VehiclesFashionRecipesBlogsHuntTravelsSportFunHandmadeITEducation
Mini-Games
x

x
zakruti.com » Knowledge, science, education » Historical films
The Greatest Speech in History? Alexander the Great & The Opis Mutiny

The Greatest Speech in History? Alexander the Great & The Opis Mutiny

FBTwitterReddit

video description

Rating: 4.0; Vote: 1
Alexander the Great is one of the most extraordinary individuals in history. He became king of the fringe Greek kingdom of Macedonia in 336 BC at the age of just 20, and before his death twelve years later, had imposed Macedonian overlordship on Greece, destroyed the mighty Persian Empire and led an army deep into modern Afghanistan and to the Indian frontier. At Opis he faced a mutiny by his Macedonian troops, angered that he wanted to send some of them home, while appearing to give preference to his new Asian subjects, and adopting many of their customs. Alexander dealt ruthlessly with the ringleaders, before (according to 'The Anabasis' by Roman historian Arrian) making a speech to his army in which he berated his troops for their disloyalty. The speech, as it has reached us, was no doubt written by Arrian rather than Alexander. His actual words are now impossible to ascertain. But Arrian had access to eyewitness accounts which are now lost (principally Ptolemy and Nearchus, and modern historians generally agree that the speech was a real historical event, and that Arrian gives a good representation of its likely content. Putting its (contested and debated) value as a historical source to one side, the scene - as it appears in Arrian - is a brilliantly written moment of high drama and emotion, in which Alexander first highlights his debt to his father Philip, before launching into a tirade in which he lists his own astounding achievements and qualities of leadership. The speech has been abridged and edited by myself for this video. You can read Arrian's full version in English translation here
Date: 2022-09-12

Comments and reviews: 20


Any modern man with normal levels of testosterone would exchange his meaningless life working a dead-end 9-5 administrative job or some other slave waging job, where is soul is extracted daily through a tube inserted in his neck draining his blood, for a campaign of 12 years fighting the most powerful forces ever seen so far, including the most advanced civilization (and Empire) of the time - the Persian -, across three continents facing unparalleled hardships and near death battles. Even dying in such a scenario would be a thousand times more worthy and dignified than dying in current era's New York City as an old, lonely, divorced, and abandoned by your own people and family, deeply depressed and in an apartment that is not yours. You rent a small, uncomfortable apartment because your slave waging job, where you worked for 40 years, didn't pay you enough to buy two house; and the one house you paid for, your wife took from you when she rape-divorced you 20 years ago.
I would have followed Alexander to the end of the world.

reply

Under Granik, his helmet was cut with a sword that penetrated to the hair. under Iss - a sword in the thigh. under Gaza he was wounded by a dart in the shoulder, under Marakanda - by an arrow in the shin so that the split bone protruded from the wound; in Hyrcania, with a stone to the back of the head, after which his eyesight deteriorated and for several days he remained under the threat of blindness; in the region of the Assakans - with an Indian spear in the ankle. In the kingdom of the Mulls, an arrow two cubits long, breaking through the shell, wounded him in the chest; in the same place. he was hit with a mace on the neck.
Plutarch. On the fate and valor of Alexander, II, 9.

reply

Alexander's speech is so good in the way hiding his selfishness from his soldiers mind. If he wanted to cherish Macedonia he could have done it inside Greece. But why he waged war only becoz of his own desire to take the world. Even from the past to present many people have and had this same desire to rule the world. Hilter done the same, killed many Jews even his own country people got killed by him. Alexander too killed his own men at some extent. He knows how to handle his people's emotion to fulfill his own desire. Becoz his teacher was Aristotle and many other great scholars.
reply

Lol these arent Alexanders words. Good music. Good imagery. But some of the people reacting as if this is a primary source with facts in regards to the speechnot the conquestslol there is no written record. So this is purely artist interpretation. Entertaining video. But thats all it is. His words wouldnt be phrased using 21st century language/syntax too. There are great vowel shifts in history (Old English-Middle English-Modern English etc.
reply

Peoples petty perceived slights of those who have done so much for them never cease to amaze me. Like people who complain about how hard life is living in a country where any food they could possibly want is within reach. Where running water is merely a turn of a knob. Where you can transport yourself 100 miles in an hour, or across the country in 5-6. In their AC & heated homes. Spoiled, ungrateful little children.
reply

Fun fact: Alexander is called 'Alakshendra' in Sanskrit (Indians called the Greek emperor that way.
Greeks called Chandragupta (Emperor of India) who won Afghanistan back from the Greeks was called 'Sandrakottos' or 'Andrakottos'.
So Americans and English can call Vladimir Putin 'Vitamin Protein'.
Britain can call Biden 'Job Burden'.

reply

macedonians like the rest of greeks: had greek names, spoke greek, worshipped the same greek gods, named their placenames with greek names, participated in greek olympic games, traced their originis in greek mythical heroes, spread everywhere the greek language and culture, used coins written in greek
reply

Did he bury the women and children he slaughtered with full honours? The man was a psychopathic egomaniac. Dandamis, the Indian philosopher whom he sought out, had one question for him, to which he had no answer: Why did you come?
reply

Ancient Greek are nothing like this, you should get a native Greek person to read the ancient scripture because the way it is read it is not from a Greek obviously and the letters are pronounced completely wrong -a native Greek
reply

I'd like to think I give a similar speech from time to time to my Family whenever they want to catch an attitude with me or forget who was the one who worked his ass off their entire life to give them all that they have now.
reply

His spreading of Greek culture was his greatest fulfillment.
That histrionics shows Alexander was a conqueror of hearts & minds, not just lands, & makes this more a crusade & less a consolidation of territories.

reply

Honestly he sounds like first class grade A ahole in this speech, its very self serving diatribe and what I would expect of a megalomaniac. However such bold leadership may have that a strong character trait.
reply

In a savagely diluted form, he gave some of the best advice for a leader who should believe, do, and espouse its worth:
I ask nothing of you I will not and have not done myself.

reply

PITY the diversity peoples. Truly pity them.
Their culture is nothing more than the bitter envious worship of mine.
We are their gods and how it makes them weep.

reply

That was the most entitled, self absorbed speech I have ever heard. It is no mystery now why he died at the hands of his own men. What a delusional piece of shit!
reply

How the historian managed to grasp these words of Alexander. It is captivating and making all his subjects think twice to question his judgements 2000 years ago.
reply

That's what we need in America. if you served your country and come out with any disability rating you should no longer have to pay any taxes.
reply

Long live Persia and Persians
The greatest race, people, DNA in the world at all times
Down with Greece, Egypt, Arabs, Mongolia, Rimans

reply

Sounds like a guilt laden, self-aggrandizing, virtue-signaling, nationalist, violent, whiny freak. And why? Because he WAS. Good riddance.
reply

This man was bred to fight and command armys in war he new nothing else. I wonder how far he would of gone if he wasnt killed by his own.
reply
Add a review, comment






Other channel videos