The Incredibles vs. Incredibles 2
video description
Date: 2023-11-20
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 27
Tornado
The first one is a masterpiece - A dynamic, well developed plot, great, fast-paced action, personable, well-defined characters, the best kind of steady stream of humour you can expect from animated family movies, mature themes such as being stuck in a marital rut, a mid-life crisis, yearning for the glory days, dealing with the problems that come with hyperactive and frustrated, or shy, insecure children. On top of the unique family aspect regarding superheroism, which only really occurs with The Incredibles and the Fantastic Four, there's a Simpsons style satirisation of superhero storytelling and comic book fandom.
The second one naturally feels less impressive due to having a simple plot - There's nothing wrong with that, it's pleasant and even feels like relaxing downtime after the recent and stressful events of the first movie, being wonderfully suitable too. I used to think it's great as it performs its simple plot to the highest level of excellency - The action, family dilemmas, humour, and villain are all generally first rate (the twist with the villain is a bit obvious, but it works, and the film is well paced. However, for some bizarre reason, the satirisation aspect that added a fantastic layer to the original has now been done away with. I thought, perhaps Syndrome allowed that plot to work well as he really encompassed that theme in the film as the main villain of it, by being an overzealous, obsessive superhero nerd, with priorities way out of whack. However, now I see that things could've been done with the new superheroes - There could be a main hero and sidekick dynamic with two of them, that parodies Batman and Robin, or a powerful superhero like Superman, who has super-strength, can fly, and has laser vision, could have a weakness like kryptonite - Let's say he's allergic to cryonite peanuts (a parody of kryptonite) as it makes him swell up and be weak, and he could be a show-off who then gets made fun of by others, as he flees helplessly from the weakness, creating an entertaining dichotomy - Jack Jack has many powers, so another Super having a few wouldn't seem far-fetched. Evelyn and Winston could've given Elastigirl her own Bat signal, testing it out, and the conversation could go like this -
Elastigirl: What kind of self-absorbed, narcissistic superhero would want that? No way! Just call me, if you need me. Phones exist and are super easy to use. This is a no-brainer.
Winston: Well, it's to give people hope.
Elastigirl: Everyone has a TV. Everyone watches the news. Just press the on button and a number button for the destination. Again, clearly a no-brainer. Indisputable logic, really.
Therefore, I think Incredibles 2 is very good, but The Incredibles is a masterpiece.
reply
The first one is a masterpiece - A dynamic, well developed plot, great, fast-paced action, personable, well-defined characters, the best kind of steady stream of humour you can expect from animated family movies, mature themes such as being stuck in a marital rut, a mid-life crisis, yearning for the glory days, dealing with the problems that come with hyperactive and frustrated, or shy, insecure children. On top of the unique family aspect regarding superheroism, which only really occurs with The Incredibles and the Fantastic Four, there's a Simpsons style satirisation of superhero storytelling and comic book fandom.
The second one naturally feels less impressive due to having a simple plot - There's nothing wrong with that, it's pleasant and even feels like relaxing downtime after the recent and stressful events of the first movie, being wonderfully suitable too. I used to think it's great as it performs its simple plot to the highest level of excellency - The action, family dilemmas, humour, and villain are all generally first rate (the twist with the villain is a bit obvious, but it works, and the film is well paced. However, for some bizarre reason, the satirisation aspect that added a fantastic layer to the original has now been done away with. I thought, perhaps Syndrome allowed that plot to work well as he really encompassed that theme in the film as the main villain of it, by being an overzealous, obsessive superhero nerd, with priorities way out of whack. However, now I see that things could've been done with the new superheroes - There could be a main hero and sidekick dynamic with two of them, that parodies Batman and Robin, or a powerful superhero like Superman, who has super-strength, can fly, and has laser vision, could have a weakness like kryptonite - Let's say he's allergic to cryonite peanuts (a parody of kryptonite) as it makes him swell up and be weak, and he could be a show-off who then gets made fun of by others, as he flees helplessly from the weakness, creating an entertaining dichotomy - Jack Jack has many powers, so another Super having a few wouldn't seem far-fetched. Evelyn and Winston could've given Elastigirl her own Bat signal, testing it out, and the conversation could go like this -
Elastigirl: What kind of self-absorbed, narcissistic superhero would want that? No way! Just call me, if you need me. Phones exist and are super easy to use. This is a no-brainer.
Winston: Well, it's to give people hope.
Elastigirl: Everyone has a TV. Everyone watches the news. Just press the on button and a number button for the destination. Again, clearly a no-brainer. Indisputable logic, really.
