What if Carthage won the Punic Wars, part 2?
video description
Date: 2022-07-15
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 9
Hypso
The tribal groups your talking about in the Middle East are bedouins. The reason why the bedouins live in a tribal society is because they live in the sandy desert were its difficult to build civilizations. It's similar to the Samis in Northern Europe and the inuits in north Asian because they live in environments that don't have the materials or resources to construct civilizations.
reply
The tribal groups your talking about in the Middle East are bedouins. The reason why the bedouins live in a tribal society is because they live in the sandy desert were its difficult to build civilizations. It's similar to the Samis in Northern Europe and the inuits in north Asian because they live in environments that don't have the materials or resources to construct civilizations.
reply
Luke
Not possible. The first what if of Carthage part 1 would have eliminated this timeline. Why. The military victories over Rome N the eventual uniting of North Africa by Carthaginians would have render this moot. Carthiginian influence would have in time spread southward. Carthiginian influence buttressed by a Navy N powerful army would have impacted the world scene.
reply
Not possible. The first what if of Carthage part 1 would have eliminated this timeline. Why. The military victories over Rome N the eventual uniting of North Africa by Carthaginians would have render this moot. Carthiginian influence would have in time spread southward. Carthiginian influence buttressed by a Navy N powerful army would have impacted the world scene.
reply
Charles
Abolition would exist, as Christianity would exist. And this national feeling would exist - this time not in Rome, but in the Sassanid empire. As the Sassanids wanted to reconquer the Archaemenid Empire in OTL, they would also want to do this in this TL. So this national feeling would start in the Middle East and would reach us later, but it would reach us.
reply
Abolition would exist, as Christianity would exist. And this national feeling would exist - this time not in Rome, but in the Sassanid empire. As the Sassanids wanted to reconquer the Archaemenid Empire in OTL, they would also want to do this in this TL. So this national feeling would start in the Middle East and would reach us later, but it would reach us.
reply
DanishnSonic
Very interesting with fair point. Its a nice theory, even if we cannot predict 100 percent what would happen, one factor because of the personalities and upbringing of kings may actually change the tide of wars and such. But it is still a remarkable speculation
reply
Very interesting with fair point. Its a nice theory, even if we cannot predict 100 percent what would happen, one factor because of the personalities and upbringing of kings may actually change the tide of wars and such. But it is still a remarkable speculation
reply
livingood1049
Kinda dropped it like a hot potato lol well it had to end somewhere haha. I'm just amused to see you making friends again, Muhammad was a traitor, good thing that worked out for him isn't it.
I just appreciate the no BS assessments man keep it up!
reply
Kinda dropped it like a hot potato lol well it had to end somewhere haha. I'm just amused to see you making friends again, Muhammad was a traitor, good thing that worked out for him isn't it.
I just appreciate the no BS assessments man keep it up!
reply
Good
Well if the roman empire fell, you say people wouldnt have inspiration but wouldnt they be inspired by carthage instead or the next biggest and most successful empire
reply
Well if the roman empire fell, you say people wouldnt have inspiration but wouldnt they be inspired by carthage instead or the next biggest and most successful empire
reply
John
4: 50 Unlikely. Carthage was a completely different type of state to Rome and was more focused on economic domination rather than aggressive military expansion.
reply
4: 50 Unlikely. Carthage was a completely different type of state to Rome and was more focused on economic domination rather than aggressive military expansion.
reply
Areis
Now if they were cleaner hygiene wise unlike the Spanish and other Europeans. They may have a harder time without diseases helping them conquer the America's
reply
Now if they were cleaner hygiene wise unlike the Spanish and other Europeans. They may have a harder time without diseases helping them conquer the America's
reply
slibertas1996
Nope. Christianity still wins in Europe (via Spain) because Paul goes to Carthage instead of Parthia. Nice try.
reply
Nope. Christianity still wins in Europe (via Spain) because Paul goes to Carthage instead of Parthia. Nice try.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
