Top 10 Worst Changes the Harry Potter Movies Made
video description
Date: 2023-11-20
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 30
Elizabeth
I'm sorry, but Hermione and Ron do not belong together, just like how Harry and Ginny don't belong together. Ginny is nothing but a fangirl who never grows out of it, and Ron constantly berates Hermione. He insults her at every opportunity and doesn't apologize. If it wasn't for Ron, Hermione wouldn't have been in danger of the troll in the first place.
Ron and Ginny are both toxic to the people they fell in love with. I like a majority of the Weasley's, but Ron and Ginny just irritate me to no end.
Yes, I am a Harry and Hermione shipper, but only because Harry and Hermione are perfect for each other. They were both raised in the non-magical world so they understand each other, they can hold entire conversations without speaking, and when Hermione was injured in the Department of Mysteries battle, Harry felt as if his whole world was crumbling.
So, yeah, don't you dare say that all Harry Potter fans want to see Ron and Hermione, and Harry and Ginny, together. I'm a Harry Potter fan and I prefer Harry and Hermione.
reply
I'm sorry, but Hermione and Ron do not belong together, just like how Harry and Ginny don't belong together. Ginny is nothing but a fangirl who never grows out of it, and Ron constantly berates Hermione. He insults her at every opportunity and doesn't apologize. If it wasn't for Ron, Hermione wouldn't have been in danger of the troll in the first place.
Ron and Ginny are both toxic to the people they fell in love with. I like a majority of the Weasley's, but Ron and Ginny just irritate me to no end.
Yes, I am a Harry and Hermione shipper, but only because Harry and Hermione are perfect for each other. They were both raised in the non-magical world so they understand each other, they can hold entire conversations without speaking, and when Hermione was injured in the Department of Mysteries battle, Harry felt as if his whole world was crumbling.
So, yeah, don't you dare say that all Harry Potter fans want to see Ron and Hermione, and Harry and Ginny, together. I'm a Harry Potter fan and I prefer Harry and Hermione.
reply
Levente
TOO MUCH NAGIGI.
First off, why did Ron & Hermione have to fight the goddamn snake in the finale instead of a human foe, like Fenrir Greyback or Bellatrix Lestrange?
Second, why did the snake attack Harry in Godric's hollow? Why couldn't it just hold him up until Voldemort arrives like in the book? Voldemort directly controls it, Nagini being a Horcrux, and Voldemort wants to kill Harry himself, not get him bitten to death by his pet.
And most importantly, why was half of the finale a snake biting the camera!
Too much boring teenager stuff in the sixth movie, sacrificing Voldemort's backstory. If you want to omit something, omit the tteen drama instead.
Missing mistery/crime story in movie 4. We woulld have survived a three hour movie if it was interesting like the book was, and the book indeed was, mostly due to the mistery of the plot. Even omitting the entire yule ball storyline would have been forgivable in that case.
reply
TOO MUCH NAGIGI.
First off, why did Ron & Hermione have to fight the goddamn snake in the finale instead of a human foe, like Fenrir Greyback or Bellatrix Lestrange?
Second, why did the snake attack Harry in Godric's hollow? Why couldn't it just hold him up until Voldemort arrives like in the book? Voldemort directly controls it, Nagini being a Horcrux, and Voldemort wants to kill Harry himself, not get him bitten to death by his pet.
And most importantly, why was half of the finale a snake biting the camera!
Too much boring teenager stuff in the sixth movie, sacrificing Voldemort's backstory. If you want to omit something, omit the tteen drama instead.
Missing mistery/crime story in movie 4. We woulld have survived a three hour movie if it was interesting like the book was, and the book indeed was, mostly due to the mistery of the plot. Even omitting the entire yule ball storyline would have been forgivable in that case.
reply
Sigridmflclfmd
I dont understand why people hate how Voldemort died in the movies. I know its weard but if Harry and Voldemort standed in the great hall why wouldnt anyone around him just avada kadevra from the side and just be like Yeah now hes gone instead of just be like oh no i hope Harry will win
I have dont readed the books yet but i understanded it like Harry and Voldemort was in the great hall with everyone around them (im not so good at english)
reply
I dont understand why people hate how Voldemort died in the movies. I know its weard but if Harry and Voldemort standed in the great hall why wouldnt anyone around him just avada kadevra from the side and just be like Yeah now hes gone instead of just be like oh no i hope Harry will win
I have dont readed the books yet but i understanded it like Harry and Voldemort was in the great hall with everyone around them (im not so good at english)
reply
Eva
I feel so bad that they cut off poltergist (i know i messed spelling so bad) beacuse they could create so much more moments to laugh
Also i think in the scene when Ron leaves and Harry and Hermione just start akwardly dancing seems like they were just waiting to get rid of Ron, while in the book they were feeling so bad that they didn't even want to say his name
And also: HARRY! DID YA PUT YOUR NAME IN DA GOBLET OF FYAH!
reply
I feel so bad that they cut off poltergist (i know i messed spelling so bad) beacuse they could create so much more moments to laugh
Also i think in the scene when Ron leaves and Harry and Hermione just start akwardly dancing seems like they were just waiting to get rid of Ron, while in the book they were feeling so bad that they didn't even want to say his name
And also: HARRY! DID YA PUT YOUR NAME IN DA GOBLET OF FYAH!
reply
Shalakha2013
Not only Ron and Ginny, they messed up a greatest character, Dumbledore. The guy has been shown as calm, intelligent and witty. His characterisation was a central theme in the book, but movies couldnt even half justice. Some of the best lines of the entire series is his and yet in the movies they failed miserably with him.
You cant deny, Dumbledore's got style.
reply
Not only Ron and Ginny, they messed up a greatest character, Dumbledore. The guy has been shown as calm, intelligent and witty. His characterisation was a central theme in the book, but movies couldnt even half justice. Some of the best lines of the entire series is his and yet in the movies they failed miserably with him.
You cant deny, Dumbledore's got style.
reply
Sunshine
I disagree with the dishonourable mention of Harry breaking the elder wand as someone called movieflame actually said it was a good change cause since Harry's an auror he might end up getting disarmed and in the cursed child he was disarmed by voldemort's daughter breaking the elder wand was a good choice so that it doesn't end up in the wrong hands
reply
I disagree with the dishonourable mention of Harry breaking the elder wand as someone called movieflame actually said it was a good change cause since Harry's an auror he might end up getting disarmed and in the cursed child he was disarmed by voldemort's daughter breaking the elder wand was a good choice so that it doesn't end up in the wrong hands
reply
dustinbachstein
Very good video again! For me, one scene is missing in your list: I very much disliked the scene in movie 6 where Death Eaters burn the Burrow, which is absolutels never happening in the book. It would have made much more sense to me to add a few more memories about Riddle's past instead. This is by far my personal #1!
reply
Very good video again! For me, one scene is missing in your list: I very much disliked the scene in movie 6 where Death Eaters burn the Burrow, which is absolutels never happening in the book. It would have made much more sense to me to add a few more memories about Riddle's past instead. This is by far my personal #1!
reply
Ali
I'm pissed they cut out basically every single important plot point in the Half-Blood Prince movie. That's my favorite book and one of THE most vital to the plot of the entire series. and they butchered that book WAY worse than any of the others when it comes to the movies. Look how they massacred my boy
reply
I'm pissed they cut out basically every single important plot point in the Half-Blood Prince movie. That's my favorite book and one of THE most vital to the plot of the entire series. and they butchered that book WAY worse than any of the others when it comes to the movies. Look how they massacred my boy
reply
Ann
Cutting out the scene with Harry, Ron, and Hermione meeting Neville's parents really messed up the Order of the Phoenix movie. It shows more of the reason for why Neville felt like he was not meeting with his family's expectations of him, until he finally gained his confidence after the Azkaban breakout.
reply
Cutting out the scene with Harry, Ron, and Hermione meeting Neville's parents really messed up the Order of the Phoenix movie. It shows more of the reason for why Neville felt like he was not meeting with his family's expectations of him, until he finally gained his confidence after the Azkaban breakout.
reply
CaTsie
Honestly, I feel breaking the Elder Wand was a good change. I do wish he would have fixed his first wand with it, but it was a good thing he broke it. He would go on to become an Auror. How many times do you think you'd be disarmed as an Auror hunting dark wizards? It's a good thing for it to be gone.
reply
Honestly, I feel breaking the Elder Wand was a good change. I do wish he would have fixed his first wand with it, but it was a good thing he broke it. He would go on to become an Auror. How many times do you think you'd be disarmed as an Auror hunting dark wizards? It's a good thing for it to be gone.
reply
Aysha
1. The Patil sisters weren't in the same house. One of them was a Ravenclaw. She became Head girl of Her house, like Hermione.
2. Voldemort's family history was erased completely.
3. The fact of Fenrir biting Remus, causing Remus turning into a werewolf was cut down too.
reply
1. The Patil sisters weren't in the same house. One of them was a Ravenclaw. She became Head girl of Her house, like Hermione.
2. Voldemort's family history was erased completely.
3. The fact of Fenrir biting Remus, causing Remus turning into a werewolf was cut down too.
reply
Maytal
I may not read the but I watch Ginny closely in the movies and I can tell they did something wrong with her character and did nothing 2 her and 2 try 2 forced Harry and Ginny 2gerher but feels so ackword and bland like twilight.
Ginny deserves better.
reply
I may not read the but I watch Ginny closely in the movies and I can tell they did something wrong with her character and did nothing 2 her and 2 try 2 forced Harry and Ginny 2gerher but feels so ackword and bland like twilight.
Ginny deserves better.
reply
EditorOfSL
Number 1: Putting Hermione in the films more than she features in the books. You might as well have called the series Hermione Granger and the Rising Know-It-All.
The Sphinx was a girl, by the way, did you not read the fourth book?
reply
Number 1: Putting Hermione in the films more than she features in the books. You might as well have called the series Hermione Granger and the Rising Know-It-All.
The Sphinx was a girl, by the way, did you not read the fourth book?
reply
Roos
What about the scene were Ron, Harry and Hermione visit the house elves who all work at Hogwarts in the kitchens. It always makes me laugh about the amount of food they get. You can also see how different each house elf acts.
reply
What about the scene were Ron, Harry and Hermione visit the house elves who all work at Hogwarts in the kitchens. It always makes me laugh about the amount of food they get. You can also see how different each house elf acts.
reply
Blades
Im sorry but dumbledore asking Harry if he put his name on the goblet of fire is much more better in the film than the book because it shows you how scary the tri wizard tournament is and how sad and mad albus was
reply
Im sorry but dumbledore asking Harry if he put his name on the goblet of fire is much more better in the film than the book because it shows you how scary the tri wizard tournament is and how sad and mad albus was
reply
Tate
Tbh Voldemorts death in the movies was by far the most disappointing death. In the books, he falls like a mortal being, and in the end thats all he was. They shouldnt have made his death magical
reply
Tbh Voldemorts death in the movies was by far the most disappointing death. In the books, he falls like a mortal being, and in the end thats all he was. They shouldnt have made his death magical
reply
Catherine
What about Harry repairing his wand with the elder wand and then the elder wand going back in the tomb with dumbledore, not just taking the elder wand and breaking it and throwing it away.
reply
What about Harry repairing his wand with the elder wand and then the elder wand going back in the tomb with dumbledore, not just taking the elder wand and breaking it and throwing it away.
reply
Harley
I liked the angry approach that dumbledore takes when he questions Harry about putting his name in the goblet of fire in the film. You could really sense his fear for him.
reply
I liked the angry approach that dumbledore takes when he questions Harry about putting his name in the goblet of fire in the film. You could really sense his fear for him.
reply
Cool
Excuse me but what about order of the phoenix cutting out all quidditch in the film?
And skipping snape teaching defense against the dark arts in half blood prince?
reply
Excuse me but what about order of the phoenix cutting out all quidditch in the film?
And skipping snape teaching defense against the dark arts in half blood prince?
reply
Garrett
I didnt mind Harry breaking the elder wand. I just wish they showed him repairing his own.
Voldemorts final battle should have shown him just falling over dead.
reply
I didnt mind Harry breaking the elder wand. I just wish they showed him repairing his own.
Voldemorts final battle should have shown him just falling over dead.
reply
Evyatar
am i the only one who was upset that voldemort and harry's chat before voldemort's death was cut off in the film? this was one of my favorite moments in the books!
reply
am i the only one who was upset that voldemort and harry's chat before voldemort's death was cut off in the film? this was one of my favorite moments in the books!
reply
fanjoy
What about:
Bellatrix torturing Hermione in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1:
-movie: Mudblood scar on her arm
-book: the Cruciatus curse
reply
What about:
Bellatrix torturing Hermione in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1:
-movie: Mudblood scar on her arm
-book: the Cruciatus curse
reply
Jared
FYI, the script writer for The Goblet of Fire put little care into the writing, such as wanting the dragon to burn down the Forbidden Forest when chasing Harry
reply
FYI, the script writer for The Goblet of Fire put little care into the writing, such as wanting the dragon to burn down the Forbidden Forest when chasing Harry
reply
yari
What about harry en ginnys first kiss? I would love to see in the movies their first kiss at the party after the quidditch cup (HP and the halfblood price)
reply
What about harry en ginnys first kiss? I would love to see in the movies their first kiss at the party after the quidditch cup (HP and the halfblood price)
reply
Astitva
Books give more what the movies havent, we know they can't put the whole book in movies but they didn't put many main scenes
Love books, movies too
reply
Books give more what the movies havent, we know they can't put the whole book in movies but they didn't put many main scenes
Love books, movies too
reply
StarTyger
Oh, come one, Dumbledore! There was no way Harry could have put his name in the Goblet of Fire. He would have been rejected like the twins, remember?
reply
Oh, come one, Dumbledore! There was no way Harry could have put his name in the Goblet of Fire. He would have been rejected like the twins, remember?
reply
Samayalupta
Only a series on harry potter can fill these loopholes as if they were incorporated in the film it would be so long that no one would like to watch
reply
Only a series on harry potter can fill these loopholes as if they were incorporated in the film it would be so long that no one would like to watch
reply
Shubh
I honestly like the second Dumbledore more cuz he is badass and has a really creative fight with Voldemort and more capable character than the original
reply
I honestly like the second Dumbledore more cuz he is badass and has a really creative fight with Voldemort and more capable character than the original
reply
Captain
Harry. Did ya put yur name in tha Goblet of Fyre! It is amazing how such a bad change from the book to a movie adaptation could become a meme.
reply
Harry. Did ya put yur name in tha Goblet of Fyre! It is amazing how such a bad change from the book to a movie adaptation could become a meme.
reply
CarterStreet128
I totally disagree with #3, I think leaving out peeves was a good thing. He would have been too much of a distraction from the story.
reply
I totally disagree with #3, I think leaving out peeves was a good thing. He would have been too much of a distraction from the story.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
