Why was The Battle of Stalingrad so Deadly?
video description
Date: 2023-12-16
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 19
knowledgia
I really hate it when the video is not really about the title, but a general -let's talk about the general situation. - Here's an outline for a video that answers the title: Detailed description of Stalingrad and important structures, house to house fighting, sewer fighting, engineers and weapons, morale, Commissars, Generals Chuikov versus Paulus, problem of supply, Germans left to die where they stood. You're welcome.
reply
I really hate it when the video is not really about the title, but a general -let's talk about the general situation. - Here's an outline for a video that answers the title: Detailed description of Stalingrad and important structures, house to house fighting, sewer fighting, engineers and weapons, morale, Commissars, Generals Chuikov versus Paulus, problem of supply, Germans left to die where they stood. You're welcome.
reply
-enyawlaw1063
It's funny how this video couldn't resist taking a cheap shot at the Soviet's at the end. What would happen if the Soviet's did not do what they did? I guess the Nazi would be making this video about their victory in WW2, NOT you.
reply
It's funny how this video couldn't resist taking a cheap shot at the Soviet's at the end. What would happen if the Soviet's did not do what they did? I guess the Nazi would be making this video about their victory in WW2, NOT you.
reply
-Basta11
You can see from the map it-s location on the Volga. Stalingrad was absolutely important. Without it, the Soviets would be cut off of oil and other supplies from the South. It would be very difficult to keep fighting without oil.
reply
You can see from the map it-s location on the Volga. Stalingrad was absolutely important. Without it, the Soviets would be cut off of oil and other supplies from the South. It would be very difficult to keep fighting without oil.
reply
-kaal6foot255
actually the sovient citizens were helping german soldiers while the red army suffered from lack of food and supply obaying the order 227(suicide mission) which no soldier of red army couldn't back down no matter what.
reply
actually the sovient citizens were helping german soldiers while the red army suffered from lack of food and supply obaying the order 227(suicide mission) which no soldier of red army couldn't back down no matter what.
reply
-theo9952
What 24 hours lifespan? I would be dead within 24 minutes. Or more likely 24 seconds. From a heart attack. And a good thing too. Better than being torn to shreads by machine guns or blasted to pieces by bombs and mines.
reply
What 24 hours lifespan? I would be dead within 24 minutes. Or more likely 24 seconds. From a heart attack. And a good thing too. Better than being torn to shreads by machine guns or blasted to pieces by bombs and mines.
reply
-azazel5701
Just imagine if this was in the mid 40s and the casualties surpassed millions, with todays tech and fighting techniques and strategies just imagine how many casualties will be made in the nezt major war
reply
Just imagine if this was in the mid 40s and the casualties surpassed millions, with todays tech and fighting techniques and strategies just imagine how many casualties will be made in the nezt major war
reply
-ripwednesdayadams
The Soviets really went through hell and are the MVPs of WWII. Chuikov-s brilliant -hug the enemy- strategy and his command style during the battle of Stalingrad made operation Uranus possible.
reply
The Soviets really went through hell and are the MVPs of WWII. Chuikov-s brilliant -hug the enemy- strategy and his command style during the battle of Stalingrad made operation Uranus possible.
reply
-brtipratt
Your explanation of order 227 is factually incorrect and very misleading. I highly encourage you to edit this further with the correct information as your explanation encourages misinformation
reply
Your explanation of order 227 is factually incorrect and very misleading. I highly encourage you to edit this further with the correct information as your explanation encourages misinformation
reply
-geoffreylee5199
The Soviets would shoot their own soldiers from behind to keep going forward. Definitely a terrible war crime - worst to their own than the Nazis were to the Soviets.
reply
The Soviets would shoot their own soldiers from behind to keep going forward. Definitely a terrible war crime - worst to their own than the Nazis were to the Soviets.
reply
knowledgia
Now ofc it isn't for sure but my father and all his siblings think that my uncle's father was positioned at Stalingrad so I'm just shocked what he might have gone through
reply
Now ofc it isn't for sure but my father and all his siblings think that my uncle's father was positioned at Stalingrad so I'm just shocked what he might have gone through
reply
-usmaniqbal1322
Good video but order 227 didn't apply to soldiers but to officers or commanders
You could still retreat back to your lines if you were a soldier
reply
Good video but order 227 didn't apply to soldiers but to officers or commanders
You could still retreat back to your lines if you were a soldier
reply
-gasperstarina9837
Life expectancy in Stalingrad was 24 hours. So if you were in lost position would you put bullet in your head or risk slow painful death?
reply
Life expectancy in Stalingrad was 24 hours. So if you were in lost position would you put bullet in your head or risk slow painful death?
reply
-FreeMan4096
Germany had no idea how much USA's supplies were trully arriving to Soviet Union. All stalin had to do was force civilians to fight
reply
Germany had no idea how much USA's supplies were trully arriving to Soviet Union. All stalin had to do was force civilians to fight
reply
-djole93podbara
Everybody talking that Ussr had many casualties, but the axis forces also had the same amount of casualties, about a milion
reply
Everybody talking that Ussr had many casualties, but the axis forces also had the same amount of casualties, about a milion
reply
-amerrashed6287
Throughout WW2, German always has the most advanced weapons and troops numbers but they lack the strategic plans!
reply
Throughout WW2, German always has the most advanced weapons and troops numbers but they lack the strategic plans!
reply
-lu77xiaojun37
It would it not be correct to say that Operation Uranus caught the Germans. wait for it. with their pants down? -
reply
It would it not be correct to say that Operation Uranus caught the Germans. wait for it. with their pants down? -
reply
-TheLokoViejo
The art of war says a siege is no good, but a prolonged siege even when successful, comes at a great price.
reply
The art of war says a siege is no good, but a prolonged siege even when successful, comes at a great price.
reply
knowledgia
The Nazi clique claimed victory in November 1942. Under a year later, the Nazis were clearly doomed to lose.
reply
The Nazi clique claimed victory in November 1942. Under a year later, the Nazis were clearly doomed to lose.
reply
-n543576
Women in WW2?
Shit better let those guys who were talking about Battlefield 5 they were wrong. again.
reply
Women in WW2?
Shit better let those guys who were talking about Battlefield 5 they were wrong. again.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