Therefore, I think Incredibles 2 is very good, but The Incredibles is a masterpiece.
reply
Daniel
I really enjoyed The Incredibles and lo the many 14 years it took for a sequel I expected The Incredibles 2 to be every bit as good as the original. After all, they had more than plenty of time to draft a fine storyline and to develop and flesh out all characters to the degree needed. I liked the sequel but while it should have been as good as the original, given the time to pick up the script and animation storyboard every now and then, sadly it wasn't. The very fact that so many said this was better in the original and that was better in the sequel bears this out. I do hope that they make another movie or, lacking that. do as was done with Big Hero 6 ie. make it into a TV serial, but only if all production values are high. Often when working at home or taking a power nap I'll have The Incredibles on in the background as white noise. It's just such an all-around great movie. For me, it's Pixar's finest effort, but that's just me.
Just F. Y. I.: The Incredibles 2, from 2018 and in competition with all the great superhero movies since, still holds the highest opening weekend grossing record, just about 20 million ahead of what other animated sequel? Why Pixar's own Finding Dory! I hope Incredibilians everywhere enjoy the two movies as much as I do.
reply
I really enjoyed The Incredibles and lo the many 14 years it took for a sequel I expected The Incredibles 2 to be every bit as good as the original. After all, they had more than plenty of time to draft a fine storyline and to develop and flesh out all characters to the degree needed. I liked the sequel but while it should have been as good as the original, given the time to pick up the script and animation storyboard every now and then, sadly it wasn't. The very fact that so many said this was better in the original and that was better in the sequel bears this out. I do hope that they make another movie or, lacking that. do as was done with Big Hero 6 ie. make it into a TV serial, but only if all production values are high. Often when working at home or taking a power nap I'll have The Incredibles on in the background as white noise. It's just such an all-around great movie. For me, it's Pixar's finest effort, but that's just me.
Just F. Y. I.: The Incredibles 2, from 2018 and in competition with all the great superhero movies since, still holds the highest opening weekend grossing record, just about 20 million ahead of what other animated sequel? Why Pixar's own Finding Dory! I hope Incredibilians everywhere enjoy the two movies as much as I do.
reply
ItzAngel
I would most likely think that the First Incredibles was focusing on the plot story more darker yet it has original plots to it, The movie was about Bob, and The Second incredibles was about Helen, The incredibles 2 was most likely action and has funny humor than the first one
I wouldn't be too surprised if pixar is going to make a third movie for the incredibles but this time, focusing on both the main character's Children, Violet being a pre-teen and Dash being around violet's age while jack-jack is around Dash's age it would be pretty interesting to see them grow up and now have full superhero experiences and they're parents being proud for them
reply
I would most likely think that the First Incredibles was focusing on the plot story more darker yet it has original plots to it, The movie was about Bob, and The Second incredibles was about Helen, The incredibles 2 was most likely action and has funny humor than the first one
I wouldn't be too surprised if pixar is going to make a third movie for the incredibles but this time, focusing on both the main character's Children, Violet being a pre-teen and Dash being around violet's age while jack-jack is around Dash's age it would be pretty interesting to see them grow up and now have full superhero experiences and they're parents being proud for them
reply
Manuel
Awesome! I see that this is a comparison of two of my favorite Pixar films (which are the first Incredibles, which is The Incredibles, and the second Incredibles, which is Incredibles 2!
Did you know that.
Rounds in which the original is the winner are: Comedy, Action and Villain
Rounds in which the sequel is the winner are: Animation and Story
The winner overall is The Incredibles!
The loser overall is Incredibles 2!
This video makes me think the original is better than the sequel due to the final score being a 3-2 win for the original movie!
reply
Awesome! I see that this is a comparison of two of my favorite Pixar films (which are the first Incredibles, which is The Incredibles, and the second Incredibles, which is Incredibles 2!
Did you know that.
Rounds in which the original is the winner are: Comedy, Action and Villain
Rounds in which the sequel is the winner are: Animation and Story
The winner overall is The Incredibles!
The loser overall is Incredibles 2!
This video makes me think the original is better than the sequel due to the final score being a 3-2 win for the original movie!
reply
kahlia
I liked both movies a lot, but Syndrome is definitely a better villain. He was someone you could identify with and you actually kind of felt bad for him or at least felt like Mr. Incredible really was a little responsible for what happened. In Incredibles 2, Screenslaver is a cool villain but the surprise was dumb because it was someone nobody really cared about. I think it would've been cooler if the rest of the movie revolved around Underminer, but I liked that he got away and the family had to deal with the repercussions of failing to catch him.
reply
I liked both movies a lot, but Syndrome is definitely a better villain. He was someone you could identify with and you actually kind of felt bad for him or at least felt like Mr. Incredible really was a little responsible for what happened. In Incredibles 2, Screenslaver is a cool villain but the surprise was dumb because it was someone nobody really cared about. I think it would've been cooler if the rest of the movie revolved around Underminer, but I liked that he got away and the family had to deal with the repercussions of failing to catch him.
reply
Natmeris
While the animation may be better in the 2nd, I don't really like its presentation. For many sequels, they take out some of the grittiness and made the visuals overall brighter and I just dont like it. It looks less mature as well. I'd prefer if they just kept the same palette. In another sequel where this happened it was Hoodwinked 2. There is little difference between the various Toy Story movies, why did they have to change the look here? Animation visual doesnt have to change, just the quality can be different.
reply
While the animation may be better in the 2nd, I don't really like its presentation. For many sequels, they take out some of the grittiness and made the visuals overall brighter and I just dont like it. It looks less mature as well. I'd prefer if they just kept the same palette. In another sequel where this happened it was Hoodwinked 2. There is little difference between the various Toy Story movies, why did they have to change the look here? Animation visual doesnt have to change, just the quality can be different.
reply
Whos
I like the story line of the first one although everything else I like the second. I like how the second one almost everyone get their shine unlike the first movie where it mostly focused on bob. The second movie focuses on helen yet the kids and all other supers are involved and I get to see more diverse power which is cool.
On the personal level my obsession with elastigirl is too real so ima have to go with incredible 2
reply
I like the story line of the first one although everything else I like the second. I like how the second one almost everyone get their shine unlike the first movie where it mostly focused on bob. The second movie focuses on helen yet the kids and all other supers are involved and I get to see more diverse power which is cool.
On the personal level my obsession with elastigirl is too real so ima have to go with incredible 2
reply
Joey
I do prefer The Incredibles but I still think Incredibles 2 is almost as good. I honestly think Incredibles 2 has a better concept and idea but the story for the Incredibles was executed just perfectly. My only complaint with Incredibles 2 was I wish the final battle was maybe around 5-10 minutes longer. and finally, a comment section that treats both movies fairly instead of just saying The Incredibles had better.
reply
I do prefer The Incredibles but I still think Incredibles 2 is almost as good. I honestly think Incredibles 2 has a better concept and idea but the story for the Incredibles was executed just perfectly. My only complaint with Incredibles 2 was I wish the final battle was maybe around 5-10 minutes longer. and finally, a comment section that treats both movies fairly instead of just saying The Incredibles had better.
reply
Cat
I prefer The Incredibles 1. The Incredibles 2 started off good and was pretty fun to watch for the first half of the film, but then it just went downhill. Spoiler warning
And I thought that battle at the end on the ship was pretty lame. The end fight against the giant omnidroid in The Incredibles 1 was was more epic.
reply
I prefer The Incredibles 1. The Incredibles 2 started off good and was pretty fun to watch for the first half of the film, but then it just went downhill. Spoiler warning
And I thought that battle at the end on the ship was pretty lame. The end fight against the giant omnidroid in The Incredibles 1 was was more epic.
reply
Mixture
They made jack jack so powerful that the family aren't unique in their own way anymore, I loved that before he had powers they all had their each own unique power that makes them significant to the whole family, now that jack jack has almost all of their powers is just Jack jack became like A Mary Sue for me.
reply
They made jack jack so powerful that the family aren't unique in their own way anymore, I loved that before he had powers they all had their each own unique power that makes them significant to the whole family, now that jack jack has almost all of their powers is just Jack jack became like A Mary Sue for me.
reply
fanjoy
tbh the first Incredibles movie was pretty good, but Id have to disagree with the round concerning the fight scenes. I mean, the jungle scenes are still one of Pixars best, but I loved watching the kids trying to fight the hypnotized supers and watching elastic girl have more time on screen to fight
reply
tbh the first Incredibles movie was pretty good, but Id have to disagree with the round concerning the fight scenes. I mean, the jungle scenes are still one of Pixars best, but I loved watching the kids trying to fight the hypnotized supers and watching elastic girl have more time on screen to fight
reply
Sugary
No doubt that the original movie's way better than the sequel. The sequel plays it too safe and it feels like the first movie but only changed the focus being on Elastigirl. It's a shame that the sequel didn't live up to the high expectations. It had a lot of potential and they wasted it
reply
No doubt that the original movie's way better than the sequel. The sequel plays it too safe and it feels like the first movie but only changed the focus being on Elastigirl. It's a shame that the sequel didn't live up to the high expectations. It had a lot of potential and they wasted it
reply
ULTIMATE
Incredibles 2 is a complete betrayal of the original. It serves no purpose, incredibles is a superhero dissection, incredibles 2 is a generic super hero. Also incredibles 2 has a meh story while the original is one of the best super hero stories of all time
reply
Incredibles 2 is a complete betrayal of the original. It serves no purpose, incredibles is a superhero dissection, incredibles 2 is a generic super hero. Also incredibles 2 has a meh story while the original is one of the best super hero stories of all time
reply
blueraccoon
To anyone who likes Incredibles 2, keep in mind please I also like the movie too but one i problem I must mention. I speak this well, some scenes may cause seizures and some theaters, home video don't include Warning. please Mrs mojo pin my comment
reply
To anyone who likes Incredibles 2, keep in mind please I also like the movie too but one i problem I must mention. I speak this well, some scenes may cause seizures and some theaters, home video don't include Warning. please Mrs mojo pin my comment
reply
Ben
Incredibles 1 & 2 are kinda like Zombieland and Zombieland: Double Tap for me, since I grew up with it I think the first one is always gonna hold a special place in my heart which will make me prefer it but the second movie was still an amazing follow up
reply
Incredibles 1 & 2 are kinda like Zombieland and Zombieland: Double Tap for me, since I grew up with it I think the first one is always gonna hold a special place in my heart which will make me prefer it but the second movie was still an amazing follow up
reply
L3umas
The 2nd one actually taught us more of a lesson, had much better fight scenes, better animation, a better story, far better action cause the fight scenes were more thoughtful and had a cooler aspects of usage of their powers so the 2nd one for me
reply
The 2nd one actually taught us more of a lesson, had much better fight scenes, better animation, a better story, far better action cause the fight scenes were more thoughtful and had a cooler aspects of usage of their powers so the 2nd one for me
reply
soo
at least it isn't another hero5. uhh that was sad 9: 29 goosebumps
stickman escape adventure, lg tv advertisement. please, don't touch anything, stanley parable, anger games, wimpy kid. for stress relief,
reply
at least it isn't another hero5. uhh that was sad 9: 29 goosebumps
stickman escape adventure, lg tv advertisement. please, don't touch anything, stanley parable, anger games, wimpy kid. for stress relief,
reply
Reading
I loved both movies, but I doubt I'll be watching Incredibles 2 again any time soon. Screen Slaver is so SCARY! I mean, that MASK! She looks ready to murder me! Darn thing gave me nightmares for a week.
reply
I loved both movies, but I doubt I'll be watching Incredibles 2 again any time soon. Screen Slaver is so SCARY! I mean, that MASK! She looks ready to murder me! Darn thing gave me nightmares for a week.
reply
Jack
Either way these two movies have both good expeditions for my liking. I will always love the original movie but the 2nd was incredible! Im still surprised Brad Bird is the voice of Edna. I love it!
reply
Either way these two movies have both good expeditions for my liking. I will always love the original movie but the 2nd was incredible! Im still surprised Brad Bird is the voice of Edna. I love it!
reply
MegaDrax08
My Version
Animation Incredibles 2
Comedy The Incredibles
Story The Incredibles
Action Incredibles 2
Villain The Incredibles
I Liked The Original Better But I Do Like 2
reply
My Version
Animation Incredibles 2
Comedy The Incredibles
Story The Incredibles
Action Incredibles 2
Villain The Incredibles
I Liked The Original Better But I Do Like 2
reply
Third
The moment it came down to the villain, everyone knew who was going to win this.
Although the way they worded it made it seem like they went back on their No Nostalgia rule.
reply
The moment it came down to the villain, everyone knew who was going to win this.
Although the way they worded it made it seem like they went back on their No Nostalgia rule.
reply
Miles
Action: Equal
Comedy: Equal
Story: Incredibles
Villain: Incredibles
Animation: Incredibles 2
Love both so so much but I do prefer Number 1.
reply
Action: Equal
Comedy: Equal
Story: Incredibles
Villain: Incredibles
Animation: Incredibles 2
Love both so so much but I do prefer Number 1.
reply
JangoFettFan9563
The Incredibles 1 is my favorite Pixar film of all time! Incredibles 2 is incredible except for the villain (aka Evelyn Deavor.
reply
The Incredibles 1 is my favorite Pixar film of all time! Incredibles 2 is incredible except for the villain (aka Evelyn Deavor.
reply
TheMail518
Well whether or not The Incredibles 1 or 2, they are both the best Pixar movies
I love that family and that they are all supers
reply
Well whether or not The Incredibles 1 or 2, they are both the best Pixar movies
I love that family and that they are all supers
reply
esther
I love the unsaturated color scheme on the original coz it looks more lifelike unlike the second sequel its too vibrant for my taste
reply
I love the unsaturated color scheme on the original coz it looks more lifelike unlike the second sequel its too vibrant for my taste
reply
Normancon
Something seems entirely off with the soundtrack of the second. It just didn't hit home like the first for me.
reply
Something seems entirely off with the soundtrack of the second. It just didn't hit home like the first for me.
reply
Bogdan
The We need you to share your perception with the world and How do we do that is stuck in my head.
reply
The We need you to share your perception with the world and How do we do that is stuck in my head.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
