, isn't absolving some ideas from criticism (like you suggested for dignity and faith) and trying to reach for the stars, i. e expand your nation or make megaprojects, for its own emotional sake - isn't all that the same thing? It seems to me that prioritizing ideals and grandiose goals over practical matters (example from the video - colonizing space over fixing things on Earth) is quite disconnected from reality.
What exactly do I misunderstand?
Could anyone help me figure this out?
reply
Watching this video for the third time, I'm still confused. If decadence is the culture putting its ideas above reality, isn't absolving some ideas from criticism (like you suggested for dignity and faith) and trying to reach for the stars, i. e expand your nation or make megaprojects, for its own emotional sake - isn't all that the same thing? It seems to me that prioritizing ideals and grandiose goals over practical matters (example from the video - colonizing space over fixing things on Earth) is quite disconnected from reality.
What exactly do I misunderstand?
Could anyone help me figure this out?
reply
Thomas
Hi man, interesting video! I just want to let you know that Established Titles is really a bit of a scam, and worth researching a little more. A 1-foot piece of land (or similar) is too small to be registered in the Land Register of Scotland, being known as a 'souvenir plot'. It is impossibly to acquire ownership of such plots under Scots Law.
Additionally, the titles 'Lord', 'Lady', etc. cannot be acquired by purchasing land. Instead, Established titles provide a deed poll - this document simply allows you to change your name; it does not grant you a title.
reply
Hi man, interesting video! I just want to let you know that Established Titles is really a bit of a scam, and worth researching a little more. A 1-foot piece of land (or similar) is too small to be registered in the Land Register of Scotland, being known as a 'souvenir plot'. It is impossibly to acquire ownership of such plots under Scots Law.
Additionally, the titles 'Lord', 'Lady', etc. cannot be acquired by purchasing land. Instead, Established titles provide a deed poll - this document simply allows you to change your name; it does not grant you a title.
reply
Commander
8: 11 How exactly is Europe in the 16th in 17th centuries in any way similar to being barbaric? It had an established hierarchy of feudalism, multiple established states across the continent, and now an eagerness to carve up the world, I would not compare these pretty well-established orders to say the Nomads of the Steppes. This is nothing more than a blatant just bad take on history, even if going by your own definition, if your definition of civilization is democracy then I am sorry for you buddy but civilization does not require democracy to function.
reply
8: 11 How exactly is Europe in the 16th in 17th centuries in any way similar to being barbaric? It had an established hierarchy of feudalism, multiple established states across the continent, and now an eagerness to carve up the world, I would not compare these pretty well-established orders to say the Nomads of the Steppes. This is nothing more than a blatant just bad take on history, even if going by your own definition, if your definition of civilization is democracy then I am sorry for you buddy but civilization does not require democracy to function.
reply
Eks
Societies collapse when the Populus as a whole cares more about their feelings. Rather than maintaining some kind Intellectual Base.
It's more likely to happen in times of great Affluence. Because there's less of a reason to need Pragmatic Individuals.
We've seen it with the collapse of the Romans.
Where people would rather indulge in luxuries. Instead of recognize what's going on outside their comfy little homes.
-When there are more people who live in the Real World:
There won't be as many long-term problems in society.
reply
Societies collapse when the Populus as a whole cares more about their feelings. Rather than maintaining some kind Intellectual Base.
It's more likely to happen in times of great Affluence. Because there's less of a reason to need Pragmatic Individuals.
We've seen it with the collapse of the Romans.
Where people would rather indulge in luxuries. Instead of recognize what's going on outside their comfy little homes.
-When there are more people who live in the Real World:
There won't be as many long-term problems in society.
reply
doxen
Wouldn't any generation that grows up on the heels of the generation which built their society be decedant then? If that's the case, then it means that every subsequent generation would progressively devolve into decadence, as you've been saying. It's a tough pill to swallow, but it seems that any society, no matter its righteous inception, is doomed to either lose to another more powerful nation, or have it's people become so disillusioned that the nation implodes.
It's not a nice thought, but it is a realistic one.
reply
Wouldn't any generation that grows up on the heels of the generation which built their society be decedant then? If that's the case, then it means that every subsequent generation would progressively devolve into decadence, as you've been saying. It's a tough pill to swallow, but it seems that any society, no matter its righteous inception, is doomed to either lose to another more powerful nation, or have it's people become so disillusioned that the nation implodes.
It's not a nice thought, but it is a realistic one.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















