
The Real Reason No One Recognized Luke In The Mandalorian
video description
Date: 2020-12-24
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 10
MaximumNewbage
Dude. The fact that Rey refers to Jedi as mythological figures in the force awakens is because the people who made that movie were incompetent. Before the the Empire rose to power, EVERYONE knew who the Jedi were because there were a big part of intergalactic politics. Luke was born roughly around the time the Jedi were destroyed. Let's say that INTERPOL (The world police, just like the Jedi were basically galactic police) was destroyed overnight like the Jedi were. Would people treat them as mythical figures and forget about them in just a few decades? Of course not. It makes no sense.
Even the way the Mandalorian treats Jedi makes no sense, acting as if they were shrouded in mystery and from an ancient past etc. Dude. It was like 20 years ago from Mando's perspective that everyone knew everything about the Jedi and the Jedi were up in everybody's business. How the hell does he not know about Jedi?
reply
Dude. The fact that Rey refers to Jedi as mythological figures in the force awakens is because the people who made that movie were incompetent. Before the the Empire rose to power, EVERYONE knew who the Jedi were because there were a big part of intergalactic politics. Luke was born roughly around the time the Jedi were destroyed. Let's say that INTERPOL (The world police, just like the Jedi were basically galactic police) was destroyed overnight like the Jedi were. Would people treat them as mythical figures and forget about them in just a few decades? Of course not. It makes no sense.
Even the way the Mandalorian treats Jedi makes no sense, acting as if they were shrouded in mystery and from an ancient past etc. Dude. It was like 20 years ago from Mando's perspective that everyone knew everything about the Jedi and the Jedi were up in everybody's business. How the hell does he not know about Jedi?
reply
Jay
There's no reason why Luke should be particularly well known. It's a bit strange that the Mandalorian had never even heard of jedi before the end of season one, but I'm not surprised that most people wouldn't know about Luke specifically. For the most part, the only people who are famous during and right after wars are the leaders involved. People would know about the rebels destroying 2 Deathstars and killing Palpatine and Vader, but it doesn't surprise me that no one would know the specifics of who was involved.
reply
There's no reason why Luke should be particularly well known. It's a bit strange that the Mandalorian had never even heard of jedi before the end of season one, but I'm not surprised that most people wouldn't know about Luke specifically. For the most part, the only people who are famous during and right after wars are the leaders involved. People would know about the rebels destroying 2 Deathstars and killing Palpatine and Vader, but it doesn't surprise me that no one would know the specifics of who was involved.
reply
John
The Empire doesn't have a very light touch. The death of Palpatine will be news anywhere they hear about what (if anything) is going on on the far side of their own planet. Anyone not under a rock will have heard of Luke though they may not care. Cara dune will know what he looks like but may not care. Din will have seen the exorbitant bounties various Imperials will have set on Like but no one has ever collected. They'd know who he was most likely.
reply
The Empire doesn't have a very light touch. The death of Palpatine will be news anywhere they hear about what (if anything) is going on on the far side of their own planet. Anyone not under a rock will have heard of Luke though they may not care. Cara dune will know what he looks like but may not care. Din will have seen the exorbitant bounties various Imperials will have set on Like but no one has ever collected. They'd know who he was most likely.
reply
Chris
Umm, actually, Boba Fett should have recognized Luke from their encounter 5 years ago in which he was thrown into the giant mouth of that ground monster thing, and everyone thought he'd died. But he survived. I mean, Boba Fett was fighting with Luke directly, so I don't think anyone's going to be able to explain that away, unless, of course, it comes up next season where Boba Fett reveals to the others who that actually was. Maybe?
reply
Umm, actually, Boba Fett should have recognized Luke from their encounter 5 years ago in which he was thrown into the giant mouth of that ground monster thing, and everyone thought he'd died. But he survived. I mean, Boba Fett was fighting with Luke directly, so I don't think anyone's going to be able to explain that away, unless, of course, it comes up next season where Boba Fett reveals to the others who that actually was. Maybe?
reply
Matthew
I think the mandalorian is a good place to start for someone interested in a space saga but not with some magical powers.
Nothing in the show (bar Boba Fett) is hinging on the established lore being known. Enough exposition occurs to clue someone in on the broader themes.
Luke is a legend in the starwars universe but only to those who follow the story of the alliance and the Jedi.
reply
I think the mandalorian is a good place to start for someone interested in a space saga but not with some magical powers.
Nothing in the show (bar Boba Fett) is hinging on the established lore being known. Enough exposition occurs to clue someone in on the broader themes.
Luke is a legend in the starwars universe but only to those who follow the story of the alliance and the Jedi.
reply
x5-992
Pretty sure Gideon recognized him. Maybe Cara, or at the very least knows the names. What gets me is how quickly the Jedi were forgotten. They had a massive temple in the biggest city in the galaxy, they lead the clones in a huge war. Yet in A New Hope people who were alive during the Clone Wars believe it to be ancient and forgotten.
reply
Pretty sure Gideon recognized him. Maybe Cara, or at the very least knows the names. What gets me is how quickly the Jedi were forgotten. They had a massive temple in the biggest city in the galaxy, they lead the clones in a huge war. Yet in A New Hope people who were alive during the Clone Wars believe it to be ancient and forgotten.
reply
Jinyu
I do find it funny that Cara wouldn t know who he is. As a survivor of Alderaan and a member of the Rebel Alliance, how would any member not know the man who destroyed the Death Star without a targeting computer thereby getting revenge for Alderaan and become probably the most well known rebel outside of the command structure.
reply
I do find it funny that Cara wouldn t know who he is. As a survivor of Alderaan and a member of the Rebel Alliance, how would any member not know the man who destroyed the Death Star without a targeting computer thereby getting revenge for Alderaan and become probably the most well known rebel outside of the command structure.
reply
Marjorie
Maybe some of them didn't but for one reason or another (shocked, stunned, scared, watching the scene play out) didn't say anything and played it cool? What would the dialogue have been. Hi Luke, thanks for dropping by! By golly, it's Luke Skywalker!
reply
Maybe some of them didn't but for one reason or another (shocked, stunned, scared, watching the scene play out) didn't say anything and played it cool? What would the dialogue have been. Hi Luke, thanks for dropping by! By golly, it's Luke Skywalker!
reply
Roy
As I recall in a New Hope not even Luke Skywalker himself had ever heard of the Jedi until Ben himself told him about them.
The Empire did an outstanding job in erasing the memory of the Jedi Knights from the galaxy's common folk collective mindset.
reply
As I recall in a New Hope not even Luke Skywalker himself had ever heard of the Jedi until Ben himself told him about them.
The Empire did an outstanding job in erasing the memory of the Jedi Knights from the galaxy's common folk collective mindset.
reply
xanithkl
The real reason is because this universe with their droids & hyperspeed spaceship technology does not have the most basic i. e. intergalactic internet infrastructure. Otherwise, Mando and others can just search Whois Jedy.
reply
The real reason is because this universe with their droids & hyperspeed spaceship technology does not have the most basic i. e. intergalactic internet infrastructure. Otherwise, Mando and others can just search Whois Jedy.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos















