The Ultimate Cinderella Movie Face-Off
video description
Date: 2023-11-21
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 30
Allison
I love that in the 2015 live action adaptation of the animated Disney film, we learn why Cinderella's stepmother is so cruel towards her. We were told previously that she was jealous of her charm and beauty when her own daughters were awkward and ugly, but in the live action version, we see a bit of her life with Ella's father and she overhears him tell Ella that he misses her mother, his first wife, and finds his new wife and stepdaughters trying, although he adds that they must try to be accepting of the situation. It is heartbreaking especially when she shares with Ella how happy she was with her first husband and was devastated when he died, choosing to remarry only for the benefit of her daughters, regardless of Ella's father's lack of status. But it definitely makes her a relatable villain.
reply
I love that in the 2015 live action adaptation of the animated Disney film, we learn why Cinderella's stepmother is so cruel towards her. We were told previously that she was jealous of her charm and beauty when her own daughters were awkward and ugly, but in the live action version, we see a bit of her life with Ella's father and she overhears him tell Ella that he misses her mother, his first wife, and finds his new wife and stepdaughters trying, although he adds that they must try to be accepting of the situation. It is heartbreaking especially when she shares with Ella how happy she was with her first husband and was devastated when he died, choosing to remarry only for the benefit of her daughters, regardless of Ella's father's lack of status. But it definitely makes her a relatable villain.
reply
Lightening
No matter how many adaptations there are, I so love the story of Cinderella! It's really wonderful, having a girl we relate to, who wants love, while being a slave. Of course, Disney's animated version holds up to me so much, but I also love the live-action version and Cinderella Story. Yet to watch the Hammersmith version, Another Cinderella Story, Sneakerella, Ever After, and the Amazon Prime exclusive, but I have a feeling I'll love all of them.
reply
No matter how many adaptations there are, I so love the story of Cinderella! It's really wonderful, having a girl we relate to, who wants love, while being a slave. Of course, Disney's animated version holds up to me so much, but I also love the live-action version and Cinderella Story. Yet to watch the Hammersmith version, Another Cinderella Story, Sneakerella, Ever After, and the Amazon Prime exclusive, but I have a feeling I'll love all of them.
reply
Olvia
These may not be Cinderella canon movies but Im going to mention it. Happily NEver After and Ella Enchanted.
The first one is animated with the voices of Sigourney Weaver, Freddie Prinze Jr and Sarah Michelle Gellar. It might be considered forgotten and a bomb but I love the movie since childhood
For the second one is a different version introducing Anne Hathaway. Unlike other Cinderellas, shes under a spell to do anything but its a fun movie
reply
These may not be Cinderella canon movies but Im going to mention it. Happily NEver After and Ella Enchanted.
The first one is animated with the voices of Sigourney Weaver, Freddie Prinze Jr and Sarah Michelle Gellar. It might be considered forgotten and a bomb but I love the movie since childhood
For the second one is a different version introducing Anne Hathaway. Unlike other Cinderellas, shes under a spell to do anything but its a fun movie
reply
cammygram1
I have grown up over the last 60 plus years watching all these movies, I know many people don't agree with many of them but all the same I watched them. Easy for youth of today to not agree with the messages I would still like to acknowledge these movies all brought the many naysayers of today a small movie history on how many of these we saw on the road on a road to more understanding of today.
reply
I have grown up over the last 60 plus years watching all these movies, I know many people don't agree with many of them but all the same I watched them. Easy for youth of today to not agree with the messages I would still like to acknowledge these movies all brought the many naysayers of today a small movie history on how many of these we saw on the road on a road to more understanding of today.
reply
Jahrell
Forever and always will love the 1998 Rodgers and Hammerstein version with Brandy and Whitney Houston. Not only cause Brandy is my all time fav singer but cause that version was just beautiful all around with the scenery, diversity, casting, etc. Whitney made the right choice choosing brandy for the role, and then playing as the fairy godmother with her vocals and gracefulness was just majestic imo
reply
Forever and always will love the 1998 Rodgers and Hammerstein version with Brandy and Whitney Houston. Not only cause Brandy is my all time fav singer but cause that version was just beautiful all around with the scenery, diversity, casting, etc. Whitney made the right choice choosing brandy for the role, and then playing as the fairy godmother with her vocals and gracefulness was just majestic imo
reply
tech2017
I won't watch ANY version of Cinderella accept the live action Disney remake. It is one of only 3 times that Disney did a live action remake that was GOOD.
And just look at the cast
Lily James- Cinderella
Richard Madden- The Prince
Cate Blanchett- Lady Tremaine
Helena Bonham Carter- Fairy Godmother
Directed by Kenneth Branagh
That is ALL A list talent.
reply
I won't watch ANY version of Cinderella accept the live action Disney remake. It is one of only 3 times that Disney did a live action remake that was GOOD.
And just look at the cast
Lily James- Cinderella
Richard Madden- The Prince
Cate Blanchett- Lady Tremaine
Helena Bonham Carter- Fairy Godmother
Directed by Kenneth Branagh
That is ALL A list talent.
reply
Lady
You didn't show Every Cinderella.
Leslie Ann Warren was, is, and always will be my favorite Cinderella. Brandy and Whitney were in the recast Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella, but She was in their movie way back, shortly after the highly popular animated movie.
I've always loved her final gown.
reply
You didn't show Every Cinderella.
Leslie Ann Warren was, is, and always will be my favorite Cinderella. Brandy and Whitney were in the recast Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella, but She was in their movie way back, shortly after the highly popular animated movie.
I've always loved her final gown.
reply
Kahena
My Favorite Versions of Cinderella
1. Cinderella 1950
2. Cinderella 2015
3. Ever After A Cinderella Story
4. Rogers and Hammersteins Cinderella 1997
5. A Cinderella Story
6. Another Cinderella Story
7. Into the woods Cinderella
8. A Cinderella Story A Christmas Wish.
reply
My Favorite Versions of Cinderella
1. Cinderella 1950
2. Cinderella 2015
3. Ever After A Cinderella Story
4. Rogers and Hammersteins Cinderella 1997
5. A Cinderella Story
6. Another Cinderella Story
7. Into the woods Cinderella
8. A Cinderella Story A Christmas Wish.
reply
Alexya
The Slipper & the Rose (1976) & The Glass Slipper (1955. I love these 2 versions. I wish they would have been part of this list.
Especially The Slipper & the Rose. Which is a forgotten gem. & my favorite version of Cinderella.
With the 1997 Brandy version & Ever After tied for second.
reply
The Slipper & the Rose (1976) & The Glass Slipper (1955. I love these 2 versions. I wish they would have been part of this list.
Especially The Slipper & the Rose. Which is a forgotten gem. & my favorite version of Cinderella.
With the 1997 Brandy version & Ever After tied for second.
reply
CJ
Some really glaring omissions. No Leslie Ann Warren -- the sine qua non of the cannon for quite a while. No _Slipper and the Rose_, one of the cheekier and award nominated? No Julie Andrews -- who should always be listed just because it's freakin' Julie Andrews? And so many others. Oh well.
reply
Some really glaring omissions. No Leslie Ann Warren -- the sine qua non of the cannon for quite a while. No _Slipper and the Rose_, one of the cheekier and award nominated? No Julie Andrews -- who should always be listed just because it's freakin' Julie Andrews? And so many others. Oh well.
reply
Kara
I like Cinderella:
The first Cinderella live- action and second is interesting are (The Prince The kinghelper/ sword freighter)
Cinderella (1950)
A Cinderella story
A another Cinderella
A another Cinderella story 3
Happy every after
Cinderella(the 90' s)
reply
I like Cinderella:
The first Cinderella live- action and second is interesting are (The Prince The kinghelper/ sword freighter)
Cinderella (1950)
A Cinderella story
A another Cinderella
A another Cinderella story 3
Happy every after
Cinderella(the 90' s)
reply
Justin
Very very great epic list I like it a lot very very great job mis mojo one of my absolute favorite list ever my favorite Cinderella movies are Cinderella 2015 ever after a Cinderella story Rodger & Hammerstein's Cinderella
reply
Very very great epic list I like it a lot very very great job mis mojo one of my absolute favorite list ever my favorite Cinderella movies are Cinderella 2015 ever after a Cinderella story Rodger & Hammerstein's Cinderella
reply
DonSchorschi
I'm actually a little bit mad that you didn't include Three hazelnuts for Cinderella. It's the most popular Cinderella movie in Europe (especially Middle and east Europe) and it is played every Christmas.
reply
I'm actually a little bit mad that you didn't include Three hazelnuts for Cinderella. It's the most popular Cinderella movie in Europe (especially Middle and east Europe) and it is played every Christmas.
reply
Tamara
There's another Cinderella movie you're forgetting. done by Roger and Hammerstein and it of course was a musical with Leslie playing Cinderella. also Ginger Rogers played the prince mother.
reply
There's another Cinderella movie you're forgetting. done by Roger and Hammerstein and it of course was a musical with Leslie playing Cinderella. also Ginger Rogers played the prince mother.
reply
awesomegirl5
You didn't show A Cinderella Story once upon a song, A Cinderella Story if the shoe fits, A Cinderella Story Christmas Wish, A Cinderella Story Starstruck and DJ Cinderella
reply
You didn't show A Cinderella Story once upon a song, A Cinderella Story if the shoe fits, A Cinderella Story Christmas Wish, A Cinderella Story Starstruck and DJ Cinderella
reply
Joanne
The Disney cartoon of Cinderella was the first film my mother took me to see at the pictures. Will always be the best. My mother as dementia now so it's a precious memory.
reply
The Disney cartoon of Cinderella was the first film my mother took me to see at the pictures. Will always be the best. My mother as dementia now so it's a precious memory.
reply
Sanford
How on earth do you do a video about Cinderella and not show a single clip of the Julie Andrews or Leslie Ann Warren versions! Ridiculous and you've lost all credibility.
reply
How on earth do you do a video about Cinderella and not show a single clip of the Julie Andrews or Leslie Ann Warren versions! Ridiculous and you've lost all credibility.
reply
Carlyn88413
I wrote a paper on this topic in college. I focused on Ever After and Rodgers and Hammersteins Cinderella (Whitney and Brandy. So this is a fun jog down memory lane
reply
I wrote a paper on this topic in college. I focused on Ever After and Rodgers and Hammersteins Cinderella (Whitney and Brandy. So this is a fun jog down memory lane
reply
Haley
Cinderella could be its own genre its been done so much haha! But I still the lore so much, no matter the varying adaptations! Ever After is still my favorite for sure!
reply
Cinderella could be its own genre its been done so much haha! But I still the lore so much, no matter the varying adaptations! Ever After is still my favorite for sure!
reply
Diana
My top four favorite adaptations have to be #1-Ever after, #2-1997 roger's and Hammerstein #3 Shelley Duvall's Fairy Tale theatre's Cinderella #4-a cinderella story.
reply
My top four favorite adaptations have to be #1-Ever after, #2-1997 roger's and Hammerstein #3 Shelley Duvall's Fairy Tale theatre's Cinderella #4-a cinderella story.
reply
EvilChina
1 Evil Queen
2 Stepparents
3 Valentina Zenere
4 La Teresa
5 Annabelle
6 Meghan
7 Gaston
8 Genie Ye
9 Conjuring
10 Rubi Ruby
reply
1 Evil Queen
2 Stepparents
3 Valentina Zenere
4 La Teresa
5 Annabelle
6 Meghan
7 Gaston
8 Genie Ye
9 Conjuring
10 Rubi Ruby
reply
Dianela
I never liked the story of Cinderella except for Ever After! Ever After is my favorite movie I can recite it by heart. I mainly love how she saves herself
reply
I never liked the story of Cinderella except for Ever After! Ever After is my favorite movie I can recite it by heart. I mainly love how she saves herself
reply
supershines12
You forgot to talk about Cinderelmo and how in that Elmo's dog named Prince becomes human by Elmo's god person and Prince ends up with the princess
reply
You forgot to talk about Cinderelmo and how in that Elmo's dog named Prince becomes human by Elmo's god person and Prince ends up with the princess
reply
Zamya
Cinderella (1950, A Cinderella Story, Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella, Rags, Another Cinderella Story, Ever After, Ella Enchanted, Cinderella (2015)
reply
Cinderella (1950, A Cinderella Story, Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella, Rags, Another Cinderella Story, Ever After, Ella Enchanted, Cinderella (2015)
reply
Shelby
A Cinderella Story with Hilary Duff, will ALWAYS be the best live action (not including the original cartoon) and Ella Enchanted is up there too
reply
A Cinderella Story with Hilary Duff, will ALWAYS be the best live action (not including the original cartoon) and Ella Enchanted is up there too
reply
Adrian
Forgot about Cinderella goodtime entertainment movie and glass slipper movie and Cinderella 3 wish movie and Shelley Duvall fairytale theater
reply
Forgot about Cinderella goodtime entertainment movie and glass slipper movie and Cinderella 3 wish movie and Shelley Duvall fairytale theater
reply
kchez110
Total miss here not to include Lesley Anne Warren and Stuart Damon. Will always be my favorite. What about Julie Andrews and Jon Cypher?
reply
Total miss here not to include Lesley Anne Warren and Stuart Damon. Will always be my favorite. What about Julie Andrews and Jon Cypher?
reply
Emelie
What about After The Ball with a gender bender fashion situation?
Loved that one! But Ever After and Brandy will always be my faves!
reply
What about After The Ball with a gender bender fashion situation?
Loved that one! But Ever After and Brandy will always be my faves!
reply
Trina
I'll always love A Cinderella Story, since I grew up with it, and presented a fun modern version of the classic fairytale.
reply
I'll always love A Cinderella Story, since I grew up with it, and presented a fun modern version of the classic fairytale.
reply
Denise
1950's Cinderella will always be my favorite one, but i also like 2015 version and The Glass Slipper, with Leslie Caron.
reply
1950's Cinderella will always be my favorite one, but i also like 2015 version and The Glass Slipper, with Leslie Caron.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
